Podcast Summary: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark – Episode 452: Morals & Morale

Introduction

In Episode 452 titled "Morals & Morale," hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark delve into two spine-chilling true crime stories perfect for the Halloween season. Amidst their engaging banter and occasional humorous exchanges, Karen and Georgia explore the devastating 1918 Hammond Circus Trainwreck and the enigmatic case of "The Watcher" from Westfield, New Jersey. This episode not only recounts historical and contemporary tragedies but also reflects on human resilience and the lingering effects of unresolved mysteries.

1. The 1918 Hammond Circus Trainwreck

Background of the Hagenbeck Wallace Circus

The episode opens with an exploration of the Hagenbeck Wallace Circus, a prominent Midwestern circus rivaling giants like Barnum & Bailey by 1918. Established in 1907 through a merger, the circus was renowned for its spectacular elephant acts and a diverse lineup of approximately 250 performers, including the star equestrian Rosa Rosalind, aerialists known as the Flying Wards, strongmen like the Dirks Brothers, and the dedicated clown Joe Coyle.

The Tragic Event

On June 22, 1918, tragedy struck when the circus's wooden train collided with a sleeping troop train near Hammond, Indiana. The crash occurred around 3:45 AM when the troop train's engineer, Alonzo Sargent, had fallen asleep at the wheel, leading to an inevitable collision due to his failure to heed the circus train's safety signals.

Georgia [29:17]: "Shit. Yeah."

Karen [29:05]: "The engineer on the troop train hasn't seen any of these warnings because he has fallen asleep at the wheel."

Survivor Accounts and Immediate Aftermath

The collision resulted in immediate fatalities and chaos as fires ignited from the spilled kerosene and oil lamps. Survivors recounted harrowing experiences of escaping the burning wreckage while trying to rescue loved ones. Notable survivors included Joe Coyle, who, despite severe injuries, desperately attempted to save his family.

Survivor Henry Miller [31:03]: "I was pounded into the corner of my berth. My scalp was split open."

Investigation and Accountability

A subsequent joint investigation blamed both Alonzo Sargent for negligence and the circus for using outdated wooden train cars instead of safer steel ones. Despite Sargent being charged with manslaughter, the case concluded in a mistrial, leaving lingering questions about accountability. The circus faced numerous lawsuits, leading them to eventually transition to steel cars and sustaining significant financial and emotional losses.

Legacy and Memorialization

The tragedy left a lasting impact on the circus community and led to the establishment of Showman's Rest, a dedicated burial ground for circus performers. Annual Memorial Day services honor the victims, ensuring that their sacrifices are remembered.

Georgia [36:18]: "Yikes."

Karen [36:41]: "The death toll is likely higher because of the transient nature of the circus."

2. The Enigmatic Case of The Watcher

Introduction to The Watcher

Transitioning to a more contemporary mystery, Karen and Georgia recount the eerie saga that inspired the Netflix series "The Watcher." The story revolves around the Broaddus family, who moved into a historic home at 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey, only to receive unsettling letters from an anonymous neighbor known as "The Watcher."

The First Letter

In June 2014, Derek and Maria Broaddus began renovating their new six-bedroom Dutch Colonial home. Shortly after, they received a handwritten letter welcoming them but with a sinister undertone, hinting at the house's dark past and hinting at mysterious happenings.

Georgia [56:43]: "Have you found all of the secrets it holds yet?"

Karen [56:36]: "A little hacky, a little corny."

Escalation and Continued Threats

Weeks later, a second, more threatening letter arrived, referencing black mold and the children's activities, intensifying the family's fear. Despite involving the police and increasing security measures, the letters persisted, suggesting deeper, more personal animosity.

Georgia [60:05]: "657 Boulevard is anxious for you to move in."

Investigation and Theories

Investigations revealed that the letters were postmarked locally, but DNA analysis of the envelopes pointed to an unidentified woman, eliminating the immediate neighbor family who were initially suspected. Various theories emerged, including potential vendettas, hoaxes, or disgruntlement from previous residents, but concrete evidence remained elusive.

Karen [73:44]: "It's a card."

Georgia [75:28]: "It's a card."

Impact on the Broaddus Family and Community

The relentless harassment led the Broadduses to list their home for sale multiple times, each attempt thwarted by the lingering fear instilled by the letters. The community remained divided, with some supporting the family's plight while others remained skeptical of the underlying motives behind the letters.

Georgia [82:04]: "It's all about style, durability and price."

Reflection and Conclusion

Throughout Episode 452, Karen and Georgia intertwine historical and modern tales of tragedy and mystery, highlighting themes of human vulnerability, the quest for truth, and the enduring impact of unresolved events. Their discussions not only recount the gruesome details but also empathize with the victims' and families' struggles, presenting a thought-provoking narrative that resonates with the listeners' fascination with true crime and the macabre.

Georgia [82:28]: "Do you want a cookie?"

Karen [83:18]: "Follow the show on Instagram and Facebook at myfavoritemurder."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Karen Kilgariff [29:05]: "The sonic boom of the crash vibrated glass window panes in houses near the tracks."

• Survivor Steinhaus [31:03]: "When I woke up, I thought someone had slugged me one in the neck."

• Georgia Hardstark [56:53]: "This is a terrifying..."

• Karen Kilgariff [73:55]: "It's a card."

Final Thoughts

Episode 452 of My Favorite Murder masterfully balances detailed storytelling with the hosts' personable interactions, delivering compelling narratives that honor the victims while engaging listeners in deep, often unsettling, mysteries. Whether recounting the historical horrors of a circus tragedy or unraveling the perplexing case of The Watcher, Karen and Georgia ensure that each story is both informative and emotionally resonant, making it a memorable addition to the My Favorite Murder series.