Podcast Title: Murder Sheet
Host/Author: MurderSheet (Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee)
Episode Title: The Delphi Murders: The Bridge Guy Video and the Motion to Reconsider
Release Date: March 13, 2025
1. Introduction to the Delphi Murders Case
In this episode of Murder Sheet, hosts Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee delve into recent developments in the high-profile Delphi Murders case. The primary focus is on the emergence of the "Bridge Guy" video and the subsequent motion to reconsider filed by the defense team. This episode provides an in-depth analysis of these events, exploring their implications for the case and the broader criminal justice system.
2. The Bridge Guy Video Release
Timestamp: [03:31] Kevin Greenlee
Kevin Greenlee begins by addressing the release of a 43-second video captured by Liberty German, one of the victims. This footage allegedly shows the abduction of Liberty German and Abigail Williams by Richard Allen, the convicted murderer.
"This is kind of the famous video that she captured on her phone, capturing the image of her killer and, you know, capturing his voicing guys down the hill." — Kevin Greenlee [03:31]
Áine adds that the video was previously shown during the trial in both raw and stabilized formats. The stabilized version, which is less shaky and more discernible, has now surfaced online.
Timestamp: [04:08] Áine Cain
"Yeah. It shows Richard Allen kidnapping the two girls just prior to him committing murder." — Áine Cain [04:08]
3. Defense Team's Potential Involvement and Website Release
The hosts discuss the mysterious manner in which the stabilized video was released. Contrary to Judge Gull's earlier announcement that public exhibits would be sold via thumb drives, the video appeared on a website allegedly affiliated with Richard Allen's defense team.
Timestamp: [04:42] Áine Cain
"And obviously this is not what she anticipated. It showed up on a website that is apparently affiliated with Richard Allen's defense team, if Ms. Winicke and others are to be believed." — Áine Cain [04:42]
Áine expresses skepticism about the credibility of Kara Wienicke, an appellate attorney associated with the defense, questioning her reliability.
Timestamp: [05:12] Kevin Greenlee
"It's not the stabilized version. It's not the raw version." — Kevin Greenlee [05:12]
4. Financial Controversies Surrounding the Defense Team
Áine highlights previous instances where the defense team solicited public funds, raising concerns about transparency and accountability.
Timestamp: [06:37] Áine Cain
"They have solicited funds from the public, and the public responded, sending them something to the tune of $40,000. Since that time, there's been no accounting for what was done with that $40,000." — Áine Cain [06:37]
This financial mismanagement casts doubt on the defense team's integrity and intentions behind releasing the video.
5. Impact on Families and Public Perception
The premature and unauthorized release of the video has significant emotional repercussions for the families of the victims. Áine emphasizes the trauma inflicted by the sudden dissemination of such distressing content.
Timestamp: [22:54] Áine Cain
"I can tell you they're lying about a lot. And there's a lot they're not telling you about the case." — Áine Cain [14:49]
Kevin adds that the release is particularly harmful as it violates the families' privacy during their grieving process.
Timestamp: [35:17] Áine Cain
"The release of this video was not done in the orderly way that the court had described just a few hours earlier. I feel that the way it was done showed a real lack of concern and care and empathy for the families." — Áine Cain [32:51]
6. Critique of Defense Team's Performance
Both hosts criticize the defense team's overall performance throughout the trial, labeling it as ineffective and poorly executed. They argue that the defense's actions, including the mishandling of exhibits and lackluster legal strategies, have been detrimental to Richard Allen's case.
Timestamp: [40:11] Áine Cain
"They were vigorous. And it's also complicated by the fact that when Judge Gull raised concerns about the quality of the legal work being done by this team and removed them, Mr. Allen fought vigorously to get them returned." — Áine Cain [40:11]
7. Speculation on the Source of the Video Leak
The episode explores potential sources behind the video leak, pondering whether it originated from within the defense team or from their closely associated inner circle. The lack of clear evidence makes it difficult to pinpoint the exact source.
Timestamp: [23:25] Kevin Greenlee
"But I can do it." — Kevin Greenlee [Something mismatched here; possibly [23:25]]
Timestamp: [25:04] Áine Cain
"And have they had access to protected materials for a long time?" — Áine Cain [25:04]
The hosts remain uncertain but lean towards the defense team's involvement due to the history of mismanagement and questionable decisions.
8. The Motion to Reconsider and Notice of Appeal
Moving beyond the video release, the hosts discuss the motion to reconsider filed by Jennifer O.J., an appellate attorney for Richard Allen. This motion references the Supreme Court's Glossip case, arguing that certain testimonies during the trial were incorrect and should warrant a new trial.
Timestamp: [40:02] Kevin Greenlee
"I don't think you'd win it. I think that is such a high bar." — Kevin Greenlee [40:02]
Áine scrutinizes the defense's arguments, noting the lack of concrete evidence to substantiate claims of erroneous testimony.
Timestamp: [41:16] Áine Cain
"There's a lot of wishful thinking on the part of the defense they try to use." — Áine Cain [41:16]
Moreover, the court's swift denial of the motion to reconsider underscores the challenges the defense faces in overturning the conviction.
Timestamp: [43:29] Áine Cain
"Court takes no action on defendant's motion to reconsider." — Áine Cain [43:29]
9. Reflections on Audience Behavior and Conspiracy Theories
The hosts express concern over the emergence of conspiracy theories and unwavering support for Richard Allen despite the overwhelming evidence against him. They question the psychological and social factors driving people to defend a convicted child murderer, highlighting the dangers of misinformation and blind allegiance.
Timestamp: [44:14] Kevin Greenlee
"What makes people become conspiracy theorists in defense of a child murderer?" — Kevin Greenlee [47:17]
Áine adds that such behavior often stems from emotional manipulation and the creation of cult-like followings, making it difficult for individuals to reassess their beliefs objectively.
Timestamp: [33:37] Kevin Greenlee
"It's crazy how overt it is. It's not subtle." — Kevin Greenlee [33:37]
10. Conclusion and Future Outlook
In wrapping up, Áine and Kevin reflect on the ongoing challenges within the Delphi Murders case, emphasizing the need for continued vigilance against misinformation. They remain hopeful that the appellate process will bring about a fair and thorough examination of the case, ultimately upholding justice for the victims.
Timestamp: [44:39] Kevin Greenlee
"But it's, it's definitely, it definitely feels like we're circling, in terms of this case, we're circling the drain." — Kevin Greenlee [44:39]
Áine emphasizes the importance of accurate reporting and public awareness to prevent further deception and ensure the truth prevails.
Timestamp: [35:25] Kevin Greenlee
"The evidence proved that he did it. I think it looks like him. I think it sounds exactly like him." — Kevin Greenlee [35:25]
Key Takeaways:
- Bridge Guy Video: The unauthorized release of the stabilized "Bridge Guy" video heightens suspicions about the defense team's integrity and intentions.
- Defense Team Criticism: The episode critically examines the defense team's poor performance and questionable financial practices.
- Impact on Families: The premature video release exacerbates the trauma experienced by the victims' families.
- Motion to Reconsider: The defense's motion to reconsider faces significant hurdles, with the court denying its merit swiftly.
- Public Perception: Unwavering support for Richard Allen amidst mounting evidence highlights the pervasive issue of misinformation and conspiracy theories in public discourse.
Notable Quotes:
- Kevin Greenlee [03:31]: "This is kind of the famous video that she captured on her phone, capturing the image of her killer and, you know, capturing his voicing guys down the hill."
- Áine Cain [04:08]: "Yeah. It shows Richard Allen kidnapping the two girls just prior to him committing murder."
- Áine Cain [06:37]: "They have solicited funds from the public, and the public responded, sending them something to the tune of $40,000. Since that time, there's been no accounting for what was done with that $40,000."
- Áine Cain [35:17]: "The release of this video was not done in the orderly way that the court had described just a few hours earlier. I feel that the way it was done showed a real lack of concern and care and empathy for the families."
- Kevin Greenlee [47:17]: "What makes people become conspiracy theorists in defense of a child murderer?"
This comprehensive summary encapsulates the critical discussions and insights presented in the episode, providing listeners with a thorough understanding of the latest developments in the Delphi Murders case and their broader implications.