Loading summary
A
Hi everyone, it's Carter. Exciting news. Video episodes of Murder True Crime Stories are now on YouTube. Every Friday, I'll be dropping a full video episode, going deeper into the cases that still haunt us. The mysteries that haven't been solved, and the stories that deserve more than just a headline. Same depth, same commitment to telling the real story. But now you can watch it. Subscribe at Murder True crime stories on YouTube to catch a new video episode every Friday. This is crime house. Social media has undeniably changed society. We're now more connected than ever. But it turns out that constant communication isn't always a good thing. In December of 2014, the small town of Cortland, Mississippi learned this firsthand. After a 19 year old woman named Jessica Chambers suffered a tragic death, the community received an outpouring of support from all around the globe. In the year to follow, amateur detectives formed online discussion groups using sites like Facebook. Their official goal was to help the police solve Jessica's murder. But in reality, all they did was harass the people they believed were guilty without any evidence to back up their accusations. That obsession with true crime backfired, stalling the investigation into Jessica's murder. And all these years later, her friends and family are still paying the price. People's lives are like a story. There's a beginning, a middle, and an end. But you don't always know which part you're on. Sometimes the final chapter arrives far too soon. And we don't always get to know the real ending. I'm Carter Roy and this is True Crime Stories, a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. New episodes come out every Tuesday, Thursday and Friday, with Friday's episodes covering the cases that deserve a deeper look. Look. Thank you for being part of the Crime House community. Please rate, review and follow the show and for ad free access to every episode, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. This is the first of two episodes on the murder of 19 year old Jessica Chambers in Cortland, Mississippi. Please note, this episode contains graphic descriptions of violence and murder. Please listen with care. Today we'll discuss the brutal crime that shocked the town of Cortland, Mississippi on December 6, 2014. Because the case was so heavily impacted by social media, we'll start by covering the murder itself. Then we'll learn who Jessica Chambers was. Just like the armchair detectives who fixated on her case. And of course, we'll follow detectives as they search for clues and eventually land on a prime suspect. Next time, we'll dive into the two trials that followed. Although prosecutors were certain they had found Jessica's killer. Getting a conviction proved to be more difficult than they expected. Because of that, Jessica's family is still searching for answers. All that and more coming up. You'd have to zoom in pretty far on a map to notice the small town of Cortland, Mississippi, located in the northern part of the state, an hour south of Memphis, Tennessee. Only about 500 people live there, and most have been in Cortland their entire lives. The area is predominantly blue collar. Most people are farmers or factory workers. And though many of them live below the poverty line, they like to say they are rich in spirit. Cortland has one of the highest rates of church attendance in the United States and is the kind of place where neighbors really do look out for one another. So it's safe to say that faith is the first priority for many families in Cortland. Maybe the second is football. Every Saturday during the height of the season, practically the entire town gathers at the local high school to cheer on the team. And while Cortlandt has problems with petty crime and violence, like anywhere else, most people would call it safe. Or at least it was safe. But that all changed on December 6, 2014. That night, at around 8:10pm Local firefighters got a call that would haunt them forever. Someone had spotted a young woman staggering down a rural road outside of town, half naked and dazed. Even more disturbing, the victim was engulfed in in flames. Because of the way she stumbled down the street, the caller said she looked like some kind of zombie. And when firefighters arrived just minutes later, they found she was covered in severe burns that extended from the tips of her toes to the inside of her throat. From the beginning, they could tell the attack was deliberate. The victim's car, a black Kia Rio, was smoldering a few yards away. It looked like someone had doused the vehicle and the young woman in gasoline before setting them both on fire. And yet she was somehow able to escape and stay on her feet long enough to walk away. By the time paramedics arrived, the woman was still clinging to life, but just barely. The EMTs found her lying in the fetal position next to a ditch. With every ragged breath she took, a flap of burnt skin hanging from her nose fluttered in the dirt. Emergency workers were stunned to find the young woman was still relatively lucid. She could nod weakly or shake her head in response to questions, and. And though it clearly hurt her to speak, she was able to croak out a few words here and there. Most of it was unintelligible, but some of what she said was clear as day. Knowing that her time was probably running out, a volunteer firefighter named Brandy Davis asked the victim who attacked her. According to eight witnesses, she said that someone named Eric was to blame. After that, she fell silent, trembling as EMTs loaded her onto a stretcher. They rushed her to a local hospital just a few minutes away. It was a Saturday night and the ICU was busy, but doctors dropped everything when they saw the extent of the young woman's injuries. Second and third degree burns covered 93% of her body. As she drifted in and out of consciousness, the police managed to identify her as 19 year old Jessica Chambers. That was how they got in touch with her parents, Ben and Lisa. As painful as it was, they were able to sit by their daughter's bedside. In her final moments, Ben couldn't bear to see his little girl in so much pain. For six long hours, he sat outside the hospital room while Jessica fought to stay alive. Sadly, she was too far gone by then. Her mom, Lisa, held her hand as she passed away around 1 or 2am on December 7, 2014. Jessica's death shocked Cortland. Her older sister, 25 year old A.J. just couldn't wrap her head around it. Growing up, she and Jessica spent their days in the neighbor's backyard playing kickball with the other kids on their street. Cortland was so small, it felt like everyone was family. AJ couldn't imagine anyone doing something so horrific to her sister. No one could. Pretty much everyone who knew Jessica loved her. She was fun, loving, kind and talented. Growing up, she made a name for herself as an athlete, playing softball and joining the cheerleading squad in middle school. Jessica knew how much football meant to the town, so she wanted to be right there on the field, supporting the players from the sidelines. It helped that she was short, slender and blonde, the quintessential cheerleader. And by all accounts, she loved it. She was the flyer, the most sought after role on the squad. Not only was she the top of the pyramid, she was also the one launched into the air during acrobatic routines. It was definitely a little risky. On more than one occasion, her parents had to close their eyes when they watched, terrified that her teammates would accidentally drop her to the ground. But for Jessica, cheerleading was exhilarating. In 2013, Jessyca graduated high school and passed her role as flyer down to someone else. After that, she got a job at a local department store. But the photos she took in her cheer uniform were the ones that circulated most widely in the media. A year later, after her death, the Headlines basically wrote themselves. A popular former cheerleader had been burned alive. A story like that was bound to spread, especially because Jessyca's case came at a time when public interest in true crime was growing. Publications like Buzzfeed covered her death extensively and helped circulate the story to a wider audience. So it wasn't surprising that within weeks, dozens of social media pages dedicated to the case had popped up. Their armchair detectives, who knew nothing about Jessica or her community, debated what had happened to her. They accused her friends, ex boyfriends, and even her father of killing her. Many tried to get in contact with the accused over social media to interrogate and harass them. This only made the grieving process more difficult for Jessica's family. And the red herrings made it harder for the Mississippi police to do their jobs. The local sheriff, Dennis Darby, was put in charge of the case. For him, the crime hit especially close to home. Jessica's dad, Ben, worked as a mechanic in his department. Solving the murder was priority one for Sheriff Darby. But the town had never dealt with such a high profile case. Rather than try to do everything themselves, the deputies assembled a task force of state and local investigators. Having experienced detectives on their side would give them the best chance at finding the culprit. At the outset of the investigation, the team was confident. But the scene of the crime itself proved to be their first challenge. The fire and its aftermath had obliterated all traces of forensic evidence, and what hadn't been burnt in the flames was washed away by the fire department. Officers tried their best to sift through the debris that remained, but they couldn't come up with anything usable. There were no signs of the killer in the surrounding area either. Dozens of emergency responders had stampeded through the dirt, trampling over any existing footprints. So the team turned back to the only lead they did have, One that Jessica provided in her final moments. According to firefighters at the scene, she blamed someone named Eric for attacking her. Police poured over her phone, searching for any conversations with the mystery man. They looked at her texts, her social media accounts, anything that might help, but there was no mention of him anywhere. At that point, they cast a wider net. Local deputies, along with FBI officials, started making a list of every single Eric in the surrounding area. Just to be safe, they included people named Derek, too. Over the next few weeks, they conducted dozens of interviews, and yet, no one they spoke to had any clear connection to Jessica. None of her family and friends knew who the mysterious Eric might be either. The investigation was going nowhere fast, and before long, detectives were forced to admit they'd hit a dead end, they had no choice but to consider other possibilities. When she was found, Jessica's throat was burned and raw from breathing in scalding smoke. Law enforcement believed her injuries could have prevented her from pronouncing certain sounds. So while the firefighters insisted she accused Eric of being the culprit, it was possible she meant to say something else. It's not that the first responders misheard, but that her vocal cords were too damaged for her to speak clearly. That meant the police would have to go back to the drawing board. Burning someone alive is a particularly violent way to commit murder. Because of that, investigators were scared, certain the motive had to be personal. So they focused on her family, friends, and romantic partners. They wanted to know every single person who saw Jessica in the days before her death. That's when detectives realized there was much more to Jessica's story than met the eye.
B
Foreign Debt Debt do you have $10,000 or more in credit card debt? Maybe you're even barely getting by by making minimum payments. With credit card debt hitting record highs, National Debt Relief offers real debt relief solutions for people struggling to keep up. These options may reduce a large portion of credit card debt for those who qualify. You don't need to declare bankruptcy, and you may be able to pay back less than you owe regardless of your credit. National Debt Relief has already reduced the credit card debt for more than 550,000 consumers. So don't wait if you owe 10, 20, or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in credit card debt, you can now take advantage of this financial debt relief as the cost of living increases. To find out how much you could save, Visit National Debt Relief.com that's National Debt Relief.com.
A
On December 6, 2014, 19 year old Jessica Cham was found on the side of a road in Cortland, Mississippi. And though she had been set on fire and was severely injured, she was still conscious at the scene. She told firefighters that someone named Eric had attacked her. Jessica died in the hospital six hours later. And as the story of her horrific murder spread across the country, a police task force leapt into action to find the killer. Unfortunately, their initial efforts to track down Eric hit a wall. So early on, detectives turned their attention to Jessica's personal life. They quickly realized she'd been through a lot in her 19 years. Jessica Chambers was born in Clarksdale, Mississippi, near Cortland on February 2, 1995. She was one of seven children with three brothers and three sisters. That meant Jessica grew up in a full house with so many Mouths to feed. Her parents had to work hard to make ends meet. It was a lot of pressure that pushed her father, Ben, to make some mistakes. In the early 2000s, Ben was busted for manufacturing crystal meth. During the same period, he was arrested for driving under the influence. Later on, he got sober and turned his life around, becoming a mechanic and eventually getting a job with the sheriff's department. But even then, Jessica's teenage years were turbulent and at times, tragic. In 2006, her next door neighbor was shot in his front yard. Six years later, in 2012, one of her older brothers passed away in a car accident. Jessica might have been naturally rebellious, but these experiences only caused her to act out even more. She liked to push boundaries, especially when her parents disapproved of her decisions. As the years wore on, the relationship between Jessica and her mother Lisa became especially tense. According to Lisa, she and her daughter shared the same short temper. When they argued, they didn't hold anything back. Friends remember Jessica and her mom having full on screaming matches in their front yard. Sometimes these ended with Jessica leaving the house to go stay with friends for a few months. Things between the mother daughter duo weren't always perfect, but in the end, Jessica always came back home. After digging into these disputes, investigators found that many of them traced back to Jessica's taste in men. Lisa felt that her daughter had fallen in with a rough crowd and went out with guys who didn't treat her right. To make matters worse, Lisa said Jessyca could be manipulative with her boyfriends, using them to get what she wanted. She even threw her mother under the bus in the process. For example, Jessica sometimes said her mom locked up all the food in the house to starve her as a punishment. Lisa insisted these stories were lies designed by Jessica to pressure her dates into giving her money so she could go to Burger King. On other occasions, Jessica agreed to go out with a guy on the condition that he brought her cigarettes beforehand. She claimed they were for her mom, but in reality, she smoked them all herself. Lisa said that these wild stories made Jessica's dates think she was some kind of monster. And while that probably wasn't fair, there was another major factor underpinning these relationships. Race. Jessyca was white but had a lot of black friends and often dated black men. And on more than one occasion, Jessica told her friends and boyfriends that her parents were racist. Ben did acknowledge that he doesn't believe in in interracial relationships, but Lisa disputed her daughter's characterization. She emphasized that she didn't like the Behavior of the guys Jessica went out with and said it didn't have anything to do with race. Still, that tension was at the root of some of their most passionate arguments. In 2013, a year before her death, Jessica was dating a young black man named Brian Rudd. Because Lisa didn't approve of the relationship, she kicked her 18 year old daughter out of the house. Brian's mom went outside the next morning to find her son sleeping with Jessica out on the front porch. Overcome with sympathy, she agreed to let Jessyca stay with them for a few months. That summer, the couple broke up and Jessica moved back in with her mom. But even though she and Brian were no longer dating, they were still close. And apparently he wanted to rekindle their relationship. In May of 2013, around the time Jessyca graduated high school, the two of them met up at Lisa's house. While they were there, someone fired a gun. Jessica claimed that Brian tried to shoot her because she wouldn't get back together with him. Brian said it was the other way around. He told police that she tried to shoot him to get him to leave. It was a messy situation that ended with Brian moving to Iowa to live with his older brother. Jessica coped differently. Soon she started dating another young man named Travis Sanford. But just a few months into their relationship, in the fall of 2013, Travis was sentenced to six years in prison for robbery. Although he and Jessica stayed together, it seemed like his run in with the law was a wake up call for her. Once he was behind bars, she got a job at a local department store and tried to straighten out her act. All in all, things seemed to be going well for her in the days before her death on December 6, 2014, which made the crime even more baffling for the police. Her official boyfriend, Travis Sanford, was incarcerated at the time of the attack, so investigators knew he couldn't be responsible. And even though Jessica had personal feuds with some of her friends, none of them seemed capable of such a brutal murder. The only thing left to do was to reconstruct the 19 year old's final hours. That's how detectives learned Travis Sanford wasn't her only boyfriend. It turned out she'd recently gotten involved with another man, a 26 year old named Quinton Tellis. On December 10, 2014, just three days after Jessica was pronounced dead, Quentin sat down with police. He explained that he and Jessica had been dating for a few weeks at the time of her murder. They were introduced through some friends, and Jessica's older sister AJ had gone to elementary school with Quentin and knew him well. According to Quentin, Jessica picked him up on the morning of her death. One of her best friends, a young woman named Keisha Meyer, was also in the car. The trio drove around town for about an hour. He said they didn't do much. They just chatted and laughed about some local gossip. Then Jessica dropped Quinton back off at his house. He was adamant that he wasn't with Jessica for long. Even under pressure from investigators, Quinton was cooperative and seemed to be forthcoming. He voluntarily offered a DNA sample and even took a polygraph, which he passed. He also gave them an alibi, claiming he was with some friends. About 30 minutes after Jessica was attacked. Sometime around 8:45 that night, after making sure Quentin's story checked out, detectives turned their attention to the rest of Jessyca's day. Based on location data from Jessica's cell phone, investigators were able to get a rough idea of her mother, although they weren't always able to verify if she was alone or not. But from what they could gather, that afternoon was a pretty slow one for the 19 year old. She spent the majority of her time at home, relaxing, passing the hours with her mom. Then, just before 5pm that evening, Lisa said Jessica got a phone call from a friend. After a short conversation, Jessica told her she was going out. Lisa didn't ask many questions. It didn't seem like her daughter was headed anywhere important. She was wearing camouflage sweatpants and her hair was tossed into a messy bun. Cell phone data confirmed that Jessica's next stop was a nearby gas station, where she paused to fill up her Kia Rio sedan. Security footage showed her fueling up her car and paying at the counter. In the video, nothing about her behavior seemed out of the ordinary. She didn't interact with anyone other than the cashier. Then she headed to a nearby friend's house, though it's not clear if this was the same friend who'd called her or someone else. But we do know that Jessica spent the next 45 minutes there. Then at 6 o', clock, Jessica left her friend and drove to the neighboring town, a place called Batesville, which isn't much larger than Cortland. Police had no idea what she did there or who she may have been with. Finally, sometime around 7:30 that night, she pulled over on the back road where she died, only a couple of miles away from her mom's house. 45 minutes later, a passing driver spotted her burning car. After weeks of investigating, detectives felt like they had a good idea of who Jessica Chambers was, and they knew all about her friends, her family, and her romantic life. But none of it added up to a solid lead. The 90 minutes between 6pm and 7:30 seemed to be the crucial window. Police believed that whoever Jessica met up with in Batesville could point them to the killer or was the killer. But for the time being, they had no idea who that might be. Her car was too burnt up to offer any forensic evidence. Her final words pointed them to a man who might not exist. And even though police believed the motive had to be personal, the people closest to her all had solid alibis. Deputies spent countless hours going over the evidence with a fine toothed comb. Even then, it took them almost a year to realize they'd made a serious mistake. It turned out one of their prime suspects had lied straight to their faces.
B
A mother is on trial for allegedly luring her own son in law to his death. And her search history may have given away everything. This is Vanessa, the host of Crime House 24 7. Right now in a Utah courtroom, 60 year old Tracy Grist is standing trial for murder, accused of masterminding a family plot to kill her son in law, Matthew Rastelli. Prosecutors say Matthew was lured from California under the pretense of picking up his wife and kids. What he didn't know, he was walking into a trap. Within seconds, he was shot seven times, three of them in the back. And months before the killing, investigators say Tracy sent a text to one of her daughters that read, quote, matt made it so I want to kill him. He straight up lied. I'm gonna kill him. End quote. Hear the rest of that story and never miss another on Crime House 24. 7, where we cover breaking true crime news daily. Follow crime house24.7 wherever you listen to podcasts so you never miss a story as it.
A
Hi listeners, it's Carter Roy. I wanted to take a moment to tell you about another show from Crime House that I know you'll love. America's Most Infamous Crimes. Hosted by Katie Ring. Each week Katie takes on a notorious crime, whether unfolding now or etched into American history, revealing not just what happened, but how it forever changed our story. Society serial killers who terrorize cities, unsolved mysteries that keep detectives up at night, and investigations that change the way we think about justice. Each case unfolds across multiple episodes released every Tuesday through Thursday. From the first sign that something was wrong to the moment the truth came out or didn't. These are the stories behind the headlines. Listen to and follow America's most infamous crimes Tuesday through Thursday on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music or wherever you listen to podcasts. By September 2015, it had been nine months since 19 year old Jessica Chambers was burned alive in Cortland, Mississippi. So far, a task force of local and federal agents had failed to arrest anyone for Jessica's murder. Her family and friends were starting to get frustrated with the lag of progress. To make matters worse, a mob of Internet detectives was still harassing them. Practically every day. These people congregated on Facebook pages and online discussion boards to debate their wild theories. Most of the so called leads they floated were totally unsubstantiated. And lately, many of them had taken on a racial angle. For example, some posters spread misinformation about Jessica's ex boyfriend, Brian Rudd. Brian was black, which they believe somehow implicated him in Jessica's death. Officially, the police had never considered him a suspect. He didn't even live in Cortland anymore and hadn't at the time Jessica was killed. But none of that mattered to the trolls. Other Internet users honed in on a 19 year old who worked at the gas station where Jessica was seen a few hours before her death. Without any other clear suspects, the virtual mob descended on him too. Some of them focused on the fact that he was of Arab descent. They claimed, without evidence, that the gas station where he worked was often used to carry out drug deals. The harassment got so bad that the local police had to step in and formally announce that the young man was not a suspect. On the contrary, he had gone out of his way to help the authorities by finding surveillance video of Jessica filling up her car. Even then, the online trolls didn't stop. They were convinced that Jessica was a victim of gang violence and concocted wild narratives that placed her at the center of a vast conspiracy. They wanted to make the case about racial tensions. A narrative that Jessica's friends in the police flatly rejected. Overall, the residents of Cortland were baffled and and incredibly frustrated by all the online attention. Clearly, the Internet sleuths weren't going to help solve Jessica's murder. In fact, they were just making things worse. So the authorities tried to ignore the noise and focus on the case. And In August of 2015, they finally got the lead they'd been waiting for. That month, 26 year old Quentin Tallis was arrested in Louisiana. Remember, he and Jessica had been dating for a few weeks at the time of her death, and Quentin told police he was with her the day she died. But he insisted he had nothing to do with her murder. After her death, he started dating another woman. And in early July, 2015. They moved to Louisiana and got married. One of the first things Quentin did once they arrived was place a call to Chase bank to activate a debit card. The problem was the card belonged to a dead woman. 34 year old Mandy Hsiao was a Taiwanese international student who had received her master's degree from from the University of Louisiana. In April 2015, she was found stabbed to death in an off campus apartment. Just three months later, on June 29th, bank records showed that someone had withdrawn $1,000 from her account. The same night she was murdered. Her debit card was missing from her wallet, and Quentin Tellis was the one who who had it. He was arrested in September. A month later, he was charged with three counts of unauthorized use of a credit card and possession of a quarter pound of marijuana. And the police affidavit stated that investigators believed he had something to do with Mandy's murder, too. When news of the crime reached detectives in Cortland, Mississippi, they saw Quentin in a new light. Months earlier, they dismissed him as a suspect in the murder of Jessica Chambers. Now they weren't so sure. Investigators took another look at Quinton's alibi and filed subpoenas to access his cell phone records. After cross referencing his official statements with the new data, it seemed like he'd been lying to them. According to the district Attorney, John Champion, experts made a mistake in their initial analysis of Jessica's cell phone. After adjusting their criteria to account for the error, location data showed that she and Quinton were together in the hours leading up to her death. That contradicted Quinton's previous testimony a year earlier. Back in December of 2014, he told authorities that he'd only seen Jessica for about an hour on the morning of her murder. Clearly, he was hiding something. To learn more, the Cortland police had him sent back to Mississippi for another round of questioning. Quinton stuck to his original story. Even when police confronted him with the cell phone data, he insisted that he was with his friend, a man who went by the name Big Mike. During the period that Jessica was killed, the police had no choice but to return him to Louisiana, where Quentin was still being held on suspicion of illegally using Mandy's credit card. But now they had a new lead to follow. They tracked down Big Mike, and according to him, he wasn't even in town the day Jessica was killed. With that, Quinton's alibi had officially fallen apart. So in early 2016, the authorities interrogated him for the third time. Finally, Quentin confessed that he was with Jessica that evening. The two of them met at a Taco Bell in Batesville at around 6pm after she left her friend's house in Cortland. This was the key window of time. Police had already identified the 90 minutes leading up to her murder. Still, Quinton continued to insist that he had nothing to do with her death. But given the fact that he'd been lying to them for months, the authorities refused to take him at his word. On February 23, 2016, a grand jury indicted 27 year old Quentin Tellis for the murder of Jessica Chambers. Meanwhile, the investigation into Mandy Hsiao's death was ongoing. Though the Louisiana police still considered Quinton a suspect, they had yet to charge him with her murder. Back in Cortland, Jessica's family was shocked to hear the news about his indictment. They hadn't heard an update on the case in months. And suddenly the police had a potential culprit. And they weren't the only ones who were taken aback. The army of ever present Internet sleuths was outraged. In the years since Jessica was killed, the mob had harassed countless people they suspected of being involved in the crime. But almost none of them had named Quinton as the killer. Many refused to believe he was responsible, and they took to the web to let out their frustration. For these detractors, there were two major issues with the police's newest suspect. The first had to do with Jessica's final words. For over a year, everyone had been searching for a man with a name that sounded something like Eric. Quentin Telles clearly didn't fit the bill. Because of that, some people argued that he couldn't possibly be guilty. Law enforcement responded to the criticism by emphasizing that Jessica's mouth and throat were damaged by the fire. They believe she wasn't able to pronounce a T sound because of her injuries. They argued that maybe she had been trying to say talus and the firefighters at the scene misheard her. That struck some Internet commentators as a stretch, but they also had a second, larger objection to the arrest. At a press conference following his indictment, the district attorney said unequivocally that Jessica's murder had nothing to do with gang violence or drugs. Though he acknowledged that Quinton was a member of a gang, he was adamant that the motive was personal. That flew in the face of the conspiracy conspiracies that many Internet sleuths had spent a year furiously debating on Facebook. Over time, some of them had become utterly convinced, without real evidence, that Jessica was deeply embedded with gangs in Cortland, many were confident that she was also dealing drugs. They believed multiple people must have colluded to kill her. These Internet users, who had never even been to Cortland or met anyone involved in the case, were certain they were correct. Investigators released several public statements to try to contradict the Internet hysteria, but in the end, they had to turn their attention away from the trolls to focus on building their case. Quinton's trial was scheduled for October 9, 2017. The authorities hoped a guilty verdict would prove the online skeptics wrong once and for all. But when Quinton telles day in court came, the prosecution got more than they bargained for. Thanksgiving so much for listening. I'm Carter Roy and this is True Crime Stories. Come back next time for part two on the murder of Jessica Chambers and all the people it affected. True Crime Stories is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. Here at Crime House we want to thank each and every one of you for your support. If you like what you heard today, reach out on social media, cross crime house on TikTok and Instagram. Don't forget to rate, review and follow True Crime Stories wherever you get your podcasts. Your feedback truly makes a difference. And to enhance your Murder True Crime Stories listening experience, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. You'll get every episode ad free. We'll be back on Thursday. True Crime Stories is hosted by me, Carter Roy and is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. This episode was brought to life by the Murder True Crime Stories team. Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benedon, Natalie Pertofsky, Laurie Marinelli, Sarah Camp, Tara Wells, Hania Said, Nicolette Tavalero, Cassidy Dillon and Russell Nash. Thank you for listening.
B
A mother is on trial for allegedly luring her own son in law to his death and her search history may have given away everything. This is Vanessa, the host of Crime House 24 7. Right now in a Utah courtroom, 60 year old Tracy Grist is still standing trial for murder. Accused of masterminding a family plot to kill her son in law, Matthew Rastelli. Prosecutors say Matthew was lured from California under the pretense of picking up his wife and kids. What he didn't know he was walking into a trap. Within seconds he was shot seven times, three of them in the back. And months before the killing, investigators say Tracy sent a text to one of her daughters that read, quote Matt made it so I want to kill him. He straight up lied. I'm gonna kill him. End quote. Hear the rest of that story and never miss another on crime house 247 where we cover Breaking True Crime News daily follow crime house 247 wherever you listen to podcasts so you never miss a story as it breaks.
A
Thanks for listening to today's episode of Murder True Crime Stories. Not sure what to listen to next? Check out America's Most Infamous Crimes, hosted by Katie Ring. From serial killers to unsolved mysteries and game changing investigations, each week Katie takes on a notorious criminal case in American history. Listen to and follow America's Most Infamous Crimes now wherever you listen to podcasts.
Host: Carter Roy
Release Date: April 14, 2026
Podcast Network: Crime House / PAVE Studios
This episode launches a two-part deep dive into the brutal, unsolved murder of Jessica Chambers, a 19-year-old woman from Cortland, Mississippi, whose horrific death in December 2014 shocked her small town and reverberated across the nation. Host Carter Roy examines not just the crime itself but also the devastating ripple effects of social media-fueled speculation—“armchair detectives”—on both the investigation and the lives of those close to Jessica. Roy reconstructs the last day of Jessica’s life, explores her background and the police investigation, and explains how online scrutiny obstructed justice.
[03:00–07:50]
“Knowing her time was probably running out, a volunteer firefighter named Brandy Davis asked the victim who attacked her. According to eight witnesses, she said that someone named Eric was to blame.” — Carter Roy [06:40]
[08:30–12:45, 16:26–20:40]
Family and Upbringing:
One of seven siblings, Jessica grew up amid financial pressures and family turbulence (her father’s early drug arrest, a neighbor shot, a brother killed in an accident). Her relationship with her mother was “especially tense,” marked by arguments and estrangement, but always eventual reconciliation.
Personality and Activities:
Described as “fun, loving, kind, and talented,” Jessica was a star cheerleader, the “flyer” who performed stunts, and worked at a local department store after high school.
Turbulent Relationships:
She sometimes dated men her mother disapproved of and had a history of complex, sometimes contentious, relationships with both family and boyfriends. Issues of race were intertwined in these conflicts, as Jessica was white but often dated Black men.
“Jessyca was white but had a lot of black friends and often dated black men. And on more than one occasion, Jessica told her friends and boyfriends that her parents were racist.” — Carter Roy [19:30]
“But in the end, Jessica always came back home.” — Carter Roy [19:05]
[13:30–15:15, 20:40–29:00, 29:45–32:40]
Initial Investigation – The “Eric” Lead:
Police focused intensely on finding an “Eric” or “Derek” in Jessica’s circle—searching her phone, interviewing dozens—but found no relevant connections.
“At the outset, the team was confident. But the scene… proved to be their first challenge. The fire and its aftermath had obliterated all traces of forensic evidence.” — Carter Roy [13:50]
“They looked at her texts, her social media accounts, anything that might help, but there was no mention of him anywhere.” — Carter Roy [14:35]
Effect of Trauma on Final Words:
Police later considered Jessica’s throat burns might have made her speech unintelligible, casting doubt on the “Eric” clue.
The Social Media Frenzy:
Amateur sleuths on Facebook and discussion boards spread unfounded accusations, targeted her friends and ex-boyfriends (often with a racial slant), and even harassed her grieving family.
“Their official goal was to help the police. But in reality, all they did was harass the people they believed were guilty without any evidence… That obsession with true crime backfired, stalling the investigation…” — Carter Roy [01:14]
“The online trolls didn’t stop… they were convinced Jessica was a victim of gang violence and concocted wild narratives that placed her at the center of a vast conspiracy.” — Carter Roy [30:07]
Police Response:
Authorities repeatedly attempted to set the record straight about who was not a suspect (especially a gas station worker also harassed by internet trolls).
[20:50–28:20, 32:40–39:35]
Timeline of Jessica’s Last Day:
Quinton Tellis Enters the Story:
Jessica was involved with 26-year-old Quinton Tellis at the time of her murder. Tellis claimed to have seen her briefly that day and provided an alibi, giving a DNA sample and passing a polygraph.
Break in the Case – Arrest in Louisiana:
In 2015, Tellis was arrested in Louisiana on unrelated charges involving another murdered woman, Mandy Hsiao. This prompted Mississippi police to reconsider his alibi and cross-check cell phone data, revealing he'd lied; his story didn’t match his and Jessica’s cellphone locations.
“It turned out one of their prime suspects had lied straight to their faces.” — Carter Roy [28:10]
Tellis’ Changing Story:
Initially denying time spent with Jessica on the day she died, he later admitted being with her that evening. However, he insisted he had no involvement in her murder.
“Finally, Quinton confessed that he was with Jessica that evening. The two of them met at a Taco Bell in Batesville… Still, Quinton continued to insist that he had nothing to do with her death.” — Carter Roy [38:11]
Indictment:
On February 23, 2016, a grand jury indicted Quinton Tellis for Jessica Chambers’ murder, despite neither physical evidence nor a confession tying him directly to the crime.
[32:40–40:40]
“They had harassed countless people they suspected… But almost none of them had named Quinton as the killer. Many refused to believe he was responsible, and they took to the web to let out their frustration.” — Carter Roy [37:40]
On the Impact of Social Media:
“That obsession with true crime backfired, stalling the investigation into Jessica’s murder. And all these years later, her friends and family are still paying the price.”
— Carter Roy [01:16]
Reflecting on Jessica’s Family Dynamics:
“When they argued, they didn’t hold anything back. Friends remember Jessica and her mom having full-on screaming matches in their front yard… but in the end, Jessica always came back home.”
— Carter Roy [19:00]
On the Arduous Investigation:
“The fire and its aftermath had obliterated all traces of forensic evidence, and what hadn’t been burnt… was washed away by the fire department.”
— Carter Roy [13:50]
On Quinton Tellis’ Shattered Alibi:
“It turned out one of their prime suspects had lied straight to their faces.”
— Carter Roy [28:10]
Regarding Online Harassment and False Theories:
“They wanted to make the case about racial tensions—a narrative Jessica’s friends and the police flatly rejected.”
— Carter Roy [30:10]
| Segment | Description | |:------------------------------------------|:-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | 03:00 – 07:50 | Details of the crime scene, Jessica discovered alive, her final words | | 08:30 – 12:45 | Portrait of Cortland, Jessica’s early life and family | | 13:30 – 15:15 | The investigation’s early focus on “Eric” | | 16:26 – 20:40 | Jessica’s turbulent adolescence and relationships | | 20:50 – 28:20 | Final day timeline, friends, gas station video, early leads | | 29:45 – 32:40 | Social media’s distraction and harm to the case, online harassment of suspects | | 32:40 – 39:35 | Quinton Tellis’ Louisiana arrest, unraveling of his alibi, indictment for Jessica’s murder | | 39:35 – 41:15 | Internet backlash, DA’s press conference, ending preview for part two |
Carter Roy maintains a thoughtful, methodical tone, balancing empathy for Jessica and her family with a critique of the social media-driven distortion of justice. The narrative places heavy emphasis on humanizing Jessica, exposing the darker side of true crime fandom, and showing the consequences of misdirected internet activism.
The episode closes with the indictment of Quinton Tellis—a suspect previously discounted by both police and the online community—setting the stage for episode two, which will cover his trials, the difficulty in securing a conviction, and the enduring search for answers by Jessica’s family.
“Come back next time for part two on the murder of Jessica Chambers and all the people it affected.” — Carter Roy [41:10]
For more on this case, tune in to the next episode of Murder: True Crime Stories.