Loading summary
Mr. Ballin
Wondry subscribers can listen to new episodes of Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries early and ad free right now. Join Wondry in the Wondry app or on Apple Podcasts. Sometimes a medical condition does not have to be life threatening in order to be life destroying. Small, persistent issues can become exhausting, transforming from minor annoyances to something that totally upends your day to day existence. And for the people in today's two stories, their conditions made their lives truly unbearable. In the first story, an 11 year old girl's persistent 15,000 cough a day struggle left doctors baffled and her mother desperate for answers. Despite countless tests, nothing seemed to explain the chaos until one psychologist uncovered a chilling possibility. In the second story, a six year old girl's first day of school would turn into a nightmare when classmates began bullying her for this mysterious smell she couldn't understand. Years of isolation and confusion would follow until a shocking discovery revealed an unexpected truth. From Ballin Studios and wondry, I'm Mr. Ballin and this is Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries, where every week we will explore a new baffling mystery originating from the one place we all can't escape our own bodies. So if you like today's story, please place a note on the windshield of a random car that says Sorry about the damage along with the follow button's phone number. The show is brought to you by Progressive Fiscally responsible financial geniuses, Monetary magicians. These are things people say about drivers who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Visit progressive.com to see if you could save Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states or situations.
Cassie Depechel
Hey, I'm Cassie Depechel, host of Wondery's podcast Against the Odds in our new season. It's August 3rd, 1991. A cruise ship sails into a brutal storm off South Africa's Wild coast and soon starts flooding. But with no leadership in sight, the ship's entertainers take charge, leading a desperate evacuation before Oceanos sinks. Listen to against the Odds on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Mr. Ballin
And now here's our first story called 15,000 Coughs. In late April 2013, 38 year old Alejandra Soto was in her kitchen loading up a tray with Gatorade, a bowl of soup, a package of throat lozenges and an inhaler. Upstairs, she could hear her 11 year old daughter Maggie coughing in her bedroom. Her cough sounded bad, but it was a vast improvement compared to the past few days. Maggie had come down with a severe case of Bronchitis, a condition that develops when the airway to the lungs becomes inflamed, causing a persistent cough. Alejandra had taken the week off from her demanding office job to take care of her daughter. She knew there'd be an avalanche of emails waiting for her when she got back to work. But her daughter's health came first, and she did not want to take any chances. Back when Maggie was a baby, she developed a severe case of pneumonia and almost died. Ever since, Alejandra had been incredibly cautious anytime Maggie developed any kind of respiratory illness. Thankfully, though, Maggie did seem to be recovering from this latest bout of bronchitis. She'd been on medication for the last four days and seemed to now have more energy and strength, too. Alejandro hoped that in another few days, the bronchitis would disappear completely. As Alejandra grabbed the tray of supplies for her daughter off the kitchen counter, her phone lit up. It was more calls from clients that she was missing. She took a calming breath and reminded herself that in a few days she'd be back at work. Then she could put in some overtime to catch up, and everything would go back to normal. A few weeks later, in mid May, Alejandro was setting the kitchen table for dinner while Maggie sat at the far end doing her homework. And at some point, Maggie just started coughing, and she was coughing so hard that her face turned beet red. Instinctively, Maggie reached for her inhaler, which she had been prescribed back in April for her bronchitis, and she breathed in the medication, and right away her cough quieted down, and so she went back to work. But just minutes later, Maggie started coughing again. As Maggie took another puff from her inhaler, Alejandra rushed over and began rubbing her daughter's back, trying not to show how concerned she was. Two weeks earlier, Alejandra had thought Maggie was getting better, and so she sent her to school. However, just a few days ago, Maggie had developed this dry cough. Now, Maggie had said she felt fine, but she was actually coughing more now than she had been before. Alejandra had taken her to the doctor's office for an exam, but the pediatrician just said to keep using her inhaler. The cough would clear up with time. Except now it seemed like Maggie's cough was only getting worse. And so Alejandra sat down next to her daughter at the table and told her that it might be time for another doctor's visit. She'd see if the pediatrician could squeeze them in tomorrow, and then maybe afterwards they could grab some ice cream. Maggie said she liked the sound of that. Then she got up to help her mother bring dinner to the table. The following day, Alejandra sat in the pediatrician's office, ignoring the constant buzz of emails on her phone while the doctor examined Maggie. He listened to her lungs with a stethoscope and told Maggie to breathe in deeply, and as she did, she exploded into a coughing fit. The pediatrician was sure that Maggie's bronchitis had cleared up. He told Alejandra that her daughter could be having some kind of allergic reaction like hay fever, and so she wanted Alejandra to try over the counter allergy medications and see if maybe that alleviated the cough. On the way home, the mother and daughter grabbed some allergy medication from the pharmacy, along with some ice cream cones from the ice cream shop. As promised, Maggie took the allergy meds with some water in between licks of her cone, and within a few minutes, her cough seemed to be getting a bit better. Alejandro hoped that maybe now this would be the end of her coughing fits, and by tomorrow morning they could go back to their usual routines. A month later, Alejandra sat inside of a dimly lit acupuncture spa that smelled like incense. Her daughter, Maggie, was lying on a massage table in the center of the room, looking completely calm as an acupuncturist pressed thin needles into her forehead. Alejandra tried not to flinch as she watched. She was very squeamish about needles and was impressed by how little they seemed to bother Maggie. In fact, this was the calmest Maggie had looked in weeks. She wasn't coughing at all. Generally, Maggie's cough had gotten drastically worse. Most of the time she was coughing about every four seconds. She coughed all day long from the time she woke up to the moment she fell asleep. Somehow, Maggie could sleep through the night without coughing, but the rest of the time, she coughed incessantly. Maggie also said that her nose, throat, and stomach all hurt, which only made sense to Alejandra. She estimated that Maggie was coughing more than 10,000 times a day. Alejandra was genuinely scared for Maggie's health, and so at this point, she was basically willing to try anything to help her daughter. And since Western medicine did not seem to be solving Maggie's cough, Alejandra had decided to try something different. Acupuncture. And so far, the acupuncture appeared to be working. Maggie's cough went away while the acupuncturist placed the needles around her body. Alejandra had no idea why this treatment seemed to work when so many others had failed, but she was not about to question it. After the acupuncturist had finished applying all the needles, they slowly began to take them back out again. She had Maggie breathe in deeply and sit upright as she worked. Alejandra felt relieved they'd actually found a treatment that seemed to work. However, after all the needles were out and Maggie got off the table, she immediately began to cough. Two and a half months after that, Alejandra sat in a hospital examination room watching a neurologist test her daughter's coordination skills. The doctor had Maggie mimic his movements as he balanced on each foot and tapped his nose and did a few dance moves. Maggie laughed in between coughs as she followed his choreography. It was it was clear the doctor was good at working with kids, and Alejandra was grateful for that because it had been a long day. They'd been at the hospital since that morning, putting Maggie through a battery of physical exams, lab tests and imaging scans. The doctors wanted to explore every possibility because at this point, Maggie was coughing an average of over 15,000 times a day. Alejandra did her best to put on a brave face in front of her daughter, but inside she was a mess. For sure, she was terrified that something mysterious and potentially deadly was making her daughter ill. But Alejandra had to admit that she was also very stressed about all the work she'd been missing to make all of these doctor's appointments. Eventually she would have to clock a lot of extra hours just to catch up, which meant more time away from Maggie. Now she would do anything for her daughter, but physically and emotionally, she was reaching a breaking point. At some point, the neurologist told Maggie to have a seat, and then he bent over his clipboard to scribble a few notes. Alejandra held her breath, hoping the doctor would have some kind of news, but instead he said there was nothing wrong with Maggie's coordination skills. However, the neurologist said he had a theory about what might be wrong with her. There was one last specialist he wanted Maggie to go see. A week later, Dr. Daniela Vega took notes while her new patient, Maggie, sat at the kid sized table in her office, coughing away as she worked on a puzzle. Dr. Vega was a psychologist, and Maggie had been referred to her office by the neurologist at the hospital. Dr. Vega asked Maggie to describe her symptoms. Between coughs, Maggie told her that her nose and throat hurt, her stomach ached, and sometimes she got these tingly sensations in her thumbs and pinky fingers. She said she coughed all day long, except for when she was sleeping or receiving acupuncture treatments. Dr. Vega made a few notes while Maggie continued to cough and work on her puzzle. But just a moment later, Maggie clearly stopped doing her puzzle and let out a huff like she was bored with the puzzle. And with this appointment, Dr. Vega asked a few follow up questions, but now Maggie's answers were short. There was an edge of annoyance in her voice, but to Dr. Vega, it made sense. Maggie had been to so many doctors at this point, she'd very likely answered all these questions dozens of times, yet still she was coughing. As Dr. Vega watched Maggie cough, she noticed she had a little routine. Maggie would scratch her nose, then squint and then cough. Every few seconds she'd scratch, squint, cough, over and over like clockwork. Dr. Bega made a note of it. Then the doctor put her clipboard down and asked Maggie what kind of music she listened to and what her friends were like at school. Maggie looked surprised, but she started telling Dr. Vega all about her classmates, her favorite subjects at school, and what she wanted to be when she grew up. Suddenly, Maggie was animated and engaged and seemed to love how intently Dr. Vega was listening to her. And while she was talking, Maggie barely coughed. Dr. Vega scribbled down a few more notes on her clipboard and thanked Maggie for sharing so much with her. Then she led Maggie back out to the waiting room, where her mother was busy typing out emails on her phone. Alejandra stuffed her phone into her bag and rushed over to her daughter to ask how it went. Maggie very eagerly told her mother all about how she and Dr. Vega had talked about school and all the different things going on in her life and how fun the appointment was. And then after that, Dr. Vega asked them to wait for just a few minutes while she ducked into her office. She just wanted to reread Maggie's case file to make sure that the hunch she was forming was correct. Once she was back in her office, Dr. Vega pulled up Maggie's medical history. Specifically, she wanted to read the section about Maggie's case of pneumonia when she was only 18 months old. Dr. Vega suspected that there was nothing physically wrong with Maggie. Rather, her persistent cough was actually a vocal tic, a completely psychological phenomenon. The conversation she had just had with Maggie about her friends and about school and what she wanted to be when she grew up tipped off the psychologist. When Maggie was talking about things that interested her, she coughed less. The cough also disappeared completely when she slept, which would not necessarily happen if this cough was caused by an infection. But perhaps most importantly, Maggie didn't seem worried about her cough or about trying to get better. It was almost like she subconsciously knew that she wasn't actually really sick. Dr. Vega suspected that part of what brought on this tic was Maggie's severe case of pneumonia when she was a toddler. When she was ill, her mother, Alejandra, had slowed down and paid way more attention to her. And then, ever since, anytime Maggie had a cough or flu like symptoms, once again her mother would be extra attentive. Dr. Vega was pretty sure that subconsciously, Maggie was coughing to get attention from her mother, who seemed to be constantly overloaded with her work. And so while Maggie's cough was actually real in the sense that she really did feel this need to cough, the underlying reason for it was not physical. It was all in her head. Once Dr. Vega delivered this diagnosis, Maggie was treated with a low dose of an antipsychotic as well as daily talk therapy that included breathing and muscle control exercises. After only a week of treatment, Maggie's cough rate decreased from almost 1,000 coughs an hour to just about 40. Then her doctors decided to try her on a different antipsychotic, and after only 12 days on it, Maggie stopped coughing altogether.
Narrator
Inspired by the hit Wondery podcast Against the Odds comes the gripping guidebook how to Survive against the Odds Tales and Tips for Animal Attacks and Natural Disasters. This might just be the most important book you'll ever read. Go inside life or death situations where everyday people survived nature's most extreme scenarios and learn how you can too. In these tales, you'll hear about the grit, willpower and know how needed to endure shipwrecks, alligator attacks, earthquakes and more. You'll learn from experts, including top doctors, about what happens to your body and mind in life threatening situations, plus important tips on what to do and equally important, what not to do when faced with a situation that is truly against the odds. Go to www.survivalguidebook.com to get your copy of how to Survive against the Odds today or visit your favorite bookstore.
Luke LaManna
Medical Mysteries Fans I've got a story.
Mr. Ballin
That'S right up your alley.
Luke LaManna
In a recent episode of Declassified Mysteries, which was titled the Secret of Churchill's Anthrax island, host Luke LaManna reveals how Winston Churchill ordered a top secret biological weapons program on a remote Scottish island during World War II. What began as a classified experiment turned deadly and decades later, a mysterious group called Dark Harvest forced the government to confront its toxic past. And this is just one of many declassified stories on this podcast called Redacted that will fascinate all you medical mysteries listeners. So go ahead and search for declassified.
Mr. Ballin
Mysteries wherever you get your podcasts.
Luke LaManna
And remember, you can listen to both redacted and medical mysteries early and ad free with a wondery subscription.
Mr. Ballin
And now here's our second story called the Putrid Smell In August 1986, on the first day of first grade, six year old Eloise Taylor walked into her brand new elementary school. She felt excited to be around all these people her own age. She'd been looking forward to meeting her classmates all summer and couldn't wait to make friends. She got in line with all the other kids in her class and followed her new teacher, Ms. Brody, down the hall to their classroom. Ms. Brody gave Eloise the desk right at the front of the room and Eloise was determined to be her best student. She began unpacking her school supplies, then sat at her desk and turned around to say hello to the girl right behind her. But when she did, that girl just wrinkled her nose and made a face like Eloise had done something wrong. She turned her back to Eloise and started whispering to other classmates. Eloise was confused, but she didn't have time to dwell on it because Ms. Brody called for attention and began passing out a worksheet. First day of school had officially begun. Eloise listened intently as Ms. Brody began her lesson, and she figured Ms. Brody must have noticed how well she was paying attention because during the lesson, Ms. Brody kept pausing to look over at Eloise. Eloise sat up a little straighter, confident she was making a great first impression, and so she wasn't surprised when Ms. Brody tapped her on the shoulder right after lunch and asked her to join her in the hallway. She figured she was going to tell her what a good job she was doing, but once they were in the hallway, Ms. Brody crouched down and asked her if she had taken a bath the night before. Eloise was confused, but nodded and said yes. Ms. Brody just pursed her lips like she wasn't sure if Eloise was actually telling her the truth. She asked Eloise a few more questions about her hygiene, like if she bathed every night, how many times a day she brushed her teeth, that sort of thing. Eloise did her best to answer, feeling more and more like she was in trouble for something except she couldn't understand what she'd done wrong. As soon as they went back into the classroom, Ms. Brody announced that they were all going to move desks. She'd made a new seating chart. During lunch, Eloise dutifully emptied out her desk and waited as Ms. Brody gave out the new seating assignments. She called Eloise last, and she put her all the way in the back corner of the classroom, right by an open window. Eloise felt like the whole class was staring at her as she shoved her books into her new desk. As soon as she sat down, the kid right in front of her began inching his desk forward like he was trying to put space between them. Eloise didn't understand why nobody in her class wanted to be near her, so for the rest of the day, she just kept to herself. When the final bell rang at 2pm, Eloise shoved her homework into her backpack as her classmates began filing out of the class. Some of the boys passed by her desk on their way out the door, and each one of them whispered fish as they walked by. Eloise didn't really know what they meant, but her face still went red hot. She tried to linger behind the rest of the class as they all walked to the parking lot to wait for their parents, but one of the girls turned around and told Eloise out loud that she smelled like manure. Then a couple of boys started chanting, dead fish, dead fish over and over again. Eloise immediately burst into tears. Luckily, she saw her dad's car right at the front of the pickup line, and so she sprinted right over to it. She climbed into the passenger seat and told her dad what happened, that her new classmates hated her. Her dad let out a long, apologetic sigh, almost like he'd been expecting this. Then he told Eloise that for some reason, ever since she was little, she would occasionally start smelling like fish. Her doctors had no idea why this was happening. It was just something she was born with. Eloise was stunned. She wanted to know why her parents had never told her about this, but her dad didn't have a good answer. He just said that they didn't want her to worry about it before it became a problem. Eloise was quiet for the rest of the ride home. She couldn't smell this fish odor herself, but clearly it was strong enough to stink up her entire classroom. And now she had no idea how she was going to go back to school and face the same ridicule every day. Over the next several years, Eloise tried to keep to herself. But some of her classmates still bullied her. And when she entered middle school, the bullying only got worse. One afternoon in sixth grade, Eloise was headed to class when a couple of 8th graders cornered her in the cafeteria. They threw tuna fish sandwiches at her and laughed about how bad she smelled. Their taunting drew a crowd and suddenly the whole hallway seemed to be laughing at her. Eloise tried hard not to cry, but. But holding back the tears took so much concentration that she didn't have the energy to fight back or walk away. She just stood there, taking the ridicule until the school librarian stepped in and told everyone to go to class. The librarian shielded Eloise until the hallway cleared out. Then she invited her to clean up in the bathroom and come have lunch in the library. Eloise nodded, her whole body shaking with adrenaline. She couldn't take the bullying anymore. She had to figure out what was causing the fish odor and find a way to make it stop. From that day on, Eloise ate lunch in the library. Though there were no computers in the school at the time, the librarian helped Eloise comb through the school's collection of encyclopedias and other textbooks to try to find a cure. However, two years later, by the time Eloise graduated eighth grade, she hadn't found anything and doctors weren't able to help either. Nobody was able to figure out why Eloise smelled so bad. Eight years later, around 2003, Eloise sat down at a workstation at the local bank. She was newly graduated from college and working on her master's degree in education. Her dream was to become a teacher, but in the meantime, she had gotten a job as a bank teller. Eloise sprayed herself with the perfume she kept in her bottom drawer, then logged into her computer. She quickly got so absorbed in her work that she didn't notice her supervisor walking up to her desk. He tapped on her shoulder and told her to pack up her things and follow him. He had some new responsibilities for her. Eloise smiled, but she had a sinking feeling in her stomach. She followed her supervisor to the very back of the bank, to an isolated room with a big window. He told her she was going to be the drive thru bank teller from now on. Eloise knew the real reason she had been moved here. She felt defeated. This was like first grade all over again when she got moved to the back of the class on day one. A moment later, she could hear the soft hiss of a Lysol spray bottle down the hallway. And she knew that some of her colleagues must be spraying down her old workstation with air freshener. Eloise knew her fishy odor would eventually become a problem at work. Even though she showered multiple times a day and constantly coated herself with perfume, the odor was just too overpowering. She couldn't blame her co workers for not wanting to be around her. Eloise's odor was the reason she didn't have any friends, and it made her feel like she was a burden to her family. She didn't let herself get close to anyone. She'd tried dating someone recently who promised he was okay with her smell, but she worried that he'd eventually get sick of it. So she actually ended things before he could. And now she sat on the metal stool in front of the bank's drive thru window and tried not to take it personally. When her supervisor shut the door on his way out, she knew there was no escaping her odor, but she was beginning to realize what that truly meant for the rest of her life. If she didn't find a way to mask it or control it, this would be her future. Complete isolation as she watched the world pass her by. In the early hours of December 4, 2024, CEO Brian Thompson stepped out onto the streets of midtown Manhattan. This assailant starts firing at him and the suspect he has been identified as Luigi Nicolas Mangioni became one of the most evil, divisive figures in modern criminal history. I was meant to sow terror.
Cassie Depechel
He's awoken the people to a true issue.
Mr. Ballin
Listen to Law and Crime's Luigi Exclusively on Wondery. You can join Wondery in the Wondery app, Spotify or Apple Podcasts Every big.
Meisha Brown
Moment starts with a big dream. But what happens when that big dream turns out to be a big flop? From Wondery and Ill Media, I'm Meisha Brown, and this is the Big Flop. Every week, comedians join me to chronicle the biggest flubs, fails, and blunders of all time. Like Quibi.
Mr. Ballin
It's kind of like when you give yourself your own nickname and you try to, like, get other people to do it.
Meisha Brown
And the 2019 movie adaptation of Cats.
Narrator
Like, if I'm watching the dancing and I'm noticing the feet aren't touching the ground, there's something wrong with the movie.
Meisha Brown
Find out what happens when massive hype turns into major fiasco. Enjoy the Big Flop on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to the Big Flop early and ad free on Wondery. Plus get started with your free trial@wondery.com plus.
Mr. Ballin
The following year, in the fall of 2004, Eloise moved through her new classroom, opening up windows and setting up a few strategically placed fans. A few months earlier, Eloise had finally finished her master's in education and got a job teaching middle school. She hoped that as a teacher, she could make life better for any kids who faced bullying like she had. All through school, she was still nervous about her odor. But she had a plan. If the windows stayed open and she could keep air blowing at her, nobody would notice the fish smell. This would work, she thought. It had to. Soon her class filed in, and she began with the day's lesson. She kept checking over her shoulder, but nobody was making a face or sniffing the air. Everyone was bent over their desks, hard at work. She couldn't help but feel excited. It was working. Nobody could smell her. The following morning, Eloise doused herself in perfume, then got to school early to spray the classroom with air freshener and turn on the fans. And that day, once again, nobody mentioned a fish smell. By the time the lunch bell rang, she was overjoyed. Finally, after more than two decades of dealing with her odor, she'd found a way to mask it. Once Eloise's classroom had cleared out, she walked around with the Lysol can again and then headed over to the teacher's lounge. It was just across the hall from the cafeteria, so the teachers could usually hear their students talking while they waited in line for lunch. Eloise sat down at a table near the door and began to unpack her lunch bag. And as she did, she heard a few students talking about their summer breaks and their new classmates. Then she heard a student say he had the new teacher, Ms. Fishy. The students around him laughed and said they knew exactly what he was talking about. That afternoon, Eloise couldn't focus on her lesson. She kept stumbling over her words or forgetting what she was writing on the chalkboard, or all she could think about was whether she was filling the classroom with that pungent, reeking smell. Every noise a student made felt like a stifled laugh at her expense. She was so stressed out that when she finally got into her car after school, she just broke down and cried. Over the years, Eloise had seen countless specialists about her condition, and she'd continued to do her own research even while she was studying, all the time for her master's degree. But nothing helped. She felt trapped and utterly defeated. She'd spent most of her childhood crying on the way home from school, and now it appeared like she might spend the rest of her career the same way, too. For the rest of the week, Eloise was so preoccupied by her smell that she could barely teach. Then it got even worse. On Friday, when her fish odor stank up the entire auditorium during a school assembly, she was a laughingstock and was so discouraged that that she just couldn't continue like this. Before she left school on Friday afternoon, she headed to the principal's office and resigned. A month later, Eloise sat on her couch, feeling down. A random sitcom rerun was playing on her television, but she wasn't paying any attention to it. She was on her computer, scrolling mindlessly through a website with comedy videos. Eloise hadn't used the Internet very much until she started her master's program, since the Internet was still a newer technology. But now she was making up for lost time. Lately, she would spend hours on different comedy sites, trying to distract herself from what a freak she felt like. For the past few weeks, Eloise had been thinking more and more about suicide. She had no friends. She didn't feel like she had a future. She couldn't even bring herself to look for another job. She was at rock bottom. She clicked on another comedy video, wishing she were tired enough to go to sleep. And that's when she saw an advertisement at the bottom of a webpage for a site called Ask Jeeves, which was one of the leading search engines in the early days of the Internet. You could ask a digital butler named Jeeves any question, and he would comb the Internet for answers. Eloise was intrigued. She clicked on the banner and then typed into the search bar fishy body Odor. After hitting return, she didn't expect much. But then a couple of links began popping up. Eloise bolted upright as she clicked on the top result. It brought her to a website that described an extremely rare condition called trimethylaminuria, or TMAU for short, although apparently it was more commonly known as fish odor syndrome. It's a metabolic disorder where the body can't break down a smelly chemical called trimethylamine. The body produces the chemical when a person eats certain foods like bread, beans, eggs, and, of course, fish. And because people like Eloise can't break down this chemical, it builds up in their system and seeps into their lungs, saliva, sweat, and other bodily fluids, causing a pungent smell that comes from inside. When Eloise discovered this, there were only 600 documented cases of the syndrome in the entire world. And so eloise became number 601. After some more searching, Eloise found an online community of people living with this rare condition. They helped her learn how to manage her odor by changing her diet and taking daily supplements like chlorophyll, which may help reduce inflammation in the body. Eloise also met a doctor who understood fish odor syndrome, and they helped her find the best perfumes and deodorants to help mask the smell. And surprisingly, these steps she was taking as a result of this community worked. People stopped making fun of Eloise, and slowly she became confident enough to have friends and go out socially. After nearly 30 years of struggling with this putrid smell, Eloise found a way to lead a mostly normal life. She ultimately went back to teaching, determined to create a special curriculum for students who were different in any way to make sure that nobody suffered the same kind of ridicule that she did.
Luke LaManna
Now that you've finished this episode, I know you will love what Luke Lamanna is doing over at Declassified Mysteries. Go ahead and start with the episode titled the Secret of Churchill's Anthrax Island. It's a chilling tale of biological weapons and government secrets that's perfect for medical mystery fans just like you.
Mr. Ballin
From Ballin Studios and wondery. This is Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries, hosted by me, Mr. Ballin, a quick note about our stories they're all inspired by true events, but we sometimes use pseudonyms to protect the people involved, and some details are fictionalized for dramatic purposes. And a reminder, the content in this episode is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. This episode was written by Natalie Przovsky. Our editor is Heather Dundas. Sound design is by Andre Plus. Our senior managing producer is Callum Plews and our coordinating producer is Sara Mathis. Our senior producer is Alex Benedon. Our associate producers and researchers are Sarah Vitak and Teja Palakonda. Fact checking was done by Sheila Patterson for Ballin Studios. Our head of production is Zach Levitt. Script editing by Scott, Scott Allen and Evan Allen. Our coordinating producer is Samantha Collins. Production support by Avery Siegel. Executive producers are myself, Mr. Ballin and Nick Witters. For Wondry. Our head of sound is Marcelino Villapando. Senior producers are Laura, Donna Palavota and Dave Schilling. Senior managing producer is Ryan Lohr and our executive producers are Aaron o' Flaherty and Marshall Louie. For Wondri.
Narrator
Behind the closed doors of government offices and military compounds, there are hidden stories and buried secrets from the darkest corners of history. From COVID experiments pushing the boundaries of science to operations so secretive they were barely whispered about. Each week, unredacted Declassified mysteries we pull back the curtain on These hidden histories, 100% true and verifiable stories that expose the shadowy underbelly of power. Consider Operation Paperclip, where former Nazi scientists were brought to America after World War II not as prisoners but as assets to advance US intelligence during the Cold War. These aren't just old conspiracy theories, they're thoroughly investigated accounts that reveal the uncomfortable truths. Still shaping our world Today day. The stories are real. The secrets are shocking. Follow Redacted Declassified Mysteries on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to Redacted early and ad free right now on Wonder Plus.
MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries: Episode 88 | "15,000 Coughs/The Putrid Smell"
Release Date: June 10, 2025
Host/Author: Wondery | Ballen Studios
Duration: Approximately 33 minutes
In Episode 88 of MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries, host Mr. Ballin delves into two gripping medical horror stories that highlight the profound impact chronic conditions can have on individuals' lives. These narratives explore the complexities of diagnosing elusive ailments and the emotional turmoil that accompanies prolonged suffering. Below is a detailed summary of both stories, enriched with notable quotes and timestamps for deeper insight.
Overview: The first story centers on Maggie Soto, an 11-year-old girl plagued by an incessant cough that reaches up to 15,000 coughs a day. Despite numerous medical consultations, her condition remains bafflingly unresolved for years.
Key Events:
Initial Symptoms (00:00 - 14:34):
Escalation and Desperation:
Comprehensive Medical Evaluation (12:00 - 14:34):
Psychological Revelation:
Dr. Vega (14:34): "Maggie subconsciously coughs to gain attention from her mother, who has been overwhelmed with work."
Treatment and Recovery:
Insights and Conclusions: Maggie's case underscores the intricate interplay between psychological factors and physical symptoms. It highlights the importance of considering psychological diagnoses in unexplained medical conditions and the profound impact that mental health can have on physical well-being.
Overview: The second narrative follows Eloise Taylor, a woman who has suffered from chronic fish odor syndrome (Trimethylaminuria) since childhood. Her condition leads to relentless bullying and social isolation, severely affecting her self-esteem and quality of life.
Key Events:
Early Onset and Bullying (16:22 - 24:55):
Eloise's Father (16:22): "For some reason, ever since she was little, she would occasionally start smelling like fish... we didn't want her to worry about it before it became a problem."
Adolescence and Continued Struggles:
Career Impact and Isolation:
Discovering the Diagnosis (24:55 - 32:08):
Eloise's Realization (24:55): "I couldn't smell this fish odor myself, but clearly it was strong enough to stink up her entire classroom."
Community and Management:
Resolution and Advocacy:
Insights and Conclusions: Eloise's journey illustrates the profound effects of rare metabolic disorders on an individual's social and professional life. It emphasizes the importance of awareness, early diagnosis, and community support in managing chronic conditions. Eloise's transformation from a socially isolated individual to an empowered advocate highlights the resilience of the human spirit when provided with the right resources and support systems.
Episode 88 of MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries poignantly portrays the struggles of two young individuals grappling with persistent medical conditions that significantly impede their daily lives. Through Maggie's and Eloise's stories, the podcast sheds light on the often-overlooked psychological dimensions of chronic illnesses and the societal challenges faced by those with rare medical conditions. These narratives not only underscore the importance of comprehensive medical evaluations but also advocate for empathy and support for individuals enduring such relentless health battles.
Notable Quotes:
Dr. Daniela Vega on Maggie's Condition (14:34):
"Maggie subconsciously coughs to gain attention from her mother, who has been overwhelmed with work."
Eloise's Father on Her Condition (16:22):
"For some reason, ever since she was little, she would occasionally start smelling like fish... we didn't want her to worry about it before it became a problem."
Eloise Reflecting on Her Future (00:26:00):
"If I don't find a way to mask it or control it, this would be my future. Complete isolation as I watch the world pass me by."
Disclaimer: All stories featured in this episode are inspired by true events but may include fictionalized elements for dramatic purposes. The content is not intended to substitute professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
This summary is crafted to provide a comprehensive overview of Episode 88 of MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries, capturing the essence and emotional depth of the stories while highlighting critical moments and insights shared through the podcast.