Podcast Summary: Murder Sheet – "The Cheat Sheet: Nighttime and Nurses"

Episode Overview Released on June 20, 2025, "The Cheat Sheet: Nighttime and Nurses" is an episode of the Murder Sheet podcast, a true crime series hosted by journalist Áine Cain and attorney Kevin Greenlee. This episode delves into four distinct murder cases across Alabama, Minnesota, New Hampshire, and Indiana, providing in-depth analysis and thoughtful discussions on each.

1. Alabama Case: Lead Poisoning Attempted Murder

Case Details: The episode begins with a harrowing case from Alabama involving Brian Mann, who was convicted of attempting to murder his wife, Hannah Mann, by causing her to ingest large quantities of lead. Hannah's blood lead levels soared to the 80s, significantly above the safe threshold of 10.

Host Insights: The hosts emphasize the complexity of human emotions in such cases, highlighting the profound impact on the family, especially the children involved.

Notable Quotes:

• Unknown Speaker (Kevin Greenlee): "Hannah Mann ultimately went to the hospital... her lead levels were in the 80s... the doctors had to temporarily paralyze her because if she moved, it could throw off some of the things and the pressure on her brain." [06:31]

• Áine Cain: "She's awfully forgiving of this guy. She even says, like, I hope he changes. I don't think you should assume anyone is ever going to change after they do something like this." [07:55]

Discussion: Áine expresses concern over Hannah's forgiveness, questioning the assumption that perpetrators can change post-crime. She reinforces the severity of Brian's actions, labeling them as cowardly and harmful to the family unit.

2. Minnesota Case: Politically Motivated Assassinations

Case Details: The Minnesota case involves a series of violent attacks targeting state legislators and prominent Democratic figures. On June 14, 2025, at 2:05 AM, a masked assailant impersonating a police officer entered the home of State Senator John Hoffman and his wife Yvette, shooting both of them. The perpetrator, Vance Luther Bolter, continued his spree by attacking Melissa Hortman and her husband Mark, both active in Democratic politics and abortion rights activism. Bolter's manifesto and subsequent actions suggest a politically motivated agenda against liberal politicians.

Host Insights: The hosts dissect the aftermath, including a disinformation campaign that emerged, attempting to deflect blame onto the victims' political affiliations. They critique the spread of conspiracy theories and emphasize the importance of factual reporting over sensationalism.

Notable Quotes:

• Unknown Speaker (Kevin Greenlee): "If you are targeting people who are politicians and who are making policies and you are killing them or terrorizing them based on your opinions of their views, you're really perverting the system in a really disgusting way." [17:25]

• Áine Cain: "There appeared to be basically a disinformation campaign... it seems like the goal was to essentially deflect blame." [24:08]

Discussion: Áine expresses frustration over the disinformation surrounding Bolter's motives, criticizing both sides for spreading unfounded theories. The episode underscores the tragic loss of life and the manipulation of narratives in politically charged crimes.

3. New Hampshire Case: Death in a Psychiatric Unit

Case Details: In New Hampshire, Jason Roth died under suspicious circumstances in a state prison's psychiatric unit. Former correctional officer Matthew Miller is accused of causing Roth's death by placing his knee on Roth's back for nearly two minutes, leading to suffocation.

Host Insights: The discussion centers on the legal maneuvering to secure the testimony of Jennifer Fitzgerald, the sole nurse present during the incident. Attorney General John Farmella offered Fitzgerald immunity to testify, ensuring her statements couldn't be used against her, highlighting the complexities of the legal system in securing evidence.

Notable Quotes:

• Unknown Speaker (Kevin Greenlee): "The Attorney General in the state of New Hampshire wrote a letter giving this nurse... a deal which says that anything she says in her testimony cannot be used against her in any prosecution." [35:34]

• Áine Cain: "People make a big deal about immunity deals and they just don't understand how anything works... the system would collapse in two minutes without immunity deals or plea deals." [36:25]

Discussion: Áine defends the use of immunity deals as essential for the legal process, emphasizing their role in maintaining system functionality. She also highlights the nurse's right to protect herself legally while contributing to the case.

4. Indiana Case: Assaults on Nurses in a Hospital Setting

Case Details: The Indiana segment covers assaults on nurses at a community hospital in Munster, Lake County. Abdullah Adib, a 25-year-old disabled individual, was charged with battery after violently attacking nurses at the facility. On April 30 and May 5, Adib assaulted multiple nurses, leading to his transfer to a specialized facility following his aggressive behavior.

Host Insights: The hosts discuss the broader implications of such assaults, touching upon the strained mental health system and the challenges faced by healthcare professionals dealing with volatile patients.

Notable Quotes:

• Unknown Speaker (Kevin Greenlee): "It sounds like that's the way things look from Kane's Corner." [46:02]

• Áine Cain: "The mental health system in this country is very badly broken... It's shattered on the floor. It's a mess." [46:42]

Discussion: Áine emphasizes the need for comprehensive support systems for both patients and healthcare workers. She advocates for long-term solutions to manage individuals who cannot function within society, criticizing the current reliance on punitive measures like incarceration for handling such cases.

Additional Discussions

Disinformation and Media Responsibility: Throughout the episode, Áine and Kevin underscore the dangers of misinformation, especially in high-profile cases. They advocate for responsible journalism and the necessity of verifying facts before forming public opinions.

Mental Health and the Criminal Justice System: The hosts highlight the intersection of mental health issues and the criminal justice system, pointing out the systemic failures that lead to tragic outcomes for both victims and perpetrators.

Conclusion

"The Cheat Sheet: Nighttime and Nurses" offers a comprehensive examination of complex murder cases, intertwining legal analysis with empathetic discussions on the human elements involved. Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee provide listeners with a nuanced understanding of each case, emphasizing the importance of accurate reporting and systemic reform in addressing underlying societal issues.

Notable Quotes Compilation

• [06:31] Kevin Greenlee: "Hannah Mann ultimately went to the hospital... her lead levels were in the 80s... the doctors had to temporarily paralyze her because if she moved, it could throw off some of the things and the pressure on her brain."

• [07:55] Áine Cain: "She's awfully forgiving of this guy. She even says, like, I hope he changes. I don't think you should assume anyone is ever going to change after they do something like this."

• [17:25] Kevin Greenlee: "If you are targeting people who are politicians and who are making policies and you are killing them or terrorizing them based on your opinions of their views, you're really perverting the system in a really disgusting way."

• [24:08] Áine Cain: "There appeared to be basically a disinformation campaign... it seems like the goal was to essentially deflect blame."

• [35:34] Kevin Greenlee: "The Attorney General in the state of New Hampshire wrote a letter giving this nurse... a deal which says that anything she says in her testimony cannot be used against her in any prosecution."

• [36:25] Áine Cain: "People make a big deal about immunity deals and they just don't understand how anything works... the system would collapse in two minutes without immunity deals or plea deals."

• [46:02] Kevin Greenlee: "It sounds like that's the way things look from Kane's Corner."

• [46:42] Áine Cain: "The mental health system in this country is very badly broken... It's shattered on the floor. It's a mess."

This summary encapsulates the critical discussions and insights presented in the episode, providing a thorough overview for listeners and those interested in the intricate dynamics of true crime cases covered by the Murder Sheet podcast.