Murder in the Moonlight: Episode 2 - Keep Your Enemies Close

Introduction and Parallels to "In Cold Blood"

In the second episode of Murder in the Moonlight, host Keith Morrison draws a compelling parallel between the tragic murders of the Stock family and Truman Capote's seminal true crime novel, In Cold Blood. Highlighting the similarities between the Clutter family and the Stocks, Morrison sets the stage for a deep dive into a case that echoes the unsettling narrative of In Cold Blood. He reflects, “In Cold Blood was as famous as a book could be... there were heated disagreements, said Charman disliked Matt” (03:26).

The Stock Family's Tragedy

The serene life of the Stock family on America’s Great Plains was shattered one Easter night in 1959 when Sharmon and Wayne Stock were brutally shot to death in their farmhouse. Their children, Tammy and Steve Stock, grappled with a tumultuous mix of emotions following the murders. The family’s grief culminated in a massive funeral held at Murdoch High School gymnasium, which was "packed to the rafters" with over 2,000 mourners (03:34). Steve recounts the overwhelming scene: “It was just like, holy cow. It was just packed with people. It was really overwhelming” (03:41), while Tammy describes the Stocks as “pillars of the community” (03:26).

Suspect Focus: Matt Livers

As the investigation unfolded, suspicion naturally fell on Matt Livers, Wayne and Sharmon’s 28-year-old nephew. Unlike the industrious Stocks, Matt was considered the black sheep of the family, often bouncing between dead-end jobs and living with his grandmother. Steve Stock shares familial tensions, stating, “Had a lot of falling outs about him staying with grandma and dad” (06:10). Despite Uncle Wayne’s efforts to help Matt, his lack of direction and strained relationships within the family made him a prime suspect.

Interrogation and Confession

Detectives delved into Matt’s background, noting his erratic behavior and strained relations with the family. On April 25, eight days after the murders, Matt was brought in for questioning. Initially cooperative, Matt claimed he was with his girlfriend in Lincoln, Nebraska, during the time of the murders, a statement he would vehemently deny under pressure. During a lengthy interrogation, Matt agreed to take a polygraph test, believing it would exonerate him. However, the polygraph results indicated deception, leading detectives to persist in their questioning. Under intense pressure, Matt broke down, admitting his involvement: “You got a gun right along, right?... Right” (17:47). He detailed his actions, stating, “Put the gun to her face and blew her away... I was already fired up and, you know, had a grudge” (18:13).

Accomplice: Nick Sampson

Matt’s confession revealed the involvement of Nick Sampson, a 21-year-old cousin. Despite Nick’s steadfast denial of any involvement, a subsequent polygraph test showed deception similar to Matt’s. Investigators unearthed critical evidence linking Nick to the crime, including a marijuana pipe found at the scene and a 12-gauge shotgun borrowed from his grandfather—a weapon matching the one used in the murders. Additionally, a suspiciously cleaned 1997 Ford Contour owned by Nick’s brother was discovered, containing blood evidence from Wayne Stock beneath the dashboard (27:19). Nick was ultimately charged alongside Matt, solidifying their roles as perpetrators.

Physical Evidence and CSI Breakthrough

The breakthrough in the case came through meticulous forensic work by CSI Chief David Coford. Initially, the cleaned Ford Contour yielded no evidence. However, after Matt confessed to disposing of the shotgun in the vehicle, Coford re-examined the car using sterile filter paper and discovered a bloodstain, later confirmed to be Wayne Stock’s (28:33). This physical evidence, combined with Matt’s confession and Nick’s incriminating background, provided a comprehensive case against both suspects.

Conclusion and Lingering Mystery

With Matt Livers and Nick Sampson arrested and charged, the community began to find some closure. Steve Stock expressed relief, stating, “We’re not going to wander for the rest of our lives” (21:28). However, the discovery of a mysterious gold ring at the crime scene introduces a new layer of intrigue. Inscribed with two names and three letters, the ring remains an unanswered question, hinting at deeper secrets yet to be uncovered in future episodes. Morrison hints at the significance of this clue, stating, “The key to a secret. And the start of a very strange trip” (30:58).

Notable Quotes

• Steve Stock: “It was just like, holy cow. It was just packed with people. It was really overwhelming” (03:41).
• Matt Livers: “I have absolutely nothing to do with this” (22:23).
• Matt Livers: “Put the gun to her face and blew her away... I was already fired up and, you know, had a grudge” (18:13).
• Steve Stock: “...police are moving on to the next phase of this. We're not going to wander for the rest of our lives.” (21:28).

Looking Ahead

As the episode concludes, Morrison teases future developments with the enigmatic gold ring, promising listeners a deeper exploration into the unresolved aspects of the case. The meticulous unraveling of the Stock family murders showcases the relentless pursuit of justice, while leaving room for further mysteries to emerge.

Note: Timestamps in brackets (e.g., 03:41) refer to the corresponding moments in the podcast transcript where the quoted statements occur.