Murder: True Crime Stories — Episode Summary: UNSOLVED: Mary Phagan 2

Host: Carter Roy
Podcast: Murder: True Crime Stories
Release Date: December 10, 2024

Introduction

In the second and final installment of the Mary Phagan case, host Carter Roy delves deeper into the tumultuous trial of Leo Frank, the repercussions of his conviction, and the tragic aftermath that ensued. Building upon the foundation laid in the first episode, this summary captures the intricate details of the trial, the strategies employed by both the defense and prosecution, and the enduring legacy of this infamous case.

The Trial of Leo Frank

Courtroom Dynamics and Public Sentiment

On July 28, 1913, Leo Frank stood trial for the murder of 13-year-old Mary Phagan, whose body was discovered in the basement of the Atlanta pencil factory where she worked. Despite a lack of concrete evidence linking Frank to the crime, multiple factors made him a convenient target:

• Socioeconomic Tensions: Frank was a well-educated Jewish industrialist from the North in a Southern city still grappling with post-Civil War sentiments.
• Media Influence: Local newspapers fueled public outrage by portraying Frank as a depraved monster, intensifying the community's desire for retribution.

Carter Roy [07:24]: "Mary's body had been discovered... there was no real evidence linking Leo to the crime. But to the press and the police, that didn't really matter."

Defense Strategy

Leo Frank and his legal team, led by Luther Rosser and Reuben Arnold, aimed to present a fact-based defense:

• Challenging the Prosecution's Timeline: Demonstrating inconsistencies in the prosecution's sequence of events.
• Highlighting Mishandled Evidence: Pointing out critical evidence that was ignored or improperly handled by investigators.
• Undermining Key Witnesses: Attempting to discredit the prosecution's star witness, Jim Connolly.

Carter Roy [10:45]: "The defense's strategy was to state the truth without any bells or whistles and let the facts speak for themselves."

Prosecution Tactics

Hugh M. Dorsey, Atlanta's Solicitor General, spearheaded the prosecution with a relentless approach:

• Emotional Appeals: Leveraging public sentiment and media portrayal to sway the jury.
• Compelling Testimony: Utilizing Jim Connolly's testimony to paint Frank as the guilty party.

Carter Roy [12:30]: "Dorsey was ready to play dirty if it meant getting a conviction."

Key Testimonies and Challenges

Jim Connolly's Testimony: Connolly, the pencil factory's sweeper and handyman, provided the prosecution's linchpin:

• Alleged Confession: Claimed Frank confessed to murdering Mary after a struggle.
• Inconsistent Actions: Described activities that raised questions about his reliability.

Carter Roy [09:15]: "Under oath, Connolly testified that he... saw Leo holding a length of cord... and then Conley testified that Leo confessed to murdering Mary Fagan."

Defense's Cross-Examination Efforts: Frank's attorneys spent extensive hours attempting to dismantle Connolly's credibility but faced difficulties:

• Changing Stories: Connolly's inconsistent testimonies during the trial weakened the defense's position.

Carter Roy [13:50]: "Leo's attorneys spent 16 hours... trying to break down Conley's testimony through cross examination."

Verdict and Immediate Aftermath

Despite the defense's efforts, the jury reached a verdict swiftly:

• Guilty Verdict: Delivered after merely an hour and 45 minutes of deliberation.
• Public Reaction: The courtroom, once packed, emptied in anticipation, with fears of potential riots if the verdict was unfavorable.

Carter Roy [17:05]: "The jury only needed an hour and 45 minutes to reach a verdict. When they returned... it was nearly empty."

Frank awaited news in his prison cell, confident in his innocence, only to face a devastating guilty verdict that shattered his hopes.

Repercussions and Lynching

Governor Slaton's Clemency Decision

Post-trial, Leo Frank's legal team embarked on a relentless appeal process:

• Multiple Appeals Denied: Both state and federal courts rejected requests for a new trial.
• Clemency Petition: Governor John M. Slaton reviewed over 10,000 pages of documents, ultimately commuting Frank's sentence to life imprisonment rather than granting a full pardon.

Carter Roy [23:15]: "Governor Slaton... decided to put the National Guard on standby... to prevent further violence."

Public Outrage and Mob Justice

Governor Slaton's decision ignited widespread fury:

• Riots Ensued: An angry mob, emboldened by public sentiment, demanded retribution.
• National Guard Intervention: Ensured the safety of Governor Slaton and his family as they fled Georgia under armed protection.

The Lynching of Leo Frank

On August 17, 1915, a mob led by Newton Morris, a local judge, abducted Leo Frank from prison:

• Forced Confession: Mob members attempted to coerce Frank into admitting guilt, offering his life in exchange.
• Execution: Ignoring his pleas of innocence, the mob hanged Frank in Marietta, Georgia, at dawn.

Carter Roy [25:50]: "Leo was dead. A few hours later, Sheriff William Frey... called in to report the crime."

No perpetrators were ever brought to justice, and Frank's lynching underscored the deep-seated prejudices and systemic failures of the time.

Legacy and Reflection

Posthumous Exoneration

Seventy years after his murder, the state of Georgia officially pardoned Leo Frank, acknowledging the miscarriage of justice:

Carter Roy [26:45]: "In recognition of its failure to protect him... the state of Georgia posthumously pardoned Leo Frank for the murder of Mary Fagan."

Long-Term Impact

The ordeal of Mary Phagan and Leo Frank catalyzed significant societal changes:

• Labor Reforms: The 1938 Fair Labor Standards Act, which ended child labor in factories and mines, addressed some of the root causes that led Mary to work in dangerous conditions.
• Anti-Defamation League: Shocked by the lynching, the ADL was founded to combat antisemitism and protect civil rights, playing a pivotal role in future civil rights movements.

Carter Roy [27:00]: "In 1938, the Fair Labor Standards Act... led to the founding of the Anti Defamation League."

Closing Thoughts

Carter Roy reflects on the tragic narrative of Mary Phagan and Leo Frank, emphasizing that such injustices are products of their time but also highlighting the progress made since:

Carter Roy [27:10]: "If there are any positives we can take away from this case, it's that this probably never would have happened now."

Conclusion

The murder of Mary Phagan and the subsequent trial and lynching of Leo Frank remain poignant reminders of the dangers of prejudice, media influence, and systemic injustice. Through meticulous examination, "Murder: True Crime Stories" sheds light on these historical events, ensuring that the lessons learned resonate with future generations.

Credits:
Executive Producer: Max Cutler
Sound Design: Ron Shapiro
Written by: Greg Benson
Edited by: Alex Benedon
Fact-Checked by: Catherine Barner
Production Assistance: Kristen Acevedo and Sarah Carroll

Follow Crime House on Instagram: @crimehouse