Podcast Summary: Murder Sheet Episode: The Delphi Murders: First Person: Doug Carter Part One
Release Date: January 28, 2025

Introduction

In this compelling episode of Murder Sheet, hosts Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee engage in an in-depth conversation with Doug Carter, the recently retired Indiana State Police Superintendent. Carter provides a first-hand account of his 40-year law enforcement career, with a particular focus on his pivotal role in the high-profile Delphi Murders case. This episode offers listeners a nuanced exploration of the complexities involved in managing a massive criminal investigation, leadership challenges, and the emotional toll such cases can have on those involved.

Doug Carter's Background

Doug Carter begins by sharing his roots in law enforcement, tracing his passion back to his upbringing in LaPorte, Indiana. Growing up in a family dedicated to public service, with his father serving as a state trooper, Carter was influenced early on to follow a similar path.

“I grew up in a state police family. My dad was a state trooper... I decided I was either going to be a lawyer or a trooper like my dad and I chose that path.” (05:14)

Carter's career trajectory saw him spending over 18 years as a state trooper in Hamilton County before transitioning into the role of sheriff—a position he held for two consecutive terms. His appointment as Superintendent of the Indiana State Police in 2012 by then-Governor Mike Pence marked a significant milestone in his career.

Handling the Delphi Murders

The crux of the episode centers around Carter's involvement in the Delphi Murders investigation, a case that has captivated national attention. Carter recounts the initial moments of receiving the distressing news and the swift mobilization that followed.

“I was in my office that morning when I was briefed on the search... I remember standing on the hill, talking to Tobe, overlooking the bodies.” (11:02)

As the investigation unfolded, Carter had to navigate the logistical complexities of coordinating multiple agencies and managing resources under immense public scrutiny. He emphasizes the emotional burden of dealing with such a tragic case.

“You deal with death, dying and destruction every day of your life. And there was something different about this.” (11:42)

Leadership Insights

Carter delves into his leadership philosophy, highlighting the principles of servant leadership and the importance of empathy within a law enforcement context.

“Just don't ever ask anybody to do what you haven't done and care deeply about other people.” (07:35)

He shares an anecdote about Lieutenant Jerry Holman, illustrating his commitment to the well-being of his team.

“Holman was spending untold hours working on the case... Carter insisted that Holman take a break and see the concert.” (05:55)

This approach not only fosters a supportive work environment but also underscores Carter's dedication to maintaining morale during prolonged investigations.

Public Perception and Media Interaction

Being the public face of the Delphi investigation brought its own set of challenges. Carter discusses the intense public and media scrutiny, particularly surrounding the "New Direction" press conference and the release of composite sketches.

“Our message is working. We want people to continue to think about this.” (25:35)

He reflects on the mixed reactions to the sketches, acknowledging both the support and criticism they received. Carter candidly addresses how his words were analyzed and sometimes misinterpreted by the public.

“I hate that. I can't help it because I never said anything I didn't mean.” (25:56)

Managing Inter-Agency Collaboration

One of the significant hurdles Carter faced was coordinating efforts among various law enforcement agencies without falling into territorial disputes. He emphasizes the importance of unified command and collaborative strategies.

“We did it together with a unified command, a structure that allowed us to consolidate some of our resources.” (16:22)

Carter credits the FBI and other agencies for their invaluable support, particularly in managing information flow and utilizing systems like Orion to streamline data handling.

Emotional Toll and Personal Reflections

Carter does not shy away from discussing the emotional impact of the Delphi case, both on himself and his team. He contrasts his resilience with his father's experience, who became cynical over his career.

“Don't become cynical like me. Use those words that you just used to me on.” (09:30)

This personal testimony underscores the mental and emotional challenges faced by law enforcement officers in the wake of traumatic cases.

Relationship with Victims' Families

Throughout the investigation, maintaining a strong rapport with the victims' families was paramount. Carter speaks highly of the families of Abby and Libby, acknowledging their strength and unwavering support.

“They were still so kind to us. I'll never forget that.” (21:16)

He describes a mutual respect and a shared sense of purpose in seeking justice for the victims, which provided inspiration and motivation during the prolonged investigation.

Navigating Public Speculation and Conspiracy Theories

Carter addresses the proliferation of conspiracy theories and public speculation surrounding the case, particularly fueled by social media and media narratives.

“There was a lot of criticism of me from the defense for handling that press conference the way I did.” (27:01)

He emphasizes the importance of sticking to factual reporting and resisting the urge to be derailed by unfounded theories, focusing instead on methodical investigation and maintaining public trust.

Conclusion and Continuing Efforts

As the episode wraps up, Carter reflects on the ongoing nature of the investigation and his unwavering belief in a positive outcome.

“I believe that good always prevails and that it would be solved.” (22:19)

He expresses gratitude towards his team and the community of Delphi, reinforcing his commitment to seeking justice for Abby and Libby.

Notable Quotes:

• Doug Carter (05:14): “I grew up in a state police family. My dad was a state trooper... I decided I was either going to be a lawyer or a trooper like my dad and I chose that path.”

• Doug Carter (07:35): “Just don't ever ask anybody to do what you haven't done and care deeply about other people.”

• Doug Carter (11:02): “I was in my office that morning when I was briefed on the search... I remember standing on the hill, talking to Tobe, overlooking the bodies.”

• Doug Carter (25:56): “I hate that. I can't help it because I never said anything I didn't mean.”

• Doug Carter (22:19): “I believe that good always prevails and that it would be solved.”

This episode of Murder Sheet offers a profound look into the intricacies of managing a large-scale criminal investigation, the burdens of leadership in law enforcement, and the enduring human spirit in the face of tragedy. Doug Carter's candid reflections provide valuable insights for true crime enthusiasts and those interested in the inner workings of criminal investigations.