My Victorian Nightmare: Ep. 29 - Butchery with Banjos and Vinegar Valentines
Release Date: February 10, 2025
Host: Genevieve Manion
Introduction
In the 29th episode of My Victorian Nightmare, host Genevieve Manion delves deep into the darker aspects of Victorian society, intertwining gruesome tales with societal norms and peculiar traditions. Skipping over the introductory promotions and advertisements, this episode offers listeners a riveting exploration of Victorian-era crimes, unconventional relationships, and the macabre side of Valentine's Day.
1. Butchered with a Banjo: The Murder of Louisa Dorff
Timestamp: 00:40 - 08:30
Genevieve opens the episode with a harrowing recount of the tragic murder of Louisa Dorff by William Condon in Cincinnati on June 17, 1871. Condon, a 23-year-old banjo player at Ryan's Saloon, brutally attacked Louisa with a brass-bound banjo, causing fatal injuries.
Notable Quote:
"The banjo cut a gash from the bridge of the nose to the lower part of her right cheek, and the screws of the instrument made a hole in the shape of a cross in the nose." [00:40]
Despite the clear evidence and Condon's apparent remorse—evidenced by his assistance in cleaning Louisa's wounds—he was never found guilty of her murder. Genevieve attributes this miscarriage of justice to the rampant corruption within Cincinnati's political landscape, dominated by saloon-owning gangs who could sway trial outcomes with ease.
Insights:
- Condon's Background: As a performer, Condon's involvement in saloon politics likely shielded him from prosecution.
- Social Stigma: Louisa was disparagingly labeled as a "kept woman" and later as a "miserable, besotted prostitute," reflecting the era's harsh judgments on women's morality and social standing.
2. A Naked Maniac's Reign of Terror in Chester, Illinois
Timestamp: 08:31 - 16:45
The episode transitions to an even more gruesome account of Louis Tockstein, an insane man who committed a spree of brutal murders in Chester, Illinois, on December 17, 1871. Tockstein, after escaping custody, entered the Ryan household naked and mercilessly killed three family members, including a 12-year-old girl whom he beheaded with an axe.
Notable Quote:
"The knife entered the lower lip, cutting off four teeth and severed the carotid artery and the jugular vein, causing death almost instantly." [10:15]
Historical Context:
Genevieve explores the challenges of mental health care during the Victorian era, highlighting the lack of effective treatment and the societal fears surrounding insanity. The swift movement to send Tockstein to the Jacksonville asylum underscores the period's approach to dealing with mental illness through confinement rather than rehabilitation.
3. Bloody Butchery: The Indianapolis Murder
Timestamp: 16:46 - 24:50
Another chilling tale involves Louis Antinote, who brutally murdered Robert Evers in Indianapolis on January 15, 1880. Armed with an eight-inch butcher's knife, Antinote attacked Evers, resulting in instant death.
Notable Quote:
"As the reflection of the light fell upon his face, I recognized him as the man whom we had seen in the saloon." [18:30]
Trial and Aftermath:
Antinote's trial reveals the era's judicial inconsistencies. Initially convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment, his sentence was mysteriously reduced over the years, allowing his release in just six years due to good behavior. This leniency raises questions about the fairness and rigidity of the Victorian legal system.
4. Extraordinary Matrimonial Alliance: A Same-Sex Marriage in Victorian Times
Timestamp: 24:51 - 40:00
Shifting focus from violence to societal norms, Genevieve examines an article titled "Extraordinary Matrimonial Alliance" that details the secret marriage of two women, Molly Rogers and Lena, in Williamsburg, New York. The union, described as "a criminal alliance not authorized by the laws of nature or man," sparked significant gossip and controversy.
Notable Quotes:
- "This strange and unnatural marriage was consummated just four weeks ago at the house of Molly's mother in Williamsburg, New York." [28:10]
- "In Victorian society, it was expected and admired that women in high society kept themselves away from men entirely to protect their purity." [36:45]
Analysis and Insights:
Genevieve delves into the complexities of same-sex relationships during the 19th century. Despite societal repression and the absence of widespread acceptance, such relationships thrived under the guise of platonic companionships, often referred to as "Boston marriages." These partnerships provided mutual support and affection in a society that largely marginalized female sexuality outside of heterosexual frameworks.
Valentine's Day Context:
Valentine's Day, traditionally viewed as a celebration of romantic love, also served as a platform for expressing platonic affection among women. Genevieve highlights how institutions like Vassar College embraced this, allowing women to celebrate their bonds through poetry, decorated valentines, and communal activities without societal backlash.
5. Vinegar Valentines: The Dark Side of Victorian Valentine's Day
Timestamp: 40:01 - 49:30
Concluding the episode, Genevieve explores the phenomenon of "Vinegar Valentines"—insulting or scornful Valentine cards exchanged among Victorians. These cards served as a means to express disdain or rejection in the same ornate and poetic style as traditional valentines.
Notable Examples:
- "To a suffragette valentine, 'Your vote from me you will not get. I don't want a preaching suffragette.'" [45:20]
- "To the surgeon in your life, 'Ho ho, old sawbones, here you come. When the rebels whack us, you are always ready with your traps to mangle, saw, and hack us.'" [47:50]
Historical Significance:
Genevieve connects these vinegar valentines to broader societal tensions, such as the backlash against women's suffrage and the mistrust of certain professions like surgeons. These cards exemplify how Victorians used familiar cultural practices to navigate personal and societal conflicts.
6. Closing Read: Edgar Allan Poe's "Annabel Lee"
Timestamp: 49:31 - End
To end on a poignant note, Genevieve shares a heartfelt reading of Edgar Allan Poe's "Annabel Lee." This classic poem encapsulates themes of eternal love and loss, resonating deeply with the episode's exploration of love in its many forms—be it romantic, platonic, or unrequited.
Notable Excerpt:
"But our love, it was stronger by far than the love of those who were older than we, of many far wiser than we,
and neither, neither the angels in heaven above nor the demons down under the sea
can ever dissever my soul from the soul of the beautiful Annabel Lee." [42:00]
Conclusion
Ep. 29 of My Victorian Nightmare masterfully intertwines tales of macabre crimes with incisive examinations of Victorian societal norms and customs. Genevieve Manion not only recounts historical events with vivid detail but also provides critical insights into the underlying social dynamics of the era. From gruesome murders to the subtle defiance of societal norms through same-sex relationships and vinegar valentines, this episode offers a comprehensive look into the complexities of Victorian life.
Join the Community:
Engage with My Victorian Nightmare on Instagram @myvictoriannightmare and share your thoughts on Spotify or Apple Podcasts. Don't forget to rate and review the podcast to support future episodes!