Loading summary
Transcript155 lines
- [00:01]
Narrator
Audible's best of 2024 picks are here. Discover the year's top audiobooks, podcasts and originals in all your favorite genres, from memoirs and sci fi to mysteries and thrillers. Audible's curated list in every category is the best way to hear 2024's best in audio entertainment, like a stunning new full cast production of George Orwell's 1984 heartfelt memoirs like Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson's lovely one. The year's best fiction, like the Women by Kristin Hannah and Percival Everett's brilliantly subversive James Audible. There's more to imagine when you listen. Go to audible.com imagine and discover all the years best waiting for you.
- [00:48]
Instacart Representative
The holidays are all about sharing with family meals, couches, stories, Grandma's secret pecan pie recipe, and now you can also share a cart With Instacart family carts. Everyone can add what they want to one group cart from wherever they are so you don't have to go from room to room to find out who wants cranberry sauce or whether you should get mini marshmallows for the yams or collecting votes for sugar cookies versus shortbread. Just share a cart and then share the meals. In the moments, download the Instacart app and get delivery in as fast as 30 minutes. Plus enjoy free delivery on your first three orders. Service fees and terms apply.
- [01:27]
Credit Karma Representative
Credit Karma makes building your credit straightforward and stress free with help from our Credit Builder. Sign up today@creditkarma.com and start enhancing your financial health. Credit Karma, your partner in building a brighter financial future. Credit Builder plan, is serviced by Credit Karma Credit Builder and requires a line of credit and savings account provided by Cross river bank member fdic.
- [01:48]
Anya Kane
Content Warning this episode contains discussion of sexual crimes against children as well as rape and murder. So today our cases are actually quite far flung. We're going to be doing a case based out of Pennsylvania, one that spans between New York, Tennessee and kind of Michigan. One in Minnesota and then another one in Oregon. My name is Anya Kane.
- [02:15]
Kevin Greenlee
I'm a journalist and I'm Kevin Greenlee.
- [02:18]
Anya Kane
I'm an attorney and this is the Murder Sheet.
- [02:21]
Kevin Greenlee
We're a true crime podcast focused on original reporting, interviews and deep dives into murder cases. We are the Murder Sheet and this.
- [02:29]
Anya Kane
Is the Cheat sheet. Deep fakes and deep space for this first case. Thanks so much to our friend and listener who brought this to our attention. This is a kind of a theme story that really has unfortunately become all too commonplace and we wanted to talk about it. Our sources for this are News Nation, as well as ABC27 and LNP Lancaster online via Government Technology, which is a website. So we'll be linking to all of those so you can kind of follow along. This story comes to us from Pennsylvania. It's about a private school called the Lancaster Count Country Day School. And what happened was that In November of 2023, the school started getting some anonymous tips via their sort of app where you can report things about how a male ninth grader was making deep, fake pornographic images with artificial intelligence of numerous girls at the school. Underage girls, his fellow students. This has resulted in a lawsuit. A. A lawyer named Matthew Farranda Diedrich took on this case. He's with the law firm Royer, Cooper, Cohen and Bronfeld. He's out of, I believe, Philadelphia. And what he's alleging and what the parents of some of these girls are alleging is that the school didn't take action and call police until May of 2024. So months after the initial tip, they're saying that the school did not protect students because they didn't. You know, they were mandatory reporters. You know, since then, there's been a number of resignations and a lot of controversy. The students actually even organized a walkout where they. They felt unprotected by this. And what, you know, what's kind of come out is that, you know, a parent actually had to contact police in this case, where that's where the ball really got rolling, not through the school. So the police are also noting that they think the number of victims May number around 46, including 38 current students and maybe eight former students. So this is. This is horrifying to me. You know, there's been a lot of debate about artificial intelligence and how that technology is used. And obviously, that's a huge umbrella incorporating a lot of different, you know, types of things, from people making crummy art online to, you know, people writing in kind of soulless ways to technology that might be helpful, like identifying cancers. So, I mean, like, it's. It's a range of technology. I don't think it is necessarily helpful to kind of demonize AI as a whole, because it just can mean a lot of different things. Some of it helpful, some of it not so helpful, but it kind of. You know, we've done a lot of reporting on child sexual abuse materials and how predators can gather that. And what's scary now is that they can essentially compile that without ever needing to have access to a child, because AI has gotten better, and it can make realistic looking images. And to me, even though, you know, this, this kind of thing doesn't necessarily involve, you know, like an actual situation where a young woman or a girl is taking a picture of herself and sending it to somebody. It's still just as violating and just as disturbing for those girls involved. It's incredibly violating. It's incredibly horrifying for them and exploitative. And so it really concerns me that this sort of thing is happening. And it seems like, as usual, the government is pretty slow to react to new technology and act accordingly. What do you think?
- [07:16]
Kevin Greenlee
Yeah, raises lots of interesting issues, including issues around the First Amendment and free speech that are going to be tough to wrestle with as AI continues to grow and develop.
- [07:31]
Anya Kane
I mean, we have a situation where, you know, the alleged perpetrator in this case is not an adult man, it's a ninth grade boy, or was when this happened. He's been seemingly removed from the school. I suppose that means expulsion, but I don't feel like we've essentially taken a generation or generations of children. We've unleashed them on the Internet, we've given them free rein, which means they have access to a lot of information, which is good, but it also means that they have access to hardcore pornography. And as they're kind of coming into their own sexuality, I think that we shouldn't. That is a problem. That's not a good thing. Developing. Especially boys, they're developing into that, they're interested in sex. That's how kids are. That's, you know, that's human nature. We're not going to change that. But then we're telling them, not only can you now watch a lot of, you know, frankly, very hardcore, very exploitative pornography is probably going to short circuit your, your brain to a certain extent and make you think that this is normal sex. Not only we're going to do that, but now we're going to let you become the pornographer because you can take pictures of your classmates and put them into this AI Nexus and make realistic pornographic images and probably at some point pornographic videos with that. And that seems like not ideal. And I mean, I think having consequences for people doing this is necessary, but the genie's out of the bottle. You're not going to ban AI, you're not going to ban people from, you know, using it however they want. But I think, you know, I think you need to protect kids. And it's not just going to be girls who are having, being subjected to this. It's going to be boys too. It's going to be Young boys. And it's, I think we need to teach our kids that, you know, there needs to be some parenting here of like, you know, what kind? Like, how is this kid thinking that this is okay? I mean, like, teaching kids this is not okay. This is, you know, consent is important. You need to be an honorable, respectful young man and not be doing this. You could be interested in sex and not be exploiting other people. Like, I think being a teenager is super confusing. They're, you know, the hormones and they're kind of doing all this stuff. But I, I think that's, there needs to come from home a message of, you know, just because you have hormones, just because you're doing this doesn't mean any kind of behavior to deal with that is acceptable. I don't think we should treat this as, oh, kids are being kids. I think it, it, it's, it's predatory and dehumanizing. And I, I think for a lot of women who are older like me, like, I'm just glad I got out of high school before any of this was going on because, I mean, if this, if I were one of those girls, it would be really upsetting and really violating to me. And back then, like, you know, I, I, I feel like laws need to reflect that. And it's, it's not about saying we're putting the genie back in the bottle, but it is about saying there'll be consequences when people are taking images of underage children and mocking up pornography about it. Like, that's not acceptable behavior.
- [10:44]
Kevin Greenlee
So what kind of laws would you like to see?
- [10:47]
Anya Kane
Oh, I don't know. I mean, you have to be careful, as you said, to not just trample all over any freedom of speech. But I think, I think there can be some kind of narrowly crafted thing here where you, you make this unacceptable. Tis the season for gift giving. So support our wonderful new sponsor, Quince, and get yourself some affordable, high quality gifts. Quince is a company that specializes in making the finer things in life. Cashmere gold Italian handbags. Affordable on any budget.
- [11:17]
Kevin Greenlee
All Items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. Their wonderful line of Mongolian cashmere sweaters starts at just $50. They pulled this off by cutting out the middleman and partnering directly with ethical, safe and responsible factories.
- [11:35]
Anya Kane
We recently gave ourselves the gift of quints. Kevin got their suede bomber jacket. It's so comfortable and warm and I think he looks really cute wearing it. I myself got a black Mongolian cashmere V neck sweater and a dark blue Mongolian cashmere turtleneck sweater. I'm really struck by the softness of the fabric. I also really like the way I look in these pieces, which for me is a big coup.
- [11:58]
Kevin Greenlee
Quinn's also has 14 karat gold jewelry, Italian leather handbags and European linen sheet sets. Give the gift of luxury this holiday season without the luxury price tag. Go to quince.commsheet for 365 day returns plus get free shipping on your order. That's Q U I n c e.com msheet to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com msheet behind the bright lights and adrenaline of pro sports is an equally exciting world of negotiations and deal making.
- [12:43]
Credit Karma Representative
That's what we cover each week on.
- [12:44]
Kevin Greenlee
Our podcast the Deal. I'm Alex Rodriguez, former baseball player turned business executive.
- [12:50]
Credit Karma Representative
And I'm Jason Kelly, chief correspondent for Bloomberg Originals.
- [12:53]
Kevin Greenlee
Over the next couple months, we'll hear from all stars like Jay Williams.
- [12:56]
Anya Kane
I want to be an owner one day.
- [12:57]
Kevin Greenlee
Billie Jean King, learn the business and so many more. Listen to the deal wherever you get your podcast.
- [13:06]
Human Rights Campaign Representative
Today, the LGBTQ community is at a crossroads with our loved ones and hard won rights increasingly under attack. For decades, the Human Rights Campaign has been at the forefront of the fight for equality in the face of discrimination and harassment. With the support of people like you, HRC fights for a world where lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer people can live openly and thrive free from fear. If you're ready to support the fight for equality, to donate today, visit HRC.org give that's HRC.org give and serious punishment about it.
- [13:46]
Anya Kane
You know, I mean, this is, we've started and you know, in recent times taken CSAM seriously as a crime. You know, and I think we can incorporate this. And also it's about education, teaching young girls and boys what's okay. What is being a good citizen look like? What does being a good community member look like? Um, why it's okay to be experiencing some of these new sexual feelings, but perhaps what's a healthy way to deal with that versus what's a horrible and dehumanizing way to your fellow classmates looking at each other not as just objects, sexual objects, but looking at each other as human beings could be helpful.
- [14:32]
Kevin Greenlee
I'm curious, in, in your mind, would you see these laws more in the criminal area or the civil area? In other words, if someone would produce an image like that of you when you're a young person, should you have the right to sue them civilly or would you like to see the person.
- [14:48]
Anya Kane
Go to jail Both, Both. I also actually, when you bring up civilly, I think that's a good point. I think when you hit people, I mean, you could say, let's all teach our young people how to be good adults. But that also requires good adults to do that. And some people are not good people and they don't care about other people and they're not going to do that with their kids and their kids are going to learn accordingly. So it's unrealistic to think that that would fix everything. So one thing that, you know, might make parents be a little bit more wary of what their kids are doing online though is if suddenly their family is open to a massive civil lawsuit because their child has been doing stuff like this. So I don't know when it comes to crafting actual laws around it and looking at appropriate punishments, I would leave that to the legal experts. I think it's a situation where you do need to take into account that if it's a young boy doing this in high school, perhaps that should be treated less severely than an adult man. Right. I think that needs to be taken into account. I think you need to take into account a lot of different things. But what I would like to see, I guess is and it seems like some states are going in this direction, looking at, you know, encouraging states to take action and look at what, what should be done and hearing from families and parents and schools and what they're seeing and sort of acting accordingly. I just think there needs to be, there needs to be scrutinized carefully.
- [16:12]
Kevin Greenlee
Shall we move on?
- [16:13]
Anya Kane
Absolutely. So are we doing next case that kind of. I looked at that span from New York to Tennessee or do you want to do one of yours first?
- [16:25]
Kevin Greenlee
No, do yours.
- [16:26]
Anya Kane
I'll jump in. So this is another listener recommendation and thanks very much to this person for recommending it. It's really kind of a pretty fascinating and just elaborate one that I'd never heard of before. So I appreciate to that person. Appreciate that person. I would say my sources for this are the Nashville Scene as well as I got some information from Williamson Scene and there's also a website called nicolisi.com and I will link to that has some helpful information. So this is the disappearance of Nico Leasey and it goes all the way back to 2011. So September 30, 2011, an 18 year old boy named Nico Leesi, he and his 20 year old friend Robert Nicholas Neil Knight III, they're hanging out, they're in Addison, New York, that's up in Steuben County. And you know, around 2pm they interact with Nico's uncle and they're, they're kind of captured on some surveillance footage that day. You know, Nico, just to give you a description since he's missing, he's, he's white, he had brown hair, brown eyes. And he was last seen wearing a black hooded sweatshirt, red shorts, sneakers, wearing a silver crucifix necklace. And these two guys are hanging out in a 2004 GMC Canyon pickup truck and they, they tell people that they got the truck from Knight's grandfather. That was not true. That truck was stolen. So kind of first indication something's wrong, they tell people that they're going to go camping around Buffalo and then they head out. So the following on rather on October 1st of that year we have, you know, the following day, night, goes back to his parents house in Romulus, Michigan. So obviously quite far away from Buffalo. It's not clear exactly when he gets there but it's somewhere between 6am and 10am and he claims that Nico dropped him off but no one saw Nico. Meanwhile, a young man living on Flintlock Drive in Franklin, Tennessee that day sends Nico a Western Union money order for $90 which is then picked up in Ohio. That's gonna become important later that afternoon, Nico gets a call from his grandmother around 5pm Eastern time. And he does pick up the phone. He answers and he says he can't talk but would call her back. He never does. Around that same time his phone pings for the last time around Flintlock Drive in Franklin. So he did have a connection to Franklin, Tennessee. We've actually covered a case from Franklin, the murder of Peggy Cox, I believe I remember. And so it's a suburb of Nashville, I guess it's near Nashville and Nico had experience there. He had actually attended Franklin high school for 11th grade before moving back to New York. So he lived in Franklin for a bit this same day while this is going on, Nico's driver's license is found in front of the post office in Hornell, New York. And it's the good Samaritan who finds it, mails it to nico's mother and October 3rd she gets it in the mail and she's very concerned. In the interim, Nico's Facebook page just abruptly is shut down. It just disappears. Later on night, his brother Christopher admits that he and his brother did that from their house in Romulus. They had access to Nico's Facebook page and they shut it down. So October 5th, Nico is reported missing. Three days later, Michigan police go and Question Knight. And as a result of that interview, he ends up getting committed to a psychiatric hospital. So, you know, no one is. No one. No one sees Nico at this point. No one knows where he is. Night is subsequently released. And remember, he's the guy who was last with Nico, seemingly. But on October 10, unfortunately, he dies of a drug overdose. So all this is happening very quickly. I can't imagine the pain that Nico's family went through. Not only is their son missing, but the guy who went off with him is suddenly dead, and answers are not coming. So the next big development in the case, and it's just baffling because he leaves from New York. This other guy ends up in Michigan. He seemingly is in Tennessee. That's where his phone is. That's where he's, you know, he picks up a call like, we know he's alive at that point, and then nothing. It's just like, what? But it's going to get weirder. So July 2016, the pickup truck that was stolen that they were driving in is finally found, because that had been missing, too. It was. It was in a garage on Colorado Avenue in the Sylvan park neighborhood of Nashville. And it was at the home of people named James Schrader and Deborah Lynn Carter. They were parents of a young man named James Schrader. He's going to become important later. But the. The truck was all stripped down for parts, kind of almost like it had been chopped for a chop shop. And then in 2017, the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation took over the case. Other people passed away associated with it, including Christopher Knight, Robbie's brother, who gave some answers about how the Facebook page got shut down. And then in August 2023, Nico was declared legally dead. So a really bizarre twist came up very recently in this case. And to kind of go into it, we need to talk about a man named Eduardo. I hope I'm saying his last name right. Aguirre. Aguirre was a real estate agent. He was a realtor with a place called Hodges and Fushi Realty, Inc. You can actually look at. He. His Zillow page is still up. It talks about how he was a first generation high school and college graduate, and he likes to travel, make new friends. He's a really good realtor. He. He does it full time. It's not a side job. And he's going to do a great job for you. And so, you know, just kind of normal thing. He's 32 now, so he's kind of up and coming, but he has fallen into Some major legal trouble. So the incident in question occurred on March 10, 2022. Aguirre met up with a woman who he previously worked for. They considered each other good friends. They had lunch and they actually drank together. So they drank some alcohol. And the woman said that normally she did not do that at lunch, but she felt very comfortable with a G, you know, then afterwards, he said, let's go to a liquor store. They go to the liquor store. She took. Take some liquor with him. Again, not something she'd normally do, but she kind of felt embarrassed to say no at that point. They're kind of doing some day drinking together. So she drinks this liquor with him, and they're in his Dodge Ram truck together, and she starts to lose consciousness. She said it was a very weird feeling that came on. All of a sudden, she felt like she couldn't move. Her head felt really heavy. And as she's kind of incapacitated, Agire sexually assaults her. She's trying. She's crying. She's trying to push him off. He's telling her not to push him. After he assaults her, he takes her to the hospital. The following day, she filed a police report against him. Now, the DNA in this case was not great because, you know, she had bathed and changed clothes in between. It's very critical in cases like this for the victim to be kind of tested right away because otherwise a lot of evidence can be lost. So while there was male DNA found associated with the attack, it didn't conclusively match Aguirre. But the defense, in fairness, wasn't really contesting that something happened. They just said it was a drunken consensual encounter between two people who were both intoxicated. So the jury ended up hearing this, and they convict. They actually acquitted Agir on three of four counts, but they convicted him on one count regarding the sexual assault, and he could go to jail for eight. He can go to prison rather for eight to 12 years. So what came out during trial, and keep in mind, the jury never heard this, that is that Aguirre is a person of interest in Nico's case. So you're probably. How does this have anything to do with that? Well, putting it together myself, it seems that Aguirre was the young man on Flintlock Drive who was having those interactions with Nico. He sent him money, and Nico came to see him. And so again, Williamson County Circuit Court Judge David Veal ruled against this coming in, which I understand, because it doesn't really have anything to do with the rape case. But what there was A Nathan Neese, who's the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation Assistance Special Agent in charge, who's the lead agent on the case, he was basically saying like, you know, the prosecution saying, hey, Agira previously lied to police, like he's not a trustworthy person. He lied in this lease, in, in this, in Nico's case. And so we need to kind of consider that. So let's go back to December 2011. Agir graduated from the school in 2009. And around the time of Nico's disappearance, he, you know, he was already graduated, but he consented to an interview with the high school resource officer. And he told that officer that Nico had come to his house late in the day on October 1, 2011, and that the following morning he and Nico played soccer with Aguirre's dad and uncle. But the uncle got injured, so the dad took him to the hospital around 8:15am and then they watched Aguirre's brother's soccer team play. Nico left really abruptly without saying goodbye, got his backpack, just left. And his dad backed up that story. But in 2016, he gave a lot more detail to police. He claimed he had wired Nico gas money. So he was the guy who sent him that money. He said that Nico came and showed up with a bunch of guns and said he needed to get rid of a truck. So. So he gave it to one of Aguirre's friends named James Schrader. Of course, that fits because the truck was found at Schrader's place. Schrader is no longer alive to kind of give any information. He died in 2014. And in. So, so basically, Schrader and a guy named Jacob Quirant, who also died in 2015, chopped it up for scrap. From there, Aguirre said Nico spent one night at his house and then got in touch with a guy named Jose Vargas, who's from Springfield, who helped him find a room at a place on Westminster Drive in Franklin. They went there, they spoke with a unidentified Hispanic middle aged guy, and Nico moved into that place. He went to apply for jobs the next day. Next thing Aguirre knows, Vargas is contacting him saying, hey, Nico left get get his stuff or pay his rent. Aguirre shows up at the house, claims that he sees a bunch of Hispanic people that he does not recognized, gets Nico's clothes and then throws them out at a nearby apartment complex. Now, since then, Aguirre has stopped cooperating. He will not talk to tbi. Vargas did talk to law enforcement in the past. There's not even any clue about who this unidentified Hispanic man is, or, you know, if he is even real. And TBI at this point, believes that foul play was involved. So what do you make of all of this? Isn't this just completely, like.
- [28:33]
Kevin Greenlee
It's crazy.
- [28:34]
Anya Kane
It's really a wild story. What do you think about Aguirre? He's kind of all over this thing with Nico, and then he's subsequently busted for rape. What do you think about that?
- [28:47]
Kevin Greenlee
It's such a bizarre story. You said listener sent this to us.
- [28:52]
Anya Kane
Yes. Yeah. Thank you to that listener.
- [28:55]
Kevin Greenlee
Yeah. It's a fascinating case.
- [28:57]
Anya Kane
I really feel that it's very concerning. And the fact that Nico's never resurfaced, you know, even if he went to Franklin totally willingly, it seems like something very bad happened to him there. And I can understand why they're. They're treating it as a homicide at this point. And I'm not saying Aguirre is responsible for what happened to him. It seems like, you know, maybe or maybe not. But the fact of the matter is, I think a lot of these people know more than they're saying. And that's what Nico's mom, Monica Button, who's been advocating for him for years, has said. She attended Aguirre's trial. She's very hopeful that now that he's going behind bars, that other people will come forward and saying, like, now that I'm not worried about this guy, I'll tell you what I know, and I certainly hope that happens, because sometimes that's all. Sometimes someone going to prison is what it takes for a case to kind of come open, because people are less scared at that point. And if you happen to have a tip, and I don't. Cops really don't need, like, investigative suggestions where people are, you know, saying, hey, try genetic genealogy. But for people who are in Franklin who might know people who are involved, like, spread the word. And if people end up having some kind of relevant information, the way you submit that is 1-800-TBI. Find that's TBI F I N D. Or submit a tip to the email tipstotbitn.gov and yeah, that's that saga. I really. My heart goes out to Nico's family, and I hope they get some answers.
- [30:34]
Kevin Greenlee
So I want to move on and talk about a case out of Minnesota. This is an appellate decision, and our source for this was that appellate decision. And also a terrific story summarizing that appellate decision that I found on Fox 9. And I talk about this because obviously we've covered the Rich and Allen case a lot. And people always are trying to create the impression, oh, there might be a new trial there because of an appeal. I don't think there will be. Spoiler alert. I don't think there will be a new trial in the Richard Allen case. But people who think that might be a possibility are, are interested in that process. And I thought it might be interesting to look at a case where a new trial is going to be granted because a conviction got overturned. This is a murder conviction, as I said. It's in Minneapolis. A man named Deandra Turner was convicted of shooting and killing Drew McDonald Ginley back in June of 2021. And appellate judge Cochran was the gentleman who overturned that decision. And I'm going to quote from this article, quote, Appellate Judge Cochran overturned the the conviction citing evidentiary errors and prosecutorial misconduct. The decision noted that the state's case was weak with no forensic evidence presented, no gun, no DNA and reliance on grainy surveillance footage. Additionally, the state improperly used an out of court statement where its sole witness identified the shooter at the suggestion of a police sergeant. In court, that witness denied knowing who fired the fatal shot, unquote. So for me, the biggest thing there, that part of the end about the out of court statement where a person was led to make an identification of the shooter, which then that person didn't stand by in court. Do you have any, do you have any thoughts as to why an out of court statement may not be as relevant as an in court statement?
- [32:48]
Anya Kane
It's not under oath.
- [32:49]
Kevin Greenlee
Exactly.
- [32:51]
Anya Kane
I got it.
- [32:53]
Kevin Greenlee
She's pretty sharp, folks.
- [32:55]
Anya Kane
Well, I mean it's. Yeah, it's just sort of like when people like oftentimes I think in true crime there's a lot of emphasis put on things that happen out of court and that will never be allowed in court. People might be, you know, all this guy's Facebook's pretty weird and it's like that's not going to get introduced unless it's directly relevant.
- [33:16]
Kevin Greenlee
So, you know, and also as Anya mentioned in court is sworn. So if I go out and I buy a fedora and I wear it and I say, Anya, what do you think of my fedora? She'll say, kevin, that looks good.
- [33:28]
Anya Kane
I would not be that nice about it.
- [33:31]
Kevin Greenlee
You say, kevin, that fedora looks good. But then let's say later on that becomes a contentious matter that's taken to court and Anya is, takes an oath to tell the truth.
- [33:42]
Anya Kane
Prosecution calls Anya Kane and I smirk at you. You say, look like a dork.
- [33:45]
Instacart Representative
Yeah.
- [33:46]
Kevin Greenlee
Because when you're in court, if you lie, you're subject to perjury. And when you're not in court and you're not sworn, you're not. So a lot more reliance is placed on what happens in court as opposed to out of court, with the big.
- [34:01]
Anya Kane
Dramatic moment be you throwing your hat on the ground. I'm sorry, I've kind of gotten off track here. Just imagining you sitting. You're not even allowed to wear a hat in court. So why are you doing this? And why am I getting mad at you about something that hasn't even happened?
- [34:16]
Kevin Greenlee
It didn't happen. It was just supposed to be an example.
- [34:18]
Anya Kane
I'm furious. Why would you do this to us?
- [34:24]
Kevin Greenlee
Anya is so smart.
- [34:25]
Anya Kane
It's so realistic. It's so realistic, I could see it. Anyways, go ahead.
- [34:31]
Kevin Greenlee
It's my special fedora I got for my birthday.
- [34:33]
Anya Kane
A now I feel bad.
- [34:35]
Kevin Greenlee
But that's not all. To get back to the case, Cochran also raised some other issues. For instance, attorneys, quote, attorneys referring to witnesses who did not testify. Anya, why would that be a problem?
- [34:48]
Anya Kane
Oh, I don't know, Kevin. My little layperson brain can't even handle that one. Yeah, I mean, because obviously they didn't testify. So, like, what's. What happens? A trial is supposed to be what happens in court. It's not supposed to be some sort of, like, kitchen sink. Like, let's bring in everything. Like, think about it this way. If you've ever argued with a loved one or a spouse, it's better to kind of be like, hey, this thing you did was problematic in this way. And let's talk about it. You don't say, like, hey, remember that thing you did three years ago? That has nothing to do with this. Yeah, that really, you know, ground my gears. Like, you have to. There's limits to what is relevant in a court case. What's entered into evidence, what has merit. That's what's supposed to matter.
- [35:31]
Kevin Greenlee
And the entire world of evidence that the jurors are supposed to consider is what is admitted in court and what witnesses who come to court say. If I'm trying to convince any of that my fedora is a good idea, and I say, oh, Anya, Everybody down at McDonald's loved it.
- [35:47]
Anya Kane
Sounds about right. Hanging out the McDonald's, peacocking around in your fedora. That's where you've been instead of working.
- [35:58]
Kevin Greenlee
Next, the prosecutor claimed that defendant Turner was, quote, drunk and probably high without proof. Oh, an why would that be a problem?
- [36:09]
Anya Kane
I mean, cuz, like, you. You. You can't just Say things in court. You can't just. You can't just say, you know, you can't just make claims without evidence. I mean, you can like the. Okay, the area where it gets a little bit, in my understanding, more of a gray area. You can make arguments in your closing argument. Like, you can argue things. Like you can say, well, this is what the evidence shows and get a little bit more loosey goosey there. But even that, like, you, like you can't just then say whatever you want. There's rules. I mean, what people don't understand, like a trial is not a free for all. A trial is not the. The shootout at the OK Corral where people are just doing whatever. It's not a bar fight. It's it. There are rules of what you can and can't do, what can and can't be admitted as evidence, what the jury can and cannot hear. It's all very tightly choreographed. And the choreography notes are like, you know, all of the legal decisions and all the other court cases and what have been established as trial rules in whatever state you're dealing with. It's all very buttoned up. And it's not just about, like, you know, freestyle, let's, you know, do a dance off to determine this guy's guilt. It's like you have to do, you know, I mean, like, you have to follow the rules. So I think people kind of miss that because they're used to a lot of, like, courtroom dramas where people are standing up and doing whatever, and that's just not how it works.
- [37:41]
Kevin Greenlee
Exactly. The final thing cited in this article is that the prosecutor. The prosecutor also insinuated the defendant Turner was in a gang again without offering proof. So, yeah, so there's a lot of problems with this trial.
- [37:59]
Anya Kane
Seems like it.
- [38:01]
Kevin Greenlee
So that is the level of things you need for a case to be overturned. And so this case was thrown out. And so now the prosecutors, prosecutors in the case are going to have to make the decision whether or not to retry it. And it is a shame because this, the victim, Mr. McGinley, was someone who was a very valued part of the community. And the community really lost someone special when he was murdered. And so everybody who cared about him and who loved him and misses him deserves justice.
- [38:33]
Anya Kane
Yeah, they're going to have to go through this whole ordeal again. You know, it's. That's why it's especially important for prosecutors to have a really buttoned up case where they're not just throwing in, honestly. Like, it's as. It's as important of what you don't include in your case as what you do include. Right. Because you don't want to include something that's going to lead to a mistrial or, or a successful appeal. It. Like, you don't. Like, like, it's sort of like when we talk about, like, you know, when, like we've used, like, kitchen examples, but when you're, like, making a meal, you don't just, like, dump in everything in your kitchen because, like, you might have, like, rat poison in there. Like, like you. You want to be very selective about your ingredients.
- [39:17]
Kevin Greenlee
Yes. As we learned when you made corn.
- [39:19]
Anya Kane
Pone, that corn pone was fine. And I'm sorry that you got your hopes up for it to, to a, to an insane degree that you thought it was going to be some magical thing, but it was fine. It was fine. There was no rap hoisin in the corn pone. Good lord.
- [39:38]
Kevin Greenlee
Talking about kitchen sinking sad glimpse into our life.
- [39:46]
Anya Kane
And you know, you were just as responsible for that corn pone.
- [39:50]
Kevin Greenlee
How so?
- [39:50]
Anya Kane
You were participating in the creation of it. It wasn't just me. Freaking corn pone. And you were the one who really wanted to. Oh, my. Anyway, let's move on.
- [40:03]
Kevin Greenlee
Let the corn pone go.
- [40:04]
Anya Kane
Yeah, I'm letting it go.
- [40:09]
Kevin Greenlee
Listeners to the Cheat Sheet probably know that I always get in trouble when I pick cases based on the headlines. And I apologize in advance because that happened again this week when I look at a case out of Oregon. The headline was alien chasers offer hints in decades Long quests to solve. Quote, longest running murder mystery.
- [40:34]
Anya Kane
How could you resist that?
- [40:35]
Kevin Greenlee
I see longest running murder mystery. Obviously, I'm going to click, and then when I see what it is about. And this, by the way, is a story that appeared on Fox News. But when I see that headline, I'm going to click and it's. It. It's not really a mystery and it's not really murder.
- [40:58]
Anya Kane
Wow. So I'm really glad you picked it for our show that focuses on murders and mysteries.
- [41:03]
Kevin Greenlee
It's a cattle mutilation story. What? So. So have you heard about the cattle mutilation?
- [41:11]
Anya Kane
Can you murder a cow?
- [41:13]
Kevin Greenlee
It's mutilation.
- [41:14]
Anya Kane
Okay, but then why does the headline say that?
- [41:16]
Kevin Greenlee
Well, as I said, it's not really a murder.
- [41:20]
Alex Rodriguez
Forget one size fits all diets. With noom, you get a personalized weight loss plan that's tailored to your lifestyle. Have cravings, food fomo. Noom can help you lose weight while still enjoying your favorite foods. Noom's users love the flexible approach blending psychology and biology to help you lose weight in a way that's sustainable for you. Plus, you can rest assured Noom's approach is grounded in science. They've published more than 30 peer reviewed scientific articles describing their methods and effectiveness. Stay focused on what's important to you with Noom's psychology and biology based approach. Sign up for your trial today@noom.com youm.
- [41:57]
Credit Karma Representative
Know that feeling when your favorite brand really gets you. Deliver that feeling to your customers every time. Memorable moments like these are key to building your business and your brand. Brands like Headley and Bennett use Klaviyo's marketing automation platform to turn their customer data into more personalized connections across AI powered email, SMS analytics and more. Making Every Moment Count Build smarter digital relationships with your customers and make every moment count with Klaviyo. Learn more@klaviyo.com.
- [42:31]
Kevin Greenlee
So there have been stories going around for decades which you may or may not heard of, in which animals, usually some form of cattle, are alleged to have been not only killed but also their bodies to have been mutilated. These stories have gone on for decades. Decades, decades. I think they really first started gaining real prominence in the late 60s or early 70s, and at that time people began offering the theory, well, maybe what's going on is it's a cult or maybe it's aliens from deep space. And I say aliens from deep space to justify the title of this episode or something of that nature. And it's not. And one thing to note too is that when a story, if you were to see a newspaper story or a television story that says, oh, there's a lot of cattle mutilations taking place in Columbus, Indiana, then other people are going to see that story. And they say, oh, also I'm seeing something similar in another part of Indiana. And so when people see something that's happened once, they start seeing it everywhere and so there would be like a cluster of reports, they end up getting kind of debunked and then they go away for a while. And I think we're also going to include a link in our show Notes to an article from the Skeptics Dictionary, which I thought did a great job of discussing all of this. Essentially, in most instances, what it is is just natural predators.
- [44:14]
Anya Kane
Yes, predators, obviously, duh. Like literally.
- [44:18]
Kevin Greenlee
And scientists have been able to, oh, somebody says, oh look, here is a cow with certain cuts and stuff on it and certain organs missing. It must be aliens. And then scientists will be able to say, well, here's another cow with those exact Same markings. And look, we know exactly how it happened. It was natural predators. And generally speaking, if there's two possible explanations for something, and one involves rewriting the law of physics to include aliens visiting from outer space to come and mysteriously mutilate cattle, and the other one is just based on normal earthly creatures doing normal earthly things, we can be pretty assured that the explanation that is true is the one involving normal earthly creatures doing normal earthly things.
- [45:06]
Anya Kane
Yes. Well said, sir. Well reasoned.
- [45:10]
Kevin Greenlee
Have you been. Had you heard these kind of mulation stories over the years?
- [45:13]
Anya Kane
No, honestly, aliens. Aliens visiting Earth has never really held that much excitement for me. I don't know why I, that's. I definitely enjoy, like, Unsolved Mysteries and kind of even some of the more, you know, like, I don't. I don't know if that's considered paranormal, but like, that's kind of fun, even though I don't believe in any of it. But it's. It's not, you know, and it's like. And there's also. Yeah, why are they coming here to mutilate cattle when they could do anything else? You know, like, it raises questions, but it always just seemed like, I don't know any. Any probably person working in the cattle business can tell you that there would be predators that could do this to their cattle. And you know, that that's a problem for them and it's part of the business and you gotta watch out for it. That's why there's like pest management stuff. And.
- [46:01]
Kevin Greenlee
And it's also interesting, certainly recently in the Richard Allen case, we saw a lot of instances of reporters getting details wrong. Sometimes minor details, sometimes big details. When stories of these cattle mutilations happen, there was invariably huge details to get reported incorrectly to make it seem more mysterious than it really is. And if you go back to the primary sources, there's really not a mystery there. It's just generally natural predators. And people see it, they, oh, it's a mysterious cattle mutilation. Because I don't know anything about cattle.
- [46:36]
Anya Kane
And maybe, like, I don't know, like.
- [46:37]
Kevin Greenlee
And then you see a newspaper article saying, oh, cattle mutilation is happening. And then you see something that you think is similar. Oh, no, it's a wave, it's a cluster.
- [46:44]
Anya Kane
It's all happening now. And I like. I should also say, like, I think I probably contributed to that because I think I really freaked out a guy at McDonald's today. Yeah.
- [46:53]
Kevin Greenlee
Because Anya has a touching lack of faith in me. Again, we had one of our special lunches at McDonald's.
- [47:00]
Anya Kane
Wow, how romantic.
- [47:01]
Kevin Greenlee
Well, I don't want to spoil you too much. And we're walking out of McDonald's and says, I want to make sure you cover this with respect to this cattle emulation thing. She says, calumnulation isn't funny. She says it very loudly. And a man near us is like, turns his head and just looks at us.
- [47:22]
Anya Kane
I didn't even notice that.
- [47:24]
Kevin Greenlee
So did you think I was going to come up here and do a comedy routine making fun of dead cows?
- [47:29]
Anya Kane
Well, after your big fedora routine, I don't know. A lot of the trust is gone.
- [47:36]
Kevin Greenlee
Anya, you had the McDonald's remark prior to any talk of fedora's.
- [47:41]
Anya Kane
I don't know, I just. Well, it's just. It's those poor animals, you know? But I mean, it's. It's. I just didn't know because you were like. You're like, oh, I have a case. Aliens. And I was like, oh, God, what is this going to be? What? I said, well, that was the vibe.
- [47:55]
Kevin Greenlee
Ooh, aliens. We got to. We got to go back to not talking to each other about the kids.
- [48:02]
Anya Kane
About it at all or the ad on the podcast. Well, you'll do your episodes. I'll do my episodes.
- [48:11]
Kevin Greenlee
There's lots of icy silences.
- [48:13]
Anya Kane
We could do it like, you know, you love that. No, you hate that Frank Sinatra album duets, where they would record the duets. Like, Frank Sinatra would record his part of the duet, and then the other artists would record theirs. And, you know, we could do that. No, I'm not being serious. That's not practical.
- [48:32]
Kevin Greenlee
And also, we enjoy one another's company.
- [48:34]
Anya Kane
Do we know we do. We're just joking around, guys. Don't worry about it. Our listeners are like, what the hell is going on?
- [48:42]
Kevin Greenlee
Well, I'll tell you what the hell is going on. If you want me to speak like you and swear like a sailor. Christmas. Christmas is going on. It's the season where carolers come to your door, be decked in lovely Christmas Murder street T shirts, which are identical to regular T shirts. Also, you have under the tree. Put things under the tree. Yeah, what better to put under the trees and a T shirt.
- [49:10]
Anya Kane
Exactly.
- [49:11]
Kevin Greenlee
Know what else you can do with the tree? You. But you can throw a T shirt on it, like.
- [49:16]
Anya Kane
So you're gonna put a murder sheet T shirt on the Christmas tree?
- [49:20]
Kevin Greenlee
Yeah, why not? Why don't you get, like, one of the extra larges? And that could be like a Christmas tradition for you and your loved ones. You can have your child who's little Timmy is going to put the murder sheet T shirt on the Christmas tree this year? And that's how we really know that the holiday has begun. And we're really thrilled to be a part of all your holiday traditions.
- [49:38]
Anya Kane
That's how your family members know you really lost it.
- [49:41]
Kevin Greenlee
So you can buy these tre shirts from us for the holidays.
- [49:45]
Anya Kane
I love that.
- [49:46]
Kevin Greenlee
What if a caroler comes to your door and they're not dressed in a murder sheet T shirt? Well, you could have like a little box of them and say, here, here, caroler. Now you fit in with the others.
- [49:56]
Anya Kane
Sort of like a modified trick or treating suggestion. Like, remember, you had your infamous trick or treat ideas. Now you're bringing it to Christmas.
- [50:03]
Kevin Greenlee
I'm all about bringing people together.
- [50:06]
Anya Kane
Yeah.
- [50:07]
Kevin Greenlee
Making people feel included. And the way to do that, Murder sheet T shirts, which you can. Where, Where, Where? If a person in this great land of ours wanted to procure a murder sheet T shirt, where could they go?
- [50:21]
Anya Kane
Are you asking me during your ad? Okay, so it's murdersheetshop.com.
- [50:28]
Kevin Greenlee
Just go there. All of your murder sheet T shirt needs are there for you. There to be met.
- [50:36]
Anya Kane
There to be met.
- [50:37]
Kevin Greenlee
There to be met indeed.
- [50:39]
Anya Kane
They're waiting for you.
- [50:40]
Kevin Greenlee
Your needs are there waiting for you. Maybe you didn't even realize what the shirt looks like. You want to see what the shirt looks like? You want to. You want to procure a shirt?
- [50:49]
Anya Kane
Probably a good idea before you put it on your family tree.
- [50:55]
Kevin Greenlee
Isn't there a murder sheet T shirt on our tree?
- [50:59]
Anya Kane
Yeah, of course.
- [51:01]
Kevin Greenlee
I wouldn't make something up like that just to try to sell a T shirt.
- [51:07]
Anya Kane
What about people who don't have a Christmas tree to celebrate a different holiday this time of year? Or just the tree is too much hassle right now. What can they do?
- [51:16]
Kevin Greenlee
Well, you can buy, I think, a T shirt holder and just display the T shirt itself with, like lights on it.
- [51:23]
Anya Kane
Maybe like a mannequin or something to set up a mannequin with the. With the shirt. No one will worry about you. No one will think something's very wrong.
- [51:33]
Kevin Greenlee
I gotta tell you, even for me, you're verging into creepy territory. You're wanting people to buy a mannequin and put our shirt on. That's just disturbing. And I. I think it's time to push the button to do this. Jesus.
- [51:49]
Anya Kane
All right, thanks, everybody.
- [51:53]
Kevin Greenlee
Thanks so much for listening to the murder sheet. If you have a tip concerning one of the cases we cover, please email us@murdersheetmail.com. if you have actionable information about an unsolved crime, please report it to the appropriate authorities.
- [52:13]
Anya Kane
If you're interested in joining our Patreon, that's available at ww patreon.com/murder sheet. If you want to tip us a bit of money for records requests, you can do so at www. Buymeacoffee.com murdersheet. We very much appreciate any support.
- [52:37]
Kevin Greenlee
Special thanks to Kevin Tyler Greenlee who composed the music for the Murder Sheet and who you can find on the web@kevintg.com if you're looking to talk with.
- [52:48]
Anya Kane
Other listeners about a case we've covered, you can join the Murder Sheet Discussion group on Facebook. We mostly focus our time on research and reporting, so we're not on social media much. We do try to check our email account, but we ask for patience as we often receive a lot of messages. Thanks again for listening. So it's the holiday season right now and you might be looking for things to gift both your loved ones and perhaps yourself for some self care. And one thing we'd like you to keep in mind is we have a wonderful sponsor called Via Hemp. This is a company that makes it possible for us to do our show. They support us and so supporting them also supports us and they've got some really cool deals for Murder Sheet listeners who are interested. If you're 21 and older you can go to viahemp.com that's v I I a h e m p.com and you can get 15% off their products which are these amazing premium award winning THC and THC free gummies. They've also got things like topicals, drops, vapes. Each one of them is crafted with a specific mood or effect in mind.
- [54:00]
Kevin Greenlee
That is neat. Plus I'd like to say in the ad we've we've run on the show about this, you in particular talked about how their their product, in particular the Zen product helps you fall asleep. You know you're not the only one in this marriage who has trouble falling asleep and so that project has also helped me. It's really difficult to settle down at night sometimes, especially doing this podcast and looking at some of the things we look at and some of the things we have to think about. It's hard to let that go and so I find this very helpful to help relax at the end of the day.
- [54:35]
Anya Kane
Yeah, it's like it's a nice CBD CBN thing. So it's THC free. They have a lot of THC free stuff too and That's. And that's, you know, something that you can look into. THC is not your thing. You don't, you know, you're not out of luck there. And we use their. Their CBD products, and that is one that I really do enjoy it. It just. It's sort of like helping your brain shut off. Like, because I think you and I are both, you know, kind of anxious, so we'll be, like, up at night, like, oh, did we do that? What's like, should we make a list for tomorrow? And it's like, just go to bed. And so basically what the CBD does is kind of yells at our brains to just go to bed, which we need.
- [55:08]
Kevin Greenlee
Did we make a list for tomorrow?
- [55:09]
Anya Kane
Oh, God, Kevin, maybe I should go get something. Don't start. Don't start.
- [55:13]
Kevin Greenlee
Maybe I should go get some of this.
- [55:14]
Anya Kane
So have some Zen.
- [55:16]
Kevin Greenlee
I'm really stressing out here on you, Kevin.
- [55:19]
Anya Kane
Take your Zen figures in and shut up.
- [55:24]
Kevin Greenlee
So.
- [55:25]
Anya Kane
So this.
- [55:25]
Kevin Greenlee
This product has been a blessing for Anya in more ways than one. Because it does help me shut up. Because it helps me relax.
- [55:31]
Anya Kane
Shut them down. No, but, but, but truly, this is. I mean, and it's not just, you know, anxiety or sleep. They've got stuff for all kinds of things. You can, you know, experiment with microdosing. Some of them just, you know, boost your mood. It's just like, whatever you can think of, they probably have it. So go to their website, check it out, and see if there's anything that might be interesting for you.
- [55:53]
Kevin Greenlee
And let them know we sent you.
- [55:55]
Anya Kane
Yeah, please do let them know we sent you. And just know that it. I think this ships legally to most states, and it's, you know, very much, you know, by the book in that sense. And it'll ship in, like, discrete packaging, so in case you're worried, in case your anxiety is getting the best of you, that's something to note. And, yeah, I guess that kind of wraps it up. But we just want to thank Vi again for sponsoring us. This really helps us out. And when you support our sponsors, you're directly supporting us, especially if you're using our code, because that lets the sponsor know that you know that we sent you. So, again, this holiday season, gift yourself some peace of mind. If you're 21 and older, head to via hemp.com and use the code M sheet to receive 15% off. That's via hemp.com and use code M sheet at checkout. Please support our show and tell them we sent you. And this holiday season, enhance your every.
- [56:45]
Kevin Greenlee
Day with via and put that on your list of things to do tomorrow.
- [56:48]
Anya Kane
Yes.