Murder: True Crime Stories

Episode: SPECIAL: Nicole Brown Simpson 1 with Dr. Tristin Engels
Release Date: June 17, 2025

Introduction: Revisiting Nicole Brown Simpson's Story

In this special two-part episode of Murder: True Crime Stories, host Carter Roy delves into the life and tragic death of Nicole Brown Simpson, offering a comprehensive exploration beyond the infamous trial of her ex-husband, O.J. Simpson. Joined by Dr. Tristin Engels, a licensed clinical and forensic psychologist, the episode seeks to shed light on Nicole's personal experiences, the impact of domestic abuse, and the psychological dynamics that played a role in her life and untimely demise.

Early Life and Family Dynamics

Nicole Brown Simpson's story begins in the early 1950s in West Germany, where her father, Lou Brown, served with the U.S. Air Force. After World War II, Lou met Judy, a German woman, and they married, bringing their two daughters, Denise (1957) and Nicole (1959), into the world. The siblings shared a strong bond, with Denise being a fiercely protective older sister, providing Nicole with guidance and support.

In the early 1960s, the family relocated to Long Beach, California, where Lou thrived in real estate and insurance, expanding his family with two more daughters, Dominique (1964) and Tanya (1970). The move to a gated community in Southern California during the mid-70s marked a new chapter for the Brown family, with Nicole and Denise re-establishing themselves in new high schools. Nicole's beauty was prominent, earning her the title of Homecoming Princess, while Denise became Homecoming Queen—a testament to their attractiveness and social standing.

Pursuit of a Modeling Career

As a teenager, Nicole recognized that her beauty could open doors, shaping her aspirations towards a modeling career. Dr. Tristin Engels provides psychological insight into this phase:

Dr. Engels [08:43]: "Adolescence is when we enter the psychosocial stage of development known as identity versus role confusion... society sends a very narrow message to girls about the importance of being attractive in order to matter in the world."

This societal pressure often leads to identity confusion, depression, and a reliance on external validation, which can profoundly affect personal and romantic relationships.

Meeting O.J. Simpson: The Beginning of a Turbulent Relationship

In June 1977, Nicole began working as a hostess at The Daisy, a trendy Beverly Hills restaurant. It was here that she met O.J. Simpson, a renowned football star nearing 30 years old. Initially unaware of his fame, Nicole found herself captivated by his presence after learning about his achievements from her boss.

Carter Roy narrates their relationship's inception:

Carter Roy [11:19]: "OJ asked Nicole out almost immediately. The only problem was he was still married to his high school sweetheart, Marguerite. According to OJ, the marriage was already over."

Despite the legal complications, Nicole and O.J. began dating, and their relationship quickly became the talk of Los Angeles. By 1979, they had moved into a lavish $5 million mansion in Brentwood, hosting glamorous parties and living what seemed to be the epitome of success. However, beneath the surface, signs of controlling and abusive behavior began to emerge.

Signs of Abuse: The Cycle Unfolds

Nicole's relationship with O.J. Simpson was marred by controlling behaviors and abuse. Multiple incidents highlighted the volatile nature of their union:

• June 1977: O.J.'s jealousy surfaced when Nicole was seen kissing a male friend, leading to public embarrassment and emotional distress for Nicole. (Timestamp: [14:50])

• Early 1980s: Nicole discovered another woman's earrings in her bed, leading to a confrontation where O.J. allegedly threw her against the wall, marking the first instance of physical abuse in their relationship. (Timestamp: [16:19])

• December 1988: A violent altercation resulted in O.J. arrest for spousal battery after Nicole sought police intervention due to escalating abuse. (Timestamp: [21:45])

Dr. Tristin Engels explains the psychological patterns at play:

Dr. Engels [19:45]: "What you're describing is the cycle of abuse, and it commonly has four stages... The psychological effects of the cycle of abuse include trauma, bonding, self-blame, loss of identity, poor self-esteem, anxiety or post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, even suicidal thinking."

These dynamics created a complex environment where Nicole struggled to leave O.J., despite the increasing signs of abuse and control.

Nicole's Pursuit of Independence

In February 1992, after 14 years together, Nicole filed for divorce from O.J., marking her first attempt at independence. The divorce was finalized in October 1992, granting her financial support but leaving her feeling trapped due to O.J.'s relentless stalking and controlling behavior. Despite moving into her own condo and experiencing newfound freedom, Nicole remained under O.J.'s shadow, as he frequently monitored her activities and movements.

Dr. Engels sheds light on this behavior:

Dr. Engels [34:23]: "This would qualify as stalking... Clinically, stalking is often tied to narcissistic traits, abandonment fears, insecurity, entitlement, and poor attachments."

O.J.'s inability to let go, despite the dissolution of their marriage, further exemplified the toxic nature of their relationship.

The Fateful Night: June 12, 1994

On the evening of June 12, 1994, Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend, Ron Goldman, were tragically murdered outside Nicole's condo. The events leading up to the murders were a culmination of years of abuse and tension:

• Afternoon: Nicole attended her daughter's dance recital with O.J., who appeared distant and preoccupied.

• Dinner at Mezzaluna: The group enjoyed a meal where Nicole expressed happiness about her daughter, Sydney, and plans for a family vacation. Unbeknownst to others, Nicole had secretly formed a close friendship with Ron Goldman, an aspiring actor. (Timestamp: [40:58])

• Evening: After dinner, Nicole spent time at home with Ron Goldman. At approximately 10 PM, Ron arrived to drop off Nicole's forgotten glasses. This seemingly innocent act would tragically escalate.

Shortly after, Nicole and Ron were found brutally stabbed in the walkway of Nicole's condo, marking one of the most infamous and controversial murders in American history.

The Investigation: O.J. Simpson as the Prime Suspect

Following the murders, detectives quickly identified O.J. Simpson as the primary suspect due to:

• Relationship Dynamics: The tumultuous history between Nicole and O.J.

• Forensic Evidence: Blood stains matching O.J.'s were found at various locations, including his Bronco and Nicole's condo.

• Behavioral Signs: O.J.'s lackluster reaction to the news and his suspicious behavior further fueled investigative suspicions.

Dr. Engels provides a psychological perspective on O.J.'s actions:

Dr. Engels [43:48]: "O.J.'s reaction was certainly odd... this reaction would warrant exploring that possibility [of impression management for secondary gain]."

Despite mounting evidence, the absence of the murder weapon complicated the case. The investigation took an unprecedented turn when O.J. failed to surrender voluntarily, leading to a nationwide manhunt that captivated the nation.

Forensic Evidence and Methodology

The investigation against O.J. Simpson was heavily reliant on forensic evidence, including:

• Blood Evidence: Multiple blood types were found at the crime scene and in O.J.'s Bronco.

• Gloves: One glove was found at Nicole's condo, and another at O.J.'s residence. Both were of the same brand and size as those owned by O.J.

• Shoe Prints: Size 12 shoe prints matching O.J.'s were discovered at the crime scene and the Bronco.

Despite the robust collection of forensic evidence, the case faced challenges, particularly the absence of the murder weapon. The detectives remained confident in their evidence but lacked the conclusive proof needed to charge O.J. Simpson formally.

Conclusion: The Case Continues

As the episode concludes, the allure of a sensational trial looms large. With the forensic evidence stacked against him yet the murder weapon missing, the stage was set for a complex courtroom battle. Carter Roy hints at the impending legal drama, urging listeners to tune in for the second part of the series, which promises to delve deeper into the trial and its aftermath.

Carter Roy [49:02]: "In the end, O.J. didn't surrender. Instead, he ran. And no one, not even O.J.'s lawyers, knew where he'd gone."

The story of Nicole Brown Simpson is one of loss, resilience, and the quest for justice amidst a media frenzy. This detailed exploration aims to honor Nicole's memory by focusing on her life and the impact of domestic abuse, moving beyond the overshadowing narrative of her ex-husband's trial.

Key Quotes Highlights

• Carter Roy [00:06]: "Nicole was more than collateral damage. She was an innocent victim who never got the justice she deserved."

• Dr. Tristin Engels [08:43]: "Society sends a very narrow message to girls about the importance of being attractive in order to matter in the world."

• Carter Roy [14:50]: "Nicole spent the rest of the night crying in the bathroom."

• Dr. Tristin Engels [19:45]: "The psychological effects of the cycle of abuse include trauma, bonding, self-blame, loss of identity..."

• Dr. Tristin Engels [34:23]: "Clinically, stalking is often tied to narcissistic traits, abandonment fears, insecurity, entitlement..."

• Carter Roy [40:58]: "What started out as a quiet evening would end in tragedy."

Looking Forward: Part Two

This episode sets the foundation for an in-depth analysis of the O.J. Simpson trial and its broader implications on the legal system, media involvement, and societal perceptions of domestic abuse and violence. Listeners are encouraged to stay tuned for the continuation of Nicole Brown Simpson's story, promising further insights and revelations.

Murder: True Crime Stories strives to present nuanced and empathetic narratives of true crime cases, focusing on the victims and the underlying issues that contribute to such tragedies. Through expert analysis and thorough investigation, the podcast aims to foster a deeper understanding of the complexities surrounding these cases.

Follow & Support:

• Instagram: @crimehouse
• Subscription: Enhance your listening experience by subscribing to Crime House Plus on Apple Podcasts for ad-free episodes and bonus content.

This summary encapsulates the key points and discussions from the first part of the special episode on Nicole Brown Simpson. Tune in to the second part for a complete understanding of the case and its aftermath.