
Loading summary
Karen Kilgariff
This is exactly right.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Brought to you by Apple Card. Hey, you could be earning 2% daily cash back on that purchase. And that one. And even that one. That's because Apple card users earn 2% daily cash back on every purchase, including everyday items they buy online or in store when using their Apple Card. With Apple Pay, not an Apple Card customer, you can apply in the Wallet app on iPhone, subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs bank usa, Salt Lake City branch terms and more at Apple Co Benefits this Mother's
Georgia Hardstark
Day celebrate the woman behind it all with Pandora Jewelry.
Steven Ray Morris
Get your mom some jewelry that feels personal and reflects the moments that matter most.
Georgia Hardstark
Whether that's a date, a name, or a shared memory. You can make it even more meaningful with an engraving in your own handwriting.
Steven Ray Morris
Because the best Mother's Day gift says more than just I love you.
Georgia Hardstark
Find the perfect Mother's Day gift at your local Pandora store or online@pandora.net Goodbye.
Steven Ray Morris
Allergy season does not slow down when you're on the move. That's why Kleenex Ultra Soft tissues are ready whenever sneezes strike.
Georgia Hardstark
Kleenex Ultra Soft tissues are allergist approved and silky soft for up to 100% irritation free skin.
Steven Ray Morris
And now with the new Kleenex Snap and Go, you get that same gentle care made for life on the go.
Georgia Hardstark
Get the Kleenex Ultra Soft tissues you love in a new compact, durable package.
Steven Ray Morris
New Kleenex Snap and go. Snap.
Karen Kilgariff
Snap.
Steven Ray Morris
Shut for a clean tissue anytime, anywhere.
Georgia Hardstark
For whatever happens next, grab Kleenex Snap and go.
Karen Kilgariff
Goodbye,
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
My favorite.
Steven Ray Morris
Hello, hello and welcome to To Rewind
Georgia Hardstark
with Karen and Georgia.
Steven Ray Morris
That's right, it's Wednesday. And that means it's time for us to recap our old episodes with all new commentary, updates and insights.
Georgia Hardstark
Today we're Gonna recap episode 92, which we named the Halloween special. That's so creative of us.
Karen Kilgariff
Why, but why, you ask? Well, you'll see.
Steven Ray Morris
Let's listen to the intro of episode 90.
Georgia Hardstark
Hi.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, hi, Georgia. Hi. So nice to see you.
Georgia Hardstark
Nice to see you, Karen. Love your green top.
Karen Kilgariff
Thank you. This is my one of two blouses.
Georgia Hardstark
There's color. I like the color.
Karen Kilgariff
I just decided to go with some color.
Georgia Hardstark
It's bright, it shocks people, it brings things out of you.
Karen Kilgariff
It brings. About four minutes ago, I had fake eyelashes on.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, my God.
Karen Kilgariff
And yet then the rest of me is dressed like I've been in bed for four days. It's a great combination.
Georgia Hardstark
Well, I have something to tell you.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay.
Georgia Hardstark
I mean, it's not a Big deal. But as of today, Mimi is on Prozac. What? My cat? Yeah. Am I the most Los Angeles person you've ever met in your fucking life? My cat and I are on pharmaceutical for depression and anxiety.
Karen Kilgariff
Wait, why is Mimi on Pros? Like, she's so chill.
Georgia Hardstark
She's a grumpy bitch, and she's unhappy.
Karen Kilgariff
Listen, where did you get the pros?
Georgia Hardstark
At my therapist.
Karen Kilgariff
You're not.
Georgia Hardstark
No, we took her to the vet, and I was like, look, she's just hiding in a box of my favorite murder merch all day.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, people love that. We should make them pay extra for.
Georgia Hardstark
Right. For Mimi fur. Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
So I'd be so pissed if I ordered some. A new shirt and be like, I have all my own animal hair. I don't need this.
Georgia Hardstark
So, as you can tell, this is the spooky episode of my favorite murder.
Karen Kilgariff
We start out with the creepiest thing of all. A cat on Prozac.
Georgia Hardstark
Everyone who's not from Los Angeles is like, what the fuck is wrong with these people?
Karen Kilgariff
That's hilarious. Oh, yeah. So this is our special Halloween episode.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Where because our normal show is not scary at all or creepy or a huge bummer. So we figured we'd go a little ghosty for you on this one, and we asked you guys to write us your personal real. We begged you to make them true.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. And we. We. We. We read for truth. Authenticity. Is that what it's. We read for authenticity to make sure you guys weren't lying liars who lied.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right. And Steven. Steven, a lot of people don't know this, but in his mustache, there is a lie detector. So he will sniff that shit out. The second literally sniff it out flicks that email open, he'll be like, no way.
Georgia Hardstark
Steven's mustache keeping my mustache is tingling.
Karen Kilgariff
There's lies in this email since 1985.
Georgia Hardstark
I don't know when he was born. I'm guessing it's 1985.
Karen Kilgariff
I bet it was in the late 80s.
Georgia Hardstark
87.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. I wasn't specific. I can't. I'm pretending to be that I won that somehow, and I didn't.
Georgia Hardstark
You did. And I just try too hard sometimes by guessing. You're bombed out. I'm gonna go.
Karen Kilgariff
Don't. Hey, take a Prozac real quick. Take one. Take one of Mimi's Prozacs. We're fine. Last night, George and I had dinner.
Producer/Editor
Steven, this.
Karen Kilgariff
You'll think this is funn. And one of the people at dinner was like, how long have you been doing this podcast. I was like, almost a year. George is like, almost two years. I was like, what? That blew my mind.
Georgia Hardstark
I know. Mine too. I think I asked you as a question. I wasn't like, two years, Karen. No, it was like, almost two years.
Karen Kilgariff
Wait, it must be two years.
Georgia Hardstark
That can't be right.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, man. Crazy. It's gone so fast. It's been so fun.
Georgia Hardstark
That's a million years in podcast years, I think.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, two years for real.
Georgia Hardstark
You know what I mean? Like, this is the infancy of podcasting, and so that means two years is a long time.
Karen Kilgariff
So this is a dog year situation. Is that what you're saying? Got it. So this is like her 17th year. Coming up on.
Georgia Hardstark
Yes. Do you know what we need to talk about?
Karen Kilgariff
What?
Georgia Hardstark
The thing that I. And everyone wants to talk about. This Mindhunter. Did I say it right?
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, that's how you pronounce it.
Georgia Hardstark
That's how you pronounce it. Great. So let's talk about it.
Karen Kilgariff
So you're a.
Georgia Hardstark
No, I'm not an. I am on, like, episode five, and I must. I'm a sometimes, Okay? I don't. I don't. I'm a sometimes. I don't wanna talk shit on it because I fucking like it. It's really cool and exciting. But the. And I. But it's. But I'm a sometimes.
Karen Kilgariff
Well, there's so much buildup, and I'm sure I had a lot to do with that because there's no way I wasn't gonna love this series. I just. I permanently loved it before I ever laid my eyes on it.
Producer/Editor
And there were.
Karen Kilgariff
It did, of course, because all pilots start slow and are difficult. But I loved it. And I love his directing and I love whoever Art directs for David Fincher.
Georgia Hardstark
There's, like, things like that I love. It's just like scene by scene that it's the interpersonal relationships of certain characters that I don't give a shit about. I love when they're actually interacting, interviewing the criminals. Then there's other. Like, the guy who played Ed Kemper needs all the awards.
Karen Kilgariff
In my mind, I start going, like, how did you cast this role? Because you have to get a guy that's like, we need people that they have to be over six' six. Like, they have to be really giant. But they also then have to be great actors. How many? It's not like, you know, LA is full of those people. So I'm like, this guy. I bet you they found this guy in, like, the Canadian Outback.
Georgia Hardstark
He's probably Really? A serial killer. That's his jail he's actually in.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, they were like this. He's just good. We have to hire him.
Georgia Hardstark
Listen, I know it's weird, but worse
Karen Kilgariff
things happen in Hollywood.
Georgia Hardstark
Wait, like what?
Karen Kilgariff
Every day. Oh, you've read the articles. But I. Yes, Ed Kemper. Like, for me, I was like, I'm in whatever is happening here and whatever
Producer/Editor
they're trying to develop.
Karen Kilgariff
Because I could feel that thing of their.
Steven Ray Morris
It was.
Karen Kilgariff
It's, you know, a period piece. Basically. It's like starts in the late 70s, all that.
Georgia Hardstark
Those old cars, man, I was thinking the same thing.
Karen Kilgariff
When they would kind of come around a corner and there would just be streets lined with old cars and all different, you know, they looked so real. I just. I don't know, I go way into the detail. But then I also love that actor. So the lead actor I love, he's like a. I mean, he's from a million things, but he's also like a Broadway star. He's a little sweet baby angel and beautiful and. Yeah. And kind of had the perfect.
Steven Ray Morris
Like.
Karen Kilgariff
That's not how you picture an FBI. Like some hard nosed cigarette smoke. So.
Georgia Hardstark
Reminds me of Dennis from It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia so much that I keep thinking it's a joke.
Karen Kilgariff
That it's gonna be like a sketch. Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
That like he actually is a horrible person. Yeah. I don't know. Yes, it's very. It's jarring to me. I mean, I'm gonna keep watching. Of course.
Karen Kilgariff
Keep watching. I binged it.
Producer/Editor
When.
Karen Kilgariff
I think it was when we were going. We were leaving for the Anaheim leg of the tour. I like to call our weekends legs of tours because that's how, you know, rock stars talk about it. But I bit. My friend Molly was like, oh, it's on right now because they put it up at midnight on Netflix. And I was like, what? So I started watching it at 1am the night before we left for that weekend. Because I was like. And I got. I think I got through the first five and then, you know, we had to leave. And then I came back at the end, which was so satisfying.
Georgia Hardstark
Well, Halloween is when we started hanging out two years ago.
Producer/Editor
That's.
Georgia Hardstark
Holy shit, right?
Karen Kilgariff
Nice one. Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
Halloween two years ago is when the podcast was born. It was in utero.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right.
Georgia Hardstark
That's when we planted the seed.
Karen Kilgariff
That's when we did it with our personalities.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. That's when we actually boned. And then, you know, you don't get pregnant for like two or three Days. Right. So it could take a while.
Steven Ray Morris
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
And that's when you were like, the inception moment was Georgia texting.
Producer/Editor
I can't remember.
Karen Kilgariff
Or calling me and then being like, let's just do a pod. Let's just do it.
Georgia Hardstark
Let's just do a podcast.
Karen Kilgariff
And I was like, well, okay, if you make it really easy for me, then I will. And you're like, I will.
Georgia Hardstark
Let's have a baby together. We'll name a podcast. We'll love her and caretake her. What are you gonna be for Halloween this year?
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, me? I'm gonna be on my couch. What? I am every year on my couch.
Georgia Hardstark
Good.
Karen Kilgariff
No, I actually. Our friend has a party that everybody goes to. That's a ridiculous, humongous.
Producer/Editor
Our friend Scotty.
Karen Kilgariff
And he said I promised him that if we were in town on the day he has it, that I will go. I always say I will remember the year that I was supposed to go. I dropped my phone in the pool. And then I couldn't tell you that
Georgia Hardstark
I wasn't going, but it was so boozy. I think you would have lost your mind anyways. Yeah, it's just like grown up alcohol, like grown up drunk kid party, but fun.
Karen Kilgariff
So, I mean, just kind of legendary. But also, I think I should do the thing of the old people going early. Who cares about this topic? For real. But I also.
Georgia Hardstark
Let's go early. I'll go early with you because I want to go.
Karen Kilgariff
Let's go early. And then also because the parking is so crazy in that neighborhood.
Georgia Hardstark
Look how old we are.
Karen Kilgariff
I mean, and these kids are so loud and they take marijuana.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, they're so loud and they take marijuana.
Karen Kilgariff
They will take marijuana right next to you.
Georgia Hardstark
And then how could you even see what anyone's dressed as?
Karen Kilgariff
It's too dark and your vision's gone because you're high on marijuana.
Steven Ray Morris
Okay, we're back.
Georgia Hardstark
Karen, how many blouses. Now that you're a full time podcaster with sponsorship deals left and right, how many blouses do you have?
Steven Ray Morris
I don't want to fuel the haters, but I think I have upwards of
Karen Kilgariff
six blouses at this point. So.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, I mean, and jewel tones, too. What if you had told Karen 2017 Karen, that she would be wearing jewel tones on the regular.
Steven Ray Morris
She'd spit in your eye, and then
Georgia Hardstark
she and Mimi would take their Prozac and fucking leave.
Steven Ray Morris
Prozac, Cher. I love the announcement of that where it's like, so, you know, do you feel like now 10 years later has Mimi's Mental health journey improved since those days?
Georgia Hardstark
No, we've just gotten comfortable with her anger. You know, Like, I realize it's not. It's not about what's around her or what's, you know, it's just her. She's mad. And now she's old and mad and has to live with a dog and little cat who, like, she's just not fond of. So I think that Mimi's biggest problem and Prozac isn't going to take care of this is that she's supposed to be an only cat, so.
Steven Ray Morris
And she's the opposite.
Karen Kilgariff
You're just like.
Steven Ray Morris
And I guarantee that will never happen to you, Mimi.
Georgia Hardstark
But she's going on strong. 2017 was a long time ago, and Mimi's still kicking it.
Steven Ray Morris
So I think we know a lot of people who are great examples of how bitterness and spite actually are great engines and really move you along really nicely.
Georgia Hardstark
Fuels the fire of life.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay, so this is an episode where we just read Halloween hometowns, which I love for us. Like, what a great way to fucking not have to do our homework for an episode.
Steven Ray Morris
Themed it out. This is back when I had two jobs. So we're just like, how about we
Karen Kilgariff
have other people do the work for us?
Georgia Hardstark
Yes. Right. And Steven's mustache can figure it all out for us.
Steven Ray Morris
That's right.
Georgia Hardstark
All right, let's get into some spooky hometowns.
Steven Ray Morris
Finding a gift on Mother's Day can
Georgia Hardstark
be tough, but with a gift from Aura Frames, you can say thank you and celebrate the life you share.
Steven Ray Morris
Aura Frames gives you free unlimited storage, so you can add as many photos and videos as you want.
Georgia Hardstark
You can preload photos before the frame ships and keep adding more from anywhere, anytime.
Steven Ray Morris
And every Aura Frame comes in a premium gift with no price tag included. I mean, we've talked about Aura Frames so many times, but I will tell you now, everybody in my family has Aura frames and, like, talks about each other's aura frames. They are a part of the hang when everybody comes over because there's just these beautiful family photos that roll through that frame that are from all different eras of our lives that you wouldn't sit down and, like, open up the photo album like you used to.
Georgia Hardstark
Named number one by wirecutter. You can save on the gifts moms love by visiting Oraframes.com for a limited time.
Steven Ray Morris
Listeners can get 25 off their best selling Carver map frame with code MFM.
Georgia Hardstark
That's a U R A frames.com promo
Steven Ray Morris
code MFM support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Brought to you by Apple Card Apple card users get 2% daily cash back on purchases made in store and online, whether it's for big ticket items or everyday purchases. When they use their Apple Card with Apple Pay now, that's a benefit that's just too good to pass up. You could be earning 2% daily cash back when you use your Apple Card with Apple Pay to buy Turmeric for your signature curry, 2% back on flights to visit the family in Tucson, and even 2% back on your kid's new tuba. You might even be able to get 2% back on a tuba tutor, not an Apple Card customer. You can apply in the Wallet app on iPhone subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs bank usa, Salt Lake City Branch Terms and more at Apple Ca this podcast is
Georgia Hardstark
brought to you by Squarespace Creative people
Steven Ray Morris
are not always great with project management, spreadsheets, or the concept of time.
Georgia Hardstark
Squarespace helps you get organized online with a website, scheduling, tools and payments all in one place.
Steven Ray Morris
Squarespace gives you everything you need to offer services and get paid.
Georgia Hardstark
You can build a customizable website for consultations, events, experiences, or whatever you're offering and make it easy for clients to find you.
Steven Ray Morris
Squarespace also helps the business side, making sure you get paid on time with professional invoices and online payments.
Georgia Hardstark
Plus streamline your workflow with built in appointment scheduling and email marketing tools.
Steven Ray Morris
And if you sell products, Squarespace can automatically calculate shipping costs in real time based on the destination size and weight of each order, which helps avoid overcharging or undercharging for shipping.
Georgia Hardstark
With Squarespace, you'll simplify your workflow and give customers a seamless shopping experience.
Steven Ray Morris
Head to squarespace.com murder for a free
Georgia Hardstark
trial and when you're ready to launch, use Offer Code murder to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
Karen Kilgariff
Goodbye.
Georgia Hardstark
We asked you guys to send us in scary stories and you guys interpreted that how you will. Steven's must lying mustache of justice yeah, sorted those out and here they are.
Karen Kilgariff
Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
Go Karen.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay, I'm going to read this one first. The subject line is I'm glad she didn't look us in the eye. Hi hey all Sociopath My story is from a couple years ago. My niece, 2 years old at the time, was standing on top of my desk pulling books out from the attached bookshelf. One by one I stood behind her, ensuring she didn't fall to her death should she trip on a Nancy Drew and Stumble. I spent so much of my life standing behind Nora, letting her do what she wanted and just being there. And then it just. It's such a weird feeling of like. Oh, I wonder how many people did this for me. When I thought I was out by myself, like doing stuff. And then there's just an adult there waiting to catch you.
Georgia Hardstark
Or. Or not. Or that should have been there. Yes. And then wasn't.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
So many options. Everything okay? So I stood behind her, said that to our left is a bedroom door which goes into a hallway that leads to the kitchen to the right and the garage to the left. Kind of like a three way intersection. We were in there for a little while. Her pulling books me estimating how long it would take to clean up up when it happened. From my peripheral vision, I saw my great aunt slowly start to pass by the door frame. I could see the red robe she wore all the time, her short curly dark hair and her ever present bright red Taylor Swift lipstick.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God.
Karen Kilgariff
My great aunt died four years before that day. When she vanished from the door frame, I scooped up my niece who had stared unblinkingly at her the whole time. So the baby saw it too.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God.
Karen Kilgariff
And followed. But when I turned into the hallway, nothing was there. She was 100% real. We both saw her.
Georgia Hardstark
What the fuck?
Karen Kilgariff
But no matter how many times I've told this story, absolutely no one believes me. I'm into weird stuff. I believe the Loch Ness monster is real. Me too, girl.
Georgia Hardstark
No.
Karen Kilgariff
Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
Yes. How?
Producer/Editor
Because.
Karen Kilgariff
Because first of all. Okay, don't make me get mad at you, Georgia.
Georgia Hardstark
Well, I think aliens are real. Let's go. Ready? Go.
Karen Kilgariff
No, I don't like those. I think the lock. Steven, are you with me on this?
Georgia Hardstark
Totally, you guys.
Karen Kilgariff
Because listen, and this might be your theory too. We don't know what's in the ocean at all.
Georgia Hardstark
It's not the ocean, it's a lake.
Karen Kilgariff
But lakes are connected to the ocean in a subterranean underground tunnels. And they could be living down in caves and places that we have, we don't know are down there. Because no one's ever fucking explored 99% of the ocean.
Georgia Hardstark
I agree with all of the. All of that. The ocean is fucking amazing. And monsters are among them. The Loch Ness monster specifically was made up by a. Dude, you.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay, but that's a cynical punk rock thing. That's not true.
Georgia Hardstark
It's not punk rock. It has nothing to do with the dead Kennedys right now.
Karen Kilgariff
You're trying to be punk rock about the Loch Ness Monster. And I resent it.
Georgia Hardstark
Why am I being. Why is my musical taste being brought into this argument?
Karen Kilgariff
Because you're just.
Georgia Hardstark
Just.
Karen Kilgariff
You have to believe. You have to. It is the best idea. That's. That something that's a holdover from 50 million years ago is like, oh, but I was hiding around the corner. Nobody killed me off that.
Georgia Hardstark
When that.
Karen Kilgariff
When that meteor hit. I was just chilling and I saved all this algae. I don't know. I just want to believe in it really bad.
Georgia Hardstark
Same. Well, they. They found a supposedly extinct coelacant like that had been dead for millions of years. And they found it like 20 years ago. And it's just been hiding out under Madagascar for millions of years. I believe in cedar carfish or whatever, but the Loch Ness monster, specifically, I believe in dinosaurs.
Karen Kilgariff
Listen, I don't think he wears that
Producer/Editor
little Tam O Shanter.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay? So that I agree with you is ridiculous.
Georgia Hardstark
No, he doesn't have. He doesn't wear a kilt.
Karen Kilgariff
No. That would be crazy. He's a fish. He can't wear a skirt.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay, let's put a pin in this. This.
Karen Kilgariff
I have a.
Georgia Hardstark
And say you're wrong and come back
Karen Kilgariff
to it when that Loch Ness monster corpse washes up. Finally.
Georgia Hardstark
I will. 100%. I'll go on record right now. I'll tell you you're wrong. No, I will not admit that I ever said any of this. 100%. Karen, we have the recording. No, never. That never happened. How do you believe the recording? That's.
Producer/Editor
I double recorded this.
Georgia Hardstark
Aliens.
Karen Kilgariff
I'm taking a picture of this recording.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay, go.
Karen Kilgariff
We've totally lost our place.
Georgia Hardstark
The ant. Oh my God.
Karen Kilgariff
I was scared. I was scared.
Georgia Hardstark
I forgot.
Karen Kilgariff
Guys, we're super scared. Remember the old lady with the lipstick that passed by?
Georgia Hardstark
We believe her.
Karen Kilgariff
I believe baby saw it.
Georgia Hardstark
Baby. A baby watching a ghost is the scare. Is that you're seeing too.
Producer/Editor
That's your proof.
Georgia Hardstark
Down and down. Because like humans have all these things that are like get in the way of them able to see these spiritual things. And baby's just like, what A ghost? Okay, whatever.
Karen Kilgariff
Why would that baby look away from the greatest game in the world? Pull books off a shelf. It wouldn't.
Georgia Hardstark
You still play that game? I love it. I love it. We're gonna get through one story on this.
Karen Kilgariff
I love these ones. We just. It's all digressions. Okay? She says it was the most surreal thing that has ever happened to me. And I remember the moment clearer than anything else I've ever experienced.
Georgia Hardstark
Wow.
Karen Kilgariff
Looking back on it, though. I remember she walked with her head down, staring at the floor ahead of her, and never turned to make eye contact with either of us. Almost like she didn't see us at the time. This confused me, but now that I've had time to think about it, she looked miserable. And I'm really grateful she didn't make eye contact with me. I have no reason to think this, but it can't be a good omen to make eye contact with a dead person.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, that makes sense.
Karen Kilgariff
That's good logic.
Georgia Hardstark
I don't want to ever make eye contact with a dead person. I'm gonna say that on this podcast. I know it's controversial. Stan.
Karen Kilgariff
Yep. Again. Punk rock.
Georgia Hardstark
Punk rock again.
Karen Kilgariff
Well, Ravey, kind of.
Georgia Hardstark
All my bad musical taste is getting thrown.
Karen Kilgariff
You're in your big pants.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Have you ever posted that picture of you with those big pants and the choker on?
Georgia Hardstark
Which one?
Karen Kilgariff
It's the one that looks like it's. The camera's on the ground. Like, it's almost all pants. You look like a pants model. You know that one?
Georgia Hardstark
I think so.
Karen Kilgariff
You have to post it that you're so, like, 1994 in it.
Georgia Hardstark
I know, I know. I will.
Karen Kilgariff
I'm still not done with this email.
Georgia Hardstark
Go on, pants model.
Karen Kilgariff
Pants model. I don't know what it was or what it meant, but I hope she found peace, even if she hasn't. If she hasn't already. Anyway, that's my ghost story. Love you guys. Even Steven. F. Even. Oh, even Steven. I thought they were saying it like,
Georgia Hardstark
the saying, like, now we're even Steven.
Karen Kilgariff
Love you. Even Steven. That's a given. People always love Steven. Yeah, that was genuine and legit creepy.
Georgia Hardstark
I love the idea of, like, seeing a being walk by. It's not like I saw this thing out of the corner of my. Or like, I would come into the kitchen and all the drawers were open. Cause that's the fucking scariest thing in the world. Right? Like, nothing is scarier than all the. Whatever that's being open.
Karen Kilgariff
Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
Or like, all the things taken out of this thing and placed on top of this thing.
Karen Kilgariff
In those, like, conjuring movies, when they do that, when it's like someone steps out of the kitchen, when they go back, all the chairs are in a pipe.
Georgia Hardstark
Sixth Sense, in that scene when the mom comes back into the kitchen and everything's just piled up. Murder the best. Run, running, Goodbye.
Karen Kilgariff
You wish you could run but you have to stay.
Georgia Hardstark
All right, let's do the big hairy man.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay.
Georgia Hardstark
We love Those this is a love story, not a ghost story about how
Karen Kilgariff
I love hairy men.
Georgia Hardstark
Hi Karen, Georgia, Steven, and all our favorite furry babies. I finally decided to write to you after seeing your request for scary spooky stories. Till this day, my mother still thinks I'm crazy. When I was around the age of five, I had a bunk bed. I'm a side sleeper and if I laid on my right side I could see my doorway. Being five, I had the worst. Being five, the worst thing in the world would be sleeping in a room with a closed door. I had to have my door open. Ditto for about six months. Often I would wake up in the middle of the night. I'm not sure what time, but all the lights would be out and everyone would be sleeping. In my doorway I would see a figure. It was large enough to fill the entire space. You could see the outline of what I would describe as hair and red eyes. There would be heavy rhythmic breathing. What I would sometimes wonder if was the sound of my father sleeping across the hall. When I would think about this later in life, I would be terrified. I didn't want him to know I was awake. So I'd pretend to be sleeping and casually roll over. Well, little me thought it was casual. I would eventually fall asleep. I would tell my mother about him and she would dismiss him as a figment of my imagination. Finally, after one night, I said to myself, when he comes back, I'm going to jump off the bed, kick him between the legs and run across the hall to my parents room. He never came back. Years later, in grade nine, what's up Canada? I was asleep with some friends of mine. We were all telling stories and I began to talk about the big hairy man. One of the girls finished describing him. I was floored. She told me to speak to our friend Blake. I saw him in the hall at school the following Monday. All I said to him was big hairy man with glowing red eyes. His eyes started to tear up. How do you know that? He said. I said I saw him too. He proceeded to tell me the the big hairy man would sit at the end of his bed watching him. He says they spoke, but he doesn't remember what they said. Two years later, summer school, I'm talking to this chick. He would stand at the end of her bed and watch her. About a year after that, at a party at my friend's house where I was crashing for the night, I was sharing a bed with my friend. Laying in the dark, I was telling him the story. He said, if you could See me right now. I have tears in my eyes. He used to stand outside my window at night. Finally, about five years ago, talking to a girl I worked with. He would stand at the end of her bed too. None of us have any childhood connections. None of us went to the same elementary school and only met in high school or after. None of us could find a connection. Now when my husband goes away for the weekend with the kids, all doors are fucking closed, including close, just in case. After telling my mother all the sightings, the woman still thinks I'm crazy. Stay sexy and close your bedroom door before you sleep tonight. Kelly.
Karen Kilgariff
Now that's super creepy.
Georgia Hardstark
Did I ever tell you my story about seeing something weird?
Karen Kilgariff
No.
Georgia Hardstark
When I was a kid, like 5, 5 years old, and I was sleeping in a bunk bed at night and we had like. At the end of the bunk bed was a mirrored closet, like the closet, the moving doors kind. And I was laying there late at night, everyone was sleeping. And I saw the closet door open on its own. Like a foot just like pushed open on its own. And I freaked the fuck out and ran into my parents room. And that's it.
Karen Kilgariff
And you don't know what?
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, I remember it happening. I don't think that was a figment of my imagination because it actually fucking opened.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. And you were awake.
Georgia Hardstark
I was awake and it opened.
Karen Kilgariff
That's super creepy.
Georgia Hardstark
And I had to like get all of my fucking courage to run because I had to run past the closet door.
Karen Kilgariff
I mean that those moments of like when you are really young, you running,
Steven Ray Morris
Kelly. Right.
Karen Kilgariff
Kelly. Turning over, turning your back to like basically a monster in the doorway. Like, even those moments of like being brave as a little kid are so huge.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. Your adrenaline's just pumping.
Karen Kilgariff
It's so. I mean, that's so scary. Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay.
Steven Ray Morris
We are back revisiting our most legendary disagreement about the Loch Ness Monster.
Georgia Hardstark
How do you feel about it today? In today's money, what's your opinion?
Steven Ray Morris
In today's money, I think I'm three times more passionate. I've invested, I've doubled down, I've tripled down on the Loch Ness monster. I believe now more than ever.
Georgia Hardstark
Even the guy saying I faked the Loch Ness monster. Photo, photo. Karen cannot. She thinks that the Loch Ness Monster threatened his life and said, if you
Steven Ray Morris
don't tell him the proof, that man was clearly in distress. And clearly he would have never said those words had there not been a real Loch Ness monster at his neck.
Georgia Hardstark
Loch Ness Monster was like, snitches get stitches, bro.
Steven Ray Morris
And there's your proof. I rest my case, your honor. Well, how do you feel about the Loch Ness monster these days?
Georgia Hardstark
I was against it then. Not against it. I'm okay with him being real if he is real, but I. I don't.
Steven Ray Morris
I can't imagine I was accusing you of being laissez faire about the Loch Ness monsters.
Georgia Hardstark
I think I still am, but I
Steven Ray Morris
just love the idea.
Georgia Hardstark
I love the anger. Or nothing.
Karen Kilgariff
Or nothing at all.
Georgia Hardstark
I do believe there's probably some crazy ass creatures out there we don't know about. So why can't one of them be in the nest in the Loch Ness?
Steven Ray Morris
Right. Why can't they be underwater?
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. Hairy men are giant men.
Steven Ray Morris
What's better for me? Giant.
Georgia Hardstark
Giant.
Steven Ray Morris
Although I'm not against Harry in the least.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, it's like the Harry part is really. It's. It's like. What is the word?
Steven Ray Morris
It's really primal. It's really sexy and smutty and musty
Georgia Hardstark
until it tips over this, like, invisible line of too much. And it's a fine line of too much and in too many places.
Steven Ray Morris
I wonder, now that we're on the topic, if there's such thing as caveman smut. Cause, you know, we know there's hockey smut now, and we know there's like, cowboys. Gay cowboys smut, whatever is there? Do you think anyone's ever written an erotic book about? Well, there's Clan of the Cave Bear.
Georgia Hardstark
How many times have we talked about Clan of the Cave Bear on this podcast? Like, literally at least five.
Karen Kilgariff
I just seeded my own conversation and
Steven Ray Morris
brought myself back around.
Georgia Hardstark
I was waiting for you to stop so I could yell Clan of the Cave Bear at you.
Karen Kilgariff
So sorry.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, if anyone doesn't know what that is, it's what all of our moms read in the fucking 70s and 80s. And then we didn't realize it was bas. Shades of gray, but in a cave. With cave.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Steven Ray Morris
A lot of loincloth action.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. A lot of thrusting. Like, a lot of loud, hairy thrusting. I remember stealing it, being like, oh, my God, Yes.
Steven Ray Morris
I used to love stealing my mom's books and pretending I was reading, like, Judy Blume or something.
Georgia Hardstark
Definitely. Definitely. I know my mom took away the Outsiders from my brother when we were little, which made me want to read it. And we went through her closet and found it and read it.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Steven Ray Morris
Then you love it.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Steven Ray Morris
Okay, let's get back into more spooky listener stories.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Brought to you by Apple Card. Apple card users get 2% daily cash back on Purchases made in store and online, whether it's for big ticket items or everyday purchases. When they use their Apple Card with Apple Pay now, that's a benefit that's just too good to pass. Up.
Producer/Editor
Up.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
You could be earning 2% daily cash back when you use your Apple Card with Apple Pay to buy turmeric for your signature curry, 2% back on flights to visit the family in Tucson, and even 2% back on your kid's new tuba. You might even be able to get 2% back on a tuba tutor not an Apple Card customer. You can apply in the Wallet app on iPhone subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs bank usa Salt Lake City Branch terms and more at Apple Co Benefits this Mother's
Georgia Hardstark
Day Celebrate the woman behind it all with Pandora Jewelry.
Steven Ray Morris
Get your mom some jewelry that feels personal and reflects the moments that matter
Georgia Hardstark
most, whether that's a date, a name, or a shared memory. You can make it even more meaningful with an engraving in your own handwriting.
Steven Ray Morris
Because the best Mother's Day gift says more than just I love you.
Georgia Hardstark
Find the perfect Mother's Day gift at your local Pandora store or online@pandora.net Goodbye. Okay, you don't always get eight hours
Karen Kilgariff
of sleep, but you can look like
Steven Ray Morris
you did with Maybelline Instant Eraser Concealer.
Georgia Hardstark
Maybelline Instant Eraser Concealer instantly covers dark circles and under eye bags in a swipe.
Steven Ray Morris
It's a do it all concealer that helps conceal, contour, correct, highlight and hydrate.
Georgia Hardstark
The formula is crease resistant and gives up to 12 hours of moisturizing wear. And it's designed not to settle into fine lines and wrinkles.
Steven Ray Morris
The iconic cushion tip applicator and portable packaging make it easy for touch ups and on the go use. I was just using one of these.
Georgia Hardstark
We were just talking about this.
Steven Ray Morris
I mean I've been using the Maybelline Instant Eraser concealer for years, I think. Yeah, the convenience of the little spongy
Karen Kilgariff
swab at the top.
Producer/Editor
Yeah, you just dab dab dab.
Steven Ray Morris
And it's just enough so that you don't overdo it with your concealer.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Steven Ray Morris
And mine is the pink the 160, which is the pink color correcting so it like brightens up your under eyes.
Georgia Hardstark
I'm immediately using it. Find your shade of Instant Eraser concealer at your local retailer. Goodbye.
Producer/Editor
Okay, let's see.
Karen Kilgariff
Sorry I fucked up these pages. Wedding dress Ghost Hi Karen, Georgia. Stephen. Elvis. Mimi. I grew up in an old coal house House off the railroad in old Minneapolis.
Producer/Editor
Perfect start.
Karen Kilgariff
I Was in a rundown area of the city. It was in a rundown area of the city. As though. As though a designer had just said rust was their vision. Anyway, the house was haunted. The trouble began when my parents bought the house before I was born. My mother found a wedding dress in the attic, originally belonging to the old woman who died in the house. Apparently her husband had left her years before. And she died alone. Oh, no. And then I just start crying. Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
And that's it. Thanks for listening.
Karen Kilgariff
Isn't that the scariest idea in the world? Dying alone? Happy Halloween. Mom liked the dress, and since she was going to get married, she decided to use this dress to save money.
Producer/Editor
Lady.
Georgia Hardstark
Lady. You don't like it?
Karen Kilgariff
The dead lady's attic dress?
Georgia Hardstark
Well, if she didn't want someone else to use it, she should have burned it in the backyard like a normal person, you know? Oh, you know how you do right after you get married.
Karen Kilgariff
This dress is actually. When she goes to put it on, it's just all made of moths. Interconnected moths touching each other.
Georgia Hardstark
They go fly away the moment it's on. And she disappears too. Into moths. Yes.
Karen Kilgariff
But then they're in a mo. A moth pod up in the ceiling.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. And. And the daughter comes in. Mom. And she goes. Help me.
Karen Kilgariff
From far away in a few fan. Okay.
Producer/Editor
To my.
Karen Kilgariff
To say my parents marriage was rough would be an understatement. Because of the dress, they fought a
Producer/Editor
lot, but the energy of the house
Karen Kilgariff
was a darker variety. When I was young, I would hear someone calling my name when I'd investigate. No one had called for me. I'd see slithering shadows out of the corner of my eyes. I get that all the time. I always.
Georgia Hardstark
You might be having a seizure, honey.
Karen Kilgariff
I have floaters. There's all kinds of real. Get your eyes checked, everybody. But when I turned to look, the shadows were gone. My mom noticed this and she was disturbed, but my dad dismissed it as nothing a la the shining, which is spelled the shinning. Even my dog would not go upstairs at night, cowering whenever anyone tried to bring him near the room and preferring to stay outside.
Georgia Hardstark
That's the creepiest part.
Karen Kilgariff
To me, that's so not dogs. Yeah, dogs are like. I'm good out here.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, I'm gonna go shiver in the yard or you should have burned that fucking wedding Dr. Bro. I'm gonna go shiver in what should have been the wedding dress pit.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, it's way safer out in the burning area. Things came to a head when I was taking a bath.
Georgia Hardstark
No.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, you mean the skeleton hand that came up through the bubble? No, no, no, wait. I'll read. This is what it actually says.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
I was alone in the bathroom and I felt someone touch my back.
Georgia Hardstark
No, no.
Karen Kilgariff
I was too scared to turn around.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh no.
Karen Kilgariff
And soon my mother came in and I rushed to her crying. My parents marriage fell apart and eventually they divorced. And since then they've become best friends. Oh no. I never felt that dark presence again. And though I've waned in my belief in the supernatural, I still get chills as an adult when thinking back. The dress was lost in a move. Oh God. It's in a box in someone else's fucking attic.
Georgia Hardstark
Now it's in Goodwill.
Karen Kilgariff
This is part two. It's the scariest Goodwill in town. The dress was lost in a move. But seeing so many B movies in my life, I'm sure it'll come around for a sequel sooner or later. I swear I didn't read that ahead. Stay sexy.
Producer/Editor
Don't get murdered.
Karen Kilgariff
Gratefully and sincerely, Alan. Oh my God, that's awesome.
Georgia Hardstark
Scary.
Karen Kilgariff
I mean you. He had me at a wedding dress in the attic.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God. Totally. That's terrifying. Okay, that, this, that. The other. This one we did. Okay, you ready for Ghost uncle gets his way? Oh, all right. My great uncle Jack died when I was really young. He was always really kind, but also deviously sarcastic kind of guy. He was diagnosed with lung cancer and lived for several years with it, thanks to chemo. As he grew older and weaker, my great aunt Roxanne had a stand up shower installed in their bathroom so he wouldn't have to step over the tub with the traditional bath. He hated that shower. He was in complete denial about being weak. And he thought the glass see through door was ugly and tacky. Hey. Fucking men. He constantly asked her if they could go back to the traditional bath. On the day of his funeral, Roxanne was in the bathroom at the sink taking a breather from the reception. And out of the corner of her eye she saw a figure moving towards the shower. Just in time. She turned to look at the shower and the glass door freaking exploded. The glass out of nowhere, shattered.
Karen Kilgariff
Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
Needless to say, she went back to a normal tub after that. That sarcastic, hilarious dude got his way from beyond the grave. Ssdgm. Pass. Patrick.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh my God.
Georgia Hardstark
I love when like physical things happen.
Karen Kilgariff
That's. Yes. That's amazing.
Georgia Hardstark
Patrick.
Karen Kilgariff
That really. That just makes me think. After my mom died, I think I told you the story, but our good friend Ellen, Ellen Slater, her Father was sick. And this was say like a couple months after my mom died. And she went to. She. She. Like he had been sick for a while or whatever. She went to bed one night and she dreamed that my mom came to her and was like, you need to get your shit together. You need to get ready. Cause your dad's gonna die. And she woke up the next day and he had died. Oh, my.
Georgia Hardstark
The same night.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, I get. Yeah, what the fuck? I totally believe in that stuff.
Georgia Hardstark
I do too. I mean, the night my mom's dad died, so my mom, like a couple years before I was born. His name was George. That's why I'm Georgia. She was in New York visiting her sister. And they were all out. My family's from la. And out of the window, like third story window, my mom hears her dad yell her name, Janet. She rushes to the window, opens it up. Nobody's out there. That night, at that moment, he died in bed, asleep at home in El la.
Karen Kilgariff
I totally believe in those.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, those two.
Karen Kilgariff
Those are real.
Georgia Hardstark
Like, she. The way she tells it to me, you know, I 100 believe her.
Karen Kilgariff
I love it. Well, yeah, I mean, that's. It was a real experience. Yeah. And also, I think, like, when you're on this planet and you have connections with people and you're. And you leave, like there's whatever it is, a burst event or whatever it is. There's some, you know, electric.
Georgia Hardstark
There's electricity in the air.
Karen Kilgariff
It's like radio waves, but radio waves, but ghost waves. It's people. People.
Georgia Hardstark
Radio People Radio Plus AM on that AM frequency coming at you.
Karen Kilgariff
Ready for Victorian Ghost woman?
Georgia Hardstark
Always.
Karen Kilgariff
Hey there, Karen, Georgia, Stephen and Katz. My mom and I moved into a new apartment that was built in the late 1800s. So it has a lot, lots of history to it. Well, after long days of moving, my mom fell asleep on the chaise.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, well. Well, the chaise. You mean Blue Bloods.
Karen Kilgariff
Emails from Blue Bloods.
Georgia Hardstark
The chaise lounge.
Karen Kilgariff
She woke up to fingernails scratching on
Producer/Editor
the arm of the chair.
Karen Kilgariff
She woke up and saw a woman in white looking at her. The woman then slowly walked down the hallway and disappeared. For as long as we lived there, I felt strange about that house, as if somebody was always watching. The lady never bothered us or was seen again. However, the people who lived there after us have told stories that there was a ghost that would not leave them alone. I found out this story years later, and that creepy feeling now makes sense. Thanks for the awesome podcast. Stay sexy. Don't get murdered.
Georgia Hardstark
Britney, what if Bomber to move into a place and just be like, you can't even yell at your neighbors for having fucking, you know, whatever TV show they're watching on too loud, the Americans. Like, can you please turn that lower, please? Or like, fucking. What is it? Lord of the. What's the one?
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, the Lord of the Rings.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, yeah, turn that lower. And then it's like, stop haunting me. You can't do that.
Karen Kilgariff
I know in all those ghost haunting stories that I love that are on tv, the people move into a house that they just spent all their money, and then they're stuck in this house where crazy shit's happening. But they're all like, no, we have to be in denial because we don't have the money to leave.
Georgia Hardstark
Do you remember a couple years ago, there was that story about a family who moved into some house? It might have been upstate New York or something. I don't fucking know that details. And they started receiving letters from someone, threatening them, threatening their children by name. And saying specifically things about their children and their family that they did like their routine. They knew everything about them, and they were sending them these threatening letters, like, move the fuck out or I will kill you all. And they moved the fuck out.
Karen Kilgariff
They didn't find out who it was?
Georgia Hardstark
No. I mean, maybe they have at this point, someone let us know, but like, oh, my God, it was. I was just like, I'd rather have a ghost. 100%.
Karen Kilgariff
Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
It was just some creepazoid who, like, probably grew up there or whatever or
Karen Kilgariff
lived in the walls or just some
Georgia Hardstark
fucking neighbor who was like, God, they listen to the Americans so loud.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, exactly. That's that weird thing of, like, if some crazy person that lives near you and there's the slightest. You know, they're like, we brought you a pie. And you're like, I'm sorry, I don't eat pie. And then the letter writing campaign starts.
Georgia Hardstark
Luckily, the Murderina, who lives two doors down, is really fucking cool. And she's. She has the cutest dog I've ever seen in my life.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, good.
Georgia Hardstark
Thank God. Thank God.
Karen Kilgariff
That's very lucky.
Georgia Hardstark
Cause if she had just been cool, it would have been fine. But one thing. But the dog is cute, so that's cool. It's my turn. Ready for a sappy ghost story, Karen?
Producer/Editor
Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
Because this is called. Hey, y'.
Producer/Editor
All.
Georgia Hardstark
How about a sappy ghost story? I was born into a family of funeral directors who operate three funeral homes in rural Tennessee. Fuck, yes. So death has always been part of my life. We had at Least three Christmases and my eighth birthday party at the funeral home because they were too busy to leave. My dad and brother have talked about times they felt a spirit with them or was in the funeral home, but I never experienced it myself until 2007. In early 2007, my grandpa and my Yorkie dog passed away that August. I moved to Knoxville for college and was having a rough time emotionally losing my grandpa and dog, moving away, starting college clusterfuck of a month. My then boyfriend, let's call him Jack, lived in an off campus apartment and his sister lived nearby with her little dog, Peyton. One day I was napping in Jack's room while he was in the shower. I was so tired and in that half sleep, half awake state. I was laying on my left side with my back to the door and I felt a little dog jump on the bed. I figured his sister had stopped by with Peyton. The dog walked around on the bed, it put its paws on my right side just for a bit, then laid down at the foot of the bed bed. Seconds later, I felt someone sit down on the other side of the bed. Figuring it was Jack out of a shower, I didn't even bother opening my eyes or rolling over. He patted my right shoulder twice, just gave it just a slight squeeze. And then the weight of him and the dog on the bed was gone. A few minutes later, Jack came in and woke me up. I asked him why his sister had left Peyton here and he said no one had been in the apartment and the dog wasn't there. I didn't believe him, so I got up and went to the living room. No dog and and the inside deadbolt chain lock was still locked, so no one had been in the apartment. Walking back to the bedroom, I smelled Juicy Fruit gum. Jack didn't chew that gum and neither did I, but my grandpa had. He had kept an open pack in his overalls, so you always smelled it when he was around. After realizing this, I immediately started sobbing. I knew it had to have been my grandpa with my dog letting me know they were okay and I would be too thankful. Thanks so much for this amazing podcast and I can't wait to see y' all on Nashville. Ssdgm Megan oh my God, I love.
Karen Kilgariff
We're all so fragile.
Georgia Hardstark
Do you ever get when, when we're away in hotels and stuff and you're like falling asleep at night, do you feel your dogs jump on the bed? I feel my cats jump on the bed all the fucking time.
Karen Kilgariff
Do you? That's hilarious.
Georgia Hardstark
It's just like the phantom, phantom buzz. And you're like, yes, phone ring.
Karen Kilgariff
I don't get the that. But I miss it because Frank, my dog Frank, the second I get home and like, lay down to watch TV or like, whatever, he comes up and either slides all the way up and lays in front of me or goes into the bend of my legs and lays there, he's like, has to be directly pressed up against me, baby, it's the cutest. And George goes into a little weird circle, like far away, and then goes. And she's all mad. She's mad that I left, she's mad I came back. She's just always mad at me. Okay, she's glad that you came. You're here.
Producer/Editor
So this is from a Reddit thread. I found out about this because a Reddit thread got posted on Twitter and so a bunch of murderinos let us know that this person was writing in and they were trying to get heard.
Karen Kilgariff
But of course, our genius email is
Producer/Editor
chock full and no one had read this email. So we got the heads up and we went in and found it. And actually I began to email with
Karen Kilgariff
this person and had a good conversation
Producer/Editor
with them and so they sent this email. And before I get started, I just want to give a trigger warning. This is a very intense letter.
Karen Kilgariff
So, people, if you're sensitive to sexual
Producer/Editor
assault stories, you're not going to want to listen to to this. A few months ago, a co worker turned me towards the MFM podcast because a story was told about me. Spoiler alert. I wasn't murdered. For reference, it was episode 92 in October of 2017. I actually wrote to you once before and indicated that I didn't want anything more published, that I just wanted to set the record straight. But I've had a few months to sit on this and some time to bounce it off my therapist, and I've decided that I do want to tell my story. It was so crazy to hear my worst nightmare told on a podcast.
Karen Kilgariff
It felt like a violin.
Producer/Editor
So much of this has felt like something that happened to me and I want to control this part of the narrative. I want my real story told by me, with my consent. On January 8, 2017, I was working as a Medica legal death investigator and forensic autopsy tech. I was working a swing shift alone. The building we were in at the time was old and decrepit. The building was not connected to any hospital, though it did house the county morgue. The upstairs part of the building was primarily offices and the basement was the autopsy suite and body Cooler. That night, the region was experiencing widespread flooding due to rain melting the snowpack. Law enforcement resources were stretched thin and the old building was leaking and threatening to flood. The county had made press releases that county facilities would be closed the next day. In addition to scene investigations, part of my duties were to process cases for autopsy the next morning.
Karen Kilgariff
Morning.
Producer/Editor
Traditionally, I would do all of my writing and follow up from my cubicle upstairs and save the hands on processing until the very end of my shift. I would rather process three bodies in a row all at once versus go downstairs three times during my shift. Even after years of working with the deceased, the downstairs creeped me out. While I was upstairs writing a report, my computer keyboard malfunctioned. I spent some time fiddling with it, but ultimately decided to go downstairs to an abandoned office turned storage room to get a report. Normally, I wouldn't have gone downstairs for another 45 minutes or so, but I couldn't finish my report without a keyboard. I was in the office storage room with my back to the door. When I turned around, there was a man leaning on the door frame. He was wearing a scary clown mask. He was calm and cocky and he told me, you're early. He knew my routine. I was kind of frozen for a second. He rushed toward me and I swung the keyboard at him like a baseball bat. To this day, I can see some of the keys flying off in slow motion. He pushed me against a bookcase, hard. My vision went white. I think my bell got rung pretty good because there's a couple seconds I can't account for. He had my right hand pinned up near my head. He grabbed at my skirt and ripped it. I thought he was trying to pull off my lanyard that had a key card and physical keys to the building.
Karen Kilgariff
I tried to hit him, but I
Producer/Editor
couldn't get any leverage. He was so close to me. Nothing I did got any response until I tried to pull the mask off. That's when he pulled the knife. He rubbed the knife over my face. He cut my cheek and showed me my blood on the blade. He called me a whore. He told me to undress and when I refused, he put the knife under my collarbone, right at the subclavian artery and told me he would paint the walls red. He raped me. When I yelled and begged him to stop, he laughed and asked who was supposed to hear me screaming. Scream. He stopped and told me to get on my knees for the first time. He didn't have the knife to my chest or throat. I didn't think about it. I grabbed the knife by the blade and ran running up the stairs. I kept feeling something weird on the handrail. It turns out it wasn't the handrail that was weird, it was my hand. I started to run outside but realized I didn't know where he was. Our old building was like a maze. I started to go to my desk but stopped and hid under another investigator's desk. I couldn't find my cell phone and I called 911 from the desk phone. It took a couple of tries having to Remember to dial 99 before dialing out. I vividly remember hiding under the desk, trying to whisper to the dispatcher and watching the blood run down my fingers and pool on the ground. Our building was supposed to be secure and the responding police officers had no way to gain entry. I had to leave the desk and walk through two doors and a hallway to let them in. The whole time I was expecting him to pop out, but he didn't. It took law enforcement a while to clear the building. They didn't have keys, were unfamiliar with the maze like layout and had to search every body bag. The man in the clown mask wasn't found. I was released from the ER several hours later. My supervisor drove me home, but we first had to go back to the building to collect my wallet and camera keys. It was dreamlike seeing the red and blue lights illuminate the area. Officers and deputies patrolling in pairs in the pouring rain reminded me of a scene from a movie. After the scene was processed, my co workers cleaned my blood from the office stairs, desk doors and wall. An email went out to the majority of the staff telling them not to report until 0800 hours. When my coworkers, who are also my partners and best friends, went downstairs to prepare everything for autopsy, they found Evan and that he had been waiting for me in the autopsy suite. Arranged on the back of an evidence cart next to an exam table were long strips of red duct tape. Two long pieces, two shorter pieces. The red duct tape was dog eared which is never done with evidence. As it was described to me. They were ready for someone at the floor level to be able to easily grab. Ready to go. If I had been going down to process bodies in my usual routine, I would have walked backwards pulling a gurney to that exact spot. No arrest has ever been made. The only DNA that was recovered from my clothing wound up belonging to my infant son from where I had held him before going to work. The investigation of my case was transferred from one jurisdiction to another as the attack happened in a County building. This resulted in twice as many law enforcement officers being involved in various ways. The detectives investigating my case forgot to flag it as confidential, resulting in an unknown number of deputies reading details of my case. One deputy shared details of my case on a hookup app. One high ranking officer shared the details with their family. And that is how it came to you in the first place. That night turned my world upside down. I moved, changed cars, my kids, changed schools, and I ultimately resigned. The new facility that we moved into a month later is state of the art with cameras, alarms and ballistics glass. But I was never again comfortable being alone in the Morgan night. I will always have to live with the knowledge that someone very smart, collected and comfortable in a morgue is still out there. We know that he had been in the building at least twice before and likely once after. I don't know what exactly he had planned, but I'm thankful for a random faulty keyboard space bar. I'm okay. It took a while of not being okay to be where I am now. I wanted to write to you because I think sometimes the person part of your stories gets overlooked, booked. I found and reached out to the person who initially shared my story, but I think I freaked them out. Perhaps they were concerned that I was the perpetrator. Oops. If you have any questions about details or you need clarification, I'm happy to unscramble this. Thank you for your time. So.
Georgia Hardstark
Wow.
Producer/Editor
So we told a story that was thirdhand and not the person's story to tell. I don't think that the person who wrote in had malicious intent, but I think this is a very good lesson for all of us when we think about what we're doing and how we're talking and who we're talking about. So our apologies to you who had to hear her story on a podcast. That's the last thing that we want to happen. And that's, you know, that's just. That's not what we're trying to do and it's not what it's about. And we should have thought it through. And we're going to try our best to keep aware of this and to keep you in mind so that we avoid mistakes like this in the future.
Karen Kilgariff
And so George and I have decided
Producer/Editor
that we're going to donate $10,000 to the rape, Abuse and Incest National Network, Rainn and we thank you for your understanding and for writing in and communicating with me and letting us retell your story the way you wanted it told.
Georgia Hardstark
Old. Okay, we are back in 2026.
Steven Ray Morris
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
That.
Steven Ray Morris
That whole experience with the woman hearing her own story on our podcast with someone else telling it, sending it in and telling it incorrectly was really one of, like, I don't know, one of the most, of course, humbling, but also like really self assessing moments on this podcast for me. Cause it was like we're just reading stuff and trying to get like, quote unquote, trying to get our work done. And this as a possibility, of course, just never would have entered my mind.
Georgia Hardstark
And now, I mean, it felt so awful. And I think that it didn't enter our mind. And then it did and it hasn't left. You know, like, when we tour and go to the cities, we do stories based in whatever city we're in or state we're in. And you're always like, when it's a recent case, you're always like, what if that person's best friend or cousin or something is in the audience? How would I want them to react to this? Because you can't help it, but you want to make sure you're doing it in a way that doesn't feel gross.
Steven Ray Morris
Yeah. And it was really, I remember emailing with this person and. And they were incredibly fair and incredibly just straightforward about, like, not really being sure how they feel, not liking it, like. And I basically said, we can do any version of what you would like to do. We can take the entire thing down. We can take, you know, blah, blah, blah, whatever. And so what it ended up being. And what you hear in this episode is what they asked to do, which is essentially replaced the incorrect one with the correct one, which is their own story. And I think that was incredibly generous of them to allow us to do that and allow us to make that change on the show.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Steven Ray Morris
I felt very, very lucky that that's what their decision was and that they shared that story with us.
Georgia Hardstark
Definitely.
Steven Ray Morris
Okay, now we're gonna go back and finish up this last batch of haunted hometowns.
Georgia Hardstark
This is called Stabbed by a Ghost by Lacey.
Producer/Editor
Whoa.
Georgia Hardstark
Dear Karen, Georgia, Steven and respective pets. I'm a longtime listener, first time caller, as all of my hometown murders have been covered by y' all already. But I saw Steven. She probably lives somewhere fucked up, but I saw Steven was looking for some spooky, ooky, kooky. Oh, honey. Experiences for a mini. So now how to throw my hat in the ring? Oh, sweetie, I was taking a sip.
Karen Kilgariff
I know Diet Coke when she spits. Spooky, ooky, kooky. That almost came out my nose.
Georgia Hardstark
I Saw. Oh. But then she goes on to say, it makes better. This summer I was stabbed by a fucking ghost.
Karen Kilgariff
What?
Georgia Hardstark
I know how ridiculous that sounds, but here, hear me out. I worked for my family's bed and breakfast this summer. My family had been divided on whether the house was haunted or not. And until I started working there, I was firmly in the not haunted camp. I had stayed there as a guest from time to time, but I had never spent more than a few days in the house. Once I started working there, I experienced little things that I would chalk up to natural phenomena, like my bedroom door swinging open or shut all. Or all the window blinds flying up mid piss. Mid piss. That's terrifying. Can you imagine? You're just. And that's horrible.
Karen Kilgariff
And you have to finish peeing. Yeah, yeah. That's horrifying.
Georgia Hardstark
That's a funny ghost though.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, it's kind of good.
Georgia Hardstark
Something sitting in the face. Okay. Being a skeptic, I totally wrote all of this off until I was the only one on duty one night. Which you can't write it off because then they're gonna be like, oh, yeah, well, let me, let me really show you.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
I was working on preparing some banana bread and a savory bread pudding for the next morning's breakfast. Okay. Yeah, I. I had placed the bread in the oven, assembled the pudding to soak overnight, and had thoroughly cleaned the kitchen. I went to the back laundry room to work on turning a few loads of laundry while the bread baked in the oven. About 30 minutes into baking, I went to the kitchen to check on the bread. I went to slip my hands into the oven mitt and was promptly greeted by a fucking paring knife stabbing me in between my ring finger and middle finger.
Karen Kilgariff
Whoa.
Georgia Hardstark
I removed the knife and found the first aid kit. I was went to go curse out my mother for leaving a knife in the oven mitt when my blood ran cold and I remembered that I was the only one in the house being a skeptic. I used to be. I tried to find rational explanation for why a paring knife would be blade up inside an oven mint. And then it says hint. There's no rational explanation. It was not a knife I had used in the breakfast prep and it was usually kept in a drawer along with the other parents knives. I racked my brain for hours trying to wonder if I had truly put the knife in the mitt in some sort of I'll remember why this is here later scenario. But then I finally came to the conclusion that the ghost was real and probably Mad at me for taking. For talking shit about him all summer. I apologized out loud to the ghost and went to the doctor once someone else came home. Now I've just got a fun little scar to remind me of why ghosts are real and you shouldn't call them imaginary SOBs. Lots of. Of love, Lacy.
Steven Ray Morris
I mean.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh. Then she said, I withheld the name of the BNB because I didn't want you to say it on air. But if you're curious, I will write back. Would love to have you guys come visit. It's got lots of. Lots of ghosts and antique furniture.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, wow.
Georgia Hardstark
We're there.
Karen Kilgariff
That's everything I need. Yeah. Because I was thinking. I was thinking, oh, well, if you keep. Obviously if you keep your oven mitt in the same drawer as those knives.
Georgia Hardstark
Right?
Karen Kilgariff
But she wouldn't be scared if that were the truth. She'd be like. She would have already checked. And also, you would feel it, right?
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
She just used the oven mish.
Georgia Hardstark
They were out. It sounds like, man, when a ghost cuts, you move, Leave.
Karen Kilgariff
It's so crazy when ghosts can move
Georgia Hardstark
around, which is why I don't think it's real.
Karen Kilgariff
I mean, look, listen.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay, go ahead. What? Look, I think ghosts don't haunt me because I'm like, oh, cool. I'd be like, great.
Karen Kilgariff
That's funny. Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
I don't.
Karen Kilgariff
I wonder. I wonder if it is locational, situational, or, like, about the people.
Georgia Hardstark
I just don't think it's what we think it is. Enough that any of that would be true or matter.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Like, I just don't think it's a old person who's dead being like, I'm gonna make this girl freak out when she's peeing. You know what I mean?
Karen Kilgariff
I'm gonna stab her in between her fingers.
Georgia Hardstark
Right. Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
Um, but then I think that's also having been a person who has a ghost story, the frustration where you're like, well, I. This is the thing that happened. Maybe in and of itself, it isn't insane. Or, like, you could explain it, but that's not the explanation. And I'm telling you because I was there.
Georgia Hardstark
And it doesn't make you feel any better about you experiencing that thing?
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. Someone being like, yeah, well, that didn't happen. You know, like, people, anytime I tell my ghost story, they're like, you had sleep paralysis. It's like, no, because I've had sleep paralysis. And I know the difference. I know that feels like, why do
Georgia Hardstark
they need to do that? Well, because I do that too.
Karen Kilgariff
They want to solve it.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. I mean, other experiences I've actually had, I've been like, well, I had an active imagination or whatever. The.
Karen Kilgariff
Why can't I just be like?
Georgia Hardstark
That was fun, right?
Karen Kilgariff
Or it's uncomfortable just to leave it with. Anything's possible.
Georgia Hardstark
Weird world. Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Is there a man in the crawl space or is it just a ghost? Hi, Georgia, Karen, Stephen, Elvis, Mimi, Dottie, Frank and George. I will be at your Fort Lauderdale show on the 5th. November 5th. I cannot wait to see you guys. So my ghost story haunting comes from my hometown of Hamilton, New Jersey. Yes, that's the same place of the Megan Konka murder. A side note, I hope I pronounced
Georgia Hardstark
her last name right.
Karen Kilgariff
Side note, I went to the same elementary schools her a few years after this happened. So San. The elementary school was very big on stranger danger lessons. They tore that asshole's house down and made it into a park called Megan's Place. So the family didn't have to keep being reminded with that house. And our school used to take us there once a year to remind us of the true dangers of going with people we don't know.
Georgia Hardstark
And that's the Megan's Law murder, where Megan's Law came into play or started. Anyways.
Karen Kilgariff
Um, anyway, I was about 10 years old when my dad finally moved us out of an apartment and into a house. The family that lived there before us was an older couple who built the house. When the wife died of old age, parentheses, might I add, she died in the house.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, good.
Karen Kilgariff
He decided it was time to sell the house and go into a home. I remember the first time I walked into this house and the weird feeling I got. I chalked it up to all the old people's furniture being in the house and the wives sewing room being untouched since she had died. Her sewing room became my bedroom once we moved in. No weird things started happening as soon as we moved. Such as things being misplaced that no one could remember moving. Weird noises that my dad would explain by saying the house is settling and you're just freaking yourself out.
Georgia Hardstark
The house is just screaming and you're just freaking out.
Karen Kilgariff
Why don't you like screaming? You're a child.
Georgia Hardstark
The house is screaming in pain. It's perfectly normal. And you wouldn't know. We've always lived in park apartments.
Karen Kilgariff
That's right. You don't understand that houses have feelings. Like people and skin.
Georgia Hardstark
Only pain, but still a feeling.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay, so fast forward a year later, my first night all alone in the house. Oh, I was using the computer in my dad's room chatting with friends on aim.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh yay.
Karen Kilgariff
When I heard footsteps walk by the doorway right under the staircase. I ignored it as I thought it was the quote how settling and kept chatting away. Shortly after the first pair of footsteps, I heard multiple pairs of footsteps running paired with giggling.
Georgia Hardstark
No giggling please.
Karen Kilgariff
Home alone. Giggling. Being the idiot child I was, I decided it was okay for me to go investigate. As soon as my feet hit the floor, all sounds stopped.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, that's creepy.
Karen Kilgariff
I feared it was my imagination and went back upstairs to carry the on imming my friends. Once I got upstairs, the footsteps and the giggling started again.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God.
Karen Kilgariff
This time I figured it was my dad playing a prank on me since he did this often.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
I ran back downstairs yelling, this isn't funny. I looked out the window and when I saw his truck wasn't there, that's when I really started to panic.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh my God. I grabbed the landline and ran into my bedroom and locked the door. That's when I heard heavy footsteps banging up the basement stairs steps and the sound of someone banging on the basement door. No, my dad kept it locked since he was convinced someone was going to break in through the basement.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, they are.
Karen Kilgariff
I climbed under my bed and started calling my sisters for them to come get me. As soon as there was a break in the banging, I bolted out of my house and down the street. About five minutes later, my sister's boyfriend picked me up and he had me wait in the car as he checked the house to make sure no one was in there. No one was. He decided to take me home with him until my dad was able to come and get me.
Georgia Hardstark
I don't like that either.
Karen Kilgariff
Since that day, my dad made a joke about having a man living in the crawl space in his room. Anything. Anytime anything weird happens, the man in the crawl space is at fault for it. Like when my dad eats all the ice cream sandwiches and doesn't remember doing it. Thank you for reading my haunting ghost story, Alison. Oh, that was. That's so, so scary.
Georgia Hardstark
Giggling. Yeah, nobody wants giggling.
Producer/Editor
You don't like.
Karen Kilgariff
You don't think about it until like being by yourself, yourself and hearing giggling. Did I ever tell you that time that I was by myself in my house? This was before I got George, so I didn't have dogs.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
And I was sitting there trying to. I was trying to finish some writing and so it was dead silent in the house and had been for like an hour straight. And I heard directly next to my ear a zipper, zipped up.
Georgia Hardstark
What?
Karen Kilgariff
And I. Oh, no, sorry. I had gotten George because. Because I grabbed her leash and was like, come with me. And we just walked out the door. I went to the dog park and then I called my friend Rob because I was just like, this is. You're the only person I can tell this to. It sounds so weird, but I just. Zipper heard something. It was just. It wasn't in the distance. It was like someone zipped their coat next to me.
Georgia Hardstark
That's so creepy.
Karen Kilgariff
It was very clear. It wasn't like, oh, this. It sounded like a zipper. It was a zipper.
Georgia Hardstark
Zip it.
Karen Kilgariff
Like one of the plastic zippers on a 70s ski jacket. Yeah, like that. Really? You know, like how serial killers wear like Ed Kemper.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh, my God. You know, fucking Ted Bundy had some sweet ass 70s jackets.
Karen Kilgariff
He probably on his 70s ski jacket left the ski lift hat.
Georgia Hardstark
That was what to do. Because you'd be like, yeah, I went skiing over the winter break.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. I was up at Snowbird.
Georgia Hardstark
How much funny would one of those tags that says Ted Bundy's name on it goes before?
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, I would say in the $500,000 range. In this day and age, these people who love serial killer songs, these weirdos. Oh my God.
Georgia Hardstark
These people love what kind of monsters. Okay, let's see. Okay. Yeah. There's something about being home alone and I don't know how you do that. Like, I don't like having a house where there's multiple rooms. Like, I have to turn all the lights on when I alone.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah, well, I swear it. The dog saw solve everything because they hear everything. George hears everything.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
She know. She knows when people are walking up, like up the street from half a block away and starts barking. So that's like if anything, if anything, it's just like a nice warning call.
Georgia Hardstark
You're safe. Any zipper people come in, George is going to.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Going to regulate.
Karen Kilgariff
She didn't on that one, though. She was all like, what a worley Leaving.
Georgia Hardstark
I'm supposed to be scared of this. You do this all the time. Okay. Okay, here we go. Grandpa's haunting me and that's okay. Hi, Karen, Georgia, Steven, Cats and dogs. I've been listening to MFM for a while now. It's brought a change to my life I could have never expected. Thanks for helping my socially awkward self make new friends and gain some confidence in myself. Yay.
Karen Kilgariff
That's what we're talking about, Brittany. Hell yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay. All right. When I was three years old, my grandpa died. He'd been in an Accident at work and lived in a vegetative state for quite some time.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh no.
Georgia Hardstark
When I was born, that's where he was. Oh God, that family.
Karen Kilgariff
That's tough.
Georgia Hardstark
It was an incredibly tough time for my family, but most of us made it out okay. A couple years later, I was at my grandma's house. A split level with the rec room downstairs and the kitchen right above it. While my grandma was in the kitchen, she could hear me carrying on a conversation through through the vents.
Karen Kilgariff
I love this.
Georgia Hardstark
I know. When I came up for a snack, she asked me what I was doing down there. Talking to the man, I replied. My grandma asked me to describe what he looked like, but may have regretted that decision. As I described my deceased grandfather to a T. I of course thought nothing of it and went about my child business.
Karen Kilgariff
With your child briefcase? Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
I have no memory of this, but I also don't have memories from before first grade. Fair enough. A few things happened as I was growing up, but nothing too notable. A couple of things moved or fell, but it wasn't anything I was afraid of. Fast forward to having my first live in boyfriend. He would wake up with scratches every now and then and made me nervous. I remember my aunt having a picture of her and her prom date on her dresser. And his face was scratched out on the glass and on the picture.
Karen Kilgariff
Whoa.
Georgia Hardstark
It was weird. One morning I remember waking up to just one of my hanging plants swaying, but not the other. I hate that. That's the worst.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, don't worry about it. That's just a wind in here. Oh shit. It's not.
Georgia Hardstark
There was an air circulation there as the window was closed and the heater was off. So it didn't make any sense. So I decided to try to make some contact. I grabbed a voice recorder and started asking questions. Okay, wait. Here we go. Though these though. These questions. Through these questions, I learned I was my grandpa and he didn't like my boyfriend. He was right. We aren't together anymore. And then that was it. Those were the only two questions that were answered. Holy shit. I felt less scared afterwards and I didn't have anything of note and I didn't have anything of note happen after that. I do remember the night I went into labor with my child. I felt an overwhelming sense of love and protection. I hadn't even gone into labor, but I felt like he was there and he knew. A couple of small things have happened since then, but they're not as exciting. But that's my ghost story and I'm happy. I was Able to share with everyone. Thank you for all you do. And you don't have to fuck politeness if the ghost is your grandpa who really just wants love. SSDGM Brittany Yes. I love that he like physically scratched up her boyfriend and the aunt's photo.
Karen Kilgariff
It's almost like. I can't really tell you anything. I can't. If I tell you I don't like your boyfriend, you're just gonna love him more because that's how it always works.
Georgia Hardstark
Right?
Karen Kilgariff
But instead I'm going to like horror movie creep you out about your boyfriend.
Georgia Hardstark
I'm gonna make the boyfriend break up with you by scaring the ever loving shit out of him.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, it's so good.
Georgia Hardstark
That's great. Okay, give me a sign, grandpa. And just scratches up the face of your.
Karen Kilgariff
It's just like crazy white eyes.
Georgia Hardstark
What if he's like, I don't like your dog just scratches up your grandpa.
Karen Kilgariff
You don't get to choose my life, Grandpa. You have all the. You're so finicky.
Steven Ray Morris
Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
Ghost and scary human in Silver Lake Cafe Theater. Dear team Hard Kill and precious, sweet, kind, gentle Steven. Steven, stop. Is that why you picked it?
Georgia Hardstark
I'm hiding these.
Karen Kilgariff
This is ridiculous.
Steven Ray Morris
Ridiculous.
Karen Kilgariff
Stephen. I want to first let Karen know that I am from Sacramento and I love every time she shits on Sacramento because it truly is the armpit of California and Bakersfield is the butthole. Come on, everybody. There was someone that just wrote on Twitter, they wrote something like, why won't you come to Sacramento? It's like I have explicitly stated how
Georgia Hardstark
I feel about let's go in Orange County County. Despite me having fucking panic attacks. There was a Act of God.
Steven Ray Morris
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
And then. And then having that amazing show. Oh my God, the best show.
Georgia Hardstark
Anaheim show was incredible.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, so fun. Okay, let's go anyhow.
Georgia Hardstark
Yes. So we're not going to Sacramento anyways anyway.
Karen Kilgariff
We absolutely should.
Georgia Hardstark
I know. We are definitely going.
Karen Kilgariff
We should play the fairgrounds. That would be so cool, dude.
Georgia Hardstark
Like the state fair.
Karen Kilgariff
Yeah. Or we could do a live show in the Howbout Arden shopping center and just like clear some parked cars.
Georgia Hardstark
I don't know what that is. I want to do the stay of hair. I want to be between the pie eating contest, then my favorite murder live and then like the pig eating contest. No. I don't know. Is there a.
Karen Kilgariff
There's definitely a pig eating contest. It's like if you can eat a live pig, you win a ribbon, right? Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
You're waiting, pig. You win your. Wait. And pig, if you can eat your waiting pig. And then it's like, well, I don't really want that anymore.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, wait, this is my favorite thing. Georgia texted me at like 4 in the morning.
Georgia Hardstark
You up? Because you texted me. I Woke up at 4, of course. And I looked at my phone and you were. You just texted. The coffee was a mistake. Yes, at like midnight. And then I was like, you know, last time I told you I was up all night, you were like, text me. I'm up. Yes, they text you at 4:00am I
Karen Kilgariff
think I woke up like a half an hour later. And it was so exciting because I just am. You're never lonelier than when you're up in the middle of the night by yourself.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God.
Karen Kilgariff
And it was like I had a message waiting where you're like, hey, you up?
Georgia Hardstark
What's going on? But the pig thing, I said, I'm just laying here listening to the Pig People book, which everyone needs to fucking download immediately because I fall asleep to it at night even though it's like the best book ever.
Karen Kilgariff
What's the title?
Georgia Hardstark
It's called no Stone Unturned. It's about necrosis. I think I talked about it way in the beginning of the podcast, but it's Necrosearch. Who is that really awesome organization that finds clandestine graves? There's all these different kinds of people in it who are sciencey and otherwise and they're called the experts and they're called the pig people because they started burying pigs to see how decomposition worked and how it made graves look and how you could see how long a body was buried based on the foliage and based on the bugs and decomposition. So. So I listened to that to fall asleep and I'm like, why isn't this working? It's so crazy. It's so relaxing. I'm not.
Karen Kilgariff
I'm dreaming of pigs.
Georgia Hardstark
No Stone Unturned. Listen to it. It's best. Okay, Sorry.
Karen Kilgariff
No, no, no. Okay, so Sacramento, Sacramento. Plenty of shitting on Sacramento then. Anyways, this is my ghost story. The day after I graduated from college, I moved from Northern California straight to Los Angeles.
Producer/Editor
Angeles.
Karen Kilgariff
Scary enough in and of itself. My boyfriend and I literally walked the graduation stage and a few hours later jumped into our U Haul truck for the six hour drive.
Georgia Hardstark
I love that. I love it. I did that. It took about a couple days after I graduated and we, my mom and I were like, goodbye, Orange County. Yeah, forever.
Karen Kilgariff
There's nothing I love more than if something ended. You just get in the car and go. There's no reason Go hang out and visit and do all this. It's just kind of like. And on to the next one.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, life's short.
Producer/Editor
Okay.
Karen Kilgariff
I was starry eyed as I exited on vine street and thought how amazing the city looked. It does. From that weird little hill. I found a job quickly as a barista in a small theater cafe in hipster Silver Lake. I thought it was a very cool gig. The customers were semi famous comedians and people I recognized on tv. I mean there's nothing, nothing better. The cafe also hosted fun improv and comedy shows in their small black box theater.
Georgia Hardstark
The Lyric. It's the Lyric.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, okay. Yes.
Georgia Hardstark
I'm like hell bent on guessing what place this is. Yes, it's the Lyric. Kurt Braunaller, our friend, used to go in there all the time.
Karen Kilgariff
The Lyric. Hyperion.
Georgia Hardstark
Yes, yes. Okay, sorry.
Karen Kilgariff
Okay, perfect. We figured it out. The afternoons and night shows were fun and lively. However, I felt a sense of dream dread as all the customers and audience members left one by one. And an aura of evil lurked in the cafe at night.
Georgia Hardstark
That place is absolutely haunted.
Producer/Editor
Really?
Georgia Hardstark
I know it. I've been in there.
Karen Kilgariff
I've been in the.
Georgia Hardstark
In the back room. It's terrifying. So. Well, she's gonna. Why do I even talking during this? I don't know.
Karen Kilgariff
No, you're fine.
Georgia Hardstark
Adding weird.
Karen Kilgariff
No, you're fine. Okay. Naively, I accepted to close the cafe by myself every night. Naive and says one word for it. That meant I, a 5 foot 90 pound female with severe anxiety, had to close the cafe at 11:30.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh honey, don't do it.
Karen Kilgariff
You need this job.
Georgia Hardstark
You know. She said yes to. Because she then she's like, I don't have to talk to anyone while I close.
Karen Kilgariff
I'll just sweep. It'll be nubby.
Georgia Hardstark
Leave me alone.
Karen Kilgariff
Well, I was responsible for cleaning and locking up the cafe and theater, which would take about 45 minutes. The cafe was extremely quiet. I mopped the floors and suddenly I heard a roar of happy cheers, whistles and laughter that lasted approximately three seconds coming from the audience of the theater room.
Georgia Hardstark
What?
Karen Kilgariff
Uh huh. I dropped the mop and peeked into the control room upstairs to see if there was still a show going on. I looked out of the window from the booth.
Georgia Hardstark
No.
Karen Kilgariff
And saw a dim red light emitting from the back from the small black box theater and a lone chair in the middle of the stage.
Georgia Hardstark
No.
Karen Kilgariff
I felt like a sinister being was watching up at me.
Georgia Hardstark
Me. Wait.
Karen Kilgariff
From down on the stage. And I quickly locked up without cleaning the rest of the cafe A few days later my co worker who had the morning shift texted me and confronted me that I should put the pepper shakers away properly and that I and I shouldn't put them on the floor again.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh my God.
Karen Kilgariff
Then he sent me a picture of the three pepper shakers lined up neatly on the floor in the middle of the cafe. That was impossible since I would never have moved those items on the floor floor. That's just weird. I thought he was pranking me. One time I had to cover the same co workers morning shift even though I was scheduled to close that previous night. As I was closing for the night, I made sure the shell, the salt and pepper shakers were in the same exact spot on the kitchen table. The next day I opened the cafe at 6am and the pepper shakers were moved neatly aligned on the floor again in the front of the cafe. Even though I'd made sure to place them properly the night before, I'd freeze freaked me out so much that I just sat on the outside patio waiting for the waiting for the morning rush customers to come in. Last and scariest event that led me to quitting the job happened when I was closing the cafe again. I had taken the trash out by using the back entrance but had not locked up the locked locked up the door since it was one of the last things to do when closing. I continued to clean and clean count the till when I looked up and saw a skinny and tall homeless man press his face into the glass of the entrance door. His eyes were round and dark and his squished face on the glass had this obtuse and evil smile. He then darted away as I remembered I didn't lock the back door. I quickly rushed to close the back gate and saw a tall dark figure rushing towards me through the gate screen. I then slammed the door and locked it because of the front of the cafe had these huge glass panes as walls. I turned off all the lights in the cafe so that he could not see me and quickly hid in the
Producer/Editor
corner of the store.
Karen Kilgariff
This was already scary enough as I knew ghosts were probably haunting the theater too.
Georgia Hardstark
Oh no.
Karen Kilgariff
I called my boyfriend to come pick me up a 30 minute drive and I quit the job.
Georgia Hardstark
Holy.
Karen Kilgariff
It's been three years since I moved and I have a better job. I now have a higher standards when finding jobs in Los Angeles. One make sure it has a parking lot and two have co workers clothes with you. Oh my God your tiny murderino Tracy oh my.
Georgia Hardstark
I am going into Lyric Hyperion tomorrow and asking for Ghost stories immediately.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, my God, that's so scary. It's so scary. And that idea that you have to race the guy to the back door, dude, is.
Georgia Hardstark
Remember when you were 20 and you thought you were fucking invincible and, like, you could close late at night alone and leave the door open and everything would be fine?
Karen Kilgariff
Well, you're just kind of like, oh, this is fine. Yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Living my life. Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, my God, Tracy, that was a really good story, Tracy.
Georgia Hardstark
That was great. I think maybe we should end on that one. Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Stephen, these were awesome.
Georgia Hardstark
Good job, Steven.
Karen Kilgariff
Those were really fun.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah, they were so fun to read. Oh, my God, I love getting scared. We need to have, like. Like a. A pod. Like a side podcast of this. We could just keep doing our hometowns as this for a little while.
Karen Kilgariff
I know. Well, yeah, yeah.
Georgia Hardstark
Yes.
Karen Kilgariff
Yes, for sure. I love them.
Georgia Hardstark
Listen, here's what we're gonna say. Send in your hometowns. Look and listen. Send in your hometowns. If you have spooky, scary stuff like
Karen Kilgariff
that, we want to hear it.
Georgia Hardstark
Okay. I feel like not even just spooky scary, but, like, thrilling, weird. Yes. You know what I mean?
Karen Kilgariff
Like, racing a guy to the door is great.
Georgia Hardstark
That's great. I mean, near misses.
Producer/Editor
Come on.
Karen Kilgariff
Right? And also the thing of, like. And then after that, she knew, like, yeah, you have to. You can't just let somebody schedule you because they're cheap at the place and they only want to pay one person.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Like, no, dude, it's two people. Or, like, I can't close at night.
Georgia Hardstark
The salt and pepper shaker thing is the scariest thing to me. That's nuts, because, like, if he hadn't said anything to her about it, she wouldn't have known that was going on. On. That's so scary. Shit's, like, in a weird position and moved and, like, not supposed to be where it is, and it's just, like, inconspicuously placed. That's fucking terrifying.
Karen Kilgariff
It's so scary.
Georgia Hardstark
And we're back.
Steven Ray Morris
So this episode was originally titled the
Georgia Hardstark
Halloween Special, but if we were naming it today based on the episode, maybe we would call it My Two Blouses.
Karen Kilgariff
Oh, that would be a perfect one.
Steven Ray Morris
Or a cat on Prozac, which be tip of the hat to old Mimi. Or we'll name it Podcast. When Georgia talked about us coming together and having this baby that we named
Georgia Hardstark
Podcast, oh, my God. All right, well, thanks for listening, guys. We appreciate it. And let's go back to 2017 to say goodbye. Well, that was thrilling and scary and exciting.
Producer/Editor
Yeah.
Karen Kilgariff
Happy Halloween, everybody. Safe and sane.
Georgia Hardstark
Tina, Vince and I are going to be Simon and Garfunkel.
Karen Kilgariff
Well, you told me that, but then I thought you had a different one.
Georgia Hardstark
No, we're gonna be Simon and Garfunkel.
Karen Kilgariff
I love that from that 70s one. It's so good.
Georgia Hardstark
Yeah. Thanks for. Thanks, guys. We. You guys are the best. You guys. Yes.
Karen Kilgariff
So fun. And thank you for everybody who sent those scary stories in. And, I mean, there's a lot of writing taking place. You guys, really, you laid it all out for us. So thank you so much.
Georgia Hardstark
Thank you. And stay sexy and don't get murdered. Heard by Elvis. Do you want a cookie? Elvis.
Karen Kilgariff
Elvis.
Georgia Hardstark
Daddy. This Mother's Day celebrate the woman behind it all with Pandora jewelry.
Steven Ray Morris
Get your mom some jewelry that feels personal and reflects the moments that matter
Georgia Hardstark
most, whether that's a date, a name, or a shared memory. You can make it even more meaningful with an engraving in your own handwriting.
Steven Ray Morris
Because the best Mother's Day gift says more than just a I love you.
Georgia Hardstark
Find the perfect Mother's Day gift at your local Pandora store or online@pandora.net Goodbye.
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Brought to you by Apple Card. Hey, you could be earning 2% daily cash back on that purchase. And that one. And even that one. That's because Apple card users earn 2% daily cash back on every purchase, including everyday items they buy online or in store when using their Apple Card. With Apple Pay, not an Apple Card customer, you can apply in the Wallet app on Apple iPhone subject to credit approval. Apple Card issued by Goldman Sachs bank usa Salt Lake City Branch terms and more at Apple Co. Benefits Allergy season
Steven Ray Morris
does not slow down when you're on the move. That's why Kleenex Ultra Soft Tissues are ready whenever sneezes strike.
Georgia Hardstark
Kleenex Ultra Soft tissues are allergist approved and silky soft for up to 100% irritation free skin.
Steven Ray Morris
And now with the new Kleenex Snap and Go, you get that same gentle care made for life on the go.
Georgia Hardstark
Get the Kleenex Ultra Soft tissues you love in a new compact, durable package.
Steven Ray Morris
New Kleenex Snap and Go. Snap shut for a clean tissue anytime, anywhere.
Georgia Hardstark
For whatever happens next. Grab Kleenex Snap and Go.
Karen Kilgariff
Goodbye.
Date: April 15, 2026
Hosts: Karen Kilgariff, Georgia Hardstark, Steven Ray Morris
Theme: Revisiting the beloved Halloween special (Episode 92), the trio shares updates, reflections, and lively commentary on the original spooky listener stories, while tackling topics like friendship, cats on Prozac, the ethics of true crime storytelling, and, of course, the Loch Ness Monster.
This “Rewind” episode returns to one of My Favorite Murder’s most playful listener specials: the original Halloween-themed Episode 92. Karen, Georgia, and Steven dig back into the episode that featured chilling, funny, and heartfelt ghost and true crime stories submitted by their community. Alongside newfound updates and personal reflections, the group explores how their perspective on true crime and podcasting has evolved—blending their iconic humor with empathy and sincerity.
“My cat and I are on pharmaceutical for depression and anxiety.” — Georgia (03:07)
“The guy who played Ed Kemper needs all the awards.” — Georgia (07:13) “How did you cast this role?...I bet you they found this guy in, like, the Canadian outback.” — Karen (07:31)
“We’ve just gotten comfortable with her anger…Mimi’s biggest problem…is that she’s supposed to be an only cat.” (12:19)
Summary: A woman and her 2-year-old niece both spot a deceased great-aunt in her signature red robe; chilling, mysterious, and deeply memorable.
“Baby. A baby watching a ghost is the scare. Is that you’re seeing too. That’s your proof.” — Georgia (21:16)
Summary: Multiple unrelated people across years in a Canadian town share identical childhood memories of a “big hairy man with red eyes” haunting their bedrooms.
Summary: A family experiences unsettling phenomena after mom wears a dead woman’s attic wedding dress.
Summary: On the day of his funeral, a disliked shower door explodes, fulfilling the deceased’s wishes (“That sarcastic, hilarious dude got his way from beyond the grave.” — Georgia, 38:27)
Summary: In the aftermath of loss and depression, a listener senses her deceased grandpa and dog comforting her at college with familiar smells and phantom touches, turning grief into closure. (43:23–45:36)
Summary: A skeptic is “stabbed” by a knife hidden in an oven mitt while working night shift alone—a practical joke or poltergeist? Upon apologizing to the ghost, the incidents stop. (58:16–61:21)
Summary: In a New Jersey house with tragic connections, a young girl’s first night alone is upended by disembodied footsteps, giggles, and banging—inspiring a lifetime of “man in the crawlspace” jokes (63:23–67:20).
“The house is just screaming and you’re just freaking out.” — Georgia (65:02)
Summary: After a childhood of mysterious experiences, a listener concludes her grandpa is haunting her—scaring off disliked boyfriends by scratching photos and causing minor disturbances. (70:06–73:12)
Summary: A new LA transplant takes a job at a haunted Silver Lake cafe (revealed to be the Lyric Hyperion). Encounters include invisible audiences, moving objects, and a truly frightening late-night encounter with a man outside. The story ends with the lesson: never close up alone again. (73:19–82:21)
“It was really, I remember emailing with this person and they were incredibly fair….what they asked to do, which is essentially replace the incorrect one with the correct one, which is their own story.” — Steven (57:20)
This Halloween Rewind underscores what sets My Favorite Murder apart: a deep care for the listener community, a willingness to poke fun at themselves, and an openness to both joy and sorrow. From silly debates about the Loch Ness Monster to moving apologies for past missteps, Karen, Georgia, and Steven continue to balance humor, empathy, and sharp observational wit—while always inviting spooky stories (and lessons) from their ever-growing network of Murderinos.
Stay sexy—and don’t get murdered.