Murder: True Crime Stories - Episode: UNSOLVED: Mary Phagan 1

Host: Carter Roy
Release Date: December 3, 2024

Introduction

In the gripping first installment of the two-part series on the unsolved murder of Mary Phagan, host Carter Roy delves deep into the tragic story of a young girl whose life was brutally cut short in 1913 Atlanta, Georgia. This episode intricately examines the events leading up to Mary’s death, the subsequent investigation, and the wrongful suspicion cast upon Leo Frank—a narrative fraught with societal tensions and media sensationalism.

Who Was Mary Phagan?

Mary Phagan, a 13-year-old girl born on June 1, 1899, found herself in dire circumstances, compelled to leave school early to work at the National Pencil Factory in Atlanta. [05:26] Carter Roy narrates:

"Mary Fagan was born into poverty, a stark reality in post-Civil War Georgia where industrialization had left many destitute. Her work at the factory involved long hours for meager wages, earning only $1.20 for two shifts—the equivalent of roughly $38 today."

Mary's life was emblematic of the struggles faced by many young girls of her time, thrust into the harsh realities of factory labor without prospects for a better future.

The Night of the Murder

On the early morning of April 27, 1913, Newt Lee, the night watchman at the factory, discovered Mary’s disfigured body in the basement. The crime scene was rife with disturbing evidence: signs of a violent blow to the head, strangulation marks, possible sexual assault, and two cryptic notes left near her body. [05:26]

Carter Roy explains:

"The notes seemed to implicate Mary herself or her killer, but crucial investigative steps were mishandled, including the loss of bloody fingerprint evidence on the back door boards."

Initial Investigation and Suspect Missteps

The police's immediate response to Mary’s murder was marked by a rush to judgment. Three men—Newt Lee, Arthur Mullinax, and James Gantt—were swiftly arrested but later released due to insufficient evidence. The investigation’s focus soon shifted to Leo Frank, the factory superintendent, driven more by societal biases and media pressure than concrete proof.

"Detective John Black believed Leo was guilty from the outset, a bias that clouded the investigation." [05:26]

Leo Frank: The Outsider

Leo Frank, a Jewish man from Texas raised in New York, was an outsider in Atlanta’s Southern society. Despite his success and qualifications, his background made him a target in a region fraught with economic resentment towards northern industrialists.

Carter Roy provides insight into Leo's predicament:

"Leo was seen as a symbol of everything wrong with the South’s struggles—an Ivy League-educated Yankee who didn’t quite fit in, especially given his Jewish heritage."

Media Influence and Public Outrage

The media played a pivotal role in shaping public perception against Leo Frank. Influential newspaper magnates like William Randolph Hearst and Thomas E. Watson fueled the fire, presenting biased and often fabricated stories that painted Leo as a heartless murderer.

"Hearst’s Atlanta Georgian sensationalized Mary’s murder, while Watson’s Jeffersonian used it to amplify anti-northern and anti-Semitic sentiments." [23:41]

The Arrest of Leo Frank

Merely four days after Mary’s body was found, under mounting public and media pressure, Leo Frank was arrested. The investigation against him was characterized by selective evidence and coerced testimonies, particularly from Jim Conley, a black handyman with a tainted reputation.

Carter Roy discusses the flawed prosecution:

"Solicitor General Hugh Dorsey needed a conviction to salvage his career. Jim Conley became his key witness, despite inconsistencies in his statements."

Conclusion and Lead into Part Two

The episode concludes with Leo Frank's impending trial, setting the stage for the ensuing legal battle and its tragic aftermath. Carter Roy leaves listeners on a cliffhanger, promising a deeper exploration of the trial's proceedings, the miscarriage of justice, and the enduring legacy of this case in the next episode.

Notable Quotes

• Carter Roy [00:06]:
  “When you break down a murder, there's another incredibly important aspect at the circumstances. Because murder and the ensuing investigation doesn't happen in a vacuum.”

• Carter Roy [05:26]:
  “Mary Fagan or the person who killed her. And even if the handwriting proved to be a dead end, fingerprinting technology had been around for decades by 1913 and had first been used in an American criminal case three years earlier.”

• Carter Roy [23:41]:
  “Solicitor General Hugh Dorsey desperately needed to secure a conviction. He'd recently prosecuted two high profile murder cases and lost both of them.”

Key Takeaways

• Societal Tensions: The murder took place in a volatile economic and social climate, where resentment towards northern industrialists like Leo Frank was palpable.

• Investigative Flaws: Critical mistakes in evidence handling and a biased investigation led to the wrongful suspicion of an innocent man.

• Media Sensationalism: Influential media figures exacerbated the situation, turning public opinion against Leo Frank through biased reporting.

• Racial and Religious Prejudices: Leo Frank’s Jewish heritage and status as a Northern outsider made him a scapegoat in a society rife with underlying prejudices.

Next Episode Preview

Join Carter Roy in the next episode, "UNSOLVED: Mary Phagan 2," where the trial of Leo Frank unfolds, revealing the depths of judicial and societal failures that led to one of history’s most infamous wrongful convictions.

Follow Murder: True Crime Stories

Stay updated with the latest episodes and behind-the-scenes content by following Crime House on Instagram and subscribing to Murder: True Crime Stories on your preferred podcast platform.