Podcast Summary
Podcast: New Books Network
Episode: Philip Nash, "Clare Boothe Luce: American Renaissance Woman" (Routledge, 2022)
Air Date: November 17, 2025
Host: Victoria Phillips
Guest: Philip Nash (Historian, Author)
Episode Overview
This episode features historian Philip Nash discussing his new book, Clare Boothe Luce: American Renaissance Woman, which aims to offer an accessible, historically contextualized biography of a multifaceted and often contradictory 20th-century American woman—Clare Boothe Luce. Through engaging dialogue, Nash explores Luce’s shifting political stances, her remarkable professional achievements, the challenges of biographical writing, and her enduring cultural legacy.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Why Clare Boothe Luce and Why Now?
[01:38–06:06]
-
Nash was drawn to Luce partially for practical reasons, after covering her in his previous book about female ambassadors.
-
He notes Luce's immense, but under-examined, breadth of accomplishment: editor, playwright, author, journalist, congresswoman, ambassador, pundit.
-
Nash critiques the focus of biographies on "deep" figures—single-field specialists—and positions Luce as an exemplar of the "broad" figure: accomplished across many fields.
"I can't think of anyone else, any other woman, certainly in the 20th century, who has a more sort of a wider resume than she does." — Philip Nash [03:20]
-
Nash aimed to write a concise, accessible biography with academic rigor and context, repositioning Luce in the canon of US foreign and political history.
2. The Question of Political Identity
[06:06–12:07]
-
Luce’s politics defied easy categorization. Early in life, she voted for FDR (Democrat), later aligned with Republicans, yet held numerous liberal positions.
-
She was:
- Hawkish on Cold War foreign policy, advocated preemptive action against the USSR,
- A feminism supporter, including the ERA,
- Sought connection with both left- and right-wing feminists (Betty Friedan, Gloria Steinem).
"She is much, much more complicated than I think even she would have presented herself as." — Philip Nash [06:44]
-
Nash argues: While Luce might have thrived in the age of Fox News, she "would have had no time for...the falsehoods and gaslighting that goes on today." [11:28]
3. Biographical Challenges with a Contradictory Life
[12:07–16:07]
-
Nash admits the difficulty of imposing narrative order on Luce’s sprawling, sometimes incoherent, life.
"At the risk of sounding snarky, I would. My answer would be, I don't... The challenge of weaving all that into coherent narrative is very, very difficult." — Philip Nash [12:54]
-
Solution: Nash structures the book around chapters focusing on her primary activities in certain periods, with subheadings helping to organize the complexity.
-
He acknowledges a significant debt to Sylvia Jukes Morris’s 2-volume biography.
4. Authorized vs. Unauthorized Biography
[16:07–19:26]
- Authorized biographies (like Morris’s) benefit from access but risk closeness; Nash claims some valuable distance and a stronger use of secondary sources for historical context.
- Luce was a "notoriously unreliable witness to her own life"—further complicating any biographer’s task.
5. Luce’s Relationships to Hollywood, Broadway, and Celebrity
[19:26–24:24]
-
Luce failed at acting but was a major Broadway playwright (notably The Women, 1936).
-
Hollywood involvement included screenwriting and a story nomination for "Come to the Stable" (1949).
-
She regretted not focusing on playwriting, calling herself "an unsuccessful woman" by her own impossible standards.
"She was going to write an autobiography...The Diary of an Unsuccessful Woman." — Philip Nash [22:04]
6. Theatricality, Celebrity, and Politics
[23:31–30:12]
-
Luce’s public persona—glamorous, witty, always composed—helped her political ambitions.
-
She broke the mold by running for Congress as a pre-existing celebrity, something rare at the time, and was a formidable speaker.
"She would always tell women that if you're going to speak publicly, lower the register of your voice....if you're a woman and you want to get ahead, you're supposed to hide all of your attributes because otherwise the double standard will come in and will tear you down. So I think she deserves credit for...being a brash, assertive, ambitious...woman." — Philip Nash [26:47]
7. Relationships with Political Figures and Other Women
[37:18–44:23]
- Luce’s connections were vast: Eisenhower, Dulles, Eleanor Roosevelt, and many others.
- Relationships with women could be contentious—she feuded with Dorothy Thompson, later patched things up (infamously made a menopause joke), and was compared/contrasted with figures like Helen Gahagan Douglas.
- Despite media framing of "cat fights," Luce had complex, often cordial relations with women across party lines.
8. Diplomacy, Scandal, and the "Poisoned Ceiling"
[44:23–53:24]
- As ambassador to Italy (1953–56), Luce confronted sexism, political complexity, and physical illness.
- Her mysterious illness was real: slow, unintentional arsenic poisoning (from lead-based paint falling from the 15th-century ceiling in her residence).
- She was generally viewed as a capable ambassador—hard-working, effective, and popular, but did not fully achieve her larger policy objectives.
- Luce’s brief, never-served ambassadorship to Brazil (1959) was ended, she claimed, with help from LSD-guided therapy, which Nash says is documented in letters and only recently available archives.
9. Teaching the Life of Clare Boothe Luce
[54:09–57:52]
-
Nash reflects on where Luce fits in the curriculum: her life is too varied for easy categorization but exemplary in a course on American women in the 20th century.
-
Her story illuminates barriers and pathways for ambitious women in male-dominated arenas.
"How do you get ahead in life when you are an ambitious woman and very few professional opportunities are open to women?" — Philip Nash [54:44]
10. Surprises and Final Thoughts
[57:52–64:24]
-
Nash was surprised most by Luce’s complexity: highly heterodox and feminist, even as she grew more conservative.
-
Example: Her plays evolved from traditional to explicitly feminist perspectives.
-
On public television in 1975, Luce declared, "Jesus Christ was the first feminist," taking on even William F. Buckley.
"She was so involved in so many important things for such a long period...even if you're skeptical of biographies, you should make an exception." — Philip Nash [62:35]
-
Nash loves that her life was full of oddities—LSD, poisonings, political scandals, and relationships with notable men and women alike.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- "She is much, much more complicated than I think even she would have presented herself as." — Philip Nash [06:44]
- "I can imagine a political consultant just sort of drooling over her." — Philip Nash [25:08]
- "She would always tell women that if you're going to speak publicly, lower the register of your voice...she was aware of the double standard." — Philip Nash [26:48]
- "She was going to write an autobiography...The Diary of an Unsuccessful Woman." — Philip Nash [22:04]
- "Jesus Christ was the first feminist." — Clare Boothe Luce, recounted by Nash [61:44]
- On her heterodoxy: "At the same time, she is staunchly defending Richard Nixon...welcoming renewed Cold War under Ronald Reagan...she'd be hard to put in anyone pigeonhole." — Philip Nash [62:00]
Timestamps for Major Topics
- [01:38] – Introduction and why write another Luce biography
- [06:41] – Was Luce truly "right-wing"?
- [12:07] – The challenge of narrating a contradictory life
- [16:07] – Authorized vs. unauthorized biography
- [19:38] – Luce’s relationship to Hollywood, Broadway, and celebrity
- [24:24] – The role of theatricality and celebrity in her political career
- [30:12] – Involvement in Wilkie’s “One World” campaign
- [37:18] – Luce’s network: female allies and rivals
- [44:23] – The poisoned ceiling: her ambassadorship to Italy
- [53:24] – LSD, therapy, & why she declined the ambassadorship to Brazil
- [54:09] – How and where to teach Clare Boothe Luce
- [57:52] – Nash’s surprises & final reflections
- [62:58] – Summing up: why Luce matters
Conclusion
Philip Nash makes a compelling case for revisiting Clare Boothe Luce as a "renaissance woman" whose life, far from fitting any single mold, challenges our assumptions about gender, politics, fame, and achievement in 20th-century America. His biography seeks to rescue her complexity from the margins and offer students and readers new ways to think about women’s history, political shifts, and cultural change.