B (30:20)
On October 2, 1985, Irene Avila told police in Los Angeles that her 17 year old daughter Missy was missing. At first, the authorities didn't seem too concerned and they figured a girl that age was probably staying with a secret boyfriend and would come back home soon. But she never did. Irene stayed up on the couch night after night, praying her daughter would suddenly walk through the front door. She questioned Missy's friends Laura Doyle and Karen Severson again and again. Neither of them had any idea where she could be. Even so, the family held out hope for the first 48 hours. But on October 4, everything changed. That afternoon, a pair of hikers marched through the Angeles National Forest about 10 miles east of Missy's home in the LA suburbs. As they passed by a stream, the two men caught a glimpse of a shadow floating in the water. When they got closer, they realized it was a girl's body lying face down in the water. A heavy log was resting on the back of her neck, keeping her from drifting with the current. The hikers called the police and a team of investigators led by Deputy Sheriff Catherine Scott arrived at the scene. The official cause of death was drowning, but it wasn't accidental. From the beginning, it was obvious the girl had been murdered. The log that held her body in place weighed over 100 pounds. It couldn't have gotten there by accident. One of her arms was bent at an unnatural angle while her ankles were crossed. It looked like at least two people were involved. One to hold her arms behind her back and another to restrain her feet. After removing the body from the stream, Sheriff Scott noticed a thick brown ball next to a a nearby boulder. For some reason, the murderers had cut her hair before killing her. A high school ID in Missy's purse made it easy to identify the body. After breaking the news to Irene and the rest of the Avila family, police took statements from her friends. 17 year old Laura Doyle told them she, she and Missy had driven to a nearby park a day earlier on October 1st, and that's where they spotted three boys in a blue Camaro. Missy hopped out of the car to talk to them while Laura left to get gas. When she returned about 15 minutes later, Missy was Already gone. Sheriff Scott spent hours interrogating Laura about the young men in the Camaro. There was no reason for for her to doubt Laura's story. But she kept pressing the teen in the hopes that she would remember some crucial detail about the boys. No matter how hard she tried, though, Laura couldn't recall anything about them. She couldn't even say what color their hair was. Left without much to go on, the police pulled a list of every Camaro in the state and started doing interviews. In the meantime, it was impossible to keep the story out of local headlines. Still, the police held back two crucial details from the press, hoping to use them to identify the killers in the future. They didn't tell any reporters that Missy's hair was cut or that she was found with the heavy log pinning her down. The hairball especially nagged Sheriff Scott. It was just a hunch, but she thought it indicated a woman was somehow involved. She'd never heard of a male killer trying to hurt or humiliate a woman by cutting her hair. For the time being, she kept her suspicions in the back of her mind. But three days after the body was found on October 7, Irene called with an unusual tip. Apparently, Karen Severson's daughter, 3 year old Andrea, had a strange dream the night before. In it, Missy appeared to her like a ghost and told Andrea that a girl named Samantha was the killer. Aside from Karen and Laura, she was one of Missy's closest friends. Sheriff Scott didn't put much stock in prophetic dreams, but she scheduled an interview with Samantha for a few days later. In the meantime, she and her team stayed focused on searching for the elusive blue Camaro. During these early stages of the police investigation, Irina Vila and the rest of her family struggled to process their grief. Everywhere they looked, they were reminded of Missy. Without her around, it was like the light of their lives had been snuffed out. But if there was one small comfort in the midst of the tragedy, it was 17 year old Karen Severson. After Missy died, she devoted herself to filling her friend's shoes. Before the funeral, Karen told a tearful Irene that she. She would be her daughter from now on. About a week after the body was found, Karen made good on her promise by moving in with the Avilas full time. It started as a single sleepover after a long day spent discussing the investigation with the family. But one night became two, and then three. Eventually, her presence became an unspoken part of the life at the Avilas. Karen slept in Missy's bedroom. She wore Missy's clothes around the house. And she gathered the family in the living room every evening to talk about the murder. From the outside, it looked like Karen was more committed than anyone to keeping Missy's memory alive and finding her killers. That was what Irene believed. She knew Karen could be manipulative, but she never thought she was a killer. While she and Missy fought from time to time, they had always made up in the end. Besides, Irene and Missy's brothers had their hands full trying to process their grief. They could barely get out of bed. Some mornings. They certainly didn't have it in them to call, question Missy's friends, or come up with potential leads to help the police. But for Karen, it seemed to be an obsession. She insisted on the meetings in order to keep track of what everyone else was telling the cops. While Karen quietly worked behind the scenes, Laura Doyle deliberately stayed out of the way. After Missy's funeral, she stopped coming by to see the evidence. But neither Irene nor anyone else took offense. They could tell Laura felt guilty. They assumed it was because she had been the last one to see Missy alive at the park. They didn't blame her for wanting to distance herself. After all, everyone grieved in their own way. After that, Karen became the sole representative for Missy's friends and subtly worked to mold the investigation to her liking. She tried especially hard to turn the Avilas against Samantha. Not only did she make up the story about her daughter's prophetic dream, but she probably tormented Samantha secretly, too. A mysterious caller had been calling Samantha in the middle of the night to say everyone knew she had killed Missy. Before long, though, Karen turned her sights on a new target. One afternoon, Karen led Missy's brothers and a small group of friends to the crime scene to look for clues. The group spread out around the stream and the surrounding hiking trails to search. All the while, Karen made ghostly pronouncements, telling them she had surreal psychic feelings about where and how Missy died. Not far from the spot where her body was found, Missy's older brother, Mark, spotted a message carved into a tree. It said Karen's name and the name of her ex boyfriend, Randy. It had been crossed out with a big, brutal X. Above it, there was another set of names. Karen and Missy. Mark yelled over to Karen, asking if she had ever been to this area before. She turned red and told him that she hadn't. When he pointed to the names on the tree, her face fell. But always thinking on her feet, Karen quickly spun things to her advantage. She insisted she had never seen the carvings in her life, or they must have been made by her ex. As Missy's friends and family gathered around Karen wove a new theory. She told them that Randy had always liked Missy, but she had never given him the time of day. The more Karen thought about it, the clearer it all seemed. This whole time she had suspected Samantha, but the more likely killer had to be Randy. In a fit of jealousy, he must have been the one to lure Missy out into the woods. Out of everyone the group had discussed so far, he seemed to have the strongest motive, at least according to Karen. The others nodded in agreement. To cap off her monologue, Karen punched a rock dramatically. She told the group that she wouldn't just make Randy pay, she he should die for what he did. Still chewing over the new information, the crew dispersed in silence. Most were convinced by Karen's passion. After weeks of talking about Missy endlessly, they believed they finally knew who the killer was. The thought weighed heavily on them as they walked away from the carved up tree and the trickling stream. Karen smiled to herself. She had done it. She had gotten away with murder. Thanks so much for listening. I'm Carter Roy and this is True Crime Stories. Come back next time for part two on the murder of Missy Avila and all the people it affected. True Crime Stories is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. Here at Crime House, we want to thank each and every one of you for your support. If you like what you heard today, reach out on social media, Rimehouse on TikTok and Instagram. Don't forget to rate, review and follow Murder True Crime Stories wherever you get your podcasts. Your feedback truly makes a difference. And to enhance your Murder True Crime Stories listening experience, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. You'll get every episode early and ad free. We'll be back on Thursday. True Crime Stories is hosted by me, Carter Roy and is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. This episode was brought to life by the Murder True Crime Stories team. Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benedon, Natalie Perchovsky, Sarah Camp, Terrell Wells, Hania Said, and Russell Nash. Thank you for listening.