Murder With My Husband
Episode 293: The Vampire Murders
Date: November 3, 2025
Hosts: Peyton Moreland & Garrett Moreland
Episode Overview
This episode dives into the chilling true crime case known as "The Vampire Murders," which took place in Florida and Kentucky in 1996. Peyton guides listeners through the murder of Ruth Queen and Rick Wendorf by a group of teenagers who believed themselves to be part of a vampire cult, led by 16-year-old Rod Ferrell. The discussion explores the allure of fantasy as escape, the psychology of teenage cult mentality, and the devastating consequences when reality and fantasy blur—with witty commentary and thought-provoking questions from Garrett.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
Escaping Into Fantasy: Setting the Scene
- Peyton opens with reflections on why people, especially teens, are drawn to magic, fantasy, and alternative realities—tying it to Halloween and subcultures like LARPing and the occult.
- Quote: "For some, the fantasy world is a place that they choose to live in every single day. And when the lines between fantasy and reality start to blur, it can have dangerous repercussions." (06:04)
- Garrett connects this allure to Renaissance fairs, video games, and the human need for occasional escapism.
The Wendorf/Queen Family: Two Very Different Daughters
- Background: Ruth and Rick (Eustis, FL) raised two daughters—Jennifer (popular, studious) and Heather (introverted, artistic, increasingly fascinated by the occult).
- Tensions in the family grow as both daughters begin to act out in their own distinct ways:
- Jennifer gets involved with an older boyfriend, skips classes, and starts lying to her parents.
- Heather displays increasingly dark and troubling behavior: dead flowers, inverted crosses, dark artwork, and disturbing actions (e.g., a Barbie doll on a noose; rumors of self-harm).
- Quote: "She was starting to attract the attention of other teachers and students and not in a good way." (11:17)
The Crime: Double Murder & Disappearance
- On November 25, 1996, Jennifer returns home past curfew to a gruesome discovery: both her parents, Rick and Ruth, have been murdered; Heather, her 15-year-old sister, is missing.
- Peyton narrates: "She sees the blood has actually come from her mother Ruth, lying face up on the kitchen floor... her dad has also been stabbed to death on the couch." (13:14)
- Details from the scene:
- Rick had 22 wounds (likely attacked while sleeping); Ruth had 23 wounds, with clear signs of defensive injuries.
- A letter ‘V’ burned into Rick’s chest.
- A note from Heather indicating she planned to run away.
- Jennifer quickly points suspicion toward Heather’s friend—a boy named Rod Ferrell.
Introducing Rod Ferrell: The Self-Proclaimed Vampire
- Rod’s troubled upbringing in Murray, Kentucky: a single mother, Sondra (herself interested in the occult), exposure to alternative beliefs and little parental restriction.
- Moves to Eustis, FL; stands out as a trench-coat-wearing teen obsessed with "Vampire: The Masquerade."
- Formation of deep friendships with Heather and another girl, Janine—immersing themselves in fantasy and occult rituals.
- Quote: "Rod began telling Heather things, like, genuinely tells Heather, his teenage friend, that he is immortal and he's being serious, Dead serious." (24:43)
- Claims being "the devil’s child" and a 500-year-old vampire named Visago.
The Vampire Cult: Recruitment & Rituals
- After moving back to Kentucky, Rod leverages his newfound confidence and fantasy persona to form a "vampire family" or coven. He brings in:
- Howard Scott Anderson (16), Charity Keesee (Rod’s new girlfriend), Dana Cooper (19), and others—even his own mother.
- Real vampiric rituals take place—blood-drinking, initiations, late-night cemetery gatherings.
- The cult’s social dynamics:
- Many recruits came from dysfunctional homes, were vulnerable, and found belonging in this alternative reality.
Escalation & The Murders (November 1996)
- Heather tells Rod (over the phone) that her father is abusing her—a claim not substantiated by police or evidence.
- Rod seizes on this as justification to "rescue" her.
- The group—Rod, Scott, Charity, Dana—travels to Florida to pick up Heather, allegedly intending to steal her family's car and escape to New Orleans.
- The plan turns violent:
- Rod, with Scott in tow, enters the Wendorf home.
- Rod beats Rick and Ruth to death with a crowbar, burns the ‘V’ into Rick’s chest, and steals valuables.
- Peyton’s vivid summary: "He walks over, lifts up the crowbar, and just starts swinging at sleeping Rick, beating him to death on the couch." (44:12)
- The group flees with Heather, driving toward New Orleans.
Investigation, Capture, and Confessions
- Jennifer calls 911, correctly implicating her sister’s friend group.
- Police use vehicle and credit card traces to track the group.
- Charity calls her grandmother for money—from a phone booth in Baton Rouge—leading police to arrest the entire group within 3 days.
Legal Aftermath: Trials, Sentences, and Controversy
- Rod confesses, embracing his vampire persona; pleads guilty to all charges.
- Sentenced to death at age 17—youngest on Florida’s death row (later commuted to life without parole after the Supreme Court’s ban on juvenile executions).
- Scott Anderson: life in prison, later reduced to 40 years, despite evidence suggesting he did not participate in the murders directly—sparking debate between Peyton and Garrett.
- Garrett: "I don't know if I agree with that…everyone admitted he didn't touch anything. He was just like, oh, shoot, I'm going along with everything now." (59:10)
- Charity Keesee and Dana Cooper: convicted of third-degree murder and other charges; sentenced to 10.5 and 17.5 years respectively.
- Heather Wendorf: never prosecuted. Argued to be a victim herself, she was sent for psychiatric evaluation, then to a foster family and later to art school.
- Peyton: "She never even faced charges for her parents' death." (56:00)
- Families are left fractured; Jennifer is barred from contact with Heather.
Reflections on Psychology, Manipulation & Justice
- Discussion on cult/teen psychology, group mentality, and the moral ambiguity of sentencing teenagers involved in cult-related crimes.
- The hosts wrestle with appropriate accountability, the lasting effects of manipulation, and society’s evolving legal and psychological understanding.
- Peyton: "Every decision made in this case was wrong..." (58:39)
- Conversation closes with the lesson: when fantasy is mistaken for reality, the consequences can be fatal.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- Peyton (06:04): "For some, the fantasy world is a place that they choose to live in every single day. And when the lines between fantasy and reality start to blur, it can have dangerous repercussions."
- Garrett (14:05): "I am not gonna say much, but I think my first instinct is Heather might be involved. That's all I'm gonna say for now."
- Peyton (25:00): "He was, quote, the devil’s child walking with earthly feet."
- Garrett (53:14): "Justice, like, he killed... it's insane."
- Peyton (58:39): "Every decision made in this case was wrong. Every single decision."
- Garrett (59:29): "I'm usually not in agreeance with this stuff. I'm usually in agreeance with long sentencings and the death penalty, but this one I'm not. I don't agree with it."
Important Segment Timestamps
- Family background & daughters’ divergence: 08:47–12:03
- Discovery of the crime scene: 12:30–14:05
- Rod Ferrell’s upbringing & fantasy persona: 18:45–25:00
- Formation of vampire cult & rituals: 28:51–34:45
- Murders and immediate aftermath: 43:16–47:09
- Investigation, capture, and confessions: 47:23–50:40
- Trial outcomes, sentences, and legal debate: 52:24–56:03
- Hosts’ debate: culpability and sentencing: 57:21–60:25
Tone & Style
Peyton is captivating and detail-oriented in narrative, while Garrett provides candid, sometimes skeptical, commentary, often interjecting with questions or gut reactions that echo potential listener responses. The interplay is light, humorous in places, but always respectful of the gravity of the case.
Closing Thoughts
The episode unpacks the tragedy and horror that occurs when vulnerable youth are drawn into an all-consuming fantasy—fuelled by loneliness, a need to belong, and a charismatic manipulator. The discussion highlights the complexities of legal responsibility in cult crimes and the ongoing challenge of discerning intent, manipulation, and culpability among teenagers. As Peyton puts it, "when we believe something long and hard enough, the lines between reality and fantasy really do blur. And it's in that gray area that possibly the most dangerous decisions are made." (56:48)
(Summary skips sponsorships and non-content sections as requested.)