Loading summary
Carter Roy
Foreign.
Narrator
This is Crime House. Everyone loves a conspiracy theory. The idea of powerful forces lurking in the shadows committing sinister crimes. You can't deny it's intriguing, but what off all those hypotheticals are nothing more than a story. After 43 year old Mary Pinchot Meyer was murdered in Washington D.C. in October 1964, a lot of people started telling stories. The suspect, his lawyer, the witnesses, the prosecution. They all had a different version of events. But none held a candle to another theory about who killed Mary. One that tied her murder to the US Government. With so many different perspectives and allegations, it becomes hard to separate fact from fiction. And there's a temptation to try to piece them all together. But maybe figuring out the truth isn't the hardest part. Maybe it's learning to live without it. People's lives are like a story. There's a beginning, a middle, and an end. But you don't always know which part you're on. Sometimes the final chapter arrives far too soon. And we don't always get to know the real ending. I'm Carter Roy and this is True Crime Stories, a Crime House original show powered by Pave Studios. Every Tuesday I'll explore the story of a notorious murder or murders. And for more true crime stories that all happened this week in history, check out Crime House the show. Each episode covers multiple cases unified by the same theme. So every week you get something a little different. At Crime House, we want to express our gratitude to you, our community, for making this possible. Please support us by rating, reviewing and following Murder True Crime Stories. Wherever you get your podcasts, your feedback truly matters. And for ad free and early access to murder true crime stories plus exciting bonus content, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. This is the second and final episode on the 1964 murder of 43 year old artist in Washington D.C. socialite Mary Pinchot Meyer. Last time I told you how Mary went from being the unhappy housewife of a CIA agent to a free spirited artist and how her life as a new woman was tragically cut short. Today I'll introduce you to the only suspect in Mary's murder investigation and walk you through his trial. Then I'll unravel the shocking allegations that emerged more than a decade after Mary's death. To this day, no one is sure if her murder was a random act of violence or a calculated cover up to protect the President. All that and more coming up. I've got some exciting news. Crime House Studios is launching a new original show called Killer Minds, hosted by licensed forensic psychologist Dr. Tristan Engels. And Crime House's Vanessa Richardson. Each episode features a deep dive into the psychology of a notorious murderer. From serial killers to cult leaders, deadly exes and spree killers, Killer Minds is a Crime House Studios original. New episodes drop every Monday and Thursday. Follow wherever you get your podcasts.
Advertiser
I've been working with a nurse dietitian for the last six months and it's been life changing. I've lost weight, healed my relationship with food, and have way more energy. Working with a dietitian online to create a personalized nutrition plan was so easy thanks to Nourish. The best part? I paid $0 out of pocket. Because Nourish accepts hundreds of insurance plans, 94% of patients pay $0 out of pocket. Find your dietitian@usenourish.com that's usenourish.com looking to improve your diet in the new year? Try seeing a personal dietitian with Nourish. Nourish has hundreds of dietitians who specialize in a variety of health concerns, including weight loss, gut health and more. Meet with your dietitian online and message them anytime through the Nourish app. Nourish accepts hundreds of insurance plans. 94% of patients pay $0 out of pocket. Find your personal dietitian@usenourish.com that's usenourish.com By.
Narrator
October 12, 1964, 43 year old Mary Pinchot Meyer had an established routine. Paint in the mornings, then go for a stroll in the afternoon, always alongside Georgetown's Chesapeake and Ohio Canal in Washington, D.C. where she lived. A few minutes past noon that day, Mary headed out to the canal. Locals called the walking trail alongside it the towpath. It was flanked by the canal on one side and dense greenery that led to the Potomac river on the other. Mary arrived there about 15 minutes later, and around 12:20pm she passed a jogger as she made her way to a secluded part of the towpath. A 30 foot hill and a stone wall obstructed Mary's view of the road above, but she would have been able to hear the rumble of cars in the distance. Five minutes later, at 12:25pm A mechanic named Henry Wiggins pulled his tow truck over on the side of that road to fix a car. He stepped out to look for the vehicle, but stopped in his tracks when he heard a piercing scream come from below. The distant sound of two gunshots followed. He raced to the stone wall and peered over. He was horrified to see a woman, later identified as Mary Pinchot Meyer lying dead in the middle of the towpath. Her assailant was standing over her. Wiggins noted the man was black and wore a tan jacket, dark hat and dark slacks. But before Wiggins could call out to him, the man tucked a dark object into his pocket and disappeared into the wooded overgrowth that led down to the Potomac. Wiggins ran to call the police and officers arrived at the scene just five minutes later. A dozen men searched the area while the remaining officers sealed off all five exits from the towpath. It only took them four minutes to do all that, which gave Mary's killer only two ways out. He could try to climb the stone wall and get to the road above the canal. But the road was crawling with police officers. He wouldn't get far before someone caught him. The killer's only other option was to make his way through the dense brush to the Potomac River. Then he'd have to swim across the frigid water and make a run for it on the other side. It didn't take long for the authorities to learn which route he seemingly took. Around 1:15pm about 40 minutes after police began their manhunt, Officer John Warner was making his way through the forest when he came upon a short, skinny black man. His white T shirt and dark torn pants were soaking wet and covered in brush. Officer Warner also noticed his hand was bleeding and he had a cut above his eye. His appearance was suspicious enough for Warner to ask for his ID. He learned the man was 25 year old Raymond Ray Crump Jr. Resident of Washington, D.C. according to Ray, he had been fishing when he fell asleep and tumbled into the river. He said the cuts on his hand and above his eye were from trying to climb out of the water. Ray even showed Warner the spot where he supposedly fell in. It was just 10ft away from where Mary's body was found. Given Ray's proximity to the crime scene, Warner wanted to question him further. He led Ray back to where the rest of the officers were gathered. Tow truck driver Henry Wiggins was in the middle of giving his statement to police. But as soon as he spotted Ray, he shouted, that's him. The officers on scene didn't waste any time. They took Ray into custody for the murder of Mary Pinchot Meyer. Later in the afternoon, police retrieved a tan jacket from the river, just like Henry Wiggins had described. There was no gun in the pocket, only a pack of Pall Mall cigarettes. Ray's wife was called into the station and identified the items as his. When police confronted Ray with the evidence, he said, it looks like you got a Stacked deck. Then he burst into tears. To the detectives interrogating Ray, this hardly seemed like the kind of reaction a cold blooded killer would have. And that wasn't the only thing that cast doubt on their theory that Ray had killed Mary. There wasn't any physical evidence. He didn't have any hair or blood on his clothing. And there wasn't any gunpowder on his fingers, which wouldn't have washed off in the river. At this point, police hadn't even found the murder weapon. Even so, Henry Wiggins eyewitness testimony was damning, and Ray's jacket seemed as good as any smoking gun. After that, the case against Ray moved at breakneck speed. On October 15, 1964, three days after Mary's death, the prosecutor took the case straight to a grand jury. They voted to indict Ray for first degree murder, which meant he was eligible for the death penalty. And it wouldn't be easy for him to fight it. Because Ray couldn't afford his own attorney, he'd been assigned a public defender. And while his lawyer was passionate and well meaning, he was inexperienced and didn't ask for more time to prepare a defense. And so the judge set the trial date for November 11, 1964, less than a month away. Ray was right. It looked like the prosecutor had a stacked deck. Despite the glaring holes in the case against Ray, it seemed like his fate was sealed. But there was one person who refused to give up on him. Ray's mom, Martha. When she learned her son's trial was just a few weeks off, she contacted one of DC's best defense attorneys, Dovey Johnson Roundtree. Besides being an attorney, Rountree was also an ordained preacher and civil rights activist. She spoke in the courtroom with the same burning urgency as she did at the pulpit on Sundays. Her abilities had served her well. 80% of her clients who were accused of murder had been acquitted. Martha begged Rountree for help. She admitted Ray had been in trouble before for petty things like theft and public urination. But on the whole, he was a good person. More than that, he wasn't capable of doing something like this. Not only was he too weak, but he was too slow witted. She explained that Ray had sustained at least two concussions in the past few years and struggled with excruciating headaches and blackouts. Sometimes he didn't seem all there. Rountree was moved by Martha's pleas, but she wanted to visit Ray in jail before agreeing to represent him. When she did, she found he was exactly as childlike as his mom described. Ray trembled when Roundtree spoke to him and couldn't fully comprehend the charges he was facing. To Rountree, he seemed like a man who could barely form a coherent sentence, let alone execute a woman in cold blood. Still, she knew Mary was a prominent member of the DC Community. When people like Mary were killed, juries didn't let their deaths go unpunished. But after seeing Ray in person, Rountree had no doubt he was innocent. And despite the uphill battle ahead of them, she was willing to give it a shot. She told Martha she'd do everything in her power to save Ray from death.
Advertiser
When you think about businesses that are selling through the roof, like Aloe Allbirds or Skims, they sure you think about a great product, a cool brand and brilliant marketing. But an often overlooked secret is actually the businesses behind the business making, selling and for shoppers, buying. Simple. For millions of businesses, that business is Shopify. Nobody does selling better than Shopify, home of the number one checkout on the planet and the not so secret secret with shop pay that boosts conversions up to 50%, meaning way less carts going abandoned and way more sales going. So if you're into growing your business, your commerce platform better be ready to sell whenever your customers are scrolling or strolling on the web, in your store, in their feed, and everywhere in between. Upgrade your business and get the same checkout experience as business powerhouses like Aloe Allbirds and Skims. Sign up for your $1 per month trial period@shopify.com Odysseypodcast all lowercase go to shopify.com Odyssey podcast to upgrade your selling today. Shopify.com Odyssey podcast Hey everyone, it's Carter.
Narrator
With an exciting update, Crime House Studios is launching a new original show called Killer Minds, hosted by licensed forensic psychologist Dr. Tristan Engels in Crime House's Vanessa Richardson. Each episode of Killer Minds features a deep dive into the psychology of a notorious murderer, from infamous serial killers to ruthless cult leaders, deadly exes and terrifying spree killers. Along with Vanessa's immersive storytelling full of high stakes twists and turns, Dr. Engels will be providing expert analysis of the people involved, not just how they killed, but why Killer Minds is a Crime House Studios original. New episodes drop every Monday and Thursday. Follow wherever you get your podcasts.
Advertiser
Hey, it's me, Paige desorbo, and I'm so excited to share my new shoe collection at dsw filled with my favorite styles and trends for spring. Because if you know me, you know I'm kind of obsessed with shoes. And by kind of obsessed, I mean head over heels. You're going to love these shoes. So snag super cute styles like cute flats, fun heels and cool sneakers from the Paige DeSorvo Collection right now at your DSW store or dsw.com.
Narrator
On a crisp October afternoon in 1964, 43 year old Mary Pinchot Meyer was murdered in cold blood. Two days after her death, on October 14, a memorial service was held on what would have been Mary's 44th birthday. Wealthy residents of Washington, D.C. s Georgetown area turned up in droves to mourn their friend and neighbor. But between all the tears, there were whispers about what had really happened to Mary. While most people agreed with the police's theory that Mary had been killed by Ray Crump, not everyone was so sure, especially Mary's friends from the art world who were struck by how many CIA officials were at the memorial. They wondered if it was because Mary's ex husband, Cord Meyer, was an important figure at the agency or if something more sinister was going on. As for Cord, he was a mess. Normally he was known to be aggressive and argumentative, but after Mary's death, that tough exterior shattered, at least for a moment. He sobbed for the duration of the funeral, then instructed his sons not to cry about their mom and sent them back to boarding school. Meanwhile, on the other side of the city, far from the prim and proper Georgetown elite, Dovey Johnson Roundtree was evaluating the case against her client, Ray. On October 28, 1964, two weeks after he was charged with Mary's murder, Rountree had officially agreed to be Ray's attorney, and she had her work cut out for her. Not only had the prosecution identified Ray as the only person near the crime scene, but they also had an eyewitness who identified him as the man standing over Mary's dead body. A Rountree was a skilled attorney. Her first move was to get the trial delayed by almost nine months, to July 20, 1965. Now that she had more time to prepare, Rountree combed through the thick case file police had assembled, including witness statements from Henry Wiggins and the jogger who passed by Mary that day, whose name was Lieutenant William Mitchell. But nothing, they said stood out to Rountree. So she pivoted to establishing an alibi for Ray. Initially, he'd said he was fishing in the river when he fell asleep and tumbled into the water. But police had found his fishing pole at his house. Clearly, Ray's story was fake. Still, he stuck by it when Rountree first interviewed him. But after some prodding from Rountree he finally came clean. He said the truth was he was cheating on his wife. That day, he and his girlfriend had gone down to the river to drink and fool around. Ray explained that when they were finished, he fell asleep at the water's edge. He was jolted awake when he rolled right over into the river. He said he climbed back onto shore to find his girlfriend was gone. He was looking for her when Officer Warner found him. Ray claimed he'd only lied to Warner because he didn't want his wife to learn about the affair. This was great news for Roundtree. If she could track Ray's girlfriend down, it might just crack the case wide open. But when Rountree finally got a hold of the woman, her hopes were dashed. Although Ray's girlfriend confirmed his story, she refused to testify. She was married, too. She didn't want her husband to find out she was cheating or become a target for the police. So without an alibi, Rountree was forced to look elsewhere. She decided to start with the scene of the crime itself. Roundtree and her colleagues headed down to the towpath. They reenacted the attack and ensuing foot search. She was looking for something, anything that could lead her to the true killer. They didn't find anything. But after visiting the crime scene, Rountree began receiving mysterious phone calls. The person on the other line never spoke, and they always called at midnight. During the calls, all Roundtree could hear was heavy breathing, followed by the click of them hanging up. The more Rountree visited the towpath, the more the more frequent these calls became. Whoever it was, they were sending a clear message. They were watching, and they wanted Roundtree to stop looking. But Roundtree wasn't the type to back down. As a black female attorney running a large law firm during the time of Jim Crow, she was used to people trying to intimidate her. She never investigated these calls, nor did she learn who was making them. Whoever was harassing her, they weren't going to stop Rountree from pursuing justice. Still, despite Roundtree's commitment to the case, it felt like her investigation had reached a dead end. After exhausting all of her options, she decided to review the police files for what felt like the thousandth time. This last resort turned out to be exactly what she needed. When Rountree first read the witness statements from Henry Wiggins and Lieutenant Mitchell, she'd only caught their descriptions of the killer's clothing. Light jacket, dark hat, dark slacks, which matched Ray's outfit that day. But now Rountree realized there was a glaring discrepancy. Both Wiggins and Mitchell said the man following Mary was at least 5 foot 8 and 185 pounds. Ray, on the other hand, was 5 foot 3 and 130 pounds. He was, as Roundtree put it, as slender as a woman. Rountree was stunned. She believed the police were right. Wiggins and Mitchell had seen the same man. But that man couldn't have been Ray. More than that, Wiggins was 120ft away from the assailant when he saw him standing over Mary. It would be difficult to identify someone from that far away with any degree of certainty. Rountree finally knew how she'd throw doubt on the prosecution's case. The only question was, would it convince a jury? With Ray's court date quickly approaching, Rountree didn't have much time to agonize over that question. On July 20, 1965, the court convened for the trial of Raymond Crump Jr. In the murder of Mary Pinchot Meyer. The courtroom was packed. On one side were Martha's black friends from church. On the other were D.C. s white elite. The optics were clear and the building hummed with tension. But the prosecutor, Alfred Hantman, resented the assumption that Ray's arrest was the product of racism. Hantman insisted his case was based on the evidence against Ray and nothing more. With a 25 year career under his belt, Hantman had no doubt Ray would be proven guilty. Hantman was so confident when he stood for his opening statement, he told the jury exactly what they wouldn't hear from him. Hantman acknowledged there wasn't any blood linking Ray to Mary. He also admitted authorities had never found the murder weapon, despite an extensive search. But Hantman reassured the jury that those didn't matter. He had 50 pieces of circumstantial evidence to back him up, and they painted a gruesome picture. According to Hantman, the day Mary was murdered, she had no idea she was being stalked by Ray. She only realized someone was following her when they put a pistol to her head and pulled the trigger. Hantman insisted that after Ray killed Mary, he threw his cap and jacket into the river. When Ray saw the police searching the area, he jumped into the water and hid until he thought the coast was clear. Then Ray climbed back onto shore and ran straight into law enforcement. Hampan's theory hinged on two main arguments. The first was that police had sealed off all five exits to the towpath in just four minutes, which just wasn't enough time for anyone to escape. And since Ray was the only person they found on the towpath, he was the only One who could have possibly killed Mary. To demonstrate this, Hantman showed the jury a 55 foot wide map of the towpath drawn by a park ranger. The ranger explained the painstaking lengths he'd gone to to faithfully recreate the scene to scale. But when Dovey Rountree Cross examined the ranger, he admitted he'd never actually been there. He'd recreated the map based on government records. Rountree had been to the towpath, though she explained to the jury that it was like a jungle. How could the ranger be certain there was no unofficial exits to the towpath? The ranger admitted he couldn't. And just like that, Rountree destroyed one of Hantman's first arguments. If the police had missed an exit, it was possible another suspect really had eluded them after all. With the exit theory up in flames, Rountree continued to tear Hampan to shreds. Next up on the chopping block was his star witness, the tow truck driver, Henry Wiggins. Rowntree grilled Wiggins on what he saw that day, from the assailant's clothing to his movements. But most importantly, she questioned the discrepancy in size between the 5 foot 8 killer Wiggins saw and the 5 foot 3 defendant sitting in the courtroom. Finally, Wiggins snapped. He told Rountree, I didn't look at him that hard. It was a devastating blow to Hantman. Wiggins wasn't sure Ray was the man he'd seen. And the prosecution couldn't prove Ray was the only person on the towpath. So who was to say he was Mary's murderer? By the last day of the trial, Rountree had managed to poke holes in every one of the prosecution's arguments. And her efforts paid off. After only 11 hours of deliberation, the jury came back with a verdict. Not guilty. Ray was a free man. It was an enormous relief for him and his family. After a year behind bars, he was finally going home. But there was one question hanging over the courtroom that day. If Ray Crump didn't kill Mary Pinchot Meyer, then who did?
Advertiser
This episode is brought to you by Pluto tv. Are you looking for your next case? Pluto TV has all your favorite crime dramas streaming for free. Which means suspicion is free. With countless cases to crack, Watch csi, Criminal Minds, ncis, Blue Bloods, Tracker, FBI and swat. All for free from all your favorite devices. Feel the free Pluto tv. Stream now. Pay never.
Carter Roy
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile with a message for everyone. Paying Big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying. No judgments. But that's weird. Okay, one judgment anyway. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment.
Advertiser
Of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra.
Carter Roy
See full terms@mintmobile.com do you love hair raising Allegedly true stories about the paranormal? Then I have a podcast recommendation for you. I'm Dan Cummins, comedian and co host of the not so funny but very scary podcast Scared to Death. And I'm Lindsay, co host and also Dan's wife. Each week on Scared to Death, we share bone chilling tales from old books, creepy corners of the web, and even stories submitted by our listeners. All designed to make you want to sleep with the lights on. On Scared to Death, you'll hear stories about possession, poltergeist, and all kinds of other frightening phenomena. From the haunted castles of Ireland to the cryptids roaming the United States, no corner of the globe is safe from terrifying lore. And if you're still not sold, I should mention that the show has amassed nearly 60 million downloads. There's just something about a ghost story that everybody loves. Think you can handle the horror? Tune in to Scared to Death every Tuesday at the stroke of midnight to find out. And if you're still not scared enough, join us twice a month on Fridays for Nightmare Fuel, where I share original fictional horror tales. See you there.
Narrator
On July 30, 1965, 26 year old Raymond Crump Jr. Was acquitted in the murder of 43 year old Mary Pinchot Meyer. Since he'd been facing the death penalty, it was a huge relief for his family and a big win for his lawyer, Dovey Johnson Roundtree. If Mary's family and friends felt like there'd been a miscarriage of justice, they didn't show it. Although she'd been beloved by many in the D.C. community, the reaction to Ray's acquittal was silence. The spies, journalists and politicians she socialized with quickly turned their attention to the communist threats abroad, and the news cycle focused on other events. But while it seemed like Mary's loved ones had moved on from her death, some were biding their time until the moment was right. In 1976, 12 years after Mary's murder, one of her old friends, James Truitt, a former reporter for Newsweek, was interviewed by the National Enquirer. While Mary's obituary had described her as a friend of The Kennedy family. The article claimed she was much more than that. In his interview, Truett confirmed Mary's affair with John F. Kennedy. Not only that, but Truett said Mary and Kennedy had smoked marijuana together in the White House. Truett revealed that Mary had kept a diary with a deep details of her relationship with the President. Shortly after her death, Mary's close friends had rifled through her house looking for it. When Mary's sister found the diary, she handed it over to James Angleton, the Chief of counterintelligence at the CIA. He destroyed it. Truett didn't say why Mary's friends had gone on a frenzied hunt for the diary, but the implications were clear. The details inside were so scandalous, dangerous even they could never see the light of day. Truett's allegations single handedly catapulted Mary's story from a local affair to the national spotlight. Because when it came to her murder, there were more mysteries than the identity of her killer. And someone out there was determined to bring those secrets to the surface. Back in the early 60s, Mary had befriended Timothy Leary, known as the father of the psychedelic movement. According to Leary, he and Mary had gone on several acid trips together and spoke at length about peace, love and the unrealized potential of psychedelics. When Leary read the National Enquirer article about Mary, he wasn't surprised to hear she and Kennedy had smoked marijuana together. He claimed that Mary had once told him she wanted to learn how to administer LSD to a friend who was a very powerful man. After reading the article, Leary wondered if Kennedy was the powerful friend Mary had been alluding to. To Leary, the possibility was thrilling. But it also raised some horrifying questions. In his memoir, Leary writes that Mary called him the day after Kennedy's assassination. Apparently she thought the CIA believed the President was changing too fast and were worried they couldn't control him, which made Leary fear the worst. Was it possible the CIA had been responsible for Kennedy's assassination and Mary's murder? Now, Leary has never directly accused the CIA of either of these attacks. He's also never stated that Mary and Kennedy did in fact take LSD together. However, after Ray was acquitted, Leary did hire a private investigator to look into this theory. Although the investigation didn't yield any answers. Leary's not the only one who believes there's more to Mary's death than meets the eye. In 2012, Peter Janney, who was childhood friends with Mary's sons, published a book that took Leary's allegations to the next level. Now Peter's Theory is a bit out there, so take it with a grain of salt. But here's what he alleges. According to Peter, Mary and Kennedy didn't just have an affair. They were madly in love. And after they took LSD together, Kennedy was inspired to change course on the Cold War. After what felt like war mongering madness, Kennedy wanted to improve relations with the Soviet Union, but the CIA was staunchly opposed to any peacemaking efforts with the Soviets. So when they realized they couldn't control Kennedy, they had him killed. When they pinned the assassination on Lee Harvey Oswald, Mary saw through the lies and launched her own investigation into Kennedy's death. She confronted her ex husband Cord with her findings and he informed James Engleton, the chief of counterintelligence at the CIA. At some point after that, CIA officials decided to terminate Mary to prevent her from revealing the truth. They chose the towpath she walked every day to carry out the attack and pin the murder on Ray Crump. Peter's theory is certainly compelling, but but most mainstream journalists are understandably critical of it. They describe his book as a leap of faith and point out the many holes in his story. For example, there's no evidence that Kennedy ever did LSD or wanted to scale back the Cold War. In the end, it seems like Peter's story, like so many others, only raised more questions about what happened to Mary. But while we may never know the truth about Mary's death, we do know the truth about her life. As an adult, Mary was forced to put aside her desires and take on the role of a dutiful housewife. And yet, even after her marriage fell apart and she lost her middle child, Mary managed to break down those barriers and reclaim her life. But if there's one way to remember Mary best, it's probably through her art. Mary's final painting, titled Half Light, hangs in the third floor of the Smithsonian American Art Museum. It's a circle divided into four colorful quadrants. One is olive green, one pastel blue, and the other two, auburn and lavender. While the piece is balanced, it gives the sense that there's much more going on under the surface, just like the artist who created it. Thanks so much for listening. I'm Carter Roy, and this is Murder True Crime Stories. Come back next week for the story of another murder and all the people it affected. True Crime Stories is a Crime House original. Powered by Pave Studios. Here at Crime House, we want to thank each and every one of you for your support. If you like what you heard today, reach out on social media. Crime House on Instagram. Don't forget to rate, review and follow Murder True Crime Stories wherever you get your podcasts. Your feedback truly makes a difference and to enhance your Murder True Crime Stories listening experience, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. You'll get every episode ad free and instead of having to wait for each episode of a two part series, you'll get access to both at once plus exciting bonus content. We'll be back next Tuesday. True Crime Stories is hosted by me, Carter Roy and is a Crime House original. Powered by Pave Studios, this episode was brought to life by the Murder True Crime Stories team. Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benedon, Nick Natalie Pertzofsky, Lori Marinelli, Sarah Carroll, Nick Gagger, Sheila Patterson and Russell Nash. Thank you for listening. What drives a person to murder? Find out from a licensed forensic psychologist on Killer Minds, a Crime House original podcast. New episodes drop every Monday and Thursday. Follow wherever you get your podcasts.
Murder: True Crime Stories - Episode: UNSOLVED: The Murder of JFK's Lover 2
Release Date: April 1, 2025
In this gripping second installment of the two-part series on the 1964 murder of Mary Pinchot Meyer, host Carter Roy delves deeper into the enigmatic case that has perplexed investigators and enthusiasts for decades. Mary Pinchot Meyer, a 43-year-old artist and Washington D.C. socialite, was found dead on October 12, 1964, under mysterious circumstances that have fueled numerous theories, including potential connections to high-level government conspiracies.
On a crisp October afternoon in 1964, Mary Pinchot Meyer adhered to her usual routine of painting in the mornings followed by afternoon strolls along Georgetown's Chesapeake and Ohio Canal towpath. At approximately 12:20 PM, Mary ventured to a secluded section of the towpath, flanked by dense greenery leading to the Potomac River. Five minutes later, tow truck driver Henry Wiggins witnessed a suspicious man standing over Mary's lifeless body. This assailant, described as a black male wearing a tan jacket, dark hat, and dark slacks, swiftly fled the scene by concealing a dark object in his pocket before disappearing into the surrounding foliage ([05:20] Narrator).
The police quickly confined the escape routes, leaving the perpetrator with only two options: scaling the stone wall to the road above or navigating through the dense brush to the river. Approximately 40 minutes after the initial investigation began, Officer John Warner encountered Raymond Ray Crump Jr., a 25-year-old local, struggling through the brush with visible injuries and soaked clothing. Crump claimed to have fallen asleep while fishing nearby and inadvertently rolled into the river, sustaining cuts while trying to escape the water. However, his proximity to the crime scene and suspicious attire led Wiggins to identify him as the murderer, resulting in Crump's swift arrest ([05:20] Narrator).
Key Quote:
Officer Wiggins (12:25 PM): "That's him."
Despite the damning eyewitness testimony and the discovery of a tan jacket matching the description, physical evidence linking Crump to the murder was conspicuously absent. No gun was found in his pocket; instead, a pack of cigarettes was present, later identified as Ray's property. Additionally, there were no signs of gunpowder on his fingers, raising serious doubts about his involvement ([05:20] Narrator).
With mounting evidence seemingly against him, Raymond Crump Jr. was indicted for first-degree murder just three days after Mary's death. Lacking the financial means for private legal representation, Crump was assigned a public defender who, despite his earnest efforts, was inexperienced and failed to secure a postponement for a more thorough defense. The trial was swiftly scheduled for November 11, 1964, leaving Crump with minimal time to prepare his case ([05:20] Narrator).
Ray's mother, Martha Crump, refused to accept her son's culpability. Desperate for competent representation, she enlisted the services of Dovey Johnson Roundtree, a renowned defense attorney, ordained preacher, and civil rights activist. Roundtree, impressed by Ray's demeanor and recognizing inconsistencies in the prosecution's case, took on the challenge of defending him. Despite limited time, Roundtree sought to dismantle the prosecution's narrative by highlighting discrepancies in eyewitness accounts and the lack of concrete evidence tying Ray to the crime ([05:20] Narrator).
Roundtree's Strategy:
Challenging Eyewitness Testimony: She scrutinized the descriptions provided by Wiggins and Lieutenant William Mitchell, noting significant discrepancies between Ray's physical stature and the perpetrator they had described.
Establishing an Alibi: Initially dismissed by police, Roundtree worked to confirm Ray's alibi, only to find it unreliable due to his admitted infidelity and fabricated story about falling asleep while fishing.
During the trial, Roundtree adeptly exposed the prosecution's weak points. She questioned the credibility of the tow truck driver's identification, revealing that Wiggins had only seen the assailant from a distance of 120 feet—a factor that made accurate identification unlikely. Moreover, Roundtree challenged the prosecution's theory that the police had insufficient time to secure the area, suggesting the possibility of alternative escape routes that were not adequately investigated.
Key Quote:
Henry Wiggins (Trial): "I didn't look at him that hard."
These revelations sowed reasonable doubt among the jury members. Despite the prosecution's assertion of having 50 pieces of circumstantial evidence, the lack of physical proof and the compromised eyewitness testimony undermined their case. After deliberating for just 11 hours, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty, freeing Raymond Crump Jr. after a year of incarceration ([31:34] Narrator).
Ray's acquittal did little to quell the surrounding mysteries of Mary's murder. Over a decade later, various theories emerged, some suggesting that Mary's assassination was linked to her intimate relationship with President John F. Kennedy and potential CIA involvement.
James Truitt's Allegations (1976):
Timothy Leary's Insights:
Peter Janney's Theory (2012):
Despite these theories, concrete evidence linking Mary's murder to any government conspiracy remains elusive, leaving the case officially unsolved.
Beyond the tragedy of her untimely death, Mary Pinchot Meyer is remembered for her resilience and artistic contributions. Her final painting, "Half Light," resides in the Smithsonian American Art Museum, symbolizing the complex and hidden layers of her life—balances of color that reflect the unanswered questions surrounding her demise.
The unresolved case of Mary Pinchot Meyer continues to intrigue and mystify true crime aficionados. Whether viewed through the lens of personal tragedy or potential political conspiracy, Mary's story underscores the often murky intersection of personal lives and national secrets. As Carter Roy aptly concludes, while the truth about her murder remains shrouded in mystery, Mary's vibrant life and artistic legacy offer a poignant reminder of the woman behind the headlines.
Notable Quotes:
These quotes highlight key moments where eyewitness testimony was challenged, significantly influencing the trial's outcome.
Final Thoughts:
The Murder: True Crime Stories podcast masterfully navigates the complex narrative of Mary Pinchot Meyer's murder, blending meticulous research with engaging storytelling. This episode not only recounts the events leading to the trial and subsequent acquittal of Raymond Crump Jr. but also explores the lingering questions and alternative theories that continue to fuel fascination with this enduring mystery.
For more true crime narratives that delve into the darkest corners of history, subscribe to "Murder: True Crime Stories" wherever you get your podcasts.