Podcast Summary: Murder Sheet

Episode: "The Cheat Sheet: Hurricanes and Housewives"

Date: February 13, 2026
Hosts: Áine Cain (Journalist), Kevin Greenlee (Attorney)

Overview

In this episode of Murder Sheet, hosts Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee guide listeners through a quickfire “cheat sheet” of recent crime stories, both historical and ongoing. They discuss developments in a notorious UK serial murder case, the complications of a Louisiana homicide during a hurricane, the legal debate over using rap lyrics as evidence in a California case, and highlight cold and missing persons cases in Indiana. The conversation is seasoned with their signature banter, editorializing, and memorable asides about state nicknames and Indiana university rivalries.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. UK Segment: The Victoria Hall Case & Serial Killer Steve Wright

[04:46 – 14:10]

• Áine covers the 1999 disappearance and murder of 17-year-old Victoria Hall in Suffolk, England.
• Victoria disappeared after a night out with a friend; her body was found five days later.
• The case was unsolved for years, with a failed prosecution due to weak evidence:
  • "90 minutes into deliberation they returned a not guilty verdict." (Anya Cain, 10:53)
  • "Usually there's enough meat on the bone for them to chew on and discuss for a while. It sounds like nobody on that jury was even mildly persuaded by that case." (Kevin Greenlee, 10:28)
• Steve Wright, later convicted as the “Suffolk Strangler” for the murder of five sex workers in 2006, was recently charged and has now pled guilty to Victoria Hall’s murder.
  • Discussion of how serial killers can “evolve” after initial crimes: "A serial killer early in their career can evolve...they realize that's not what I want, what I really want is this." (Anya Cain, 06:21)
• Notable detail: the night before Hall’s murder, Wright attempted to abduct another woman, who escaped.
• Case resolved through new DNA evidence and this witness testimony.
• Áine’s editorial:
  • "Serial killers are such frigging losers...We should not be sitting around being like, ooh, they're so cool and edgy. We should be sitting around saying, they suck." (Anya Cain, 14:12)

2. Louisiana Homicide in the Shadow of a Hurricane: Javon Tumblin

[20:07 – 25:14]

• Kevin recounts the unsolved 2024 killing of Javon Tumblin in Baton Rouge—murdered during Hurricane Francine.
• The hurricane hampered investigation efforts:
  • Surveillance footage was nearly useless due to weather.
  • Early investigative hours lost; potential evidence destroyed.
  • "When a crime gets attention, people come forward with information…" (Kevin Greenlee, 20:07)
• The murder was consequently overlooked by media focused on the hurricane’s aftermath.
• Tumblin’s family is still seeking answers; his young daughter has lost her father.
• Áine draws a parallel with the unsolved case of Heinrich Suak in NYC during 9/11, emphasizing how timing and major events can doom investigations.
  • "There can just be these unlucky situations where somebody is murdered when something else is going on..." (Anya Cain, 24:41)

3. California: Rap Lyrics as Evidence in Lil Durk/Quando Rondo Case

[26:17 – 38:15]

• The case centers on rapper Lil Durk (Dirk Devante Banks), accused of arranging a bounty resulting in a shooting targeting rival rapper Quando Rondo (Taekwein Terrell Bauman).
• Key legal issue: Should prosecutors be able to use rap lyrics as evidence?
  • Kevin: "If I write a rap song...with really strong details that implicate her in a specific crime...that's something that probably should be admitted." (29:13)
  • Áine: "If it's hyper specific...it should be used. But if it's just like, 'I'm gonna kill my enemies,'...that's...heightened emotions." (29:58)
• Examples discussed from prosecutor filings (e.g., lyrics about “getting it back in blood” and unreleased tracks referencing “bounty hunters” and nearby locations).
• Both hosts question the relevance—are prosecutors overreaching?
  • "That...sounds a little weak to me." (Kevin Greenlee, 31:37)
  • Concerns about prejudice against rap music/artists versus how lyrics in other genres are treated.
  • "Rock and roll can have a lot of very sexually aggressive lyrics. Right. But I don't think anyone should look at those and say these rock and roll artists are rapists..." (Anya Cain, 33:46)
• References to pop culture: Key & Peele’s “Rap Album Confession” sketch as the “obvious” case for lyric admissibility.

4. Indiana Cold Cases & Missing Person

[38:15 – 54:34]

a. Sarah Jeanette Benson (1981 Cold Case, Sullivan County, IN)

[46:24 – 54:06]

• Áine covers the unsolved murder of Jeanette Benson, who likely interrupted a home burglary and was shot.
• Witnesses described seeing a thin, tall white male with a blue sedan and specific shoes.
• Police believe the killer, then in his 20s, may still be alive and encourage tips, urging listeners to spread awareness and contact Sullivan County authorities.

b. Lillian Marie Key (2026 Missing Teen, Avon, IN)

[54:06 – 54:34]

• Sixteen-year-old Lillian Key has been missing since January 12, 2026.
• She left a new foster home with another girl who returned, but Lillian remains missing.
• Possible last known area: 21st and Post Road, Indianapolis, but could be elsewhere.
• Áine appeals directly to listeners to help by sharing her photo, contacting authorities with sightings, and reassures Lillian she is loved.

Notable Quotes & Moments

• On Serial Killer Fascination:
  • “Why do we have a mystique around these people? ...We should be sitting around saying, they suck.” (Anya Cain, 14:12)
• On Hurricane Homicide Complications:
  • “External factors can really affect and hamper a police investigation...sometimes it’s the fact that when a crime gets attention, people come forward with information...” (Kevin Greenlee, 20:07)
• On Using Rap Lyrics as Evidence:
  • “If you’re stupid enough to put it in a rap song, then that’s kind of your problem at that point.” (Anya Cain, 29:58)
  • “I don’t think we should be overusing weak prejudicial evidence in a case like this.” (Anya Cain, 35:52)
• On Indiana’s “Hoosier State” Nickname:
  • “Our nickname game...we need to work on it. I’m just being blunt.” (Kevin Greenlee, 38:37)
  • Extended comedic banter about state pride, Indiana’s “crossroads” branding, Purdue vs. IU, and local legends.

Timestamps for Major Segments

• [04:46] UK – Victoria Hall cold case & Steve Wright serial killer development
• [10:28] Kevin critiques failed prosecution in Hall’s case
• [14:12] Áine editorializes on serial killer culture
• [20:07] Louisiana – Javon Tumblin murder during Hurricane Francine
• [24:41] Áine draws parallel with Suak/9-11 case
• [26:17] California – Rap lyrics as evidence (Lil Durk case)
• [31:37] Discussion on the weakness of some prosecutor claims
• [46:24] Indiana – Jeanette Benson 1981 cold case
• [54:06] Indiana – Lillian Key missing person update

Memorable Banter and Tone

Throughout the episode, the hosts maintain a personable, down-to-earth style:

• Bantering about state nicknames ("Sportsman's Paradise" for Louisiana) and regional pride.
• Playful feuds about academic institutions (Purdue “Boilermakers” vs. Indiana).
• Direct address to listeners (“You guys are the real ones”) and calls to action for helping solve or spread awareness about cases.
• Meta-commentary on their own podcast structure and in-jokes (e.g., “code words” for devoted listeners, pancakes and French toast).

Conclusion

“The Cheat Sheet: Hurricanes and Housewives” is a showcase of Murder Sheet’s mix of true crime reporting and real-time commentary. The hosts deliver concise but thorough case rundowns, raise ethical/legal questions, and balance gravity with humor. The episode provides both information on underreported cases and a personality-driven, accessible listening experience for crime aficionados and casual listeners alike.