My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Episode Summary: MFM Minisode 440 Release Date: June 16, 2025

Hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, "My Favorite Murder" blends true crime narratives with comedic elements, creating a unique and engaging podcast experience. In Minisode 440, Karen and Georgia delve into a series of listener-submitted stories that range from personal trauma to heartwarming moments, all while maintaining their signature blend of humor and empathy.

1. Introduction to the Minisode

The episode kicks off with Karen and Georgia welcoming listeners to the Minisode, setting the stage for a series of heartfelt and gripping stories shared by their audience. This segment establishes the intimate and supportive atmosphere that "My Favorite Murder" is renowned for.

2. Listener Story #1: Karen’s Latchkey Kid Nightmare [02:07 – 05:05]

Karen Kilgariff opens the session by sharing a deeply personal and harrowing experience from her childhood. As an 80s latchkey kid, Karen was home alone when intruders forcibly entered her home. The intense fear and subsequent trauma left a lasting impact, shaping her perspective on safety and trust.

Notable Quote:

“I'm just out here living my life, always on the edge, but also trying to stay sexy and not get murdered.”
—Karen Kilgariff [04:55]

3. Listener Story #2: Georgia’s Trash Cat – Penny’s Ordeal [05:05 – 08:17]

Georgia Hardstark recounts the terrifying incident involving her beloved cat, Penny. During a panic-inducing event where Penny was sprayed by a skunk, an accidental fire broke out, adding to the chaos. Despite the fear and the physical danger, both Georgia and Penny survived the ordeal, highlighting the deep bond between them.

Notable Quote:

“Penny lived another two and a half years and passed away shortly before her 22nd birthday last November. She was truly a part of me.”
—Georgia Hardstark [07:16]

4. Listener Story #3: Historical Hometown – Celebrating Founding Mothers [08:17 – 12:07]

A heartfelt letter from a third-grade teacher in Quincy, Massachusetts, brings a historical perspective to the episode. The teacher shares inspiring stories about notable women in American history, such as Deborah Sampson, Phillis Wheatley, and Abigail Adams, emphasizing their significant yet often overlooked contributions.

Notable Quote:

“Abigail Adams was an OG feminist.”
—Karen Kilgariff [11:21]

5. Listener Story #4: Georgia’s Quad Accident [14:32 – 17:25]

Georgia narrates a childhood accident involving her quad bike. At seven years old, Georgia disregarded safety instructions, leading to a dramatic fall that resulted in a broken arm. The story not only highlights the physical pain endured but also the resilience and humorous outlook Georgia developed from the experience.

Notable Quote:

“I am now 21 years old and to this day that is still the only bone I have ever broken. And I actually punch harder with that arm now. Bionic arm.”
—Georgia Hardstark [16:21]

6. Listener Story #5: A Fist Fight at a Birthday Party [17:30 – 21:44]

Emily shares a dramatic family incident from her childhood where her grandfather and grandmother engaged in a fist fight during her cousin Steven's first birthday party. The altercation, sparked by a mispronounced word, marked the end of familial relationships and left a lasting impression on the family.

Notable Quote:

“Stay sexy and don't get into a fist fight at a child's birthday party.”
—Karen Kilgariff [21:34]

7. Hoorays: Celebrating Listener Achievements [28:38 – 35:58]

The episode transitions into a series of "Hoorays," where listeners celebrate personal milestones and achievements. Highlights include:

• Joe Sweet shares his fulfillment of moving to Maine to live near the Portland Head Lighthouse, inspired by Karen's dreams.

  Notable Quote:

  “Hooray for bravery, for finding inspiration anywhere or just doing what Karen says gratefully.”
  —Joe Sweet [29:43]

• Shelby celebrates completing her doctorate in nursing alongside her daughter, Megan, who is graduating with an RN degree.

  Notable Quote:

  “So a huge hooray to my badass daughter Megan.”
  —Shelby [31:40]

• Aaron announces his upcoming wedding and reflects on his journey, thanking the podcast for its support.

  Notable Quote:

  “You're a lawyer. You did it. Congratulations.”
  —Georgia Hardstark [35:01]

8. Conclusion

Karen and Georgia close the Minisode by expressing gratitude to their listeners, acknowledging the diverse and resilient community that supports the podcast. The episode emphasizes themes of survival, resilience, and the importance of sharing personal stories to foster connection and understanding.

Overall Insights:

• Trauma and Resilience: Both Karen and Georgia share personal stories that showcase their resilience in the face of trauma, offering listeners a sense of solidarity and hope.

• Importance of Sharing Stories: The episode highlights how sharing personal and historical narratives can provide healing, education, and a deeper community connection.

• Humor and Empathy: Throughout the episode, the hosts balance serious topics with humor, making difficult subjects more approachable and engaging for the audience.

Conclusion: MFM Minisode 440 is a testament to the power of storytelling within the "My Favorite Murder" community. Through personal anecdotes and celebratory messages, Karen and Georgia create a space where listeners feel supported, understood, and connected. The episode underscores the podcast's mission to blend true crime with relatable human experiences, all while maintaining a tone of compassion and humor.