Podcast Summary: Murder Sheet – "The Cheat Sheet: Victims and Vaccines"

Release Date: August 15, 2025

Hosts:

• Áine Cain, Journalist
• Kevin Greenlee, Attorney

1. Introduction

In this compelling episode of The Murder Sheet, hosts Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee delve into a series of tragic and perplexing crime cases across multiple states, examining the motives, impacts, and unresolved questions that surround each incident. Skipping over promotional segments, the focus remains steadfast on delivering in-depth analysis and heartfelt discussions about the victims and the broader implications of these crimes.

2. Georgia: CDC Shooting Incident

The episode opens with a harrowing account of a mass shooting at the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in Atlanta, Georgia.

• Victim: Officer David Rose of the DeKalb County Police was killed while responding to the incident.
• Perpetrator: An unnamed gunman fired 180 shots, expressing extreme opposition to the COVID-19 vaccine, believing it adversely affected him.

Key Points:

• The gunman had a history of bizarre behavior and multiple 911 calls, indicating prior instability.
• He accessed a gun by breaking into his family’s locked gun safe, raising questions about firearm accessibility and family responsibility.
• Áine Cain reflects on the profound loss:

  "Officer Rose served with integrity, compassion and bravery, and he leaves behind a lasting impact on the DeKalb community."
  (02:03)

Impacts:

• Officer Rose's family, including his pregnant wife and two children, faces unimaginable grief.
• The incident underscores the urgent need for better mental health support and secure firearm storage to prevent such tragedies.

3. Virginia: Spencer Hatcher Murder

Moving to Virginia, the hosts discuss a baffling case involving the murder of Holly Hatcher, the mother of rising country music artist Spencer Hatcher.

• Victim: Holly Hatcher, 62, was brutally killed by an intruder.
• Perpetrator: Kevin Moses Walker, 41, who had no apparent connection to the Hatcher family.

Key Points:

• Walker exhibited normal behavior prior to the crime, visiting Endless Caverns and camping overnight without any signs of aggression.
• His sudden act of violence remains unexplained, leaving the community searching for answers.
• Kevin Greenlee states:

  "There's no reason, just a horrible tragedy."
  (09:58)

Impacts:

• Holly Hatcher’s husband, Michael, survived the ordeal after a shootout with Walker, highlighting both heroism and the random nature of such violence.
• The lack of motive makes the case particularly chilling and raises concerns about unidentified triggers for violent behavior.

4. Pennsylvania: Lori Wasco and State Troopers' Assault

In Pennsylvania, the discussion centers on the tragic murder of Lori Wasco and the subsequent attack on state troopers.

• Victim: Lori Wasco, 47, was killed by her 61-year-old neighbor in Susquehanna County.
• Perpetrator: The neighbor not only murdered Lori but also ambushed responding police officers, Troopers Joseph Parachinsky and William Jenkins.

Key Points:

• Áine Cain emphasizes the community's shock:

  "This is something that happened in the Delphi murders case and that can happen in other cases sometimes."
  (15:51)

• The shooter employed a semiautomatic weapon and showed a blatant disregard for law enforcement and public safety.

• Trooper Parachinsky managed to apply a tourniquet to Trooper Jenkins, showcasing remarkable bravery under fire.

Impacts:

• Both troopers survived their injuries, receiving support and recovering after the traumatic events.
• The incident highlights the complexities of neighborly relationships gone tragically wrong and the challenges in preventing such unpredictable acts of violence.

5. Wisconsin-UK Connection: Online-Driven Murder Plot

Crossing the Atlantic, the hosts explore a bizarre case linking Wisconsin and the UK, involving an online-facilitated murder plot.

• Perpetrator: Mohammed Nabeel Nazir from England orchestrated a plot via a dating app.
• Accomplice: Amy Betrow from Wisconsin, who traveled to England to carry out Nazir's directive to kill a clothing store owner following a fight.

Key Points:

• Kevin Greenlee outlines the absurdity of the plot:

  "If you're a young lady using a dating app and you get a message, oh, there's a fight at a clothing store. Let's kill a guy. You think, hey, that's the guy for me."
  (30:46)

• During her attempt to assassinate Mr. Ali, the intended victim, Betrow’s gun jammed, preventing the murder.

• She continued her spree by driving a tractor trailer to block roads, firing at police drones, but was ultimately apprehended and convicted.

Impacts:

• The case sheds light on the dangers of online interactions and the potential for extreme actions born from misguided intentions.
• It raises questions about the influence of digital platforms in facilitating real-world violence and the psychological factors driving such behavior.

6. Discussion on Criminal Behavior and Mental Health

Throughout the episode, Áine and Kevin engage in a thoughtful discussion about the nature of criminal behavior, mental health, and societal responsibilities.

• Áine Cain asserts:

  "Some people are just evil. I mean, I don't think people have like a trouble with. I think, you know, we try to, we try to intellectualize everything and say, oh, mental illness."
  (14:59)

• They debate the balance between understanding mental health issues and recognizing inherent malice in certain individuals.

• Kevin Greenlee adds:

  "People are awful indeed."
  (16:37)

Key Insights:

• The unpredictability of violent acts and the difficulty in preemptively identifying potential perpetrators.
• The importance of robust mental health support systems and responsible firearm regulations to mitigate risks.

7. Closing Remarks

The episode concludes with a lighter segment where the hosts share personal anecdotes and discuss upcoming events related to their podcast and book releases. While this section veers away from true crime discussions, it provides listeners with insights into the hosts' lives and future plans.

Notable Quotes:

• "People are awful indeed." – Kevin Greenlee (16:37)
• "Officer Rose served with integrity, compassion and bravery, and he leaves behind a lasting impact on the DeKalb community." – Áine Cain (02:03)
• "There's no reason, just a horrible tragedy." – Kevin Greenlee (09:58)
• "Some people are just evil." – Áine Cain (14:59)

Conclusion

In "The Cheat Sheet: Victims and Vaccines," The Murder Sheet offers listeners a sobering exploration of senseless violence and the complexities surrounding criminal motives. Through empathetic storytelling and analytical discourse, Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee honor the victims while prompting critical conversations about mental health, societal safeguards, and the unpredictable nature of human behavior.