Loading summary
Karen Kilgariff
This is exactly right.
Georgia Hardstark
Make everyday epic with the all new Hyundai Palisade Hybrid.
Karen Kilgariff
It's everything you love about the Palisade elevated.
Georgia Hardstark
It features class leading interior space and purposeful tech designed for real life.
Karen Kilgariff
The 2.5T hybrid engine with an up to an EPA estimated 619 miles of range on select trims. It's built for long hauls, quick errands and everything in between.
Georgia Hardstark
And the Palisade Hybrid comes with an available class exclusive dash camera feature for extra peace of mind. The Hyundai Palisade Hybrid is the SUV that will inspire you to make the most out of every journey.
Karen Kilgariff
Learn more about the Hyundai palisade@hyundai USA.com
Georgia Hardstark
Call 562-314-4603 for complete details.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Goodbye Brought to you by Apple Card hey, you could be earning 2% daily cash back on that purchase. And that one. And even that one. That's because Apple card users earn 2% daily cash back on every purchase, including everyday items they buy online or in store when their Apple Card with Apple Pay not an Apple Card customer. You can apply in the Wallet app on iPhone subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs bank usa Salt Lake City Branch Terms and more at Apple Co Benefits this Mother's
Georgia Hardstark
Day celebrate the woman behind it all with Pandora Jewelry.
Karen Kilgariff
Get your mom some jewelry that feels personal and reflects the moments that matter most.
Georgia Hardstark
Whether that's a date, a name, or a shared memory. You can make it even more meaningful with an engraving in your own handwriting.
Karen Kilgariff
And because the best Mother's Day gift says more than just I love you,
Georgia Hardstark
find the perfect Mother's Day gift at your local Pandora store or online@pandora.net Goodbye, My favorite. Hello and welcome to my favorite murder.
Karen Kilgariff
The Miniso.
Georgia Hardstark
That's right. We read you your story.
Karen Kilgariff
Your stories. I want you to go down like this is a play and I keep forgetting a line. You know this in cartoons where there's a person in like a little half shell that's like whispering lines to people. That's to me what that hand is where you're just like.
Georgia Hardstark
It's like not the normal, not the other.
Karen Kilgariff
Do this hand.
Georgia Hardstark
No. And then this is. Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
And then the end. I think you go first on this one.
Georgia Hardstark
Regular old minisode. Let's do this. Doot doot, doot doot. Okay. Sail by Salute. Washington State Fairy edition. Hello, Karen, Georgia and all of my other MFM besties. When I heard episode 524 about the Costa Concordia and how the captain did the sail by salute to impress a woman and then it says sir with this emoji. I immediately thought of the Pacific Northwest version of this exact nonsense and knew I had to share our much less tragic story with you. I live way out on a tiny island in Washington State's San Juan Islands, about 90 minutes north of Seattle. God, it's so beautiful.
Karen Kilgariff
The most beautiful. Like, what a place. What a gift to live there.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, a quiet ferry dependent archipelagio. Is that right?
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, it is.
Georgia Hardstark
Where nothing crazy ever happens except deer jumping fences to mow down entire gardens or the occasional trespassing torture. Which is why this story lives on in local legend. Back in 1983, the Washington State ferry Elwha was doing a normal Sunday run through the islands. Think people heading home. Cars packed with island essentials and tourists scanning the horizon of the Salish Sea for our beautiful resident orcas.
Karen Kilgariff
I love an orca.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay?
Karen Kilgariff
Were they trying to kill billionaires? Is that why they were up there?
Georgia Hardstark
Beautiful resident orcas. Meanwhile, the 57 year old Captain of the Elwha ferry invites a female passenger up for a tour of the vessel's wheelhouse for the hour or so sailing.
Karen Kilgariff
Has a ferry captain ever invited you up into the wheelhouse?
Georgia Hardstark
Never been on a fucking ferry. Fucking ship.
Karen Kilgariff
And no, we gotta get you a ship.
Georgia Hardstark
Get me on a ship, you'd love it. Oh, I got so sick.
Karen Kilgariff
Get your own.
Georgia Hardstark
After a while, the captain began joking about taking a little detour in order to sail by the lovely passengers home. As they approached the mouth of the aptly named Grindstone harbor on Orcas island where she resided, she was like, oh, I live over there. And he was like, let's drive by and do a salute.
Karen Kilgariff
Even though we're on a ferry where there's all these passengers and commuters.
Georgia Hardstark
That's right. That's called common sense, Karen. But I wonder what's in his little flask. You know, at the time, the passenger thinks he's joking, as such a detour would put the Elwha way off course. He is, in fact, not joking. And when she realized he was serious, her daughter later said she began to freak out because suddenly this man is steering an entire 382 foot ferry into a harbor that it absolutely should not be entering at full speed. Because nothing is more impressively flirtatious than would you like to see your home from a dangerously questionable distance. Moments later, the Elwha slammed into a submerged reef in Grindstone Harbor. They hit so hard that people a mile away could hear it. The Fairies hall ripped open, causing around $250,000 in damages. That's over. How much in today's money?
Karen Kilgariff
In today's money? This happened in the 90s.
Georgia Hardstark
This happened in 83.
Karen Kilgariff
Ew. 83.
Georgia Hardstark
Say the number got 250,000. And thank you because Kelly put how much it is in today's money.
Karen Kilgariff
600,000.
Georgia Hardstark
700. But close.
Karen Kilgariff
Getting closer.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, I was like, in the ballpark and because we don't have time for that kind of shit here. The ferry continued on, limping its way to Shaw island, and then to Orcas is where it was patched up before heading to Seattle for more permanent repairs.
Karen Kilgariff
So it actually was such a strong ferry, it kind of made it out of there anyway.
Georgia Hardstark
It was like, all good. Let's just keep going, get this over with.
Karen Kilgariff
What about all the people on the ferry whose teeth hit the window or whatever? Fucking.
Georgia Hardstark
Thankfully no one was hurt except for
Karen Kilgariff
that one lady in the incident.
Georgia Hardstark
But here's the fucked up part. Ready for the fucked up part? The recently widowed passenger, the woman and longtime Orcas island resident who was invited into the wheelhouse that day was dubbed the siren of the San Juans.
Karen Kilgariff
Always the woman.
Georgia Hardstark
It says always the woman siren. As if this woman was just out there luring this dumbass. Like, little more to the left, Captain. And then there's some, like, music notes. Next, little more to the left, Captain.
Karen Kilgariff
That's her song.
Georgia Hardstark
She thought this man was joking and then got sucked into a situation she had zero control over. Somehow she got labeled, her reputation was questioned, and she was turned into a main character of this crazy story. Not quite the classic victim blaming, but definitely its weird maritime cousin.
Karen Kilgariff
Victim blaming, it is. Victim. How does that happen every time? It's like the same thing where it's like Pam Bondi and Kristi Noem are being brought up on charges. Fucking
Georgia Hardstark
pedophiles. The worst of the worst whose names are there and their emails that they sent are there. It's all yet there.
Karen Kilgariff
And they're on the news babbling incoherently
Georgia Hardstark
and they don't even fucking. They disclose the victims names when they fucking put the documents out, which is like literally illegal.
Karen Kilgariff
Literally. That's not what you're supposed to be doing.
Georgia Hardstark
I call it when they take the names out and they put in the. They distract from.
Karen Kilgariff
The Siren of the seas is the headline under which we have been living.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
And 2026 is when this whole thing cracks like that fucking fairy. Because enough already. And everyone has their eyes on it and everyone's paying attention not to say, listen. Send both Kristi Noem and Pam Bondi.
Georgia Hardstark
Fuck. Goodbye.
Karen Kilgariff
Goodbye.
Georgia Hardstark
But let's go from the top instead of the fucking bottom.
Karen Kilgariff
Boys first.
Georgia Hardstark
Started at the bottom.
Karen Kilgariff
Boys first.
Georgia Hardstark
And then you got him going up here. Okay. And then it says, of course, the captain lost his job after over 30 years with Washington State Ferries. And then it says, goodbye.
Karen Kilgariff
Bye.
Georgia Hardstark
And by all accounts, the female passenger's family seems to be able to laugh about it now, although none of them found it funny at the time.
Karen Kilgariff
I wonder if when Siren of the San Juan's article came out, her picture was in it, probably.
Georgia Hardstark
And her name and address, like from the 80? That's right, from this. Here's her phone number. Yeah, they used to do that, you guys. They used to just give out, like if someone's getting an award or won something. They.
Karen Kilgariff
Chris Fairbanks, as a child had his name and address printed in their local
Georgia Hardstark
newspaper of like, soccer star Chris Fairbanks. And then they put the child address in there.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. Go visit him, pervs.
Georgia Hardstark
Where are we? Goodbye. Da, da, da, da, da. It's funny. Anyways, stay sexy and don't let a man blame you for crashing a ferry. Question mark xoxo. And thank you eternally for all you do, Kelly. P.S. i celebrated my 27th year as a flight attendant on March 15th. You've been asking for those stories lately. So fasten your seatbelts and expect to hear from me again.
Karen Kilgariff
Kelly.
Georgia Hardstark
Kelly's good. That was only the first one.
Karen Kilgariff
Thank you, Kelly, for sparking and igniting. Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Our new show, Sirens of San Juan,
Karen Kilgariff
the McNeil Lehrer News Hour. Okay, I'm not gonna read you the subject line. It just says, dear Karen in Georgia, longtime listener, devoted acolyte. You recently mentioned parts of the Golden State Killer timeline that snapped a 30 year old memory into focus. A little Googling and some deeply unwelcome pattern recognition later, I'm fairly certain Joseph d' Angelo was in my bedroom closet in the fall of 1983. Fuck.
Georgia Hardstark
I fucking love these stories. Oh, my. I mean, I hate them. But when you have that realization that, oh, that thing happened. I found the rope that one time under my couch. And there shouldn't have been a rope there, but I couldn't figure out why. Okay, please. Sorry. Go.
Karen Kilgariff
No, no. That is. I think of the Golden State Killer's whole story. Him hiding shit in the furniture to come back later is so diabolical and upsetting. Demonic.
Georgia Hardstark
Demonic. Like, okay, and then stealing one earring and you're like, where'd that one earring go? That doesn't make any Sense.
Karen Kilgariff
It's mind fuckery. Like days before you're gonna do the worst thing.
Georgia Hardstark
You're not gonna call the cops and be like, I think someone was in here.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. No.
Georgia Hardstark
Cause what'd they do? You lost an ear? Oh, my God.
Karen Kilgariff
No, he just is starting to rip the seam of.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, you're fucking.
Karen Kilgariff
Am I? Okay, okay. Well, okay, and perfect point, because listen to this. We had just moved to Woodland Hills. Foothills, middle class suburbia. Easy access to the one and backyards attached to long corridors of green space. I was 15. And yes, Karen, yes, I was a latchkey kid. Georgia was too. One afternoon I came home to find that we'd been burglarized. But it was a weird one. The expensive stereo still there, valuables untouched. What was missing? My dad's wedding band. My mom's diamondless engagement ring, which had lost its diamond long ago during a diaper change.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, God. Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
Resale value zero symbolism. 100 and a single $20 bill from my bedroom. Cue teenage fury. Also missing, my dad's enormous, very sharp chef's knife.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh.
Karen Kilgariff
But it wasn't stolen. It was placed pointy and out on a shelf in my closet.
Georgia Hardstark
Goodbye. Never going in there again. Oh, my God.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. Just cemented over.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
At the time, my parents assumed the rings were taken for gold value. No one was publicly talking yet about a man who targeted wedding symbols and piggy banks and moved through suburban neighborhoods via freeway corridors true to his M.O. we also received a series of hang up calls. Heavy breathing, then a click. I carelessly assumed it was some random creep who kept redialing because I kept answering. Not someone from my closet. Today, following standard MFM advice, I called my dad. I laid out my case. There was a long pause. It was like six O's. Then he said, well, it is true there was a rash of similar break ins all over the neighborhood at the time.
Georgia Hardstark
Jesus.
Karen Kilgariff
The Golden State Killer was documented in ventura county in 1981 and Orange county in 1986.
Georgia Hardstark
Woodland Hills is right in the middle of it. Right.
Karen Kilgariff
Woodland Hills sits neatly between them with the 101 running straight through.
Georgia Hardstark
If you call Paul Holes and say, I bet they have those two rings still in evidence. Oh, yeah, right, right.
Karen Kilgariff
Also, it's so creepy to just go into people's houses and touch the things that are like. This means love. This means family.
Georgia Hardstark
Just like I know the confusion and fear I'm going to put in your mind.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, okay. Back in 83, my dad's response to the incident was to buy a Labrador.
Georgia Hardstark
That's Great.
Karen Kilgariff
Knowing now that d' Angelo famously avoided homes with dogs, I give full credit to Oreo for saving our lives.
Georgia Hardstark
Oreo Cookie.
Karen Kilgariff
So thank you for giving me the framework to retroactively terrify myself and then call every member of my family to inform them they survived the Golden State Killer.
Georgia Hardstark
Holy.
Karen Kilgariff
You're welcome, family. Ssdgm. And maybe check for knives in your closet. EMMA, Long Beach, CA oh my God. And then it says, P.S. turns out the SoCal killing started around the time DeAngelo and his wife bought a second home in Long Beach. Shut up, Emma. You are the forest Gump of the Golden State Killers. Timeline. Oh God, that is so too close for comfort. That is just unbelievable.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, because he would do it and then he'd have like a couple places that were available. So that night, if he couldn't get into that one, he'd go to this one instead just to make sure he always had one available. So he went back and they had a dog and he was like, well, it's not that one tonight, right?
Karen Kilgariff
Or somebody flicks their light on in the backyard and he has to like, go to the. I mean, right?
Georgia Hardstark
Dude. Dude and a half.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Brought to you by Apple Card. Apple card users get 2% daily cash back on purchases made in store and online, whether it's for big ticket items or everyday purchases. When they use their Apple Card with Apple Pay now, that's a benefit that's just too good to pass up. You could be earning 2% daily cash back when you use your Apple Card with Apple Pay to buy turmeric for your signature curry, 2% back on flights to visit the family in Tucson, and even 2% back on your kid's new tuba. You might even be able to get 2% back on a tuba tutorial. Not an Apple Card customer. You can apply in the Wallet app on iPhone, subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs bank usa, Salt Lake City Branch terms and more at Apple Co Benefits.
Georgia Hardstark
It's that time of year when you look around your house and think it's time for an update.
Karen Kilgariff
Luckily, Article makes it effortless to create a stylish home with long lasting pieces at an unbeatable price.
Georgia Hardstark
Article offers a curated range of mid century, modern, coastal and scandi inspired pieces.
Karen Kilgariff
Article takes great care in curating its collection, focusing solely on meaningful pieces. Pieces that will stand the test of time. There's no filler. Every item is chosen for its craftsmanship, design and lasting value.
Georgia Hardstark
With Article's 30 day satisfaction guarantee, you can shop with confidence, knowing that if you're not completely in love with your new furniture, you can easily return it.
Karen Kilgariff
Article's Customer Care Team is available seven days a week, offering knowledgeable support and even free interior design services to help you get your home just right.
Georgia Hardstark
Yes, please.
Karen Kilgariff
Don't we all kind of need that like the eye of an expert.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Where should I put this? And also what should I move here
Georgia Hardstark
and there and what should I even get? But Article has it all so you can get whatever there.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right. You could be like I have this thing. Should I get this one or that? Totally.
Georgia Hardstark
Am I scandi or am I mid century?
Karen Kilgariff
Help me be Boho chic, please.
Georgia Hardstark
If you're in the market for a beautiful new sofa, dining table or bed, head over to article.com goodbye.
Karen Kilgariff
There are so many great ways to spend your time, like shopping online or wondering what kind of bird you'd be if you were a bird.
Georgia Hardstark
Planning a financial future is rarely at the top of anyone's to do list.
Karen Kilgariff
But with Acorns, it's easy to start investing and give your money a chance to grow.
Georgia Hardstark
Acorns is easy. You can sign up in minutes and start automatically investing, even if it's your spare change. Sign up now and Acorns will boost your new account with a $5 bonus.
Karen Kilgariff
Investment join the over 14 million all time customers who have already saved and invested over $27 billion with Acorns.
Georgia Hardstark
Head to acorns.com mfm or download the Acorns app to get started.
Karen Kilgariff
Paid non client endorsement compensation provides incentive to positively promote acorns.
Georgia Hardstark
Tier 2 compensation provided potential subjects of various factors such as customers accounts, age and investment settings.
Karen Kilgariff
Does not include Acorns fees. Results do not predict or represent the performance of any Acorns portfolio. Investment results will vary. Investing involves risk.
Georgia Hardstark
Acorns Advisors LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor. View important disclosures@acorns.com MFM Goodbye. This is about a child witch. That's funny. Hello MFM fam Karen, Georgia, Vince and Patrick when my mom and her siblings were growing up in the Milwaukee suburbs in the 1960s, the summer parenting method was very much go outside until I call you for meals, which was great for neighborhood kick the can, bike races, et cetera. But it also led to power struggles, boredom and of course, witchcraft.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right, cause you would just be left to your own devices all day.
Georgia Hardstark
I think we did all of those things, yeah. One summer morning, my mom and her younger brother Greg, little Greg, were bored with the usual games and decided to set up the garage For a seance as you do. They hung up tarps, lit candles, set up a table, and made a crystal ball from an old round cherry jar. Glitter and food coloring. Next, they needed a witch. As they hadn't been out in the neighborhood yet, they decided it should be Greg. I guess my mom being a girl seemed too obvious a choice to fool the other kids. My mom found an old Halloween costume, painted Greg's face and put on a mop wig.
Karen Kilgariff
The smell.
Georgia Hardstark
She then went into the neighborhood to gather the neighborhood kids, explaining that Greg had the flu, but that their aunt was in town from far away and that she was a witch. And did they want to meet her. Greg's not here right now.
Karen Kilgariff
Greg's very, very busy with his work.
Georgia Hardstark
Right. I know you've never seen Greg and the Switch together, but trust me.
Karen Kilgariff
But listen, as similar as they look, Greg takes after his aunt.
Georgia Hardstark
Does Greg have a fucking mop of hair? No, he does not.
Karen Kilgariff
Does he? Gifts from the beyond? I don't think so.
Georgia Hardstark
Would they want to meet her? Which of course they did. Especially after my mom said that she could see the future and call dead people that the witch could.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, the mom got into it.
Georgia Hardstark
So the mom is the big sister. This is the her story. Sorry.
Karen Kilgariff
Got you. I thought, like, there was a true adult coming in from the out with apron on, being like, no, no, it is a witch.
Georgia Hardstark
Right. Much fundamental. One by one, the kids came into the garage wanting to know their future. No one cared about the dead, I guess. One by one, my uncle, the witch explained that it was very grim and that the children and their families would die all caps, if they did not shower at midnight. The kids left terrified, and my mom and uncle were delighted by their prank. At 12:15 in the morning, my mom, Uncle Greg and their parents awoke to 11 phone calls by neighbors with freshly showered and scared little kids. My mom and uncle were promptly grounded and probably whacked with a wooden spoon. Yep, had that, too.
Karen Kilgariff
Just really quick. So sorry to interrupt, but, like, the first phone call goes down. I'm so sorry. Yes, we'll take care of it.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
The second the phone hits, the rest of it.
Georgia Hardstark
Eleven phone calls.
Karen Kilgariff
Just rolling calls.
Georgia Hardstark
They were grounded. Whatever. Probably walked to the wooden spoon. But also extremely proud that their prank worked.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right.
Georgia Hardstark
My mom grew up to be an OG Murderino who still checks her for perps and pervs on a nightly basis. What the fuck?
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
And my uncle joined a biker gang.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, my God. Everything turned out great for these kids. I Love them. Thank you for all you do. And encouraging people to speak up. Fuck politeness, Discuss mental illness and in General, be wonderful. P.S. karen, my mom's birthday is May 12th and mine is May 10th. We should meet up for cake.
Karen Kilgariff
Hey, a week of cake.
Georgia Hardstark
Stay sexy and don't tell children to shower at midnight. Best, Marissa.
Karen Kilgariff
Those fucking weirded out parents that are just like, uh.
Georgia Hardstark
I love that he like the kids. Like Greg, like thought of a way to like control them, but not in a way that was like evil. Just in a like fuck with you kind of way.
Karen Kilgariff
Do what I say.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, like, it wasn't like jump from the roof.
Karen Kilgariff
No, exactly. It was. You're gonna be cold and irritated and terrified. But no one can really get me in trouble. Really?
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
But I mean, they did. I guess.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. You know, those parents were a little proud.
Karen Kilgariff
Well, I mean. Cause it worked.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
How many times did you try to like convince neighborhood kids of something? They're all like, what? Shut up.
Georgia Hardstark
Is that true? Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Just never listen to anything. No.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
Greetings murder mavens and all the furry critters, including Steven's mustache. I've got a secret life hometown that culminates with a deathbed treasure hunt. Yes, when I met my now wife, her father was a trim carpenter living a modest life. But occasional comments hinted at a more storied past. Most puzzling might be the warning that if we were ever in the Bahamas and were asked, we should say we didn't know him. I love that. And definitely were not related to him. My curiosity got the better of me and I did some web sleuthing and discovered a newspaper article from the 80s linking him to a retired major league baseball player who had been arrested for running marijuana.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh shit.
Karen Kilgariff
My father in law was listed as the co pilot of the private plane they were using.
Georgia Hardstark
Dude, he took cocaine. Be
Karen Kilgariff
he had never mentioned having a license or knowing how to fly a plane. Oh my God. To secretly discover Marty could fucking fly a Cessna if he wanted to.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, actually my stepdad John has some like cool secrets that you would not know. Really that I'm not supposed to know that I shouldn't be talking about on this national podcast. I didn't say what they are.
Karen Kilgariff
Here's what I'm gonna guess.
Georgia Hardstark
What?
Karen Kilgariff
He was a sniper in Vietnam.
Georgia Hardstark
He was it. He was in Vietnam.
Karen Kilgariff
Whoops. We're going back to the email. John, my apologies. It's none of anybody's business.
Georgia Hardstark
I'm trying to get him to.
Karen Kilgariff
But thank you for your service. Okay, okay. This man's cool points tripled in that moment and I couldn't wait to hear the story firsthand. Unfortunately, my father in law did not see this as his proudest moment and shut down the conversation immediately. Those the old school guys are. They don't want to be. You can't be a criminal, you can't be a bad guy.
Georgia Hardstark
No. You can't have done something in your youth that you're in talk about it on a podcast like I do. Right?
Karen Kilgariff
But that's. Thank God that we fucked up as much as we did because we have
Georgia Hardstark
so much to talk about and zero shame.
Karen Kilgariff
Right? And kind of like a need to get a little attention here and there. Sadly, he passed away about a year later. And thus begins the deathbed treasure hunt part of the story he always told my wife. If anything ever happens to me, check my chair. I love this guy. We always suspected he stashed cash around, and now, knowing his past, it made sense why he liked to keep income undocumented.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, shit.
Karen Kilgariff
He also had a fear that every time he was ill, it was going to be the end and would write a letter to my wife telling her where to find his stashes. So we had three conflicting treasure maps to work with.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, what a joyous gift to give your child.
Karen Kilgariff
Please give this to me when you die. Okay, start planning it now.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay. I'm thinking, like, where do I send her?
Karen Kilgariff
Where could I? We found envelopes of cash taped to the bottom of his dresser, tucked on top of the kitchen cabinets, in the lining of his chair, et cetera. The grand total was 10k. What I mean, but it wasn't the most valuable find. In the garage was a locked file cabinet with no key. It's like my mouth is water. Just around the house. We considered taking it to the dumpster as is, but something told me if it was worth locking, then there had to be something in there worth finding. Please use that kind of deduction in your life. Why would this be happening? Maybe I don't, maybe I don't.
Georgia Hardstark
Just right.
Karen Kilgariff
I don't know what I'm so mad at.
Georgia Hardstark
Have you seen the Instagrammer of the guy who's just spending every day trying to find a diamond?
Karen Kilgariff
Yes. I love him and the shit he's finding.
Georgia Hardstark
Day 32 of trying to find a diamond, a kitty cat, a bead.
Karen Kilgariff
It's so satisfying.
Georgia Hardstark
It's so satisfying.
Karen Kilgariff
And then you're like, the bead is the diamond.
Georgia Hardstark
Today you're like, yay. Cause I want you to keep doing it.
Karen Kilgariff
It's so cute. It makes me feel like that guy was a mudlarker.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Or watches mudlarking videos. And it's like, I'll never get to do that.
Georgia Hardstark
Totally.
Karen Kilgariff
But I'll do it here in this gutter.
Georgia Hardstark
I love him.
Karen Kilgariff
It's so good. Yeah, there's like, a little whatever he uses, like a screwdriver. Digging out the cracks in the sidewalk.
Georgia Hardstark
He finds the most random shit, but he's, like, so calm and asmr about it.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, I love it. We love that guy.
Georgia Hardstark
No diamond today. A kitty.
Karen Kilgariff
No diamond today. Day 32 of searching for a diamond. Okay, we're back in this email.
Georgia Hardstark
Sorry.
Karen Kilgariff
And we're really gonna focus this time.
Georgia Hardstark
Locked thing.
Karen Kilgariff
Locked file cabinet.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay,
Karen Kilgariff
here we go. God damn it. Okay, here it is. So I went to work with a variety of prying and hammering tools. Success. Among the receipts for every prescription he and his wife purchased from 1977 to 1987. I mean, that's what a lot of my junk drawers look like, is things I'm afraid to throw away.
Georgia Hardstark
What if I need it? What if I need it?
Karen Kilgariff
A receipt for a prescription. Like, stuff like that. When they give you the thing that's all stapled and there's all the information, I'm like, like, better keep it. Okay. So among those items was a folder that told the whole story of his misdeeds. Yes, during this time, he ran a moderately successful typewriter ribbon re inking company. We might. They might as well put his name in. Who else has that company? It's the most specific job of all time. Which provided a great cover. Oh, my God. For all of his travel up and down the east coast. So a typewriter ribbon re inking company is a cover for drug running?
Georgia Hardstark
Sure. I don't know. No one knows how that works, so why wouldn't it? Yeah, yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
It's so specific. It's like those independent vacuum cleaner stores on Burbank Boulevard where you're like, what
Georgia Hardstark
are you talking about? You fix fucking vacuums?
Karen Kilgariff
Post Covid.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
You still got a brick and mortar post 1989. If you fucking do this, are the good people at mealy sending you thousands, hundreds of thousands of dollars? Okay, so typewriter, ribbon, ring, inking company providing a great cover for all his travel up and down the east coast. In reality, he was a legit drug mule running cocaine from Florida to Massachusetts. He kept a newspaper clipping from a trial where he turned state's evidence and testified to taping bags of cocaine to his body. And then in parentheses, it says, you Know, like you see in the movies. He hand wrote his fine on the clipping. They got it wrong in the article. So he was arrested and fined.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God. And he hand wrote. He was like, they're wrong.
Karen Kilgariff
It's just like. Actually it was 16,000. He ended up doing a year in prison. He sent my wife a handmade Christmas card that year. That was also in the folder. And then we found the official letter from the Republic of the Bahamas informing him he was no longer welcome in their country, ever.
Georgia Hardstark
What?
Karen Kilgariff
We were just there.
Georgia Hardstark
Too bad he's. Yeah. Good thing he's not a podcaster.
Karen Kilgariff
I know. Cause it's gorgeous and there's podcasting. I really hate that he was embarrassed by this part of his life, as I'm sure he had some wild stories to tell. Yeah, I agree. He should have felt free and easy. He got through it.
Georgia Hardstark
But if you're a boomer and you're listening and you have some crazy fucking story that you're ashamed of. We are not ashamed of you. Please send it to us.
Karen Kilgariff
No. This is a time that is very different than pre Internet times where shame and keeping up with the Joneses really controlled most people's lives.
Georgia Hardstark
Right?
Karen Kilgariff
Not like that anymore.
Georgia Hardstark
No, we're fine with it.
Karen Kilgariff
And also, everybody loves an anti hero.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah,
Karen Kilgariff
but don't do drugs. I really hit. As for my mother in law, it does explain why they got divorced. We haven't told her that we discovered the big family secret. I picture her as a Skyler White type, enjoying the spoils but not wanting to know how they could afford a Corvette. Stay sexy and don't let a locked filing cabinet deter your treasure hunt.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God. Tea.
Karen Kilgariff
God, that's so good.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
A secret life as a cocaine runner is pretty incredible.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
If your dad has a boring job or mom has a boring job, ask
Georgia Hardstark
them what they did.
Karen Kilgariff
Ask them to please finally be honest with you.
Georgia Hardstark
Ask them why they never want to go to the Bahamas anyway. What do you mean?
Karen Kilgariff
Why was that person at TSA giving you that dirty look?
Georgia Hardstark
Right. You don't even. You can't go to Canada
Karen Kilgariff
for everybody up there.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Brought to you by Apple Card. Apple card users get 2% daily cash back on purchases made in store and online, whether it's for big ticket items or everyday purchases. When they use their Apple Card with Apple Pay now that's a benefit that's just too good to pass up. You could be earning 2% daily cash back when you use your Apple Card with Apple Pay to buy turmeric for your signature curry, 2% back on flights to visit the family in Tucson and even 2% back on your kid's new tuba. You might even be able to get 2% back on a tuba tutor not an Apple Card customer. You can apply in the Wallet app on iPhone subject to credit approval. Apple card issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City Branch Terms and more at Apple Co Benefits it's easy
Karen Kilgariff
to make your drive amazing with reclining seats that melt the tension away, thoughtful tech and charging ports that keep every device powered.
Georgia Hardstark
Make every day epic with the Hyundai Palisade Hybrid.
Karen Kilgariff
It features class leading interior space and available front and second row relaxation seats that let you really recline and unwind
Georgia Hardstark
the 2.5T hybrid engine with up to an EPA estimated 619 miles of range on select trims. It's built for long hauls, quick errands and everything in between no matter where you're headed.
Karen Kilgariff
The available 14 speaker Bose sound system makes for an immersive ride and the
Georgia Hardstark
Palisade Hybrid comes with an available class exclusive dash camera feature and available class exclusive blind spot view monitor for extra
Karen Kilgariff
peace of mind seating configurations for seven
Georgia Hardstark
to eight passengers and with available H track all wheel drive, you're ready to go anywhere in style.
Karen Kilgariff
Need more? You've got standard 100 watt USB C ports to keep every device powered and
Georgia Hardstark
a standard passenger talk intercom so you can threaten to turn this SUV around if you kids don't knock it off. Without taking your eyes off the road,
Karen Kilgariff
the all new Hyundai Palisade Hybrid is more than just another suv. It's still the Palisade, but with so much more.
Georgia Hardstark
Learn more about the Hyundai palisade@hyundai USA.com
Karen Kilgariff
Call 562-314-4603 for complete details.
Georgia Hardstark
Goodbye.
Karen Kilgariff
This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace.
Georgia Hardstark
Anyone can have a great idea, but making it real starts with a domain name and a website.
Karen Kilgariff
And that's where Squarespace comes in.
Georgia Hardstark
Squarespace offers powerful design tools that make it easy to build a beautiful professional website that fits your brand or business.
Karen Kilgariff
Getting started is easy. You'll choose from a library of award winning website templates and with their intuitive drag and drop editing and beautiful styling options, you'll be up and running in no time.
Georgia Hardstark
Squarespace lets you showcase consultations, events and experiences and then get paid with professional invoices and online payments.
Karen Kilgariff
You can offer courses, videos, blogs or memberships directly on your site, all behind a paywall you control.
Georgia Hardstark
Go to squarespace.com murder for a free
Karen Kilgariff
trial and when you're ready to launch use offer code murder to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Goodbye.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay, this is called finders keepers. This one's gross. Hello, Murder matriarchs and co. Thanks, blah blah. You know the rest. I have a brother who is three years younger than me. But by the time we were 2 and 5, he easily weighed as much as me and could hold his own in any fight. When he was 7 or so, we thought he was partially dead. My dad thought it was selective hearing, but eventually my mom took him to the doctor to get it checked out. The doctor comes into the room and starts testing things and uses that weird flashlight to look inside my little brother's ears.
Karen Kilgariff
I wanted one of those really bad.
Georgia Hardstark
The lights, the little.
Karen Kilgariff
The thing that. Where they're like, hey, how are you today? Da da da.
Georgia Hardstark
Vince would fucking hide it from me if I had it. I'd be like chasing around the house.
Karen Kilgariff
What's in there?
Georgia Hardstark
I love that shit. Okay. When he looks in my brother's right ear, he pauses, keeps the flashlight in the ear and grabs a pair of long thin tweezers. This is what hometowns have become and I'm so happy for it. It's that and it's this and that's okay.
Karen Kilgariff
Secret parent drug runners and shoving shit up your nose or ears. Sorry, wherever.
Georgia Hardstark
Then he proceeds to slowly extract a wax covered bead from my brother's ear. A bead. No diamond today.
Karen Kilgariff
He pulled it out and said, no diamond today.
Georgia Hardstark
No diamond today. Oh, but the diamond was in the ring, but it wasn't. My mom's jaw drops to the floor and when my brother sees it, he says, oh, I put that in there to hide from Georgia. And it says me because I didn't want her to use it.
Karen Kilgariff
This person's name is Georgia?
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, that's crazy.
Georgia Hardstark
I know. It had been in there for four fucking years.
Karen Kilgariff
And how old was this little brother?
Georgia Hardstark
Seven? Nope, not deaf. Just hiding from his siblings using three year old logic. And also, who lets a three year old play with beads? Another bygone time, I would. They're not allowed to.
Karen Kilgariff
They truly like the man looking for the diamond. That little kid found that thing on the floor, thought it was beautiful and was like mine.
Georgia Hardstark
Y stay sexy and check your children's orifices with some regularity. Georgia.
Karen Kilgariff
Such a trip to hear an email from Georgia. Thank you for finally writing in. That's so hilarious. And the reason I said shove it up your nose is because there's an infamous family story where my mom Looked at me one day and I had green shit running out of one nostril. I've told you this one.
Georgia Hardstark
I think so. I don't remember.
Karen Kilgariff
And I had to go to the emergency room and they just. They pulled out a big piece of foam.
Georgia Hardstark
Why'd you put foam in there?
Karen Kilgariff
I was bored. They used to leave me alone all the time. What am I supposed to do? Not shove shit up my nose. But it was like, she was like, I think she's really sick. It's like green snot coming. Whatever. She goes. He puts tweezers up there. And then it's just like. Is this your child's?
Georgia Hardstark
Send your email to my favorite murdermail about orifice origin stories.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay. Above the belt, orifice origin stories, please.
Georgia Hardstark
Thank you.
Karen Kilgariff
Family friendly.
Georgia Hardstark
You know that one guy who they like he was dying and they opened up his body and they found a little tree growing in his lung. Cause he had inhaled a seed. That's just one of those stories I think about when I can't sleep at night.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, because you're like what do I got in there?
Georgia Hardstark
Right? Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
Bougainvillea. I forgot about that. It was like a sprout in his lung.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
So crazy.
Georgia Hardstark
He's like. Couldn't breathe and was like dying and
Karen Kilgariff
then they're like, he's like drinking theraflu
Georgia Hardstark
and like no, actually there's a Christmas tree in your.
Karen Kilgariff
You're a tree. You've become a tree.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay, come on.
Karen Kilgariff
Subject line of this email. Quick one. I ran over myself with my own car. Less than 2 minute read beautiful besties that I've never met. When I was 16, I eagerly got my license like any other teenage girl. The car I was handed down was a 1986 Subaru GL. The car was only a year younger than me so you can guess the safety features were non existent. I've only had my license for about two weeks when I pulled into my driveway after a party one night. My parents house is up a semi steep hill and off the road a little bit. I got out of the car and was standing between my car door and the driver's side when the car starts rolling backwards. For some reason I thought that I could stop the car by simply pushing against the door frame. But before I knew it, the door knocked me down and one of the tires ran over my right leg.
Georgia Hardstark
Jesus.
Karen Kilgariff
I mean you could have died. Don't drink and drive is what I was trying to tell you. The car rolled into the yard and into a tree. My border collie mix, Cindy Just simply looking at me until the car crashed, then decided to bark and alert my parents. Yeah, Cindy's a narc. What the hell happened, you ask? I forgot to put the car into park, which I still do to this day. But thank goodness for modern safety features. When I showed up to school limping with the gigantic bruise on my leg, I lied and told my friends that something had been wrong with the car and that park had been stripped out of the gear shift. So if any of my high school friends are murderinos and remember this happening. I lied to you out of embarrassment. Sorry. I guess. Stay sexy and don't forget to put your car in park.
Georgia Hardstark
Megan, I want to hear the best stories of people who did a really dumb thing and then blamed it on something totally like that had nothing to do with it.
Karen Kilgariff
Just covered in lie because it was so embarrassing.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, and they maybe got caught.
Karen Kilgariff
We have family friends who the daughter went to take her driving test and passed. And everyone thought she wasn't going to because she was crazy smart. Like became a surgeon, I think, but was very like not there. Everything else in the other way. So she passed, pulled up in front of her house and was so excited she jumped out of the car to run in to tell her dad and the car kept going. Cause it was not only not in park, it was just. She just got out.
Georgia Hardstark
Thank you.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Is that it?
Georgia Hardstark
That's it.
Karen Kilgariff
I think that's it.
Georgia Hardstark
Thanks for listening, everyone. If you want to hear more, we have one more bonus story on our fan culture. If you feel like it.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right. You can join our fan cults@my favoritemurder.com and then you can have all the secret content that we won't. Just give it any old person that swings by.
Georgia Hardstark
Who do you think you are?
Karen Kilgariff
God damn.
Georgia Hardstark
Stay sexy and don't get murdered. Goodbye, Elvis. Do you want a cookie?
Karen Kilgariff
This has been an exactly right production.
Georgia Hardstark
Our senior producer is Molly Smith and our associate producer is Tessa Hughes.
Karen Kilgariff
Our editor is Aristotle Acevedo.
Georgia Hardstark
This episode was mixed by Liana Squillace.
Karen Kilgariff
Email your hometowns to my favorite murdermail.com
Georgia Hardstark
follow the show on Instagram at. My favorite murder.
Karen Kilgariff
Listen to my favorite murder on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Georgia Hardstark
And now you can watch My favorite Murder on Netflix.
Karen Kilgariff
And when you're there, hit the double thumbs up and the remind me buttons. That's the best way you can support our show. Goodbye. Vacation planning should feel like a breeze, not a deep dive. Into countless travel sites searching for The
Georgia Hardstark
Best Deal With Cheap Caribbean's Budget Beach Finder, you can search every destination and every date all in one search.
Karen Kilgariff
You'll save time and money with the Budget Beach Finder.
Georgia Hardstark
Say goodbye to endless scrolling and tab hopping and hello to Budget Beachbody bliss at your fingertips.
Karen Kilgariff
Go to cheapcaribbean.com to try out the Budget Beach Finder and see just how stress free vacation planning should be.
Georgia Hardstark
Goodbye. Spring cleaning is all about getting your
Karen Kilgariff
house in order and the last step is making sure it's protected too.
Georgia Hardstark
That's where SimpliSafe comes in.
Karen Kilgariff
Simplisafe offers more than just a camera. It's a full system with sensors, cameras for inside and outside your home, and 24. 7 professional monitoring.
Georgia Hardstark
If there's a break in, fire or flood, SimpliSafe's agents are ready to take action.
Karen Kilgariff
There are no long term contracts, no lock ins and no hidden cancellation fees. Simplisafe earns your business by helping you keep your home protected, not by trapping you into a contract.
Georgia Hardstark
More than 5 million people trust Simply Safe every day and U.S. news World Report named it the best home security system of 2026.
Karen Kilgariff
I really love the fact that they make it so clear that you will not be trapped into a contract because how many things do you order these days? And suddenly you realize they signed you up for a subscription or like you're paying fees you never even thought you were agreeing to. And like this is all right there upfront Total.
Georgia Hardstark
I know. I love Simply Safe because I know that they won't trap you, but I know that the minute you sign up with them, you're going to want to stay with them forever. So it's kind of a win win.
Karen Kilgariff
Everyone deserves that same peace of mind, which is why SimpliSafe is offering an exclusive discount to our listeners right now.
Georgia Hardstark
You can get 50% off your new system by visiting simplisafe.com fave.
Karen Kilgariff
That's half off@simplisafe.com fav.
Georgia Hardstark
There's no safe like simply safe.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Goodbye Brought to you by Apple Card. Hey, you could be earning 2% daily cash back on that purchase. And that and even that one. That's because Apple card users earn 2% daily cash back on every purchase, including everyday items they buy online or in store when using their Apple Card. With Apple Pay, not an Apple Card customer, you can apply in the Wallet app on iPhone subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City Branch Terms and more at Apple Co Benefits.
Podcast: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Episode: Minisode 485
Date: April 27, 2026
Duration of main content: 02:00 to 39:01 (excluding ads, intro, outro)
This MFM minisode features Karen and Georgia reading listener-submitted "hometown" stories that blend true crime, dark humor, and offbeat family tales. Stories include a ferry captain's disastrous flirtation, a brush with the Golden State Killer, a mischievous childhood séance, a hidden criminal past revealed through a posthumous treasure hunt, bizarre body orifice discoveries, and an embarrassing car accident cover-up. Throughout, Karen and Georgia riff, laugh, commiserate over victim-blaming, and encourage listeners to share their wildest family secrets—reminding everyone to "stay sexy and don't get murdered."
[02:25 - 09:13]
[09:17 - 14:13]
[17:01 - 20:47]
[21:27 - 29:10]
[32:33 - 34:44]
[36:08 - 37:43]
Minisode 485 brings exactly what fans love: true crime–infused family weirdness, friendly banter, victim advocacy, and a sense of community among listeners who love a good hometown tale—no matter how ridiculous, harrowing, or oddly heartwarming. Whether it’s madness at sea, a near-miss with a serial killer, glitter and pranks, hidden criminal pasts, or the simple agony of living down your own dumb move, Karen and Georgia turn it all into relatable, cathartic comedy.