My Favorite Murder Minisode 431 Summary
Episode Title: MFM Minisode 431
Release Date: April 14, 2025
Hosts: Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Network: iHeartPodcasts, Exactly Right podcast network
Introduction
In Minisode 431 of My Favorite Murder, hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark dive into a series of compelling listener-submitted stories, blending true crime with their signature comedic flair. This episode, released on April 14, 2025, features a variety of narratives ranging from personal encounters with potential danger to quirky family anecdotes, all while maintaining the engaging and relatable tone that fans have come to love.
Listener Stories
1. "My Own F Politeness Story" by Listener M – Los Angeles [02:16 - 08:59]
Listener M recounts a harrowing experience from their 32-year career in law enforcement with the LAPD. While commuting through LA traffic, M notices a young girl appearing uncomfortable as a station wagon follows her. Trusting their instincts, M intervenes by blocking the suspect's path and confronting him with a drawn firearm.
Notable Quotes:
- Listener M: “The girl stayed behind me, shaken, using my cell phone, a new thing back then. I called the local police, identifying myself as an off-duty officer and explicitly stating that I was the black guy holding a gun on the badge to avoid any misunderstandings in North Orange County.” ([02:57])
- Karen: “Jesus Christ.” ([04:08])
- Georgia: “Especially if you're an off-duty police officer.” ([04:56])
The confrontation leads to the man's arrest for harassing a minor, though M expresses frustration over not being called to testify. The story underscores the importance of trusting one's instincts and prioritizing safety over politeness.
2. Megan's Stalker Story – [05:38 - 09:07]
Megan, Karen’s sister, shares her brave encounter with a stalker. Living off-campus in Rochester, New York, Megan notices unusual activity around her home, including a person hiding in her bushes. Unlike most, Megan confronts the individual, chasing him down the street and deterring him from returning.
Notable Quotes:
- Karen: “Don’t ever do this.” ([06:54])
- Georgia: “Megan. She showed him she was a fighter.” ([09:07])
- Karen: “Megan. Stop it.” ([07:38])
Eventually, it is revealed that the stalker was arrested and charged with serial rape, highlighting Megan's courage and the effectiveness of her actions in stopping a dangerous individual.
3. Alex's Family Dating Story – [12:02 - 15:24]
Alex shares an amusing yet tense story about her parents' early dating life in the 1980s. Her father, a dentist significantly older than her mother, taught her mother to drive stick shift in a Porsche 911. During this lesson, they got stuck on an incline with a logging truck approaching. Her father abandoned the situation, leaving her mother to escape the looming danger on her own.
Notable Quotes:
- Georgia: “Stay sexy and don’t count on your problematically older lover to save you.” ([15:24])
- Karen: “If I was that young woman, I would have been like, it's my car now.” ([15:47])
Despite this rocky start, her parents remained together for nearly four decades, providing a humorous look at their enduring relationship despite early red flags.
4. Carl's Face – Treasure in an Old House [15:54 - 19:07]
Carl narrates the discovery of a hidden lockbox in his newly purchased mid-century home in Connecticut. While exploring crawl spaces, Carl and his partner find a box filled with old coins, valued at approximately $5,000. This unexpected find provided the necessary funds to restore their home and survive a harsh winter.
Notable Quotes:
- Karen: “It is a hilarious story now, but back then, it was a real lifesaver.” ([18:19 - 19:07])
- Georgia: “Stay sexy and don't be afraid of crawl spaces.” ([19:04 - 19:07])
The story emphasizes the serendipitous nature of finding treasure and its positive impact on Carl and his partner's lives.
5. Roya's "Hot Dog Justice" – Bodie and the Bun Explosion [22:13 - 27:58]
Roya shares a humorous tale about her family's mishap involving thousands of hot dog buns intended for a large barbecue event. Her dog, Bodie, wreaked havoc by scattering and consuming the buns, leading to an amusing yet chaotic scene. The aftermath left the family dealing with the mess and Bodie’s overindulgence.
Notable Quotes:
- Roya: “Stay sexy and guard your hot dog buns.” ([27:06 - 27:58])
- Karen: “Bodie is like, this is the best moment of my entire life.” ([25:49])
This lighthearted story provides a comedic break from the more intense narratives, showcasing the everyday chaos that pets can introduce into family life.
Concluding Remarks
In Minisode 431, Karen and Georgia expertly balance intense true crime stories with lighter, personal anecdotes, maintaining the show's signature blend of suspense and humor. The listeners’ contributions offer diverse perspectives on safety, courage, and the unexpected twists life can take, all while reinforcing the community and support among the My Favorite Murder fanbase.
Final Quotes:
- Karen: “Stay sexy and don't get murdered.” ([28:10])
- Georgia: “Goodbye, Elvis. Do you want a cookie?” ([28:14])
The episode wraps up with heartfelt thanks to listeners, encouraging continued story submissions and reinforcing the bond between the hosts and their audience.
Additional Information:
My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast where Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark share engaging true crime stories and personal anecdotes from listeners. Part of the Exactly Right podcast network, the show is known for its unique blend of humor and gripping narratives, covering a wide range of topics from infamous serial killers to personal survival stories.
For more information or to listen to Minisode 431, visit the iHeartRadio app or wherever you get your podcasts.