Podcast Summary: Nightly Scroll with Hayley Caronia

Episode 223: Did Ilhan Omar Stage Her “Attack"? Trump Thinks So

Date: January 29, 2026
Host: Hayley Caronia

Episode Overview

In this episode, Hayley Caronia analyzes the recent incident where Congresswoman Ilhan Omar was sprayed with a liquid at a Minneapolis town hall, raising questions about whether the event was staged—a theory echoed by President Trump. Hayley also updates listeners on a fired nurse who advocated harming ICE agents, celebrates Nicki Minaj’s pro-Trump activism, and critiques Hollywood politics and public reactions to controversial ICE incidents. As always, she injects her signature sharp wit and conservative perspective, dissecting media narratives and calling out perceived double standards on the left.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Ilhan Omar "Attack": Was It Staged?

• Media Narratives vs. Reality
  • Hayley discusses varied mainstream media headlines that labeled the incident an “attack” before any facts were widely available ([02:00-03:20]).

    “The Washington Post. Their headline said, rep. Alon Omar attacked at town hall meeting in Minneapolis…So I’m thinking, well, this must be bad. This must be really bad.” — Hayley ([02:20])

• Analysis of the Event Footage
  • Hayley scrutinizes multiple video angles, noting Omar's reaction:
    • Omar raised her fists and moved toward the man, pen in hand, rather than retreating—behavior Hayley finds odd if feeling genuinely threatened ([04:00-07:10]).
    • She describes a woman alerting Omar she’d been sprayed and security urging her to get checked out, but Omar insisted on finishing the speech, “playing the hero” ([07:20-08:45]).

    “Why does she go towards him? Wouldn’t you try to put some distance between yourself and this person…?” — Hayley ([04:23]) “She takes the security guard’s beard and then she basically tells the security guard she’s calling the shots, not the security guard.” — Hayley ([08:30])

• Speculation About Staging
  • Hayley references viral online theories, notably a slow-motion video showing Omar glancing at the man moments before the spray, suggesting a possible cue ([09:20-10:10]).
• Nature of the Liquid
  • Reports indicate it was only apple cider vinegar, per HAZMAT team info relayed by Alpha News ([11:00]).
• Omar’s Media Response
  • Omar appeared on CNN, positioning herself as a survivor of war and intimidation.

    “I’ve survived war and I’ve survived the apple cider vinegar attack as well… I’m built that way.” — Ilhan Omar ([12:30])

• Political Fallout & Allegations
  • AOC blamed the incident on Trump and Vance, charging that their rhetoric incited violence ([13:50]).

    “The left is always…We don’t. Right. They’re very quick to point fingers at the Trump administration…” — Hayley

• Details About the Attacker
  • The man, Anthony Kazmerzak (“Andy”), has no recent criminal record, and his background appears politically ambiguous—Following/followed by Turning Point USA university chapters, posts both pro-law enforcement and pro-Ukraine, child identifying as non-binary, etc. ([16:00-18:00]).
• Trump’s Take
  • Trump: “She probably had herself sprayed. Knowing her…” — ([18:26])
• Hayley’s Conclusion
  • Hayley is not declaring certainty but calls for Omar’s communications to be investigated, citing “too many oddities” to dismiss staging as impossible. ([18:50])

2. ICE Controversies and Public Perception

• Tim Walz & Minnesota Politics
  • Hayley criticizes Minnesota Governor Tim Walz for focusing on “woke” issues, mocking his response to other politicians ([19:34]).
• ICE Agent-Involved Shootings Public Polling
  • A new poll shows 48% of Americans believe the shooting of Alex Preddy was not justified; Hayley bemoans how opinion has outpaced fact-finding, especially when many respondents haven't seen the full video ([21:59-22:55]).
• Breaking Down the Preddy Video
  • She shares footage from January 13, with Preddy “rage-baiting” ICE agents—kicking police vehicles and appearing armed, underscoring her claim that activists are goading ICE into violent responses ([23:09-24:31]).
  • Hayley asserts leftist activists use confrontations to create propaganda—“rage baiting them and seeing how far can I push this man… Then we can use that and we have all the footage for it.” ([25:05])
• Double Standards on Rhetoric and Violence
  • Hayley cites a Democrat candidate’s inflammatory statement about Trump and other examples where she believes Democrats don’t face consequences for violent speech ([27:27]).

3. Updates on "Crazy Nurse" and School Culture Wars

• Nurse Tells People How To Harm ICE Agents
  • Nurse fired from VCU Health after posting videos about poisoning ICE agents ([28:20]).

    “Thank goodness they have the wherewithal to fire someone who is threatening pain and harm on other people.” — Hayley ([29:10])

• Teacher Suspended for “Go ICE” Comment
  • Chicago teacher placed on leave for supporting ICE on Facebook, contrasted with another teacher allowed to keep job after mocking Charlie Kirk’s assassination ([30:25-31:20]).
• Hayley’s Take on Educators & Politics
  • Argues teachers should avoid posting political opinions publicly to reduce polarization and cancel culture ([32:00-34:40]).

    “I just think we need to get back to the part where people just don't talk about politics. Like, can we just go back to when it was taboo?” — Hayley ([33:25])

• Substitute Teacher Fired Over Racially Charged Discussion
  • Critiques overreaching classroom discussions, ridicules teachers trying to be provocative ([35:37-37:30]).

4. Immigration, ICE, and Narrative Manipulation

• ICE Denied Detainee’s Request to Attend Son’s Funeral
  • Hayley walks through the background of a denied ICE detainee, whose son (with severe needs) died while he was detained; she notes the man is linked to a terrorist group (per DHS)—raising questions about selective media sympathy ([38:10-40:55]).

    “It is sad…but he was in the United States undocumented for over three decades. If you can't get it done in three decades, you're either not trying or there's a damn good reason…” — Hayley ([40:30])

• Manipulation of Social Media to Drive Fear
  • Reviews a viral Instagram video using fake ICE-raid audio to sow fear, points out the user is Puerto Rican and thus, by law, safe from deportation ([54:15-55:20]).

    “Girl, you're fine. You're not being deported. Your kids are fine. Your video is fake. You're Puerto Rican. You're fine.” — Hayley ([55:16])

5. Pop Culture & Political Alignments

• Nicki Minaj’s Ongoing Trump Support
  • Nicki Minaj appears publicly at a Trump event, doubles down on her support ([41:35-43:00]).

    “The haters are her motivation. That is very cool. She is very, very proud to be a Trump supporter…and I love that she is not backing down.” — Hayley ([43:15]) “I am probably the president’s number one fan, and that’s not going to change…” — Nicki Minaj ([42:12])

• Kristen Stewart’s Hollywood Boycott Threat
  • Stewart discusses “filming in Europe and shoving her movies down Americans’ throats,” to which Hayley responds:

    “I would like to know why she thinks she can't work freely in the United States. There is no country more free…” — Hayley ([45:10])

    • Mocks Stewart’s perception of her cultural impact.

    “No one cares. I don't think people are going to care about her little protests as much as she thinks they do.” — Hayley ([46:18])

6. Liberal “Rage Baiting” and Gender Roles

• Critique of Left-Wing Male Protesters
  • Hayley reacts to video of a liberal man resisting arrest and calling for help from fellow activists who only film instead of assisting ([49:00-51:00]).

    “Like, these are just like pussy men. Like, they're just losers, like liberal losers.” — Hayley ([49:20])

• Teamwork or Clout-Chasing in Protest Videos
  • Wonders how activists coordinate or race to post their footage for maximum attention ([52:10-53:00]).

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Omar’s Response:
  “Why does she go towards him? Wouldn’t you try to put some distance between yourself and this person…?” — Hayley ([04:23])
• On Trump’s Take:
  “She probably had herself sprayed. Knowing her, I haven't seen it…and I hope I don't have to bother.” — Donald Trump, via Hayley ([18:26])
• On Political Double Standards:
  “If the left has any standards at all, it's a double standard.” — Hayley ([25:53])
• On the Chicago Teacher Suspension:
  “Aside from teaching politics from the lens of American history, teachers should not be discussing politics…Why involve yourself?” — Hayley ([33:15])
• On Nicki Minaj:
  “She is very, very proud to be a Trump supporter…and I love that she is not backing down. She is doubling, tripling down. And I love to see it.” — Hayley ([43:15])
• On Fake ICE Panic:
  “Your kids are fine. Your video is fake. You're Puerto Rican. You're fine. Like, it's all fake. It's just all fake news.” — Hayley ([55:16])

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Ilhan Omar Incident Breakdown: [02:00–18:50]
• Trump’s Comment on Omar: [18:26]
• ICE/Tim Walz Discussion: [19:34–24:31]
• Alex Preddy/ICE Shooting Video: [23:09–24:31]
• Dem Rhetoric on Trump: [27:27]
• “Crazy Nurse” Fired: [28:20–29:10]
• Teacher Double Standards: [30:25–34:40]
• Sub Talk on Racial Slurs: [35:37–37:30]
• ICE Detainee Story: [38:10–40:55]
• Nicki Minaj Segment: [41:35–43:15]
• Kristen Stewart Hollywood Critique: [44:50–46:18]
• Liberal Protesters & Clout Chasing: [49:00–53:00]
• Fake ICE Social Media: [54:15–55:20]

Tone & Delivery

Hayley's tone is conversational, irreverent, and unapologetically right-leaning. She combines sharp skepticism with biting humor, frequently lampooning the left, the mainstream media, and “Hollywood elites.” Her show is peppered with personal anecdotes, mockery, and candid asides to her live chat. She regularly repeats slogans about “double standards” and critiques the state of political discourse.

For Listeners Who Missed It

This episode delivers a deep-dive into the Ilhan Omar "attack" controversy, laced with Hayley’s trademark sarcasm and skepticism toward mainstream media narratives and Democratic politicians. Key segments include detailed video analysis, policy commentary, and pop culture reactions—all underscored by Hayley’s call for independent investigation and critical thinking.

End of summary.