Murder Sheet Podcast Summary

Episode Title: A Conversation with Peter Van Sant on "Trained to Kill," 48 Hours, and a Career Covering Murder
Release Date: April 29, 2025
Hosts: Áine Cain (Journalist) and Kevin Greenlee (Attorney)
Guest: Peter Van Sant, Correspondent for CBS's "48 Hours" and Host of the "Trained to Kill" Podcast

Introduction to the Case and Guest

In this compelling episode of Murder Sheet, hosts Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee dive deep into the mysterious disappearance of Mark Stover, a renowned dog trainer known as the "Dog Whisperer of the Pacific Northwest." The discussion centers around Peter Van Sant's in-depth reporting on the case, both through his work with CBS's 48 Hours and his new podcast, Trained to Kill.

Key Quote:
Peter Van Sant introduces his dedication to the case by stating, “[...] it's an affront to me, an affront to my gateway to paradise, to where I still go every summer, to these islands. And I had a real stake in this story. These were my people. This is my state.” ([42:36])

Peter Van Sant’s Career Trajectory

Peter Van Sant shares an inspiring journey from his childhood in Seattle, inspired by watching Walter Cronkite, to becoming a seasoned journalist at CBS News. His career spans over four decades, covering significant global events such as the Gulf War and the collapse of the Soviet Union. Van Sant emphasizes his passion for investigative journalism and his commitment to uncovering the truth.

Key Quote:
Reflecting on his early aspirations, Van Sant remarks, “I dreamed of working at CBS News when I was in school. I was always fascinated in writing and journalism.” ([05:30])

Inside the "Trained to Kill" Case

The heart of the episode delves into the perplexing disappearance of Mark Stover in October 2009. Van Sant recounts the initial discovery of blood at Stover's residence and the subsequent investigation that unearthed a tangled web involving Stover, his ex-wife Linda Updike, and her new boyfriend Michael Oakes.

Case Overview:

• Mark Stover: A beloved dog trainer with a troubled past, including the loss of his father and sister at a young age, leading to a tumultuous upbringing.
• Linda Updike: An heiress from a wealthy Washington state family, who became romantically involved with Stover.
• Michael Oakes: Linda's boyfriend and self-described bodyguard, later identified as a key suspect in Stover's disappearance.

Notable Developments:

• Blood Evidence: Discovered at Stover’s home, leading Detective Dan Luvera to conclude a murder occurred.
• Stalking Threats: Linda Updike received harassing calls and voicemails from Stover post-divorce, escalating fears for her safety.
• Relationship Dynamics: The complex interplay between Stover, Updike, and Oakes reveals layers of jealousy, manipulation, and fear.

Key Quote:
Van Sant describes the eerie night-time footage captured by Updike’s security cameras: “She... found this one night around two in the morning... a ghostly image of Mark Stover... very disturbing.” ([24:35])

Journalistic Approaches and Ethical Considerations

Van Sant discusses the meticulous preparation required for such in-depth reporting. He highlights the importance of building trust with sources, conducting exhaustive homework, and maintaining an unbiased stance to allow all parties to share their narratives.

Techniques Employed:

• Trust Building: Establishing genuine relationships with sources to gain access to exclusive information.
• Comprehensive Research: Reviewing law enforcement briefings, case files, and personal histories to inform interviews.
• Balanced Reporting: Ensuring all sides of the story are heard without preconceived notions or bias.

Key Quote:
On maintaining neutrality, Van Sant states, “People are presumed innocent until found guilty. I think if I wasn't doing this, I'd be a defense attorney in life. And so I want to hear what you have to say.” ([32:20])

Challenges in Reporting True Crime

The conversation touches on the emotional and ethical challenges journalists face when covering violent and personal crimes. Van Sant emphasizes the responsibility to portray events accurately while respecting the victims and their families.

Key Points:

• Emotional Impact: Covering cases that hit close to home can be personally affecting.
• Ethical Reporting: Balancing the need for sensational stories with the dignity of those involved.

Key Quote:
Discussing the human fascination with true crime, Van Sant muses, “Crime is the canary in the mineshaft of our culture... we're all intrigued with the mystery of the human soul and conscience.” ([39:58])

Peter Van Sant’s Perspective on True Crime Fascination

Van Sant offers a profound reflection on why audiences are drawn to true crime narratives. He believes that these stories probe the depths of human nature, exploring the origins of evil and the complexities of the human psyche.

Key Quote:
He elaborates, “I find that crime is such an indicator of who we are and where we are as a people and a culture, and it is vitally important to all of us.” ([39:58])

Concluding Insights and Legacy

As the episode wraps up, Van Sant shares his personal connection to the Anacortes community and his unwavering commitment to uncovering the truth behind Stover's disappearance. He views his work as not only journalistic but also as a tribute to the community he cherishes.

Key Quote:
Van Sant concludes with heartfelt dedication, “It was an affront to me, an affront to my gateway to paradise... I was driven to get to the bottom of this and to see justice done in this case. And I believe it was.” ([42:36])

Final Thoughts

This episode of Murder Sheet offers an in-depth exploration of a perplexing true crime case through the experienced lens of Peter Van Sant. Listeners gain valuable insights into investigative journalism, the complexities of human relationships, and the enduring fascination with true crime stories.

Recommendation:
For those intrigued by meticulous true crime investigations and the stories behind high-profile cases, Trained to Kill by Peter Van Sant is highly recommended.

Notable Quotes Reference:

• [05:30] Peter Van Sant discusses his early career motivations.
• [24:35] Description of disturbing security footage.
• [32:20] Emphasis on unbiased journalism.
• [39:58] Insights into the allure of true crime.
• [42:36] Personal connection and dedication to the case.