Loading summary
A
Why does Progressive work hard for truckers? Because truckers unite the world. They unite kids with their first drum sets and parents with earplugs. But truckers can't do this if they're not on the road. That's why Progressive has over 360 heavy truck employees to help truckers stay on time and on track. Quote Truck Insurance today in as little as eight minutes@progressivecommercial.com, progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.
B
Hi, everybody. I'm Anya. Today on the Cheat Sheet, we're going to be discussing some cases from Indiana, California. I think we're going to Canada, our neighbor to the north, as well as. Where's your last one, Kevin?
C
My last one is from Alabama.
B
Oh, you've been doing a lot of Alabama cases lately. All right, let's do it.
C
So.
B
Oh. Content warning.
C
Yeah, do that.
B
Content warning. This episode contains discussion of murder and violence as well as the brutal murder of two young children.
C
So we are recording this all the way back in the distant past of June 18, because for some reason we thought, well, let's see if we can record three of these in a day.
B
Not for some reason, let's give them an honest answer. The answer is because we want to have more time to work on long term projects and getting some things done ahead of time is a good way of doing that.
C
But if we can do three in a day and it turns out okay, and we don't seem crazy or, or outrageous in them, couldn't we do three cheat sheets a day, five days a week, and start putting out 15 cheat sheets a week? That's a flawless plan, right? Cause isn't that what we're proving? I notice you're not saying anything.
B
There's nothing to say.
C
And then also, well, let's see how this goes. I think that's a great plan. We also have great premium over on Patreon and Apple where you get extra episodes, early episodes, ad free episodes.
B
That's right.
C
Great deal. We have a lot of fun. We'd love to see you there. Also, it's like fourth of July weekend, so be careful out there. I think Anya is going to get out her big Uncle Sam hat, get out her stilts and do her big Fourth of July routine this week.
B
What does my big fourth of July routine entail?
C
You wear your Uncle Sam pants. You get your big oversized Uncle Sam hat, and then you start walking around with sparklers in your hands, twirling them around, offering good wishes and good cheer to delighted onlookers.
B
My only sparkler memories are I remember over the summer once having a sparkler. I think I was, like, five. And I remember there were a lot of tears because I burned my hand. And I was very sad. This is, I guess we're on the eve of the 250th birthday of the United States of America. So we're about to the semi quincentennial. Is that what they're saying?
C
Yeah. And you were sharing with me some of your memories from the bicentennial, which
B
I wasn't alive for.
C
No, I was the one that was alive then.
B
What was young Kevin out doing?
C
I was, like, reading comic books, watching tv.
B
So you weren't actually celebrating your nation's birth?
C
There were comic books to be read, TV shows to be watched. I remember I grew up in Columbus, Indiana, which you always say is the Athens of the prairies. And I remember for some reason, all the fire hydrants, all of the mini fire hydrants that we have throughout our great city of Columbus, Indiana, for safety purposes were all painted for the bicentennial. I think they were, like, painted as comic book characters. At least some of them were.
B
I feel like there's not really much. I mean, like, I don't know, not that I've heard of. We're kind of in our true crime bubble a lot. So maybe there's stuff going on that we're not aware of. But I feel like I don't really hear a lot about people painting stuff or doing much. It seems like we're, you know, kind of letting this one go by.
C
Well, I'm glad you're not. I'm glad you. You put the money into the Uncle Sam suit and the hat.
B
I'm not gonna wear an uncle suit. And frankly, like. Like, shut up. Like, you're just. You're just singing inane stuff all day. I've. I've let it slide for the past three or so cheat sheets. And you're done. You're done. You're absolutely done.
C
So you see, folks, at the end of three cheat sheets, tempers start to flare. The system starts.
B
Why you always describe me in the most unflattering terms. Who wants to hear about you talking about me wearing an Uncle Sam suit? Like Also, what woman wants their husband to picture them as Uncle Sam? What is wrong with you?
C
I. I think women who love their country, who love patriotism, who have pride in their country, but.
B
Well, no, why don't you. You know what? Like, it's gonna be. It's gonna be some conversations
C
I love.
B
Also, no one can see this, but Nora's sitting, like, really placidly right behind Kevin, just looking like an arct. Meanwhile, when I yelled, Nick jumped off the couch, ready to spring into action.
C
Ha ha, ha.
B
All right, are we done with this inane banter?
C
I think it's time to start hearing about cases.
B
Let's do it. My name is Anya Cain. I'm a journalist.
C
And I'm Kevin Greenlee. I'm an attorney.
B
And this is the Murder Sheet.
C
We're a true crime podcast focused on original reporting, interviews, and deep dives into murder cases.
B
We're the Murder Sheet, and this is the Cheat Sheet. Fiends and fireworks.
C
Anya, take it away.
B
All right, I think I'm going. I'm up at bat. So my first case is in Indiana, and my source for this is the Indiana Lawyer. And I also did some digging on my case, as well as newspapers.com, which is a wonderful resource for any of you folks who are interested in researching older crimes. The media used to be better. Like, just gonna be blunt about it. Like, you used to get a lot of information from your local newspaper, even as recently as 10 years ago, that just does not exist now. And, you know, we've lost a lot. But you can go back and look at old cases that way. Evansville Courier and Press was very helpful for. For me for this one, and that was accessed through Newspapers.com, a great resource. So this is a horrible, horrible case. One of those ones that kind of defies any real understanding. You're not going to find a motive, at least not what I. I didn't find one. I didn't find one. Um, it's possible it's in the record and I just missed it. Or it's possible. I'm not saying I did the deepest dive in the world here. This is a cheat sheet. We're kind of giving you the capsulation of the whole thing, but I don't know why this happened. No explanation would really make it make sense, though. So on April 10, 2010, in Evansville, Indiana, a man named Jeffrey Weish Height was watching his fiance's two children, 5 year old Caleb and 8 year old Alyssa Lynch. So the lynch children. And this is in Vanderburg county. And for whatever, I mean, for, I mean he, he, he brutally killed them. He hog tied Caleb, a five year old boy, put railroad flares in his underwear and ignited them and then fled the house. The house burned down, killing Caleb and Alyssa, who was also in the house. He was then chased down by law enforcement and there was a high speed chase. He went to Kentucky and he threw a knife at responding officers. They tased him I believe, and they took him into custody. And he was ultimately convicted by a jury on two counts of murder and they gave him a death sentence because there were so many aggravating circumstances to this. And also, I mean one notable thing is that Alyssa was 8, Caleb was 5, they're both under 12. That's, that's yet another aggravating circumstance. So he's been asking for post conviction relief. That was denied. The Supreme Court of Indiana affirmed that decision. He went to federal court. They filed habeas corpus petitions in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana. That was denied. In 2022, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed the decision. And most recently on June 8, 2026, United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case. Kevin, as an attorney, what, what does that, I mean, what does that mean? Do, does the U.S. supreme Court hear every case that they get asked to hear?
C
No, absolutely not. The Supreme Court, they are in the enviable position of getting to choose their own workload. You can ask for your case to be heard by the Supreme Court and then it's up to the justices themselves to decide whether or not to hear it. If they think a case poses an interesting question or if they think it raises an issue that needs to be clarified, they will vote to hear it and grant that's called granting a certiori.
B
So it's almost like usually, and correct me if I'm wrong, usually, at the very least it has to ask an interesting legal question and can't just be like you're run of a mill. There's nothing surprising here. Yeah, generally, generally, okay.
C
It has to usually involve a conflict between like two different states. Has to involve a federal question of law.
B
So now that it's been rejected by the United States Supreme Court, Indiana Attorney General Todd Rakita has asked the Indiana supreme to schedule Weish Heights execution. And I believe there's maybe four other men on death row in Indiana, but they are looking to execute this man. Some complications of this, you know, the way people are executed in Indiana, we need pentobarbital That's a drug that has been used in the last round of lethal injections here. But it can be very difficult to get that. So it's not even clear if they have the means to execute him, but they are asking for it to be scheduled. And if the Supreme Court goes for it, he will be executed in Michigan City at the Indiana State Prison. I just want to note something because again, I was so troubled by the lack of motive here, and I figured I would note something. It seems like this individual was not.
A
Was.
B
Was engaged to the children's mother, but was not related to them. And I think it is worth noting that there is a lot of research out there that points to when you have young, young children living in a household with unrelated adults, adults who are not biologically kin to them, they are like, far more likely to die by an inflicted injury. When the person is a male caregiver, especially like a male caregiver who is dating the mom that is, you know, these are. These are risk, risky things as far as child abuse go. And unfortunately in this case, fatal child murder. That's not to say at all that it's da. Like, basically what they look at it with the data is like, the risk is not actually with having a single parent home. That's not the risk. The risk is bringing basically unrelated males into the household. That's not to say that no one should be able to date as a single parent or as a single mother. It's. And because most unrelated adults would never do something like this. And you can certainly find a very nice person to become a husband and a stepfather to children who's gonna be a wonderful addition to their life. I'm sure a lot of people we can talk to have wonderful stepparents who were great. It's not to say that, oh, don't do this because this'll happen. It's more to say that when you are integrating an unrelated adult into the household, just be paying very attention to how the children are treated, because that is a risk factor and that can go wrong. And it's men in particular. I mean, like, again, not all men, but when they were looking at. When they were looking at cases of fatal maltreatment, what I saw was that in. In one study, when they were looking at that, like, a very high percentage of the perpetrators were not related to the victims, and 94% of those unrelated perpetrators were men. So no shade to all the stepfathers and the fathers who stepped up and the great, you know, men who were an addition to kids lives And. And were. And got along great and everything went well. But it is to say, I just think people should be very careful and very cognizant of the numbers and of the risk factors so that they can make a very informed choice about who they bring around their children. That's all. I'll say.
C
That's a great point. Well said.
B
Now, am I going. No, we're going to end. We're going to do a sandwich, right? Because I'm going to end on my fireworks case.
C
Spoiler alert.
B
Oh, sorry.
C
So I'm going to be, I guess the filling in the Anya sandwich.
B
No, that. This sounds weird. It's getting weird. Let's just move on.
C
Yeah, we should. Third. Third Cheat sheet of the day. So, yeah, you gotta cut us some slack. Standards are slipping.
B
Don't say that. Okay, Standards are fine. Let's just move on.
C
Yeah, there was nothing wrong with that sandwich remark at all. That was top flight stuff. I'm not embarrassed or ashamed of that. Let's go to an awful, awful case out of Ontario, Canada. This summer, you need comfortable go anywhere pieces that are made with quality and care and affordability in mind. You need our wonderful sponsor, Quince.
B
Quince is a brand that brings us a little luxury in our lives. For less, they'll have you sporting 100% European linen pants and shirts. These are perfectly light, breathable looks for the hotter months, starting at just $34.
C
Or even super soft T shirts that you can wear all day. Or lightweight cotton sweaters for nighttime beach walks and bonfires. They even offer travel essentials and home goods.
B
This summer, I've been constantly wearing their 100% European linen fit and flare midi dress in deep navy. I love it. I even wore it to Crimecon with a matching quince beret and some red high heels. I really love how summery and breathable it is. It's one of those dresses where I felt I looked really polished while also feeling comfortable, even as I was trekking through all the twists and turns of Caesar's Palace. The dress is flattering and affordable and I couldn't recommend it highly enough. It's my Go to Summer look right now.
C
All of their stuff is terrific and priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. They cut costs by bypassing the middlemen. So no markups. Shop Quince today.
B
Make your summer wardrobe easier. Go to quince.commsheet for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns now available in Canada too. That's Q-U I N C E.commsheet for free shipping and 365 day returns.
A
Quince.commsheet Insurance isn't one size fits all. That's why customers have enjoyed Progressives name your price tool for years. Now. With the name your price tool, you tell them what you want to pay and they'll show you options that fit your budget. So whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that works better for you and your family, they make it easy to see your options. Visit progressive.com find a rate that works for you with the name your price tool Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state law Ever wonder who's out there making the world go round? It's truckers. Who unites baristas with coffee beans. Truckers who unites dogs with their favorite chew toy? Truckers. That's why Progressive offers truckers even more protection with cargo plus coverage to keep truckers moving right along. Quote Truck insurance today in as little as 8 minutes@progressivecommercial.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates coverage subject to policy terms, limits and conditions not yet available in California, New York and Virginia.
C
And the source for this is the National Post. It's another one of these cases that seems like there wasn't a real motive. This involves the death of an 83 year old woman named Eleanor Doney. She was killed by a 14 year old boy who's not being named publicly. Basically she was just outside in her front lawn doing some gardening. A boy walks by, talks to her for a couple of minutes and then viciously stabs her to death. And she died. I think like an hour after this attack occurred. When police investigated, they Learned that this 14 year old child was very, very online. And if people had been paying attention to his online activities, there certainly was a lot of indications there that things were going in an awful direction. He was on Discord and his chats there showed that he was very, very interested in killing in murderers. He was also interested in a character out of a Japanese comic book, Yashikage Kira. This is a character who is a murderer who tries to go through life without being exposed as a murderer and who stalks and murders women. This boy was very interested in this character to the extent that he would copy some of the language this character used. He also dressed in a way that kind of copied the clothes this character wrote. He like looked at his hand a lot too. And apparently this character that I'm not familiar with also has a hand fetish. He wrote a lot Online, this boy about getting away with murder and how he could get away with it. Unlike the historical serial killers, he's very interested online with sociopathy, psychopathy. He is like watching and consuming media about serial killers, about stabbing people, about how to get away with murder. He watched a video online about how to stab a person most effectively. He did online searches again for things like how serial killers got away. He watched a four hour YouTube video on the most sadistic serial killers in history. He's very interested in Ted Bundy. So these are the things that fill his mind. He looks up the bus schedule and he hops on the bus and he goes out walking in this neighborhood where he encounters this woman he killed. After he kills her, goes back online and he's consuming a typical YouTube diet. He's watching clips from Family Guy, clips from Breaking Bad, and then he is still watching YouTube until just about a half hour before police finally arrest him. And so what's disturbing about this is I don't know if this is a case where he was like, radicalized or changed by what he saw online, but it seems clear that at the very least, the online world gave him a platform and it gave him a venue with which to explore some disturbing interests and that he explored them in a very unhealthy way. And if people had been paying attention and if people have been keeping a good eye on him, I feel it is entirely possible that steps could have been taken to help him, to help steer him in a different direction, and perhaps this woman would still be alive today. What do you think about all this?
B
Yeah, I mean, judging from the, like, I'm, I'm of the opinion, like, kids can definitely hide stuff from their parents and guardians. I mean, right? Isn't that kind of being a teenager? I'm not, I don't consider myself, like, if someone's like, oh, my kid developed a drug problem and I didn't realize it until it was too late. Like, I can understand that. I think it's pretty, you know, but the, the dress here, the obsession with like a very violent, um, character. I'm not familiar with that property either. You know, the, the, like that level. I mean, all of that's enough, I think. Like, your, your parents, I mean, whatever. I don't know what his living situation was, but his parents or guardians had to be aware that he was a creepy little guy. You know, I mean, like, just flaunting around in that outfit. It just, I don't know, not like
C
he's having conversations online about how he can kill and get away.
B
Well, you know, maybe they don't know discord, but like, he, the way he's dressed, I mean, he looks.
C
I mean, the people he's talking with, they should have known.
B
Well, they should have. Well, yeah, they certainly should have. I mean, sir. I mean, but again, like, if those are other kids, then I'm just saying the parents have the most, you know, direct ability to do something about this. And again, if your. Your kids going through a phase where they're obsessed with, like, I don't know, something violent, I don't necessarily know that that is, that is going to make them a killer, but certainly maybe having a talk with them and ensuring that they don't have a bunch of misogynistic, creepy attitudes about everything and, you know, like, see life as a game where they're going to be the killer. You know, I think you. That's where you maybe probe a little bit deeper and you, you get a little bit more involved. And if you're seeing concerning signs, then you keep going. And it's just, you know, I don't know, people need, like, I just, like, if people just. That's. It's not really parenting to just like, let your kid on the Internet and let them consume and do whatever and take no responsibility for that. And you're just doing your kid a disservice because if they do something like this, then, you know, hopefully they go away for a while.
C
Well, I, I'm also, as I say, I think I'm interested in the people he was having these conversations with. And if you're having conversations online with somebody and you see them start doing some concerning things, you should say or do something about it. You should take it seriously.
B
You have a responsibility to say or do something about it, you know, and I don't, I don't understand how anyone in that situation could turn the other way and not do anything about it. And frankly, yeah, it disgusts me the lack of taking accountability here.
C
Let's move on to a case out of Alabama. Alabama. My source for this is the Justice Department and Fox 10 TV. Alabama has a great football program. Have nothing but good things to say about Alabama and offer them plenty of encouragement in the future because what a
B
great program they really are. But we support IU in this household.
C
But you've made clear, no taunting.
B
Because I don't want to taunt anybody doesn't mean that I'm not supporting iu.
C
We wish them nothing. But success is they continue unfettered up towards their ultimate destination.
B
Just say what you're gonna say
A
we
C
talk on the show a lot about police officers, obviously, and police officers are in a unique position because if they do something incorrectly, if they make mistakes, if they do something, God forbid, that's corrupt or wrong, it has a ripple effect. Because if a person is wrong or corrupt once, it raises questions about other cases they're involved in. And it really has a lot more impact than what might even be if first, most readily, apparently, and I'm talking today about a police officer with the Pritchard Police Department in Alabama, Emanuel Dodge. He has been arrested and charged with multiple criminal counts. I'm quoting from this press release from the U.S. attorney's office, including civil rights violations, conspiracy, taking bribes, tampering with evidence, and extortion. The criminal complaint alleges that Dodge covered up crimes and concealed evidence for violent individuals to assist them in avoiding prosecution. The complaint affidavit further alleges that Dodge conspired with other PPD officers to conduct unlawful traffic stops and detentions of victims to deprive them of rights secured by the Constitution and laws of the United States. Finally, the charges alleged that Dodge extorted individuals for bribes in exchange for letting them go free from arrest and agreed to accept corrupt payments to commit illegal acts, including transporting bulk marijuana, all while acting under the color of law as a police officer. This is horrifying stuff. But for me, it got even worse when I heard about the family of a man named Cornelius Cunningham. Mr. Cunningham was killed all the way back in February 27, 2018, and the person in charge of investigating that case is none other than Mr. Dodge, a family member. Kenitra Cunningham now says she has to wonder if perhaps his investigation of that crime was also somehow affected by his corruption. And that's a crime in which no one has been arrested or no one's been been charged. You know, she has to wonder, did he accept some sort of payoff? He let someone get free in that case? Yeah. There's no evidence that he did, but it raises the question, and it causes a lot of torment for innocent people in a horrible situation.
B
Well said. Yeah. It's like once you've proven. I mean, that's why it's so bad when police officers behave in this way or. Or do illegal things or. Or do anything remotely sketchy, frankly, because the ripple effects, as you said, and it's like these people, it's gonna haunt them. I mean, like, their. Their case, their loved one not getting justice. And would it have been different had it gone to a different officer? It's just, it's very troublesome. It can also taint an entire department. Right. It's like you hired this guy, you had him operating in your midst. How. How did you not catch this? It just when you have police officers behave in an unethical or corrupt way or bigoted or anything, like kind of throw in any negative thing, it undermines everyone's trust in law enforcement. And I think that has a really detrimental effect on society. But it's unavoidable because how can you trust when there's no basis for trust when people are behaving this way?
C
Exactly.
B
I'm glad they caught him, but it's like the damage is done. And there would, I would hope there would be extensive, extensive efforts from the agencies he was involved in and his colleagues there to regain trust and establish that here's what we're going to be doing to ensure that this can't happen again. And here's what we're doing to ensure that the rot is fully gone.
C
So, Anya, do you want to now move on to your much ballyhooed fireworks case?
B
Yeah, ballyhooed is a fun word. My case is in California and this was a pretty horrifying situation that happened out of Esparto, California. Esparto is in Yolo County. And it's. What happened was it was July 1, 2025, and a fireworks warehouse caught fire in Esparto. Obviously that's a very bad place to have a fire because there's fireworks everywhere. There were a number of explosions and ultimately a massive blast. So there were seven victims who were working there, I believe. And I'm gonna read their names because I think it's always important to reflect on the names of the dead. And these are the people whose lives were lost in this horrible situation. 18 year old angel Matthew Voller, Carlos Javier Rodriguez Mora, who's 43, Neil Justin Lee, 41. Joel Jeremias Melendez, 28, Christopher Galtiao Bocock, 45, Jesus Manasseh Ramos, 18 and Honey Ernesto Ramos, 22. So they were all killed. Horrible explosion. And also it started a fire. It started the Oakdale fire. And that was ultimately contained on July 6th. So they immediately begin investigating this fireworks concern. And ultimately they find a lot of really troubling things. One thing is that the warehouse was associated with a company called Devastating Pyrotechnics. The owner and CEO of that was a man named Kenneth Chee. Now, he was operating this business despite having been denied a license by the atf, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, to even own explosives. So they denied him that permit. And that was because he had been convicted in 1998 of assault with a firearm and firing a gun from a vehicle. And basically, if you do something like that, if you. If it's like a certain type of crime, they will just not give you a federal explosives license. And yet somehow, while the ATF said no, the state fire marshal said yes when he asked to be able to trade, sell, and launch fireworks. So he was like, I don't know how that happens, but the federal government said no. Apparently, California said yes. And they were also permitted to store fireworks in storage containers that were 2,000ft away from the site of the explosion. So you're already kind of hearing some things of like, okay, this is kind of concerning. This is sketchy. Obviously, accidents and tragedies can happen, but in instances where people are running extremely unsafe workplaces and disaster strikes, there can be legal. There can be more significant legal culpability there. And also, you find out that apparently this guy had a Yolo county sheriff's lieutenant working for him, storing a million pounds of explosive on his property, and apparently using, or is alleged to have used his position with the sheriff's office to sort of like kind of shield this operation. So April 10, 2026, eight people were arrested and charged. A number of them were charged with murder as well, including she. And so that is kind of where they are right now. The YOLO County District attorney is asking a judge to basically put down a gag order in this case. That's why it's in the news right now, or it was in the news. And my source for this, by the way, was the Sacramento Bee. They had an article on this gag order business. They're. They're basically saying, we don't want the attorneys of record to be and prospective witnesses to be commenting on this. There had been some of that going on in the press. And, you know, they basically. They're basically asking for this. So not sure what's going to happen, but it does show you that, you know, murder. Often we think of it as like, oh, I want somebody to die and I'm going to go kill them. But there can be murder charges in cases like this where there are concerns about the operation someone was running and how safe it was. And we'll have to see what happens in terms of the trials to see what sort of outcome takes place here. But certainly very concerning allegations out of California.
C
Absolutely.
B
All right. How you doing?
C
I think this is the fifth anniversary of our return from our honeymoon awesome.
B
Wow, you're really tracking everything, aren't you?
C
I am.
B
Well. Huh.
C
I remember. Have we talked about fireworks on the show? Do you like fireworks?
B
So I didn't grow, I grew up in New York and I didn't grow up in a fireworks family. It was all girls. I. I just remember reading a book about a little girl who turned into a ghost because a fireworks exploded in her hands and she lost her hands and then she's a ghost and she's haunting people and I remember being like, oh, pass on that. I don't want, I don't want to deal with that.
C
See, to me that would just be like a challenge. I remember when I grew up, Indiana had some frankly ridiculous law where there's like out of state fireworks, which were. Was code for the really cool fireworks. But you could only buy those if you signed a piece of paper saying, well, I'm buying these in Indiana, but I'll send them off in another state. No one took that seriously. We all went and we bought the out of state fireworks and set them off in Indiana. Yeah, sure, sometimes they exploded in our faces and once I lost hearing for a day or so. But, you know, isn't it worth it?
B
Didn't you almost shoot off fireworks in your face once? Wasn't that a story I've heard?
C
Yeah, this is the one where I lost hearing for a day or so.
B
Why don't you explain what happened to the listener so maybe they can learn. Be safe. Be careful as you're doing stuff tomorrow.
C
Well, you know, my dad is a firefighter, so I'm well aware of.
B
So he was just standing his head, standing there shaking his head in abject disappointment throughout this.
C
No, it wasn't my fault. We were setting off fireworks and we set them off on a metal table and one of the fireworks I set off was somehow defective, in which case. By what, by what I mean by that is when I lit it, which I lit, I lit it properly, okay? In very respectful, safe fashion. Of course, the second I lit it, it immediately goes off and goes off with great force with a loud boom, as I say, made it difficult to hear for a couple of days. But I was very lucky because also it was defective in such a way that it was supposed to go up into the air, but for some reason it went down and the metal table it was on got really pretty badly mangled and destroyed. Completely unusable. So if that had gone up in my face instead of going down, if it had gone up as it was supposed to, I probably would have been injured or killed. Yeah, but wasn't it worth it? No. Because I got to see some pretty cool fireworks.
B
Folks, be very careful with fireworks. I don't have any safety tips to give because I've never shot off fireworks, because that's just not what I'm about in my life.
C
You're a bit of a coward.
B
No, I just. I feel like there's something a bit like, what are we doing? And frankly, listen, I love you, Indiana. I know I'm gonna sound like the biggest buzzkill in the world here, but, you know, when we. There was a place where we lived in Indiana for a while where it was just. It sounded like a battlefield outside, and our dog would just freak out all night on the 4th of July, and it was like, we're. Is this not overdoing it a little bit? Like, come on. Like, I. If you want to shoot up fireworks, fine. But why. Why is. Why, like, why does it look like we've been invaded? Why is. My dog. She's having a panic attack. This was. Poor Lanny. I don't. I don't know how. I don't know how these guys will do with fireworks. They don't really seem to care about thunder, so maybe they're more patriotic dogs than Lanny was. But, you know, I just. It. That was just a lot. It was a lot to go from, like, very. Not like they used to set off fireworks at, like. Like, a business, I think, near me when I was growing up. But it, like, you know, I don't know. There were fireworks, but they just seemed more distant. Not like, oh, right outside my house. It was more of like, oh, we can go to the park and look at the fireworks in the distance. Or like, kind of look across there and then you'll see them setting it off in this town center. But. But around Indiana, it was just like, oh, my God, Doug.
C
Well, we would do that.
B
I like fireworks. I like them.
C
Yeah, we would do that here, too. But also, you know, here in the
B
Midwest, people are taking it in their own hands.
C
Yeah.
B
And their faces, apparently, at least in your case. Or their metal tables.
C
Well, I'm fine. And I got to see a cool firework for a couple of days. I didn't have to hear as much as I'm usually bothered with hearing. And I was able to dispose of a metal table.
B
What a wonderful outcome.
C
So no lasting injuries. Just. Just a lot of fun and merriment.
B
Barely an issue.
C
All in honor of our great country.
B
Are you going to try to do fireworks this year?
C
I Have not gotten any fireworks yet. Maybe.
B
Are you gonna. Yeah, I just. Honestly, I'm a little concerned. Based on your history, I was surprised.
C
As we were walking around with our dogs the other day, I saw in our neighborhood a sign that somebody had done the saddest, most pathetic, just embarrassing Fourth of December, July. I'm not going to call it a firework thing. This is. Have you ever seen this? The. The. The snakes.
B
The snakes.
C
It's like a black, thick black tablet that you, like, put on the ground, and you light it, and then it becomes like, it expands and becomes like a column of black ash, which you are asked to believe. Oh, this is a snake growing. It's just ash in the shape of a column.
B
Why are you trying to beef with our neighbors and anyone, any of the snake people?
C
And then it leaves a black mark on your driveway that lasts for years in some cases.
B
My goodness. That lasts for years.
C
Yes.
B
Mark of the snake. That sounds like a thriller.
C
When I. When I moved out of my childhood home and my parents did, there were still places on the driveway where you can see where I sadly lit a snake.
B
So. So that sounds like a euphemism, but it really does. And so. So you're basically damaging your house's resale value. Or maybe people don't care what their driveways look like. I don't know. But I don't know that just. I mean, honestly, it's all very foreign to me. I'm not going to lie. And I feel like, I mean, we have a couple of European listeners. Do you guys do fireworks in Europe? Is this just an American thing? I don't even know. I kind of assume it is, but to me, you know, I mean, if you were going to be actually seriously careful about it, I would be okay with it. But I would need your commitment not to be doing any buffoonery.
C
I don't even know the meaning of the word buffooner.
B
You don't know anything about buffoonery? That doesn't sound familiar to you at all? Well, here's a note. Since we're getting into July, we have a cool event coming up for all you folks in Ohio, the Buckeyes State. Sunday, July 12, 2026, in Columbus, Ohio. We will be appearing at the Columbus Book Festival. And again, this is Columbus, Ohio. Don't go to Indiana. I mean, you can. It's a lovely city. Columbus, Indiana. But that's not where we'll be. We're going to be going to Columbus, Ohio. And first of all, at noon on that day on Sunday, July 12th we'll be moderating a panel of authors on Midwest Murders at the festival 3pm we'll be doing author speed matching and we'll be having a blast and it's gonna be fun. I hope to see you there. Please, please, please let us know if you're coming cause we'd love to sign your book and meet you and take pictures and do whatever you wanna do.
C
And this is part of Anya's plan for our big Columbus tour. Eventually we'll go to Columbus Georgia, Columbus Mississippi, Columbus Nebraska, Columbus Wisconsin, Columbus Kansas, Columbus Montana. It's quite the undertaking.
B
It really is. And it's not going to happen. It's that much of an undertaking, but
C
I'm very excited about it. Hit the button. We've done three of these. It's time to maybe we do 15 next week.
B
But it's I, I, I'm sure all the places of Columbus are very nice. So goodbye then joining our Patreon that's available at www.patreon.com murdersheet. If you want to tip us a bit of money for records requests, you can do so at www. Buymeacoffee.com murdersheet. We very much appreciate any support.
C
Special thanks to Kevin Tyler Greenlee, who composed the music for the Murder Sheet and who you can find on the web@kevintg.com if you're looking to talk with
B
other listeners about a case we've covered, you can join the Murder Sheet discussion group on Facebook. We mostly focus our time on research and reporting, so we're not on social media much. We do try to check our email account, but we ask for patience as we often receive a lot of messages. Thanks again for listening. The sun is calling. Are you ready? From beach days to soccer plays. Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen helps protect your family skin so you can focus on the fun, not the sun. With no fragrances, parabens or phthalates, our mineral sunscreen is designed for your sensitive skin and trusted by dermatologists, pediatricians and parents alike. Be Fearless in the sky the sun with Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen Shop now on Amazon.com Be adventurous in the sun Be protected in the sun Be confident in the sun Be fearless in the sun with Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen. As experts in mineral sunscreens for nearly 30 years, we've earned awards for our high quality products and the trust of healthcare professionals. Embrace every moment in the sun with with your family and Blue Lizard by your side. Be fearless in the Sun Shop Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen now on Amazon com.
Released: July 3, 2026
Hosts: Áine ("Anya") Cain & Kevin Greenlee
In this special “Cheat Sheet” episode, journalists Áine Cain and attorney Kevin Greenlee explore a collection of recent and unusual cases from Indiana, Alabama, California, and Canada. The episode weaves in timely July 4th reflections and fireworks safety anecdotes, but remains grounded in thoughtful true crime analysis and legal commentary. Topics range from a horrific double child homicide, to online radicalization’s real-world consequences, police corruption and its ripple effects, and criminal negligence leading to deadly fireworks warehouse explosions. Expect the hosts’ characteristic mix of journalistic rigor, dark humor, and societal insights.
Summary:
Anya details the chilling 2010 double child homicide in Evansville, Indiana. Jeffrey Weish Height, engaged to the victims’ mother but unrelated by blood, murdered 5-year-old Caleb Lynch and 8-year-old Alyssa Lynch in a particularly brutal fashion—hog-tying Caleb, igniting railroad flares in his underwear, and setting the home on fire.
Legal developments:
Systemic context & analysis:
“When you have young, young children living in a household with unrelated adults... they are far more likely to die by an inflicted injury. When the person is a male caregiver... these are risky things as far as child abuse go.” (B, 12:09)
Notable Quote:
“No explanation would really make it make sense though.” (B, 06:55)
Legal insight:
Kevin explains Supreme Court procedures:
“You can ask your case to be heard by the Supreme Court and then it’s up to the justices... If they think a case poses an interesting question... they will vote to hear it.” (C, 10:11)
“I think... his parents or guardians had to be aware he was a creepy little guy. Just flaunting around in that outfit... the way he’s dressed, I mean, he looks—” (B, 23:03) “If you’re having conversations online with somebody and you see them start doing some concerning things, you should say or do something about it.” (C, 24:57)
“She has to wonder if perhaps his investigation of that crime was also somehow affected by his corruption.” (C, 28:05)
“When you have police officers behave in an unethical or corrupt way... it undermines everyone’s trust in law enforcement. And I think that has a really detrimental effect on society. But it’s unavoidable...” (B, 29:21)
“Murder—often we think of it as, ‘I want someone to die and I’m going to kill them’—but there can be murder charges in cases like this where there are concerns about the operation someone was running and how safe it was.” (B, 34:55)
Hosts’ reflections:
Kevin reminisces about childhood fireworks (“out-of-state” fireworks loopholes in Indiana), his own dangerous mishaps, and the general atmosphere around Independence Day. Anya shares her aversion stemming from a ghost story involving fireworks and her concern for anxious pets.
Memorable exchange:
Kevin: “Sometimes they exploded in our faces and once I lost hearing for a day or so. But... isn’t it worth it?”
Anya: “Didn’t you almost shoot off fireworks in your face once?... Be safe. Be careful as you’re doing stuff tomorrow.” (37:00)
Safety note:
Emphasize caution and awareness of both legal and safety guidelines, especially in light of the earlier warehouse case.
Conversational, direct, with a blend of dark humor and measured analysis; stays sensitive to victims’ experiences while not shying away from pointed commentary on systemic failures, justice, and prevention.
This episode of Murder Sheet is a prime example of how true crime can be more than lurid detail—it offers thoughtful narrative, legal literacy, social context, and occasional levity, whether recounting fireworks mishaps or deadly consequences of negligence.
For more, join their Patreon or see them at live events.