Podcast Summary: Murder Sheet – "The Cheat Sheet: Mentality and Memorabilia"

Release Date: August 8, 2025
Hosts: Áine Cain (Journalist) and Kevin Greenlee (Attorney)

1. Addressing Online Harassment and Safety Concerns

Timestamp: [03:09] – [08:34]

In this episode, Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee begin by addressing recent harassment from an individual named Temujin Kinzu (formerly Fred Freeman). Kevin emphasizes the severity of Kinzu's actions, stating:

"Our inbox is full of communications from people who have been abused and who find this sort of situation to be very triggering and who feel unsafe about participating in those kinds of discussions." ([04:40])

The hosts clarify their stance against engaging with individuals who threaten or harass, particularly highlighting the alarming behavior of Kinzu and his wife, who have been doxing and intimidating their own daughter. Áine adds:

"We're not backing down here, and we stand by our reporting and they can lie about us all they want. It doesn't really change the bare facts of the situation, which is people are seeing this for what it is." ([06:25])

The segment underscores the podcast's commitment to maintaining journalistic integrity and protecting their audience from harmful interactions.

2. Update on the Kayla Farmer Murder Case

Timestamp: [14:49] – [19:10]

Áine provides an update on the tragic 2023 case involving the murder of Kayla Farmer by her estranged husband, Joshua Farmer, in Fishers, Indiana. Emphasizing the severity of domestic abuse, she notes:

"This is just a quick note on a case we covered previously... domestic violence can escalate, the abuse can escalate to the point of murder." ([16:37])

Áine highlights newly received body cam footage that reveals the ambush at a gas station, where Joshua Farmer took Kayla's life. The discussion serves as a poignant reminder of the dangers of unchecked domestic abuse.

3. Serial Killer Investigation: Jesse Lee Calhoun

Timestamp: [20:03] – [21:22]

Kevin shifts the conversation to a concerning serial killer case in Oregon involving Jesse Lee Calhoun, a 39-year-old charged with multiple murders, including that of Kristen Smith. He explains:

"He is being investigated for involvement in yet another murder. So this man sounds like a serial killer." ([20:08])

The hosts express frustration over the lack of detailed evidence released by law enforcement and commend the resilience of the victims' families, particularly Diana Allen, who remains patient and respectful of the legal process despite the anguish.

4. Alabama's Felony Murder Law and the Lakeith Smith Case

Timestamp: [26:32] – [43:05]

A significant portion of the episode delves into the controversial application of Alabama's felony murder law through the Lakeith Smith case. Kevin recounts the 2015 incident where Smith, then 15, was involved in a burglary that led to the death of Adante Washington, a 16-year-old who was fatally shot by police during the intrusion.

"The boys were running out of the house when the cops arrived. And in the confusion, my son was shot three times in the back by the police and pronounced deceased at the scene." ([40:00])

Áine and Kevin critique the felony murder charges leveled against Smith and his accomplices, arguing that applying murder charges to acts committed during a felony, especially when the resultant death is by law enforcement in self-defense, is unjust. They draw parallels to a past case they covered involving Redline, where felony murder charges were overturned.

Kevin reflects:

"It's really hard for me to understand how felony murder is being applied here... I don't see how it's a murder if it's a justifiable homicide by police." ([36:32])

The discussion highlights systemic biases and the disproportionate impact of such laws on young Black men, calling for legal reforms to ensure fairer treatment.

5. Upcoming Book Release and Event Announcements

Timestamp: [57:50] – [67:19]

Áine and Kevin announce their collaboratively authored book, A Shadow of the Bridge, set to release on August 26th. They discuss plans for book signings, including a notable event in Delphi at the Biscuits Shop, and promotions for their upcoming appearance at Denver's CrimeCon.

"If you haven't gotten your tickets yet, consider doing Code MurderSheet, because you'll get 10% off your standard badge." ([59:36])

The hosts invite listeners to join their Patreon and other support platforms, emphasizing community engagement and upcoming live events.

6. Lighthearted Moments and Community Engagement

Timestamp: [43:02] – [80:54]

Towards the latter part of the episode, the hosts share humorous anecdotes about their personal lives, such as Kevin earning a letter in high school through participation in the varsity AV Club, and awkward experiences at book signings. They also promote merchandise like shirts and mugs from their online shop, engaging listeners with relatable and entertaining conversations.

"But if you do, you can get it from us, but not John Irving..." ([75:03])

These segments provide a balance to the heavy true crime discussions, showcasing the hosts' personalities and fostering a deeper connection with their audience.

7. Final Thoughts on Personal Safety

Timestamp: [80:54] – [81:26]

The episode concludes with Kevin and Áine discussing the importance of home security, especially given the emotional and sometimes threatening nature of true crime reporting. They endorse Simplisafe as their trusted security system provider, highlighting its reliability and comprehensive protection features.

"With Simplisafe, we're able to keep the Murder Sheet train chugging along and not worry about that too much because we know that they are so proactive about how they keep homes secure." ([81:12])

Key Takeaways:

• Commitment to Integrity: Murder Sheet stands firm against harassment and continues to deliver in-depth true crime reporting despite external threats.

• Critical Legal Analysis: The podcast critically examines the application of felony murder laws, advocating for legal reforms to prevent miscarriages of justice.

• Community and Engagement: Through book releases, event participations, and engaging discussions, Murder Sheet fosters a strong connection with its audience.

• Personal Touch: The hosts balance serious content with personal stories and humor, making the podcast both informative and relatable.

Notable Quotes:

• Kevin Greenlee: "The idea of intimidating people into silence enrages me." ([07:35])
• Áine Cain: "Domestic violence can escalate, the abuse can escalate to the point of murder." ([16:37])
• Kevin Greenlee: "I don't see how it's a murder if it's a justifiable homicide by police." ([36:32])
• Áine Cain: "This is something that's gonna give the facts and not really varnish the truth here." ([66:05])

For more detailed discussions and updates on these cases, listeners are encouraged to tune into the full episode of Murder Sheet.