Murder, Mystery & Makeup: The Crossbow Cannibal - PhD Student and Secret Serial Killer?!
Host: Bailey Sarian
Release Date: June 3, 2025
Podcast: Murder, Mystery & Makeup by Audioboom Studios
Introduction
In this gripping episode of Murder, Mystery & Makeup, Bailey Sarian delves into the chilling case of Stephen Griffiths, infamously known as the "Crossbow Cannibal." Blending her passion for true crime with her expertise in makeup artistry, Bailey navigates the dark corridors of Bradford, England, uncovering the life and heinous crimes of a man who meticulously concealed his monstrous deeds behind the facade of academic achievement.
Early Life and Background
Steven Shawn Griffiths was born on December 24, 1969, in Dewsbury, West Riding of Yorkshire, England. Raised in a fragmented household, Steve's parents divorced when he was 13, leading him and his siblings to live with their mother, Moira De Worst—a phone switchboard operator who was later arrested for fraud. This period marked the beginning of financial struggles and emotional distress for Steven.
Bailey notes, “Steven was the oldest of three children, attending Queen Elizabeth Grammar School in Wakefield, a testament to his early academic prowess.”
Early Signs of Criminality
Steven's abnormal behavior began to surface during his school years. Classmates described him as peculiar:
“Steven was fascinated by martial arts magazines and also weapons. He even carried a knife in his briefcase.”
—Classmate Martin (02:15)
His peculiar interests included skinning birds and harming animals, indicating a deep-seated cruelty from a young age. These red flags were evident, yet unnoticed by authorities.
In June 1987, at 18, Steven's aggression culminated when he was arrested for shoplifting and assaulting a supermarket manager with his knife, resulting in a three-year youth custody sentence.
Escalation of Crimes
Upon his release in 1990, Steven's obsessive fascination with serial killers intensified. He pursued a Bachelor of Science in psychology at Leeds University, excelling academically while nurturing dark inclinations. Despite multiple encounters with the psychiatric system, where he was diagnosed with personality disorders, his aggressive tendencies remained unchecked.
Bailey recounts, “Steven openly confessed to fantasies of being a serial killer to probation officers and psychiatrists, yet the system failed to monitor him effectively” (10:45).
In 1993, after another incarceration for threatening a girl's life, Steven continued to manipulate those around him, including romantic partners, with controlling and abusive behaviors.
Life in Bradford and Behavioral Changes
By 1996, Steven had moved into Holmfield Court in Bradford's red-light district, a hub frequented by sex workers—a trait that would later play a pivotal role in his crimes. His eccentric behavior earned him the nickname "Lizard Man" from neighbors, due to his obsession with reptiles, which he carried on leashes during neighborhood walks.
“He would always wear a long black coat and had his hair slicked back, sometimes even spiked with makeup.”
—Neighbor Observation (15:30)
This bizarre persona served as a cover for his sinister activities, blending seamlessly into the community while hunting for vulnerable victims.
The Disappearances: Susan Rushworth, Shelly Armitage, and Suzanne Blamires
The first disappearance occurred on June 22, 2009, when 43-year-old Susan Rushworth vanished without a trace. Following months later, Shelly Armitage and Suzanne Blamires also disappeared, their cases haunting the Bradford community.
Bailey details Shelly Armitage’s disappearance:
“Shelly was last seen on CCTV at 10 PM on April 26, 2010, after going out for dinner with a friend. She never returned.”
—Bailey Sarian (20:50)
Similarly, Suzanne Blamires was last seen on May 21, 2010, leaving her flat, marking another tragic end for a woman battling addiction.
Investigation and Discovery
The turning point came when a distressed man found dismembered body parts in the River Aire, sparking fears of a serial killer. Concurrently, surveillance footage revealed Steven arriving home with Suzanne Blamires, only to violently attack her with a crossbow.
“Steven was caught on CCTV holding a crossbow, attempting to shoot Suzanne. It was a horrifying revelation.”
—Bailey Sarian (22:10)
Further investigation linked Steven to the murders through DNA evidence found in his apartment and the discovery of a phone containing recorded footage of his crimes.
Arrest and Confession
On May 24, 2010, equipped with substantial evidence, police arrested Steven Griffiths. He confessed to the murders of Susan Rushworth, Shelly Armitage, and Suzanne Blamires, revealing a gruesome pattern of violence and cannibalism.
“Sometimes you kill someone to kill yourself or kill part of yourself. I have deep issues inside of me.”
—Steven Griffiths (25:30)
Despite his chilling admissions, he withheld information about additional victims and the location of Susan Rushworth’s remains, leaving families without closure.
Trial and Conviction
Steven's trial commenced on December 21, 2010, where overwhelming evidence led to his conviction. The courtroom was shaken as CCTV footage and DNA evidence underscored his guilt. The defense's attempt to blame systemic failures was dismissed by the judge, resulting in a life sentence without the possibility of parole.
“The system failed to act on the early warnings, but justice has been served.”
—Judge’s Statement (27:45)
Aftermath and Current Status
Since his conviction, Steven Griffiths remains incarcerated. Multiple suicide attempts and a severe attack by another prisoner in 2019 highlight his continued volatile state. The unresolved disappearance of Susan Rushworth remains a haunting void in his criminal legacy.
Bailey reflects on the systemic shortcomings:
“All the signs were there, but without concrete evidence, nothing could be done sooner. It’s a tragic reminder of the gaps in our protective measures.”
—Bailey Sarian (28:50)
Conclusion
The story of Stephen Griffiths serves as a harrowing example of how intelligence and charm can mask profound darkness. Bailey Sarian masterfully unpacks the complexities of his life, shedding light on the indicators that were overlooked and the devastating consequences that ensued. This episode stands as a stark reminder of the importance of vigilance and the perils of underestimated red flags in preventing such tragedies.
Notable Quotes:
- Martin (02:15): “Steven was fascinated by martial arts magazines and also weapons. He even carried a knife in his briefcase.”
- Neighbor Observation (15:30): “He would always wear a long black coat and had his hair slicked back, sometimes even spiked with makeup.”
- Bailey Sarian (20:50): “Shelly was last seen on CCTV at 10 PM on April 26, 2010, after going out for dinner with a friend. She never returned.”
- Steven Griffiths (25:30): “Sometimes you kill someone to kill yourself or kill part of yourself. I have deep issues inside of me.”
- Bailey Sarian (28:50): “All the signs were there, but without concrete evidence, nothing could be done sooner. It’s a tragic reminder of the gaps in our protective measures.”
This comprehensive summary captures the essence of the episode, providing an in-depth look into the life and crimes of Stephen Griffiths, while highlighting the critical points and discussions presented by Bailey Sarian.