Podcast Summary: Murder: True Crime Stories – Introducing: "Three" from Wavland

Release Date: December 6, 2024
Host: Crime House
Episode Title: Introducing: "Three" from Wavland

Introduction

In the premiere episode of "Three" from Wavland, hosts Justine Harmon and Holly Millay delve into the harrowing true crime case of Skylar Neese, a teenage girl whose tragic disappearance and murder shook a small West Virginia community to its core. This episode sets the stage for a comprehensive exploration of the events, motivations, and lasting impacts of this chilling case.

The Night of July 6, 2012

The episode opens with a vivid recounting of the fateful night when Skylar Neese and her two best friends ventured into the dense Appalachian woods. Holly Millay paints a haunting picture of the events leading up to the disappearance:

Holly Millay [00:52]: "After midnight on July 6, 2012, three teenage girls walked into the thick Appalachian woods somewhere along the Mason Dixon line. Hours later, under the glow of a nearly full moon, only two walked out. The surrounding forest had muffled the sounds of the sudden, unthinkable violence."

This segment underscores the abrupt and mysterious nature of Skylar's disappearance, emphasizing the silence that enveloped the forest after the initial chaos.

Skylar Neese’s Tragic Fate

Justine Harmon provides a somber narration of Skylar's fate:

Justine Harmon [01:24]: "For months, Skylar Neese's body lay decomposing, hidden beneath a canopy of pine and oak trees, first absorbing humidity, then freezing over with ice. For months, she waited for someone to find her, but no one knew she was there. No one could imagine what had actually happened."

This description highlights the prolonged agony and solitude Skylar endured before her remains were discovered, setting a poignant tone for the episode.

The Pact and Unraveling Friendship

The hosts delve into the complicated relationships and motives that led to the tragic outcome. Holly Millay raises critical questions about the motivations behind the crime:

Holly Millay [01:43]: "What happened to Skylar Neese? So why did they do it? Why kill Skyler? The reason Rachel's given is simple and sickening, but you've never heard it like this."

Introducing Rachel as a central figure, the episode hints at underlying tensions and disturbing motivations that culminated in murder. This segment teases the audience with the promise of uncovering the "simple and sickening" reasons that led to such a heinous act.

First-Person Accounts and Emotional Impact

The episode features firsthand accounts from individuals directly involved in the case, adding depth and emotional resonance to the narrative. An unnamed speaker recounts a dramatic moment:

Unnamed Speaker [02:16]: "And that's where she met the little sick psychopath, Sheila Eddy."

This stark statement underscores the perception of evil within the close-knit group of friends, hinting at underlying psychological issues that may have contributed to the tragedy.

Holly Millay further explores the chaos and violence of that night:

Holly Millay [02:20]: "Now, Sheila, like, sideswiped a pole. Almost wrecked. I swear, we probably almost died 100 times that night. Do you remember the blood everywhere last night? And Rachel laughed."

The juxtaposition of near-death experiences and unexpected laughter paints a confusing and disturbing picture of the group's dynamics during the critical moments.

Investigative Insights and Community Impact

Justine Harmon provides context about her long-term engagement with the case:

Justine Harmon [03:10]: "From Waveland? This is three. Would you guys rather suffocate or get shot? Get shot. Shot. Wait, it depends on where in the head. Shot."

This interaction showcases the intense and sometimes morbid discussions surrounding the case, reflecting the community's struggle to comprehend the brutality of the crime.

Holly Millay reflects on her investigative journey:

Holly Millay [02:40]: "For one young girl, a midnight joyride was just the start of a mystery that devastated a small community."

This statement emphasizes the far-reaching effects of Skylar's murder, highlighting how a single tragic event can ripple through and deeply affect an entire community.

Themes and Critical Questions

Throughout the episode, the hosts pose critical questions that drive the narrative forward:

• Why did Skylar Neese's friends turn against her?
• What psychological factors contributed to the decision to murder?
• How did this event reshape the lives of those involved and the community at large?

By posing these questions, "Three" from Wavland sets up a framework for in-depth exploration in subsequent episodes, promising listeners a comprehensive understanding of the case from multiple perspectives.

Conclusion and What’s Next

In concluding the introductory episode, Justine Harmon and Holly Millay tease the depth and complexity of the story to unfold:

Justine Harmon [02:40]: "This is the story of how a triangle of teenage friendship culminated in murder. You'll hear from the family, friends and law enforcement who lived it and are still living it."

Listeners are left anticipating a detailed dissection of the case, informed by interviews and firsthand accounts that promise to shed light on the darkest corners of human relationships and motivations.

Notable Quotes

• Holly Millay [00:52]: "Where there was laughing, then screaming, there is now silence."
• Justine Harmon [01:24]: "No one knew she was there. No one could imagine what had actually happened."
• Unnamed Speaker [02:16]: "I'm telling you, that's serial killer stuff right there."
• Holly Millay [02:54]: "They did not understand the consequences of killing someone. Nothing unusual. But it is unusual for your friends to kill you."

Final Thoughts

"Three" from Wavland sets a compelling foundation for unraveling the complex and tragic story of Skylar Neese. Through meticulous storytelling, emotional depth, and critical inquiry, Justine Harmon and Holly Millay invite listeners to explore not just the events of that fateful night, but also the intricate human emotions and relationships that led to one of West Virginia's most devastating crimes. This episode promises a gripping journey into the heart of true crime, making it a must-listen for enthusiasts seeking depth and understanding beyond surface-level narratives.

Listen to "Three" from Wavland on your preferred podcast platform and follow Crime House on Instagram @crimehouse for more updates and insights.