Murder Sheet Podcast Summary

Episode: The Delphi Murders: First Person: Becky Patty
Host: MurderSheet (Áine Cain & Kevin Greenlee)
Release Date: March 20, 2025

Introduction to the Episode

In this emotionally charged episode of Murder Sheet, hosts Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee delve deep into the tragic Delphi murders, focusing on the personal experiences of Becky Patty, Libby German's grandmother and guardian. This first-person interview offers an intimate portrayal of the loss, the relentless pursuit of justice, and the challenges faced by the families amidst public scrutiny and conspiracy theories.

Background of the Delphi Murders

On February 13, 2017, Richard Allen perpetrated a heinous act by murdering two teenage girls, Libby German and Abby Williams, in Delphi, Indiana. The case garnered national attention, leading to extensive media coverage and a prolonged investigation that has left lasting scars on the victims' families.

Interview with Becky Patty

Becky Patty shares her heartfelt journey, providing listeners with a profound understanding of the personal toll the murders have taken.

Coping with Loss and Keeping Libby's Memory Alive

Becky discusses how her family is beginning to rebuild their lives after seven years of heartbreak. She emphasizes the importance of integrating Libby's memory into daily life to maintain a sense of connection.

"We're being able to start focusing on the family again... we still include her in everything."
[07:09]

Becky highlights the constant presence of Libby in their thoughts, ensuring that her legacy of kindness and protection continues to influence their actions.

"She was always for the underdog. She was a protector. She truly was."
[16:03]

Libby's Personality and Legacy

Becky paints a vivid picture of Libby's exceptional qualities—her intelligence, maturity, and empathetic nature. She recounts how Libby's logical approach and passion for solving mysteries were evident even at a young age.

"She looked at things very logically, and you don't do that at 13."
[12:36]

Becky shares anecdotes that illustrate Libby's impact on those around her, from academic excellence to her role as a confidante among friends.

Advocacy and Public Scrutiny

Following the murders, Becky and her family became vocal advocates for solving the case. Initially driven by a desire to aid law enforcement, they faced unexpected backlash and conspiracy theories that cast them in a negative light.

"By coming out and being vocal, you also make yourself a target."
[26:03]

Becky reflects on the challenges of maintaining their stance amidst misinformation and the emotional strain it placed on the family.

"Some people just want to twist your words... every single one of us... but you can't tell them that."
[32:54]

Interactions with Law Enforcement

Becky expresses immense respect for the law enforcement officers who tirelessly worked on the case. She commends their professionalism and unwavering dedication, which provided her family with hope during the darkest times.

"Everyone that we have come in contact with were very professional... they never slowed down."
[20:14]

Impact of Leaked Photos

A particularly distressing aspect of the case has been the unauthorized circulation of photos depicting Libby and Abby. Becky elaborates on the lasting pain this has caused, emphasizing the violation of their privacy.

"Our family will never totally get away from this because you can never get all those photos offline."
[41:03]

She criticizes those responsible for minimizing the severity of the leaks, underscoring the perpetual anguish it inflicts on their family.

"Those girls were at their most vulnerable... that leak has taken it away, totally away."
[42:12]

Advice for Other Families

Becky offers heartfelt advice to families enduring similar tragedies. She stresses the importance of building a strong support system and advises against taking external negativity personally.

"Don’t let them get to you. You have to become thick skin."
[38:55]

Maintaining Mental Health

To cope with the immense emotional burden, Becky underscores the significance of support from family and friends. She encourages others to seek out and lean on their support networks during such trying times.

"All you can do is gather your support, a support system."
[40:11]

Additional Discussions

Defamation and Misconceptions

Becky addresses various misconceptions and false claims propagated via social media, clarifying misunderstandings about family relations and procedural details of the case.

"Nick McLeland has never, ever been related to Libby, ever, by marriage or any other way."
[33:05]

She confronts the distortions regarding the prosecution team and the integrity of the investigation, emphasizing the relentless effort of law enforcement despite public skepticism.

Tribute to the Silver Linings Handbook

The episode also features a heartfelt tribute to Jason Blair and his podcast, The Silver Linings Handbook, praising his compassionate approach to interviewing and the meaningful conversations he fosters around true crime and personal recovery.

"Jason is a wonderful person with a seemingly endless well of compassion and empathy for others."
[18:35]

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Becky concludes the interview by expressing her enduring grief and the perpetual impact of Libby and Abby's loss on her family. She reflects on the necessity of allowing the legal process to unfold while hoping for ultimate justice and closure.

"One day it will be over. One day it will."
[44:59]

The hosts, Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee, commend Becky's resilience and the strength displayed by the families, underscoring the importance of compassionate storytelling in true crime narratives.

Key Takeaways

• Personal Resilience: The German family’s unwavering strength highlights the profound personal impact of true crime cases.
• Media Responsibility: The episode underscores the detrimental effects of misinformation and the ethical responsibility of media and listeners.
• Advocacy and Support: Becky’s advocacy demonstrates the vital role of active participation and support systems in seeking justice and healing.
• Respecting Privacy: The unauthorized dissemination of victims' photos serves as a stark reminder of the need to protect the dignity and privacy of those affected by tragedy.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• "We're being able to start focusing on the family again... we still include her in everything."
  [07:09]

• "She looked at things very logically, and you don't do that at 13."
  [12:36]

• "By coming out and being vocal, you also make yourself a target."
  [26:03]

• "Our family will never totally get away from this because you can never get all those photos offline."
  [41:03]

• "Don’t let them get to you. You have to become thick skin."
  [38:55]

Final Remarks

This episode of Murder Sheet offers a poignant and comprehensive look into the Delphi murders through the lens of those closest to the victims. Becky Patty's testimony not only sheds light on the personal struggles and advocacy efforts but also serves as a compelling call for compassion and truth in the face of tragedy and misinformation.