Murder in the Moonlight: Episode 1 - In Cold Blood
Hosted by Keith Morrison
Release Date: February 17, 2025
Introduction: A Quiet Night on the Great Plains
Keith Morrison opens the episode by painting a vivid picture of a serene night on the Nebraska plains under a nearly full moon. The tranquility of the farmhouse in Murdoch is disrupted when two individuals arrive, setting the stage for the unfolding nightmare.
[00:03] Keith Morrison: "This is a story about fear."
The Stock Family: Pillars of the Community
The Stocks, Charmin and Wayne, are introduced as the epitome of traditional American values. They are fifth-generation farmers who have dedicated their lives to the land and their family. Their commitment to community and family is highlighted through anecdotes about their involvement in their children's lives and the meticulous care Charmin takes in maintaining their home.
[05:28] Andy Stock: "Very. They touched the lives of so many people."
Their two sons, Steve and Andy, are portrayed as responsible and loving individuals, deeply influenced by their parents' teachings about responsibility and moral living.
[06:47] Steve Stock: "One thing I always heard from mom was take responsibility for your actions, be responsible."
Easter Sunday: The Last Day of Peace
The narrative details the family's annual Easter egg hunt, emphasizing the harmony and joy that characterized the Stock household. This particular Easter, held on April 16, 2006, is depicted as the last peaceful day before tragedy strikes.
[04:37] Keith Morrison: "Tammy found their Easter baskets. Mom always made every individual Easter basket special to that child."
The absence of Andy on this Easter is noted, as he was visiting his future in-laws, leaving his puppy behind. This seemingly minor detail becomes crucial in the timeline of the events that follow.
The Night of the Murder: Discovery and Shock
Steve Stock recounts the unsettling events of the following morning. Upon arriving at the family farm to start spring planting, he notices unusual signs—his father's truck in the shop and his father's absence from his usual routine.
[09:07] Steve Stock: "I drove in and I went in the shop on the farm and dad's pickup was there, which I thought was a little bit strange."
As Steve investigates further, he discovers blood on the walls and realizes the gravity of the situation. Overwhelmed by shock, he exits the house to call for help, leaving Andy as the sole person present at the crime scene.
[11:42] Tammy Stock: "What."
Immediate Aftermath: Family in Disbelief
Andy Stock struggles to process the horror of finding his parents dead in their bedroom. His initial shock leaves him unable to recall detailed memories of the event, making him a person of interest in the investigation.
[17:09] Steve Stock: "Before I even saw Steve and Tammy, they had put me in a car and took me to another town and questioned me in a room."
The Investigation: Unraveling Clues
CSI Commander David Cofode leads the complex investigation, uncovering a brutal and meticulously executed crime scene. Multiple clues point to the involvement of at least two perpetrators:
-
Shotgun Evidence: The use of a 12-gauge shotgun with distinct blood spatter patterns indicating multiple shooters.
[20:23] David Cofode: "When we did the blood pattern analysis, we saw a void area at the top of the steps."
-
Physical Evidence: A unique shoe print near the front door, a blood-splattered flashlight, and a marijuana pipe found in the gravel driveway.
[21:26] David Cofode: "I saw a shoe print in the mud that was unusual, by a flower bed near the front door."
-
Eyewitness Testimony: A newspaper carrier reports seeing a suspicious tan-colored four-door sedan parked near the farm around the time of the murders and then fleeing the scene at high speed.
[21:43] David Cofode: "It was there. And I think the one thing I knew pretty much right at the beginning was that I could see, visibly see blood on the outside of the flashlight."
The Breakthrough: Uncovering the Truth
Despite a seemingly random and motive-less act—nothing valuable was taken, and the safe remained untouched—the investigation takes a pivotal turn. A golden ring found at the scene becomes the "golden key" to unraveling the mystery, leading investigators to consider all possible suspects, including family members.
[22:04] David Cofode: "It was there. And I think the one thing I knew pretty much right at the beginning was that I could see, visibly see blood on the outside of the flashlight."
The Arrest: A Family Betrayal
Within a week, mounting evidence and intense questioning lead to a shocking revelation—a member of the Stock family is arrested and confesses to the murders. The intricate web of family dynamics, possible motives, and hidden secrets comes to light, hinting at deep-seated issues that ultimately culminated in tragedy.
[24:30] Keith Morrison: "Well, I was upset at a loss of why my own cousin could do this to me. And you said, what? You gotta be kidding."
Conclusion: Justice in the Making
The episode concludes by highlighting the complexity of the case and the role of meticulous investigation in achieving justice. The arrest marks the beginning of resolving the mystery behind the brutal murders, with promises of deeper exploration in future episodes.
[25:02] Keith Morrison: "Murder in the moonlight is a production of Dateline and NBC News."
Key Themes and Insights
-
Family Dynamics and Secrets: The Stocks appeared to be the ideal family, yet underlying tensions and secrets played a critical role in the tragedy.
-
Community Impact: The murders shook the small town of Murdoch, a close-knit community unaccustomed to such violence.
-
Methodical Investigation: The episode underscores the importance of detail-oriented investigative work in solving complex crimes.
-
Shock and Trauma: The personal accounts of Steve and Andy Stock provide a poignant look into the immediate emotional aftermath of witnessing such a loss.
Notable Quotes
-
"[00:03] Keith Morrison: This is a story about fear."
-
"[06:47] Steve Stock: One thing I always heard from mom was take responsibility for your actions, be responsible."
-
"[20:23] David Cofode: When we did the blood pattern analysis, we saw a void area at the top of the steps."
-
"[24:30] Keith Morrison: Well, I was upset at a loss of why my own cousin could do this to me. And you said, what? You gotta be kidding."
Looking Ahead
Murder in the Moonlight promises to delve deeper into the intricate details of the case, exploring the motives behind the murders and the impact on the surviving family members and community. Future episodes will uncover more about the "golden key" and the secrets that led to this heart-wrenching crime.
Subscribe to Dateline Premium on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or visit DatelinePremium.com to listen to this episode and gain early access to all new content, ad-free.