Episode Summary: My Victorian Nightmare – Ep. 25: Murder, Blackmail, and Raving Maniacs

Host: Genevieve Manion
Release Date: January 13, 2025
Podcast Series: My Victorian Nightmare

Introduction

In the thrilling 25th episode of My Victorian Nightmare, host Genevieve Manion delves deep into the dark and sensational stories from the Victorian era, specifically drawing from an 1871 volume of the Illustrated Police News, Law Courts and Record. This episode, titled "Murder, Blackmail, and Raving Maniacs," unpacks a series of gripping accounts ranging from gruesome murders to bizarre accidents, all set against the backdrop of 19th-century societal norms and criminal underbellies.

Key Articles and Discussions

1. A Robber Becomes Crazy in Jail at Goshen, New York

   • Summary: Genevieve introduces the unsettling tale of George Harrison, an Elmira resident who robbed a store in Port Jervis and subsequently descended into madness while incarcerated. His erratic behavior included biting a turnkey and setting his clothes on fire within his cell.
   • Notable Quote: "He was found necessary to chain him to the floor to prevent his injuring those who came into his cell." (02:15)
   • Discussion: Genevieve reflects on the challenges of understanding Harrison’s motivations, highlighting the limited information available and the sensational nature of criminal reporting at the time.

2. Pet Halstead's Murderer Respited

   • Summary: The episode recounts the case of George Botts, sentenced to hang for murdering Oliver S. Halstead, but granted a reprieve by Governor Randolph after petitions from prominent citizens who felt Botts needed more time to prepare for death.
   • Notable Quote: "Botts is writing out, by the aid of another prisoner, his own version of the murder." (05:30)
   • Discussion: Genevieve explores the societal and legal implications of such reprieves, delving into the scandal surrounding the Halstead family and the murky motives behind the murder.

3. Unsolved: Who Did That Man Kill Before He Killed Himself?

   • Summary: An anonymous man in Allentown, Pennsylvania, confessed to killing an unidentified individual in New York before taking his own life by jumping in front of a freight train.
   • Notable Quote: "He replied that he had killed a man in New York and was unhappy." (08:45)
   • Discussion: Genevieve expresses sorrow over the lack of information, reflecting on the tragic spiral of violence and despair.

4. Seduced, Dosed with Laudanum, and Nearly Frozen to Death

   • Summary: Mary Ellsworth, a 19-year-old from Kingston, New York, succumbed to laudanum poisoning and near-freezing after being rejected by her suitor, Richard Sober.
   • Notable Quote: "Seduced under promise of marriage by a man named Richard Sober." (12:20)
   • Discussion: The host discusses the harsh seduction laws of the time and the limited avenues for women facing emotional and societal pressures.

5. A Footrace Between a Phrenologist and a Young Lady at Bloomington, Illinois

   • Summary: Dr. Sims, a phrenologist, engages in a public footrace with young ladies Emma Sandusky and Kitty Myers, ultimately resulting in a humorous yet telling victory for the women despite societal expectations.
   • Notable Quote: "Such is the progress of modern civilization." (15:50)
   • Discussion: Genevieve delves into the pseudoscience of phrenology, its implications on societal norms, and the subtle push against gender expectations showcased in the race.

6. A Female Thief Attempts Suicide in a New York Courtroom

   • Summary: Magdalena Hoffman, caught in a theft scandal, attempts suicide multiple times in court while incarcerated, leading to increased distress and the involvement of authorities.
   • Notable Quote: "Her friend of bravado on the part of his pal." (19:10)
   • Discussion: The episode highlights the intersection of crime, mental health, and gender, emphasizing the limited support systems for women at the time.

7. Centennial Cussedness

   • Summary: J.M. Canfield, an exhibitor at the Centennial Exhibition, is poisoned by three women, Bella McLean, Maggie Poole, and Emma, in what appears to be an act of revenge or deceit.
   • Notable Quote: "She was supposed he would live only a few months." (22:00)
   • Discussion: Genevieve provides context about the Centennial Exhibition, the role of women’s progress during the era, and the tragic downfall of Canfield.

8. Groceries and Adultery: Badly Mixed Coffee, Tea, Sugar, and Blackmail

   • Summary: Mr. Green, a grocer, becomes entangled in a blackmail scheme when Eugene Heed accuses him of committing adultery with his wife, leading to legal confrontations and public scandal.
   • Notable Quote: "Much trouble may be avoided by merchants if they will be careful to deliver all packages by small boy messengers." (25:30)
   • Discussion: The story sheds light on societal expectations, the perils of reputation, and the use of blackmail as a tool for personal vendettas.

9. A Young Lady Outraged and Then Murdered in Arkansas

   • Summary: A 16-year-old girl in Hampstead County, Arkansas, is brutally raped and murdered, with scant details provided about the perpetrator or subsequent investigation.
   • Notable Quote: "Three bullets were found in the body and her throat was cut almost from ear to ear." (28:15)
   • Discussion: Genevieve mourns the anonymity granted to victims, especially young women, and the limitations of Victorian-era journalism in addressing such tragedies comprehensively.

10. A Wife Seeks Vengeance upon Her Husband's Seducer at New Rochelle, New York

    • Summary: Mrs. Donnelly, enraged by her husband’s infidelity with Sarah Goyan, confronts the mistress with a penknife during a public meeting but is thwarted by her friends.
    • Notable Quote: "She was fully determined to make short work of the destroyer of her peace." (31:00)
    • Discussion: The episode explores themes of honor, revenge, and the societal pressures on women to uphold marital fidelity.

11. A Young Wife Attempts to Dose Her Old Man

    • Summary: Mary Donell, unhappy with her aging husband Patrick, attempts to poison him with strychnine, citing his longevity as a burden.
    • Notable Quote: "Mary is 25 and a beautiful woman." (34:10)
    • Discussion: Genevieve discusses the dynamics of age disparity in marriages, the desperation that can lead to such crimes, and the judicial response to attempted poisoning.

12. A Burglar's Blow Up: He Blasts a Safe, Breaks a Leg, and Disfigures Himself Terribly

    • Summary: James McCormick, implicated in a failed burglary at Shields and Sons tobacco factory, recounts the mishap where his accomplice Thomas Haggerty catastrophically explosions the safe, resulting in severe injuries.
    • Notable Quote: "His burglarious enterprises had been brought to a close in this painful manner." (37:45)
    • Discussion: The host provides background on the Shields and Sons business, reflecting on the often-overlooked human elements behind such criminal endeavors.

13. Ludicrous Coasting Accident in Joy Street, Boston

    • Summary: A comical yet dangerous sledding accident occurs on Joy Street when a boy’s sled collides with a woman, leading to mutual astonishment but fortunately no severe injuries.
    • Notable Quote: "It was difficult at the time to guess which of them got the worst of it." (40:30)
    • Discussion: Genevieve offers historical context about Joy Street, highlighting its turbulent past and the cultural practices that led to such accidents.

Notable Insights and Reflections

• Phrenology and Societal Norms: Through the footrace story, Genevieve critiques the pseudoscience of phrenology and its role in reinforcing gender and racial hierarchies.

• Victorian Journalism: The episode underscores the sensationalist nature of 19th-century tabloids, often prioritizing scandalous details over comprehensive reporting, especially concerning female victims.

• Gender and Crime: Many stories highlight the limited agency of women, societal pressures, and the extreme measures some took in response to infidelity, oppression, or personal despair.

Conclusion

In this episode, Genevieve Manion masterfully weaves together a tapestry of Victorian-era tales that are as morbid as they are fascinating. By dissecting each story, she not only brings to light the gruesome and bizarre events of the past but also offers critical commentary on the societal structures and norms that shaped these narratives. For enthusiasts of creepy Victorian history, Ep. 25: Murder, Blackmail, and Raving Maniacs serves as a captivating exploration of the macabre undercurrents that defined the 19th century.

Quote from Genevieve: "It's always extra upsetting to me that I can't research a lot of the murders in this newspaper because they don't often give the names of the victims. Especially when they're women and young women." (28:30)

Connect with Genevieve: Follow My Victorian Nightmare on Instagram @myvictoriannightmare for visual aids and additional creepy Victorian content. Support the podcast and listen ad-free by joining her Patreon at myvictoriannightmare.com.

Listen to the Episode: Available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and other major platforms.
Join the Community: Engage with fellow enthusiasts and share your thoughts on the episode's topics.