Loading summary
A
Ever look at your farm's website homepage and think, what am I even supposed to put here? Your website is the source of truth for your brand and if your homepage is unclear, people leave. So today I'm sharing a simple framework for what to include on your farm's website homepage so that it's clear and helps turn visitors into customers. Lets get started. Hey there, this is Corinna Bench and.
B
Welcome to the My Digital Farmer Podcast. In today's market, it's not enough to.
A
Just grow your product, you've got to know how to sell it too. Welcome to the My Digital Farmer Podcast where we reveal online marketing strategies and tips to help farmers like you get.
B
Better and more confident at marketing, learn.
A
How to find more customers, increase your.
B
Sales, and build a strong brand for your farm.
A
Let's start the show. Well, welcome to episode 349 of the My Digital Farmer Podcast. I'm your host, Corinna Bench, one of the farmers at Shared Legacy Farms out in Elmore, Ohio. I'm also the founder of mydigitalfarmer.com, which is all about trying to help other farmers like you get more confident in your marketing and sales strategy so that you can grow a profitable business. How's everyone doing today? Welcome back to the podcast. A big shout out to all of my digital farmers. If you're new to the show, I'm glad you're here today. I hope you become a super fan too. Make sure you subscribe to the podcast so that you get notified every Wednesday when a new one drops. Go check out my first 10 episodes, especially if you don't know a whole lot about marketing yet because they were designed to be an on ramp into the marketing lingo. You can start there, learn kind of the basics and the ropes, and then jump around throughout the archives of the podcast as suits your fancy. Another great way to learn the ropes of marketing is to get onto my free email list. MyDigitalFarmer.com subscribe is where you do that. When you do, I'm going to send you a email maybe every four or five days for a few months that walks you through the jungle of marketing. I'm going to show you the most important things you need to know. First, I'm going to share some resources that you should be aware of. I give you some free trainings. There's really good stuff in there, so check it out. Subscribe for free@mydigitalfarmer.com subscribe Today's podcast is sponsored by my friends at Localline A new year is the perfect time to streamline your sales and grow more profitably. So if you run a CSA or you sell wholesale or manage both, localline helps you stream streamline your sales and scale with confidence. In 2025, farms and food hubs that used Localline grew their sales by 33%, building on the 23% growth they saw the year before. Average order values increased by 31%. I know mine did. And total order count grew by 9%. Look real results across operations of all size sizes. Localline brings everything together in one platform. They have CSA management, wholesale ordering, automated inventory, barcode scanning, a box builder and POS so that you spend less time managing admin and more time growing your business. And switching couldn't be easier. There are no setup fees, my friends, no sales commissions, and their onboarding team will migrate your storefront for free to taking the workload off your plate. And that usually only takes a few days. As a podcast listener, you'll also get one premium feature for free for a full year when you use the code MDF2026 at checkout. So go to mydigitalfarmer.com localline and then enter that code MDF2026 Start 2026 organized, efficient and ready to grow with Local Line and now back to the show. The off season is usually the time of year when I take some intentional time to look at my website again and tweak it and update it and ask myself, is this still what I want it to say? Are there pictures that are crazy outdated? Do I like this tagline anymore? Are we still selling that product? Are we missing a product here altogether? And so I'm in that mode right now because this is February and so I decided that it would be time for me to talk to you guys about your websites because I think this is a good time of year for you to do a little bit of a website audit as well. And I want this podcast episode to be a helpful resource for you. In case no one's ever said this to you. Your website is the source of truth for your farm brand. Or at least it should be. All the important information should be listed there, should be able to be found by your customers when they get into research mode and they want to go check you out and decide if they want to start working with you. It's where people go when they want to learn more, when they want to double check that you're legit, they want to go and decide if you are for them. If you have Similar values. If your product is the ideal product for solving their problem, and if your home page is confusing or it's missing information and people have to think too hard, they'll leave. And if they leave, well, there's no conversion that time. And you have to work hard to get them to come back and take a look at you again. Whenever I do a presentation about websites, I always talk about this story where my boys, when they were younger, wanted to wear comfy pants everywhere. Actually, they still want to wear comfy pants everywhere. And they're like 15 and 18. Drives me crazy. I was that mom when they were really, really young. I just let them be comfortable and I wouldn't make them wear jeans even when we would go to church. I was just like, no, I just want them to be comfy and be able to play and not worry about feeling stuffy in their clothes. That was a mistake, okay? I'm telling you right now. But as a result, my boys just lived in comfy pants. They loved comfy pants. They always wanted to wear comfy pants everywhere. And I'm like, I love you, but sometimes you need to wear real pants. Like when we go to church or when we're going to our grandma and grandpa's birthday party. Like, let's just, I don't know, ratchet it up a notch and not wear your sweatpants and maybe just wear jeans at least, right? Because what you wear reflects something about you. And if you're always showing up in casual attire, to me, it says something about how we're kind of looking at life in a casual way all the time, and sometimes we need to show up with a slightly different posture. Well, a lot of farm websites are like comfy pants websites, right? They technically exist. They do the job, they're comfortable for the farmer, but they're not doing the job of representing the business and the offer super well or really professionally. A person doesn't walk away from that site feeling confident and clear and like, wow, I want to work with these people, right? So today I'm sharing a simple framework for what elements belong on a good homepage. Not a comfy pants homepage, but a solid, good khakis, Dockers jeans homepage. Okay, I'm not going to be talking about fonts or. Or the pretty design and colors. I'm talking about the messaging blocks that will move people towards action, the information that should be on your site, specifically your homepage. I know there are lots of other pages on your website. Hopefully you have more than a homepage at each of Those kind of sub pages how. Has its own purpose, but the homepage has a very specific job. And so we're going to talk about what goes on that. Because that's the page that people come to, that's the page they spend the most time on. That's the page where they decide if they want to dive deeper into your website. So what should be on that homepage? Okay, this is going to be a pretty deep dive into the topic. I have an entire project inside of Farm Marketing School, which is the website homepage offer. Excuse me, Makeover. The website homepage makeover project. And its purpose is to literally step by step help you rebuild your homepage in 30 days. And I go into a lot more detail there to help you get this done quickly. But today I want to kind of give you the big picture outline. And for some of you, this is going to be super helpful. As I go through this, I want you to be looking at your own website. I want you to be thinking about, do I have that on my website homepage? Do I want to add it? Do I feel like that might add something or is it just going to clutter it? Because these things that I'm going to share, you don't need to do all of them. But for some of you, there's going to be two or three that are missing that would really add a lot and that won't be that hard to add. So I'm going to help you see what those could be. Okay. Now when I teach about websites and you'll see this in for our marketing school in the class, if you ever join, I talk about your website is kind of like a pancake stack. I want you to imagine a stack of pancakes when you go to ihop. Hopefully you don't go to ihop, but you know what I mean. Your favorite pancake house. Or maybe you stack the pancakes for your kids and there's like four, five, six of them, right? And we put that pad of butter on the top and we pour some maple syrup over it. Are you getting hungry? Yes. Okay. A website is like that. We have different messaging stacks. They're usually like, if you were to go and look at a website right now, you, you'd be able to notice them. They are these horizontal containers of content that sit on top of each other and they are in an intentional order. So you are going to think about how many stacks you need to have on your website. Some farms need four to five, but some might need 10 to 12. But what I want you to remember here before we get started is that you don't need every pancake that I'm going to share with you today. The order of the pancakes does matter, that each pancake has a specific job, usually one job and one job only, before it passes the messaging onto the pancake below. And some of those pancakes can live on other pages, should you decide to do so. So as you're listening to these ideas today and you like the idea, but you're like, man, my homepage seems really long now, then maybe consider taking that information and putting it on a sub page somewhere else. Okay, so let's talk about the core pancakes. This is my recommended stack. What I consider foundational. So when I'm auditing websites for farmers in farm marketing school, because sometimes we'll have a farmer bring their website to the monthly Zoom group coaching call, and we'll take a look at it and we'll give some feedback and say, hey, this is what I would change. This is what's doing really well for you. And when I do this kind of work, I'm looking for these different pancakes that I'm about to talk through. Okay, are you ready? So if you want to get out a pen and paper and write this stuff down, go for it. Let's start out with the first one, the first stack on the top. This is called the header stack, and it is the first thing they see when they come to your website. It should be a header image of some sort. And I want you to remember that pictures are a form of copywriting. They are a form of persuasion and messaging. So we want this header image to visually describe what it is that you sell. It should be very clear from the picture alone what you do. So either it's a product or it's your customer doing something with the product, or it's you passing the product to the customer, or it's that transformation that the customer goes through. You've captured that somehow in the graphic, and it's clear what you sell and what you're delivering. Right. This is sometimes tricky to figure out what this should be, but it should be a beautiful picture that frankly takes their breath away. Okay. And we want this header stack to also include a tagline or a headline of some sort. Sometimes it also has an optional sub headline underneath that. And this tagline is communicating the value of your brand. Like, what is it that you do for people? What problem do you solve? Figuring out a tagline is tricky. It's definitely something worth spending some time on. And I have an entire podcast all about how to find your perfect headline or tagline. Excuse me. And I will make sure I put the link in the show notes so that you can go listen to that. I think it was one of the first 20 episodes. The header also includes a primary call to action button, usually right smack in the middle of the picture. Make sure that this entire header element pancake stack fits above the fold. What do I mean by that? Above the fold refers to the days when we all had newspapers and they would put the headline and the lead story above the fold of the newspaper because people would decide whether to take the paper and buy the paper based on what they could read on that top section above the fold. The same principle applies with websites. Many people don't want to even scroll with their thumb. They're making a decision about whether they want to continue to read your website based on what they see in the header image. So we need to get that headline, that sub headline, the call to action button above the fold, above that frame where they then first have to thumb down or use their thumb to keep looking. So ask yourself, can someone tell what I sell from this image and from this heading? And who is this for? So common mistakes that I see in this header stack are pretty landscape shots with no product. So maybe I can tell it's a farm, but I don't know what you're selling. Vague, poetic headlines that are trying to be clever and cute but are not clear. That's another common mistake. And frankly, no button. I see a lot of websites without a call to action button in the header and that is a big no, no. You are missing. You are missing money on the table when you do that. Your call to action button should be simple, should be directional, one or two words. For example, shop online, join CSA, view products. I don't know, go to ChatGPT and throw those examples in and say, give me 10 more like this and see what it comes up with. But it needs to be simple and clear what you want them to do first. Now, I know a lot of you have a lot of things that they could do, a lot of places they could start in terms of buying your products. You need to decide what is your gateway. What is the thing that most people do first? Is it that they shop at your farmer's market? Is it that they buy this specific product? Is it that you want them to buy your csa? What is it? What is the goal of this website? Is it that you want to get them on your availability list? Then that should be your button, right? Decide. And that's the primary call to action. You can always do the rest of the sales job on the other end once they click on that button. Okay, so that's the first pancake stack. It's at the top, the header. The second one is the problem stack, or sometimes I call it the meet the farmer stack. The purpose of this stack is to position yourself as the guide in the customer's journey to connect with them emotionally. To establish like, hey, here's the problem that you have. I know you have this problem and I'm, you know, positioning myself as the guide to help you solve it. Usually it includes a graphic image, a photo of the farmer or the farm family. The copy that goes along with it is all about identifying the problem that you solve for your customer. So you're giving almost like the hint of your about page, like you're introducing yourself, but you're doing it through the lens of why you started this business and how it helps the customer, what you are trying to do for the world, what you're trying to do for the customer, how you're trying to help them. And in the process, you're reflecting your shared values. You are positioning yourself as the guide. Hey, we understand you. I'm here for you. And there's usually also a button in this pancake stack that takes people either to your direct call to action, the one that you had in your header block, or it could be a button that takes them to your about page, where you go into way more detail about your story about who you are and how you're helping the customer. Okay, now remember, this is not an autobiography. Do not go into the weeds here. That's what your about about page is for. It's very customer centered. So make sure that when the customer reads this section, they walk away thinking, oh, my gosh, it's like they're in my head. They understand me, they know what I want and need. And then they want to keep reading and they keep scrolling. Okay, the next stack, number three, is what we call the solution stack or the what we offer section. And the purpose of this pancake stack is to show the main ways that you solve the problem that you just spelled out in the section above. Okay. AKA what is it that you sell? What is your main product line? So this can have many variations. It could be, you know, you're pointing to your csa. It could be you're pointing to your online store and how people can buy from that every week. It could be that you're pointing them to the fact that you go to three farmers Markets. It could be your. Maybe you have an online store that only does shipping. It could be a best sellers grid. And they're clicking and the image and it takes them to the local line store or the shopify store or whatever. Okay, so the goal of this section is to let visitors quickly see what kind of farm business this is. Right. Because they're going to see all these graphics potentially of the different products. And now they're like, oh, that's the product suite. This is what they're all about. It reduces confusion for them. They can quickly decide if they're in the right place or not. It's all about clarity. So don't worry about being complete. Don't worry about putting every single main product in here. No, we're just trying to give a smattering. You're curating the content here so they get an idea of what you're known for. And I want you to focus on your primary revenue drivers here. I know you sell a lot of different things and you have a lot of different outlets, but what are the two or three main ways that revenue comes into your, into your business? And I even want to like pause here. Like some of you might have three ways that you make money, but one of them is like 3% or something of your revenue. Like, it's just a small amount. I don't know if you need to have that listed there. Right. We're putting our primary revenue drivers in this section. Okay. All right, that's the third pancake stack. Number four is the how to buy from us stack, also known as the three part plan stack. The purpose of this section is to explain very clearly step one, step two, step three, how to buy from us. Okay, so you've just told them what your product suite is and now they're thinking, I think I want to buy this. And before they click on that picture, product picture above to go to your store, it might be helpful for you to quickly explain what's going to happen next when you do that. Like when you click on that button and it takes you to the local line store, what are they going to ask you to do there? So I'm going to tell you here now first I want you to, you know, shop our inventory, choose your products right, place your order or choose your pickup site. And then maybe step three is pick up and start cooking. Right. So we want to be really clear about what is the first thing you're supposed to do and then what's going to happen in the middle step and then when are we all going to know that you're done and you've successfully done achieved your goal. It's sometimes a little fun to figure out what should go in those, in the wording of those three steps. But it's important that you have this because people will not step into confusion. They want to see what are the stones in the creek that I'm going to have to hop on. And if you just break it down into three steps, that really helps remove friction and uncertainty. So we want to clearly explain in this section, where are they supposed to click? What's going to happen next? How do products get to them if people don't understand what's going to happen next? Or maybe they click on that picture of a product in the section before and it takes them to your store, but they can't figure out from there, like how the buying process works. They're going to click away, they're not going to complete the process. So if they need to know what the pickup locations are before they go there, then you need to make sure that gets communicated before they click onto your website in your store. Right. That's kind of what this plan section is all about. Okay, so that's section four, the how to buy plan stack. And in farm marketing school, like I said, we have this as an entire project and we spend a lot of time helping you figure out what that plan section can look like on your site. For many, many farmers, this is one of the things that's missing. And when they put it in there, it opens the floodgates and people start actually converting on their online store because now they know what they're supposed to know before they get there. I hope you're enjoying this deep dive episode into all things farm website. Have you ever looked at your own farm website and kind of thought, looks kind of meh? Well, if you've been embarrassed to send people to your website or you've wondered why your website isn't converting, I think I can help. I've audited a lot of farm websites over the years, and I see the same issues over and over again that are causing a lot of confusion. These mistakes will stop your potential clients from moving forward. And the good news is that once you know what they are, they're pretty easy to spot and fix. I've decided to organize them all for you into a free PDF called the 10 Most Common Website Mistakes. This PDF walks you through each one, step by step, what to fix first so that you can start tightening things up. You can grab it for free@mydigitalfarmer.com websitemistakes I hope you find it a helpful resource in addition to this week's episode. And now back to the show. Okay, number five, the FAQ stack, also known as the objection handling pancake. The purpose of this pancake is to overcome any hesitations or questions or objections that a customer might have at this point as they're looking at your offer. Sometimes the FAQ is one giant pancake of single grouped FAQs, like an accordion where you can list maybe five or six on top of each other and they click on the question and it expands. Sometimes, though, it's individual pancakes for every single question that you want to address. That's how it is on my website. I have the single question stacks, but that's just because I only have two of them. I have one that's like, what are your pickup sites? And there's a lot of information there. So I just turned it into its own stack. There's a picture of a pickup site and then I spell out what they are and then I have another one that's are you organic? And I use an entire pancake to talk about that. So you can do this a couple of different ways. Some common examples of FAQs are where are the pickup sites? How does shipping work? Do you have order deadlines? When do orders close? Right. Are you organic? So remember, each frequently asked question is actually an objection in disguise. And it's your job in this section as you're writing the copy for it, to make sure that you answer it well enough so they feel confident to move forward. What are your FAQs? Well, the longer you're in business, the quicker you'll figure out what they are. It's usually a list of three to five things that people are always asking you before they decide to buy from you. And you're getting sick of answering them. Okay, that's your cue. Those are the things that you put in this section. Moving on to number six. This is the lead magnet stack. Now, I've talked a lot about lead magnets over the last 340 episodes, so hopefully I don't need to explain too much what a lead magnet is, but sometimes people aren't ready to buy your product right away. And so we need to have a plan B. We need to have a way to get them on our email list so that we can deliver value to them through the email inbox over the next few weeks and coach them and coax them into becoming a a paying customer. Hopefully you have an email nurture sequence Or a weekly email rhythm to support that. So once a person actually gets on your email list, you have a way of making that conversion. So a lead magnet and like an email nurture sequence or a weekly email discipline kind of go hand in hand. You need to have both or it doesn't really work. But the lead magnet stack is where you're giving away some kind of value in advance, some kind of resource in exchange for their email address. For example, maybe you tease them with a recipe guide if you're a meat producer, maybe you tease them with a download of the cut list and the guide for how to actually read it and use it. Maybe it's a vegetable storage guide that. That's one of the ones on my website. Maybe it's just get onto our farm availability list. Okay, so just remember not everyone is going to be ready to buy and your email list is your long term asset. This is the way that you get people warm leads onto it. And then you've got this practice of emailing them every week or a nurture email sequence or a promotional email sequence that you send to them based on whatever lead magnet they got that does the work of actually selling them and getting them to buy. So I definitely encourage you to have a lead magnet on your homepage. It's usually closer to the bottom and it's positioned as kind of like the. The plan B. Okay, number seven. This one I think is kind of optional. I have included it in my website. But if you don't have room for all of these pancakes, then this might be one that you take away. It's the primary value proposition stack. This is where you are answering the question, what sets us apart? Why us as a brand? Right? What are our commitments to you? What are the values that we stand for? So this is where you're differentiating your brand, your farm from your competition or from the other options that are out there to solve this problem. So for example, you might want to use this pancake stack to focus on your regenerative practice. Or maybe you want to talk all about how your family run or how you're a longtime local farm or you're incredibly convenient or flavor first varieties or that your varieties are rare and hard to find, right? So this is not where you're teaching your whole life story or your incredibly long certifications list. This is where you're mostly focusing on your values. It's one clear paragraph or it has some bullet points. The way it looks on my website is we call the headline of this section our promise to you and then we have sort of like three blocks underneath it that talk about our commitments, the things that were promising to provide for them. And a lot of them are just, you know, beautiful values language. And I'm trying to connect with them and, and position myself as their guide. If these are the same values they have, they'll have alignment with me. And they may be like, yeah, I want to stand behind this farmer. Okay, number eight. I think this one is an absolute must. It's the testimonials or reviews. Pancake stack. And the purpose of this is social proof. Listen, if you haven't heard this from me enough, I'm going to say it again. People are looking for testimonials before they buy, and a lot of times they don't even realize that they are. So if you were to ask them, what do you need to know before you purchase my product? They're not going to tell you, oh, I need to know that it works for someone else. I need to see two or three testimonials. No, but they're instinctively looking for it. And when they see the testimonials, something unlocks in their brain and they're ready to move forward. So they will not take action until they see that your product is working for other people too. You don't need to have a lot of testimonials. I would say three. Like, if you can create a pancake stack that has three right next to each other, that should be good enough. But we also sometimes see, like, these rotating sliders where it's, I don't know, maybe four or five testimonials that just keep sliding. But you can only read one at a time. Sometimes I see it as a Google review embedded thing. So we use a tool called Embed Social. I pay a monthly fee for that. And it's a widget that goes right into my, into my website homepage and it updates in real time as people continue to leave reviews. That's not a good thing to do, by the way. Like, don't do Embed Social if you're not getting a lot of reviews on a regular basis. But if you are, for instance, a business that does a lot of online orders and you're getting a fair number of reviews from people every few days or every day, then that looks really impressive to have that constantly be populating. Because not only are they going to see, I don't know, like eight reviews that they can read right there in the block, but they're going to see the latest time and day that it was posted and they'll be like, dang, there's like a lot of super fans that are, they must be doing a lot of business. And that sends a signal too on the headline to be. You can be highlighting like over 2000 happy customers or whatever. Like, you can use language like that too to further reiterate that lots of people like you. So, so using the copy of the headlines is really important too. As you're, as you're putting these pancakes into position, we're not just thinking about what am I writing in the paragraph and what's the order of these pancakes, but we're really thinking about the power of the wording that goes in the headline because you can definitely influence someone through the word choice. And we'll talk more about that at the very end.
B
Today's podcast is sponsored by my friends@citizensalmonalaska.com if you run a CSA and you're always looking for value added products that feel aligned with your farm but don't.
A
Create more work for you, I want.
B
To tell you about Citizen Salmon Alaska. This is my fifth season partnering with them and we keep coming back for a really simple reason. It works and I genuinely love their product. Our CSA members love it too. The wild sockeye salmon is a standout and the scallops disappear fast. And I just trust the people behind the business. Citizen Salmon is a small family run seafood company working directly with independent fishermen out of Homer, Alaska. They offer wild sockeye salmon, halibut, black cod, shrimp, and even in house smoked seafood, which makes it an especially easy add on for CSA farms. Here's why this partnership is such a win for farms like mine. I get to expand my product suite without taking on fulfillment. I promote Citizen Salmon to my audience. My customers order directly from their website using a farm specific code. Citizen Salmon ships the frozen fish straight to them and I earn a commission without handling inventory, packing or delivery. And the timing just works. Halibut in the spring, salmon as the summer approaches, and beautiful seafood offerings for the holidays. They're currently signing up new farm partners through April.
A
So if you're curious whether this could.
B
Be a fit for your CSA, head to citizensalmonalaska.com and reach out to Erin to get the conversation started. That's citizensalmonalaska.com wild seafood done the right way and a partnership I'm proud to recommend. And now back to the show.
A
Okay, moving on to number nine, credentials, badges and other trust signals. Okay, so I, I don't think this one is required, especially if you have the testimonial review stack. You may not need this one too. This is another way to get at that same piece of social proof. What I often see is like certified organic, the logo for certified organic. Or maybe you've won an award like one of your products, like won best cheese in the international Fashion Festival or whatever. Or you've been featured in a publication or on the news or you're like a go to thought leader of some sort and that actually means something. Like if someone saw that brand or that logo, it would, they would know what it means. Associations that you're a part of. These are usually seen like all in a banner where there might be three or four in a row next to each other horizontally. I often see them underneath the header or I see them kind of three quarters of the way down on the page. So that's another option that you have. If you don't have a lot of badges or credentials yet, then skip that one. And then finally, number 10, the final call to action pancake stack. This is the bottom of the page closer. And so many people don't include this. I think it's a deal change, a deal break, a strong closing section that repeats who it's for, what they get. One clear button. This is a really short stack. There's not a lot of words, but it's basically just a final like, hey, are you ready to get started? It gives them one last chance to click on that button. I want you to remember, like this person is scrolling through this entire home page, right. And it potentially has 10 different stacks on it. And we want to make sure that the call to action button is showing up in multiple places, not just way up top on the header. We don't want to make them, you know, get to the eighth pancake and they're finally ready to buy after they've read those great testimonials. And then they can't find a call to action button nearby. Right. So we want to be sticking those CTA buttons in almost every single stack. I would argue possibly in every stack so it's easy to convert. Okay, so those are kind of the, the big ten. Now I'm going to go through an optional, what I call my deck of cards. My optional deck of cards pancakes. And these are some that I have seen on websites that I think can be really effective. Number one, audience specific pathways. Okay. I call this the rabbit trail method. This is great for farms who have multiple customer types, multiple marketing outlets and you're trying to figure out how do I branch people off and they can decide which path they want to go down. So if you have a meat, you're a meat producer, but you also have a CSA and you have a farmer's market. Like, how do you direct people? Right? And this is where I say, well, give them the three pathways. Give them the three rabbit trails in a pancake. And so inside the pancake, there might be three different graphics that they can click on. And if they click on the one with the meat, it's going to take them to the page that's all about your different meats. And you can do this a sales page job on that subpage. Okay, so these are often buttons like shop vegetables or join CSA or buy meat or wholesale. I don't usually actually see wholesale a lot, honestly, but you get the idea. Each is going to lead to its own page and it helps your visitors see self select quickly. Okay, that's an option. And if you were going to do that, that's probably going to be up top in the solution stack in place of the solution stack. Okay, the next deck of cards option is your location or your service area stack. This is to quickly communicate where you're located, the different places that they could go to get your product. It's especially useful for roadside stands, delivery routes, local pickup farms. It could include like a simple map. It could include your town name, it can include your counties served. And what this does is it answers. It's almost like it's a frequently asked question stack. Right? Like it's answering the question of, am I close enough to you, the customer? So if they're experiencing friction, like, oh, this looks like a really great business, I want to support them, but they can't figure out where you are, how close you are to them. This is going to help them discover that really fast. Another way you could do this is to stick this in the menu, the navigation menu. And people could click on that and it would take them to your location. Okay, the next card is visual storytelling stack or your photo collage. I actually have this on my website because I think pictures are so powerful. And I was looking for a way to basically curate a bunch of images, almost like a gallery to whet their appetite. This could be a grid of farm life images, a grid of your different vegetables and all the beautiful colors. It could be harvest packing customers, your animals. And basically what you're trying to accomplish here is build familiarity to create trust. Curate a selection of photos that are telling the story that you want them to see, show your authenticity, your realness, and really just lower the Risk for, for the customer, like, oh, this is a real place and that they look like they're treating their animals well, or that looks like a beautiful piece of land. Like they're living the life that I imagine a farmer should be living. I'm going to live vicariously through them. Right. It's kind of getting all of that done. And then finally the content preview stack. So if you publish a blog post on a regular basis, or you have a recipe that you're always posting every few weeks, or, or maybe you do video content that you update from time to time, basically a blog kind of thing, you might want to have an entire stack on your homepage that is pointing to your latest piece of content and that keeps people coming back to your website, even people who have already bought from you, keeps your site relevant because they want to keep seeing that next piece of content. All right, before we wrap up, I think it's important if we're talking about homepages of websites that we discuss the architecture of your website or your menu navigation. Because when a person comes to your main page, they read that homepage, they maybe hopefully click on a button, but you also want to have some directional guidance at the top in the menu so that they can see what other choices there are, what other information there might be on your website. So it's really the orientation piece. Here are some suggested items that I think should be in every menu on a website for a farm. There should be about the about page. It's usually just called about and that's usually the first one that they see. A contact S bar. Please have that as. As a menu item. Products, our products or farm products. Usually I see a shop or a store. That's another place that they can go. If they don't click on your big orange button in the middle of the header image, it shows up again in the navigation. And I also often see blog. Now if you don't have a blog, obviously don't include it. So you want to have fewer items is better than many items in my opinion. Don't forget that if you have a lot of stuff that you want to make people aware of, you can stick them as sub menu items. Right. You'll just have to be more intentional about what am I going to call my upper categories so that those sub menus logically fit underneath them. But I, I see that a lot. It's a great way to organize your content. Look at other farm websites for ideas of how to name your categories. In fact, inside of farm marketing school, if you Take the website homepage makeover class. You spend some time thinking about this and there's a, a resource that, that can help you kind of see some examples of other websites so you can see the wording that they chose. And I think it's a fabulous resource to help you get ideas. Okay. And then there's the footer. That's the section at the very, very bottom of your website. We often forget about it, like, oh, that's just not important. But it is important. Make sure that you've got the right stuff down there. At a bare minimum, you should have your farm name, address, phone number, possibly email address. Do not make it hard for people to locate you. If you aren't going to put your email address there, then you need to have a Contact Us page. That name, address, phone number is important for SEO. Google needs to see that, needs to know where you are because it cross checks it with your business profile and uses that to decide, you know, what to show people when they go to Google Search. But it also usually includes like important links or the site map and social icons. I know, like if I don't see social icons anywhere in the upper section of the website, then I always just automatically know to look down below and they're almost always down there. So make sure that your social icons are listed in the footer. All right, there you have it. That's my comprehensive list of all the different kinds of things you could probably put on a homepage. Remember, you don't have to do every single one of them. Not every site needs every pancake that I just listed. Can I say that again? Not every site needs every pancake, but it's good to know what the options are. Right? Some of these stacks could live on your interior pages. And I want you to remember that the order matters. Conversion often happens in a sequence. And there is a podcast in my archives where I teach about the the pastor framework. P A S T O R. This is a, a conversion framework that you're taught when you learn email copywriting. Well, any kind of copywriting, frankly. And the P stands for something, the A stands for something. And you learn what these are. And this is the order in which you typically tell your message in order to convert someone to a sale. And this framework that I've just taught you and the order in which I went at least the first 10 like that follows the pastor framework for the most part. So if you want to go and listen to that episode, I will link that up in the show notes as well. I'm going to make a note right now to find what that one was, and that'll kind of open your eyes and help you hear the same message in a different way. It's a really good framework that you can use in other places. So simplicity, simplicity trumps completeness. You don't have to throw the entire kitchen sink onto your homepage. Okay? But we do need to give enough information to make your offer compelling and clear so that they take that first step. Really think through. What is your gateway offer? What is the thing that most people get first? What is the path that most people take first into your business? Because if you do the job of building out the other marketing assets in your business, like I teach in farm marketing school, there are lots of pieces in your farm marketing machine, okay? The website is one of them. And the website passes the baton on to the next runner in your machine, and they take it from there. So if you have those other pieces in place, like an email nurture sequence, like a lead magnet, like a weekly email sequence, like offers that circulate throughout the year, that tease people to come back, like a promotional email sequence, like a social media plan that's pointing to your website, pointing to your lead magnet, pointing to your offers, right? If they're all kind of connecting, then it's working like a beautiful machine. So you don't have to have all the information here on your website. You just need to have enough to get that person to take the next step and pass the baton on to the next piece in your marketing machine. And they'll take it from there and push people to the next, coach them to the next conversion stage.
B
All right.
A
You can stop taking notes now. I want to end with just an encouragement. Listen, this is. Anytime I touch my website, I always take a big sigh. Do you do that, too? I'm like, okay, this feels like this is going to be a heavy lift and I want to make the container smaller. What if you just focused on your website homepage? Don't think about all the other pages. Or maybe you just want to focus on a sales page on your website that really goes deep into, like, your meet csa. And maybe that isn't your homepage, but whatever it is, like, like shrink the container and let's just decide. This is going to be a project. Like, I'm going to spend a good four or five hours or maybe two days of three to four hours each and just get this done. This is not something that you build in 10 minutes. If you're really needing to make over a page, it's a focused project and that's why it is a 30 day project. Build inside of Farm Marketing School. It was one of the first ones that I created many years ago. I did a website makeover challenge. Does anyone remember that? If anybody was following me in the early years and it was so popular, like people loved it. And so when I joined or when I created Farm Marketing School, I knew that I needed to make something like that again because it was so good. So I took that content and I updated it and I put it into a different format. This is a really good class inside of our marketing school. So if you want support and you just want to get it done, then come in to FMS and just take that class first. Do the job and feel good about yourself that you've got it tweaked. There is so much step by step information in that workshop that's going to help you get clarity. The other really awesome resource that's inside that project is my sample website PDF. I don't know what to call it. I need to give it a better name. It's long, it's like a hundred pages. But basically what I did is I went and found like 10, 10 to 15 really good websites that were messaged. Well, a few of them are farms, but most of them aren't actually. And I just stuck them all in one giant PDF so that you can just page through and see website by website, like what it looks like, what the stacks literally look like on top of each other. And what I love about this resource is that what it does for a farmer when they finally sit down, like they maybe have figured out what stacks they want to have, what pancakes they want to have, in what order, but now they have to sit down and actually figure out what to write in them or how they want to tweak the head, the headings and the subheadings of each section. And they can go and look at this guide and they can page through the 10 different versions and they can be like, oh, there's the testimonial section for that website. What did they write as their heading for the testimonial section? Oh, they worded it that way. What did this one do? And you page over, you know, five pages to the next website. How did they word the heading for their testimonial site? And you see patterns, you see like forms of putting words together that would work for you too. Like, I know you're a farm business and maybe not a wedding business, but the heading could be very similar. And so it just Made the process for me of rewriting my website so much faster because I was able to look at what other templates did, other businesses did. I'm like, oh, I love the wording of that. Or oh, I like how they put a picture over here and then they had. They did this little element and I just kind of copied some of the styling of some of these sites. So that's why I love that resource guide as part of that project. It's just amazing to page through. And it shortens the create the creation process because you can see it's like a Pinterest board. You see different versions of doing each pancake and then you decide which version you like the best and then you make it work for your farm. So I just want to plug that project inside of fms. It is so good. Even if you just come into farm marketing school for one month to work on this and get it done, it is so, so worth the investment. The other thing that you could do is bring your website, current website, to the group coaching call that we have every third Wednesday of the month at 1pm we come together and it's fair game. You can do how you can use that time however you want. And you can say, corinna, I would love for the group to look at my website and audit it for 15 minutes in this group coaching call. And you would be amazed how much value that is. Like to just get a two or three really helpful insights or what you're doing well or hey, this has got to change. Like, it's very humbling, but it's also, it kind of speeds up the process of auditing and fixing your website. Um, you could also send me the link to your website before that meeting and say, could you look at it before the group coaching call so that you have a little more time to prepare. I'm happy to do that as well and give you some feedback. So couple of different ways there that for marketing and school can really help help you build out a better website and support you in that and accelerate the process of fixing it. All right, Your website. Let's. Let's land this plane. Your website is not just comfy pants, my friends. It. It's. It's a salesperson. Okay? It's your salesperson. And so if you are driving traffic right now to a confusing homepage that doesn't know what it wants to tell its customer to do, you are, you are leaking opportunity. You don't need to be perfect, okay, as you put this together, but you do probably need to make it just a little more clear than it is today. So I want you to go and look at your website today. That's your call to action. Go just quickly scan your website. Have you been there in a while? Let's go take a look at it. I'm gonna do this too frankly, make sure that it's still up to date and maybe there are just a few sections that need to be added. You can use some of the things we've talked about today. Quick. Maybe go add a testimonial section if you don't have one yet, go do that and see what needs to be added. Or maybe see what needs to get taken out because it's like old news. Give it a quick refresh. And remember if you want guided help rebuilding that homepage, that project, it's one of my favorites lives inside Farm Marketing School and you can get there by going to mydigitalfarmer.com FMS today's show notes can be found at mydigitalfarmer.com 349 if you liked today's episode, please leave me a rating or a review on Apple Podcasts or the podcast of your choice. I would really appreciate it helps other people find out about the show or you can share the link with a farmer friend. If you think they have a terrible website or you know they need some help, send them this podcast episode and maybe they can learn a thing or two. Don't forget if you want to get onto my email list to get some more marketing wisdom, you can join for free. I have a bunch of stuff stuff to send your way to make your marketing better. You can go to mydigitalfarmer.com forward/subscribe. I'm also now on Instagram at my digital farmer. Would love to connect with you there especially in stories. And I want to thank you again for joining me today for listening week after week being so faithful, being so encouraging. I love your emails that you guys write to me and I love doing this work. This is my favorite thing every week to sit down and create content for the podcast. I think of you guys all the time how I can help you and serve you. So if you have suggestions or questions send them my way at my digital what is my email? I'm thinking my digitalfarmers gmail.com and I will take a look and maybe it will turn into an episode. Thank you so much for joining me today. Have an amazing week. Remember I believe in you. Bye bye Sam.
Host: Corinna Bench
Date: February 18, 2026
In this episode, Corinna Bench, CSA farmer, marketing specialist, and founder of MyDigitalFarmer.com, dives deep into exactly what should go on a farm business’s website homepage. Corinna shares her tried-and-true “pancake stack” framework, breaking homepage content into manageable, purposeful sections ("pancakes") to help farm businesses maximize clarity, lead generation, and conversions. She walks listeners through each stack’s role, common pitfalls, and practical examples—making it an actionable guide for anyone wanting to improve their farm website.
Corinna’s approach: stack distinct content blocks in a deliberate order for maximum impact. You don’t need every single pancake, but order matters.
Header Stack (Hero Section) [13:30]
Problem/Meet the Farmer Stack [20:30]
Solution/What We Offer Stack [23:55]
How to Buy (3-Part Plan) Stack [28:28]
FAQ/Objection Handling Stack [33:22]
Lead Magnet/Email Signup Stack [36:11]
Primary Value Proposition Stack [37:54]
Testimonials/Reviews Stack [39:37]
Credentials/Badges/Trust Signals Stack [42:40]
Final Call to Action (“Closer”) Stack [44:13]
“If your home page is confusing or it's missing information and people have to think too hard, they'll leave. And if they leave, well, there's no conversion that time.” (04:18)
On “comfy pants” websites vs. professional presence:
“A lot of farm websites are like comfy pants websites...they technically exist. They do the job, they're comfortable for the farmer, but they're not doing the job of representing the business and the offer super well.” (07:14)
On the purpose of each stack:
“Each pancake has a specific job, usually one job and one job only, before it passes the messaging onto the pancake below.” (11:42)
On funneling users to action:
“You are missing money on the table when you do that. Your call to action button should be simple, should be directional, one or two words.” (17:05)
On why to limit information:
“Simplicity trumps completeness. You don't have to throw the entire kitchen sink onto your homepage… But we do need to give enough information to make your offer compelling and clear so that they take that first step.” (53:08)
On website improvement as a project:
“What if you just focused on your website homepage? Shrink the container and let’s just decide: this is going to be a project.” (55:02)
Corinna encourages listeners to treat their homepage as a focused project—“not something you build in 10 minutes,” but a deliberate effort with step-by-step improvement. She points to Farm Marketing School’s “Website Homepage Makeover” course and a curated PDF of website examples for further help (available to subscribers). She emphasizes that small improvements compound, and clarity will convert more visitors into buyers.
Final encouragement:
“Your website is not just comfy pants, my friends… It’s a salesperson.” (58:23)
Show Notes & Resources: mydigitalfarmer.com/349
Connect with Corinna:
This summary is crafted to help you transform your farm website into a real sales tool—clear, inviting, and ready to turn more visitors into loyal customers.