My Favorite Murder Minisode 438 Summary

Podcast Information:

• Title: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
• Hosts: Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
• Network: Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts
• Release Date: June 2, 2025
• Description: A true crime comedy podcast where Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners.

Episode Overview:

In Minisode 438 of My Favorite Murder, hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark delve into a series of engaging hometown stories submitted by listeners. The episode is a blend of humorous and poignant anecdotes that showcase the hosts' unique storytelling abilities and their knack for turning ordinary events into captivating narratives.

Key Stories and Discussions:

1. Karen’s Badass Grandma Story ([02:24] - [06:00])

Karen kicks off the episode by sharing a tribute to her grandmother, La Donna, highlighting her fearless and nurturing nature.

• Grandma’s Protective Instincts:

  • Incident at Walmart: When Karen’s aunt was sexually harassed in Walmart ([03:00] - [04:15]), Grandma La Donna took swift action by blocking the aisle with shopping carts and confronting the man aggressively.
    • Quote: “She was hitting him with her purse and I'm sure some swear words were being thrown into the mix.” ([03:44])

• Rescue of Sadie Mae:

  • Taking the Neglected Dog: Frustrated by the sight of a malnourished dog chained outside a house, Grandma took the dog home, giving her a loving name, Sadie Mae ([04:24] - [05:12]).
    • Quote: “Sadie Mae... lived out the rest of her years being loved on and getting every single table scrap until her final days.”

• Legacy and Humor:

  • Hitman at Funeral: In a humorous twist, Grandma had a hitman attend her funeral to pay respects, adding an unexpected layer to her already formidable legacy ([05:15] - [06:00]).
    • Quote: “She fucking blocks off the aisle like a mafia oso and is just like, yeah, you guys leave aisle six to us now.” ([04:17])

2. Megan’s Safari Story ([06:09] - [09:00])

Megan recounts a family safari in Zimbabwe, focusing on a memorable encounter with a protective mother elephant.

• Encounter with the Elephant:

  • Dad’s Unexpected Reaction: While following safety protocols to avoid disturbing the elephant, Megan observes her father abruptly running away from the scene, abandoning the group ([07:18] - [08:07]).
    • Quote: “Once I turned around and can't believe what I saw. About 50 meters... is my dad, all caps, running for his life.” ([07:54])

• Family Dynamics and Humor:

  • Dad’s Reaction: Megan describes her dad’s behavior as uncharacteristic and forever remembered as the day he chose to flee an elephant encounter ([08:07] - [09:00]).
    • Quote: “That's fucking later date right out of there.” ([08:29])

3. Listener Submissions ([09:00] - [27:55])

Karen and Megan read and discuss several hometown stories submitted by listeners, each filled with humor and unexpected twists.

• "Stupid Kids with Sharp Pencils" ([11:00] - [15:18]):

  • Pencil Incident: A seventh-grade boy attempts to impress his crush by throwing a sharpened pencil, accidentally injuring Karen’s mother ([12:45] - [15:18]).
    • Quote: “Like Cupid's arrow itself, his pencil arced over the heads of his unsuspecting classmates and sunk itself straight into my mom's hand.” ([12:55])

• "The Time a Toddler Yeeted Himself into the Afterlife" ([15:18] - [18:35]):

  • Funeral Mishap: At a funeral, a two-year-old escapes and runs towards a grave, causing unexpected laughter amidst the somber setting ([15:18] - [18:06]).
    • Quote: “The grandson stands up to give a heartfelt eulogy, and his two year old breaks free... like a baby linebacker... disappearing into the grave.” ([16:00])

• "Snake Orgy" ([18:06] - [26:37]):

  • Playground Surprise: Lindsay shares a childhood memory of seeing a large pile of garter snakes while playing horse, leading to a frantic escape ([25:14] - [26:37]).
    • Quote: “I turned around to check and sure enough, it was not a nightmare, but a group of writhing snakes.” ([25:22])

4. Karen’s Guy Fieri Apology Story ([21:03] - [24:31])

Karen narrates a lighthearted encounter with Guy Fieri at the Paris Olympics, shedding light on his down-to-earth and humorous personality.

• Olympics Encounter:

  • Meeting Guy Fieri: While attending the Olympics, Karen meets Guy Fieri and apologizes on behalf of her sister’s bachelorette party antics involving Fieri-themed costumes ([21:03] - [23:35]).
    • Quote: “His response? I'm so sorry they chose to do that. I love that Guy Fieri is not only incredibly kind, but also used self-deprecating humor.” ([23:10])

• Humorous Reflection:

  • Sister’s Costume Party: Megan humorously connects the encounter to her sister’s bachelorette party where guests dressed as Guy Fieri, highlighting the hosts' playful rapport ([23:35] - [24:31]).
    • Quote: “It's like the group of Santas that go bar hopping. It should be a group of Guy Fieri's that goes.” ([23:40])

Notable Quotes:

• Karen on Grandma’s Walmart Stand:
  “She was hitting him with her purse and I'm sure some swear words were being thrown into the mix.” ([03:44])

• Megan on Dad’s Safari Reaction:
  “Once I turned around and can't believe what I saw. About 50 meters... is my dad, all caps, running for his life.” ([07:54])

• Listener on Pencil Incident:
  “Like Cupid's arrow itself, his pencil arced over the heads of his unsuspecting classmates and sunk itself straight into my mom's hand.” ([12:55])

• Listener on Funeral Toddler:
  “The grandson stands up to give a heartfelt eulogy, and his two year old breaks free... like a baby linebacker... disappearing into the grave.” ([16:00])

• Karen on Guy Fieri Encounter:
  “I'm so sorry they chose to do that. I love that Guy Fieri is not only incredibly kind, but also used self-deprecating humor.” ([23:10])

Concluding Thoughts:

Minisode 438 of My Favorite Murder offers a delightful mix of heartfelt tributes, humorous mishaps, and quirky listener stories. Karen and Georgia excel in weaving these narratives, providing both entertainment and a sense of community through shared experiences. The episode underscores the podcast’s strength in blending comedy with true crime and personal storytelling, making it a must-listen for fans and newcomers alike.

Stay Connected:

Listeners are encouraged to share their own hometown stories by emailing myfavoritemurder@mail.com and following the podcast on Instagram at @myfavoritemurder. For more episodes, subscribe on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or your preferred podcast platform.