Podcast Summary: Murder With My Husband – Episode 240: The OnlyFans Killer

Introduction In Episode 240 of "Murder With My Husband" by OH NO MEDIA, hosts Peyton and Garrett Moreland delve into a chilling true crime story that uncovers the dark side of social media fame and domestic abuse. Titled "The OnlyFans Killer," this episode explores the tragic demise of Christian "Toby" Obumseli at the hands of his girlfriend, Courtney Clenney, an influential OnlyFans model.

Background of the Case

Christian "Toby" Obumseli was born on April 12, 1994, in Dallas, Texas. A charismatic individual with a winning smile, Toby was a star linebacker at Plano East Senior High School, earning a scholarship to Abilene Christian University. His athletic prowess and infectious positivity made him beloved among peers.

In Spring 2020, Toby met Courtney Clenney, a 24-year-old aspiring influencer and OnlyFans model. Courtney, born in 1996 to affluent parents in Texas, had built a substantial online presence by 2015, boasting over 1 million Instagram followers. Her venture into OnlyFans in 2016 further amplified her income, allowing her to live a lavish lifestyle crowned by brand deals and social media collaborations.

The Relationship Dynamics

By January 2022, Toby and Courtney moved from Texas to Miami, Florida, renting a luxurious $10,000/month condo on the 22nd floor. Their ostentatious lifestyle was a facade of the perfect influencer couple—frequenting expensive restaurants, renting Lamborghinis, and attending high-profile social events.

However, beneath the glittering exterior lay a tumultuous relationship marred by frequent arguments and instances of domestic abuse. Text messages uncovered during the investigation revealed a pattern of Courtney's aggressive behavior towards Toby:

• October 2021: Toby texts, "I still gave you a good day, even though my leg was hurting because my girlfriend stabbed me..." indicating previous violent altercations.

• February 2022: Security footage captured Courtney verbally and physically assaulting Toby in an elevator, where she uttered, "I'm going to effing kill you."

Despite these red flags, Toby remained in the relationship, possibly due to financial dependency and the complexities of domestic abuse dynamics.

The Fateful Day: April 3, 2022

On the afternoon of April 3, 2022, tensions reached a breaking point. A 911 call was made from Courtney's condo address, alerting authorities to a violent situation. Police arrived to find Courtney drenched in blood and Toby with a single stab wound to his chest.

Courtney claimed self-defense, alleging that Toby had attempted to strangle her during a heated argument. She stated:

"I had no intention of actually using the weapon, but when Toby threatened me further, I hurled the knife across the room and impaled him in the chest."
(Transcript Timestamp: 24:59)

However, skepticism arose regarding the plausibility of her account. Garrett questioned:

"There is no way she threw the blade of the knife into someone fatally from 10 feet away."
(Transcript Timestamp: 25:04)

Investigation and Evidence

The investigation unveiled numerous inconsistencies and patterns of abuse:

1. History of Violence: Multiple police reports highlighted Courtney's aggressive behavior, including incidents where she had assaulted Toby, resulting in medical attention for him.

2. Digital Evidence: Text messages and video footage contradicted Courtney's claims of self-defense. Toby's texts, such as "Is our love going to kill me?" signaled his fear and the severity of their relationship.

3. Security Footage: Videos captured Courtney's violent outbursts and Toby's subdued responses, further discrediting her narrative.

4. Attempted Cover-Up: Courtney's parents were implicated for attempting to hack Toby's iCloud account to erase incriminating text messages. Although charges against them were later dropped, this act underscored the extent of their involvement in trying to protect Courtney.

Notably, the medical examiner revealed that the stab wound was consistent with a close-proximity attack, contradicting Courtney's claim of a long-distance throw.

Legal Proceedings and Aftermath

By August 9, 2022, with substantial circumstantial evidence and a history of documented abuse, Courtney was arrested and charged with second-degree murder. Her parents faced charges for their attempted tampering with evidence, though these were eventually dismissed.

Courtney remains incarcerated, awaiting trial, while Toby's family grapples with the loss and the revelations about the true nature of Courtney's behavior. The case has sparked discussions about the hidden realities behind social media facades and the challenges faced by male victims of domestic abuse.

Insights and Conclusions

This episode underscores the critical issue of domestic violence, highlighting that victims can be men facing abuse, often stigmatized or overlooked. The narrative serves as a poignant reminder that:

• Social Media Facades: Online personas can mask severe personal struggles and abusive relationships.

• Recognition and Support: It's essential to recognize the signs of domestic abuse, regardless of gender, and provide adequate support to all victims.

• Legal and Social Challenges: The complexities of financial dependency and societal perceptions can trap individuals in harmful relationships, making it imperative to foster environments where victims feel empowered to seek help.

In closing, Peyton emphasizes:

"You never really know what someone is going through behind closed doors. And a man can be just as much as a victim as a woman can in these circumstances."
(Transcript Timestamp: 37:18)

The episode advocates for greater awareness and support systems for all victims of domestic violence, urging listeners to reach out to resources like the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 800-799-7233 or visit hotline.org.

Notable Quotes

• Courtney Clenney:

  • "I had no intention of actually using the weapon, but when Toby threatened me further, I hurled the knife across the room."
    (24:59)

• Garrett Moreland:

  • "There is no way she threw the blade of the knife into someone fatally from 10 feet away."
    (25:04)

• Toby Obumseli:

  • "Is our love going to kill me?"
    (37:18)

• Peyton Moreland:

  • "Social media does not always paint the full picture. And more importantly, you never really know what someone is going through behind closed doors."
    (37:18)

Conclusion

"The OnlyFans Killer" serves as a compelling exploration of the intersection between online fame and real-life turmoil. Through meticulous investigation and storytelling, Peyton and Garrett Moreland shed light on the often-unseen struggles within relationships overshadowed by social media glamour. This episode not only narrates a tragic event but also calls for increased empathy and action towards all victims of domestic abuse.