Podcast Summary: NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast

Episode: Life’s Big Buys: Travel Splurges and When to Cut Retirement Savings for a Home Down Payment
Date: December 8, 2025
Hosts: Sean Pyles, CFP®, Elizabeth Ayoola
Guest Nerd: Kate Ashford
Main Theme:
The episode focuses on making intentional financial decisions around two classic “life big buys”—splurging on experiences like weddings and travel, and carefully weighing whether to reallocate retirement savings towards a home down payment.

1. Overview

Hosts Sean Pyles and Elizabeth Ayoola open by welcoming Sean back from his wedding and honeymoon, leading to a personal discussion about travel spending and budgeting for major life experiences. The episode then pivots to answer a listener’s complex question: is it wise to divert retirement savings to build a home down payment? The Nerds, joined by Personal Finance expert Kate Ashford, explore smart strategies for balancing short-term and long-term financial goals, with actionable tips for listeners navigating similar crossroads.

2. Key Discussion Points & Insights

A. Splurging on Major Life Events: Sean’s Wedding & Honeymoon

• Wedding Experience (02:12–04:57)

  • Sean describes his San Francisco City Hall wedding as “one of the most beautiful days of my life,” emphasizing the value of pre-planning and saving to enjoy the big day without accruing debt.
    • “We brought everyone to tears, which I felt very proud about my writing skills for… the harpist was the perfect little addition. I'm glad I splurged on that.” — Sean (02:52)

• The Honeymoon Adventure (05:07–12:13)

  • Sean and his husband traveled across Japan (Hokkaido, Tokyo, Kyoto) and South Korea (Seoul) using a mix of advanced planning and travel hacks:
    • Splurging on culture, food, memorable hotels, and practical conveniences like laundry facilities
    • Reliance on accessible, affordable public transit in Japan vs. inexpensive Ubers in Seoul due to language and fatigue
    • Shopping: combining holiday gift-buying abroad with the “one-for-you, one-for-me” approach, resulting in needing a new bag

• Budgeting for “Big Buys” (12:13–13:41)

  • Sean highlights the power of intentional, long-term saving to permit guilt-free spending on milestone experiences:
    • His total wedding and honeymoon costs: around $26,000, with $2,000 left over in savings
    • Prioritizing what brings the most value and joy—and planning not to overspend or go into debt

• Practical Travel Tips

  • Prepay major travel expenses months in advance to avoid stress
  • Use savings goals (and occasional splurges) to maximize joy and minimize financial regret
  • Consider balancing impulsive travel shopping with donations and mindful gifting

B. Listener Question: Diverting Retirement Savings for a Home Down Payment (19:36–29:26)

Scenario:
Listener (33, stable state job, union inflation raises, 22% of income to retirement, wants to buy ~$400k home, $40k saved, $8k/year for a down payment, $1k/year for repairs) asks:

• “Can I divert savings money from retirement to a house down payment?
• Is diverting future investments to retirement accounts better than using a small sum from retirement for a down payment?” (19:58)

1. Prioritizing Competing Financial Goals (21:13–22:11)

• Kate Ashford (Personal Finance Nerd):
  • “It doesn’t have to be either/or, but you do have to prioritize.”
  • Emergency fund (3–6 months), mandatory/matched retirement contributions, pay down high-interest debt, THEN home down payment.
  • Saving for a home is valid—just order your priorities, don’t sacrifice critical retirement progress.

2. Is It Ever Smart to Pause Retirement Savings? (22:11–22:58)

• Get free employer match first.
• Pay off high-interest debt if necessary.
• “It’s possible to thoughtfully pause… but there are caveats.”—Kate (22:25)
• Divert “some but not all” retirement contributions temporarily, if ahead on retirement targets.

3. Calculating What’s Safe to Divert (22:58–24:34)

• Rule of thumb: Save at least 15% of pre-tax salary for retirement.
• Listener is already saving 22%; average is only ~7.7% (Vanguard, 2024 data).
• Use a reputable retirement calculator (e.g., NerdWallet’s) to ensure you remain on track if you cut contributions, and set an end date to ramp savings back up.

“They might be ahead of where they need to be, in which case they can divert a chunk… Set an end date. This is a short-term goal.” — Kate (24:04)

4. Key Benchmarks (24:34–25:04)

• By 30: 1x annual salary saved; by 67: 10x salary (Fidelity rules of thumb)

5. Risks of Stopping Retirement Savings, and The Case for “Both” (25:04–25:58)

• Compounding growth is lost if retirement stops or is too low.
• BUT: A home is a big asset that may support retirement, so pivoting for a down payment can make sense if it doesn’t “mortgage” your long-term stability.
• “It’s going toward another financial goal that supports your financial future.” — Elizabeth (25:58)

6. Which Account to Tap or Pause? (Retirement Vehicles) (25:59–27:33)

• Listener’s accounts: Roth IRA (after-tax savings, tax-free withdrawals) and 403(b) (pre-tax, like a 401k for government/nonprofits)
• 403(b) money is “locked up” until age 59.5; Roth IRA is more flexible—can withdraw contributions (not earnings) any time, tax/penalty-free.
• If reducing savings, pause or lower contributions to 403(b) before stopping Roth IRA.

7. Using Retirement Accounts for Down Payment (27:33–28:43)

• Roth contributions can be withdrawn for any use; up to $10k of Roth earnings for a first-time home purchase, penalty/tax-free (if account > 5 years old).
• Recommend only using this if absolutely needed and when the purchase is imminent—keep money growing as long as possible.

8. Final Considerations (28:47–29:26)

• Don’t deprioritize retirement if you’re not far ahead on savings.
• For significant money moves, consult a financial planner.
• Acknowledgement: “Super impressed that at 33, our reader is saving 22% of their income… and pre-funding home repairs. We should all be so disciplined, right?” — Kate (29:12)

3. Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Personalizing Big Buys:

  • “We brought everyone to tears…I felt very proud about my writing skills for [the vows].” — Sean (02:52)
  • “That's what I love money for…being able to pay for experiences like this.” — Elizabeth (04:47)

• On Saving and Financial Freedom:

  • “I didn't go into debt. I'd been saving for so long and that helped me be in the moment and not be worried about my finances.” — Sean (04:57)

• On Retirement v. Down Payment:

  • “It doesn’t have to be either/or, but you do have to prioritize.” — Kate (21:13)
  • “Generally, the recommended savings level is 15%. So this reader is saving more than that.” — Kate (23:26)
  • “A house…can often be leveraged in your retirement years. So it can kind of be viewed as just pivoting with some of your retirement money.” — Kate (25:49)

• On Roth IRAs for Homebuyers:

  • “Roth IRAs are more flexible…You can take contributions out ahead of age 59½ without taxes or penalties.” — Kate (27:16)
  • “You can take up to $10,000 from a Roth for a first-time home purchase without paying any taxes or penalties.” — Kate (28:13)

4. Timestamps for Key Segments

• Sean’s wedding & honeymoon stories — 02:12–13:41
• Practical travel (budgeting, transit, accommodation) — 06:00–13:41
• Listener’s retirement v. down payment question — 19:36–29:26
• Prioritizing savings goals — 21:13–22:11
• When to pause retirement savings — 22:11–22:58
• Calculating how much is “safe” to divert — 22:58–24:34
• Benchmarks for retirement savings — 24:34–25:04
• Roth IRA vs. 403(b) analysis — 25:59–27:33
• Roth withdrawals for home — 27:33–28:43

5. Tone & Style

The conversational style is supportive, encouraging, direct, and practical, with plenty of real-world humor and empathy. Sean and Elizabeth openly share personal anecdotes, making advice feel relatable, while Kate provides a research-backed, “genius nerd” perspective balancing caution with realism.

6. Actionable Takeaways

• Planning for Big Buys:
  Set a goal, save intentionally, and spend on what matters most—without going into debt.

• Balancing Competing Goals:
  If you’re ahead on retirement savings (22%+ contribution, benchmarks met), it may be smart to temporarily reduce contributions to accelerate a home down payment—especially if you set an end date for this shift.

• Prioritize Employer Match & Avoid Debt:
  Never leave free money on the table (get that employer match), and pay off high-interest debt before shifting funds to new goals.

• Know Your Accounts:
  Roth IRAs allow flexibility, but reserve withdrawals (especially earnings) for when you’re close to buying a home. Use 403(b) as a long-haul vehicle.

• Consult Tools & Pros:
  Use calculators to model your long-term retirement impact before making savings changes. Big decisions? Talk to a financial planner.

7. For Listeners

Need help with your own money crossroads?
Submit questions via voicemail or text: 901-730-6373 (“N-E-R-D”).

Next Episode:
How to invest your retirement fund.

Follow Smart Money on your preferred podcast app for the latest strategies, life lessons, and financial nerd wisdom.