Podcast Summary: New Rory & MAL – Episode 311 | Are Journalists Bigger Than Artists?

Release Date: October 15, 2024

Introduction: Halloween Shenanigans and Weekend Recap

The episode begins with casual banter about October and the joys of the fall season. Hosts Rory, Mal, Julian, and Damaris share humorous stories about their Halloween preparations, including playful mishaps with pumpkin painting. Rory recounts his daughter Amara's creative (and slightly creepy) pumpkin face design, leading to laughs and discussions about upcoming costume plans [00:00 – 05:00].

Main Topic Introduction: Shifting Dynamics in the Music Industry

The conversation swiftly transitions to a significant trend in the music industry: top artists like J. Cole, Kendrick Lamar, and Drake releasing music outside of traditional Digital Streaming Platforms (DSPs) like Spotify and Apple Music. Rory highlights how these artists are leveraging platforms like Twitter and Instagram to distribute their music independently [07:00 – 14:00].

Artists Bypassing DSPs: Implications and Insights

Rory delves deeper into the implications of this shift, emphasizing that major artists are reclaiming control over their music distribution. He notes, “Everything is being released away from the machine. And I think that's going to make shit a lot more fun” [10:27]. The hosts discuss how bypassing DSPs allows artists to test the waters, gather direct feedback, and potentially reduce reliance on major streaming platforms [12:15 – 24:00].

Julian adds that this trend could herald a return to the SoundCloud mixtape era, where artists had more autonomy and creative freedom. He speculates, “I think we're going back to more of that SoundCloud mixtape wave before we were forced to have to put every last fucking thing onto DSPs” [14:53]. This move could empower artists to experiment without the constraints of platform algorithms and sample clearance issues [17:20 – 24:00].

Impact on the Music Industry and DSPs

The discussion shifts to the potential long-term effects on the music industry. Rory warns that if more artists follow this path, it could “cripple” DSPs over time, as direct-to-fan releases become more prevalent [15:33]. The hosts consider how streaming platforms might need to adapt, possibly incorporating more artist-owned content and direct licensing deals [17:20 – 24:00].

Russ’s Confrontation with Journalists: A Case Study

A focal point of the episode is the heated exchange between artist Russ and a journalist on Twitter. Russ criticizes the journalist, asserting that “journalists are not bigger than artists” and emphasizing the importance of artistic autonomy [30:06]. This confrontation sparks debate among the hosts about the evolving role of journalists in a landscape where artists control their narrative more tightly [24:00 – 35:00].

Mal and Damaris argue for a symbiotic relationship between media and artists, highlighting that journalists play a crucial role in promoting music and providing critical perspectives. In contrast, Rory and Julian explore the potential downsides, questioning whether this shift could undermine journalistic integrity and objectivity [35:00 – 45:00].

Broader Implications for Journalism and Media

The hosts explore the broader implications of Russ’s stance, suggesting that if major artists continue to reject traditional media channels, it could lead to a significant reshaping of how music is promoted and critiqued. Rory notes, “I think they have been following suit with each one… subconsciously playing the same game” [24:43]. Julian adds that without major label deals, artists have more freedom but also bear the responsibility of managing their own media presence [14:53 – 24:00].

Voicemails: Classroom Management and Gaslighting Debate

In the latter part of the episode, the hosts engage with listener voicemails, covering diverse topics from classroom management strategies to internal debates about gaslighting among the hosts.

1. Classroom Management Strategies: A teacher named Maddie shares her tactic of countering student slang by reading lyrics in a dramatic, outdated style to dissuade usage. The hosts discuss effective ways to handle disruptive language and maintain classroom decorum [83:00 – 94:00].

2. Gaslighting Debate: The conversation becomes heated as Damaris accuses other hosts of gaslighting, leading to a spirited debate about the definition and occurrence of gaslighting within their interactions. Rory defends himself by referencing behaviors and misunderstandings, while Damaris insists on specific instances of manipulation [94:00 – 112:00].

Conclusion: Reflecting on Industry Trends and Interpersonal Dynamics

As the episode wraps up, the hosts reflect on the importance of adapting to industry changes while maintaining personal and professional relationships. They emphasize the need for balanced media approaches and the ongoing evolution of artist-media dynamics. The episode concludes with announcements of upcoming events and a lighthearted sign-off [112:00 – End].

Notable Quotes:

• Rory on Artist Independence: “Everything is being released away from the machine. And I think that's going to make shit a lot more fun.” [10:27]

• Russ on Journalistic Integrity: “Your career does not exist without artists. Your job is to stand on the sideline... Relax.” [30:06]

• Julian on DSP Implications: “I think we're going back to more of that SoundCloud mixtape wave that was of 10 years ago before we were forced to have to put every last fucking thing onto DSPs.” [14:53]

• Rory on Industry Shifts: “I'm not sure it's going to be a major effect anytime soon. But I see the breadcrumbs that are being laid by the three biggest artists… something they all notice within the three of them.” [13:56]

• Damaris on Gaslighting Definition: “Gaslighting is a form of psychological abuse where a person causes someone to question their sanity, memories, or perception of reality.” [88:00]

Key Insights and Conclusions:

1. Autonomy and Control: Top artists are increasingly seeking autonomy by releasing music independently of DSPs, utilizing social media platforms to reach their audience directly.

2. Industry Disruption: This trend could disrupt existing music distribution models, potentially diminishing the influence of streaming platforms and reshaping revenue streams.

3. Journalist-Artist Relationship: The confrontation between Russ and journalists highlights tensions over narrative control and the evolving role of media in an artist-dominated landscape.

4. Media Adaptation: As artists gain more control over their releases, media professionals may need to adapt by building stronger personal brands and direct fan engagement.

5. Interpersonal Dynamics: The episode underscores the importance of clear communication and understanding within professional relationships, as evidenced by the heated debate on gaslighting.

Final Thoughts:

Episode 311 of New Rory & MAL provides an insightful exploration into the shifting dynamics of the music industry, particularly the growing trend of artist independence from traditional DSPs. The hosts engage in a lively debate about the implications for journalists and the broader media landscape, underscoring the need for adaptability and mutual respect. Amidst the main discussion, listener interactions add a personal touch, revealing the hosts' ability to navigate both industry-wide trends and interpersonal challenges with candidness and humor.

For listeners who haven’t tuned in, this episode offers a comprehensive look at how major shifts in music distribution and media relations are influencing the industry’s future, all delivered with the hosts' characteristic wit and depth.