Nightly Scroll with Hayley Caronia

Episode 141: ICE Agents, Facilities Under Attack
Date: September 25, 2025
Host: Hayley Caronia
Notable Guest: Andy (Co-host/Commentator)

Episode Overview

Hayley Caronia delivers sharp, unapologetic conservative commentary on the recent surge of attacks against ICE facilities and agents, dissecting the political rhetoric driving this violence. She offers candid analysis on media responses, criticizes prominent figures on the left, and covers viral cultural stories—from Jimmy Kimmel’s contentious late-night return to bizarre U.S. laws and the latest in Covid activism. As always, Hayley’s wit, skepticism, and no-nonsense attitude guide listeners through the night’s most explosive headlines.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. ICE Facility Attack in Dallas: Details, Motives, and Rhetoric

[02:02 – 16:42]

Incident Breakdown

• A sniper opened fire atop a Dallas ICE facility, killing one detainee and critically injuring others before taking his own life. This follows recent threats and attacks on nearby detention centers.
• Attacks on ICE agents have reportedly soared by over 1,000% this year.

Motive and Evidence

• FBI Director Cash Patel reported on X that bullet casings were engraved with "Anti-ICE," supporting an ideological motive.

  “An initial review of the evidence shows an ideological motive behind this attack… one of the unspent shell casings recovered was engraved with the phrase Anti ice.” — [05:43] (Paraphrasing Cash Patel post)

Media Reaction & Political Blame

• MSNBC & Christopher O’Leary (former FBI exec): Questioned the evident motive, compared it to prior right-wing mass shooters, and seemed "strange" it would come from the left.

  “It is a little strange because… if you are trying to carry out some kind of message countering more extreme right-wing stuff… why you would use a tactic that a famous white supremacist… used?” — [07:23]

• Hayley lampoons MSNBC's and Keith Olbermann’s responses, pointing out the left’s reluctance to acknowledge left-wing rhetoric as a cause of political violence.

Political Responsibility & Rhetoric

• A montage of prominent Democrat voices (Pramila Jayapal, Hillary Clinton, etc.) comparing ICE to "Gestapo" and "terrorists" is played, highlighting incendiary rhetoric.

  “Every single ICE agent who’s engaged in this aggressive overreach, no matter what it takes... will of course be identified.” — [12:35] (Montage Clip) “ICE agents... are coming and kidnapping and disappearing people on the streets of the United States.” — Hillary Clinton [13:16] (Montage Clip)

J.D. Vance’s Response

• The Vice President delivers a forceful condemnation of demonizing law enforcement, arguing that escalating anti-ICE rhetoric from top Democrats directly fuels political violence.

  “If you want to stop political violence, stop attacking our law enforcement as the Gestapo… If you want to stop political violence, look in the mirror.” — J.D. Vance [14:58]

2. Media & Political Figures in the Spotlight

Keith Olbermann Meltdown

• Olbermann called for DHS Secretary Kristi Noem to resign, blaming her for any violence involving detainees.

  “The victims were detainees in your care. They are your responsibility. Resign.” — (Summarized at [09:02])

The Political Double Standard

• Hayley highlights how Democrats issue tepid, generic statements after violence, then resume attacking Republicans in media appearances.

  “It’s all lip service. And thankfully, we have a vice president who’s man enough to call it out.” — [16:42]

3. Jimmy Kimmel’s Emotional Return & Media Reactions

[18:03 – 30:51]

Apology… or Not?

• Kimmel returned to late night with a tearful monologue, attempting to show remorse regarding comments made after the Charlie Kirk assassination.

  “I don’t think what I have to say is going to make much of a difference... I do want to make something clear... it was never my intention to make light of the murder of a young man.” — Jimmy Kimmel [18:03]

Panel’s Take

• Andy and Hayley debate whether Kimmel's tears are genuine and whether he truly apologized. Consensus: the apology was half-hearted, and he quickly reverted to attacking Trump.

  “He sort of scathed around saying, I’m sorry. Flat out says, I’m sorry. But 22 million Americans were impacted worldwide... I hope Jimmy Kimmel’s heart isn’t impervious to that.” — Andy [19:38] “When he started crying in the beginning, it seemed very fake to me, but I do think that he was moved when talking about Erica [Kirk].” — Hayley [21:22]

Ratings & Cultural Impact

• Kimmel's return drew 6 million TV viewers and 14 million YouTube views of his monologue, attributed more to curiosity about a possible apology than genuine support.

  “The majority of this number… I wanted to see if he would apologize.” — Andy [26:25] “6 million is a big number. No matter how you slice it…” — Hayley [25:55]

Hillary Clinton’s Take

• Clinton frames Kimmel’s suspension as authoritarian overreach by "dictator Trump," a claim Hayley fiercely disputes.

  “It is right out of the authoritarian playbook… Silence your opponents, cripple the media…” — Hillary Clinton [27:38] “That is not what happened. It’s astonishing how they’re getting this so wrong. President Trump did not get Jimmy Kimmel fired… [He] learned that actions have consequences.” — Hayley [28:40]

Closing Irony

• Clinton briefly admits, “we have got to stop demonizing each other… I include myself…” [29:55] Hayley and Andy lampoon this “moment of self-awareness” as toothless and unconvincing.

4. Attempted Assassination of Donald Trump: Courtroom Drama

[35:04 – 36:52]

• The would-be Trump assassin was found guilty on all charges and tried to stab himself in court after the verdict.
• Hayley: “Life in prison. I think that’s fitting for someone who tried to kill a presidential candidate and a former president of the United States, if you ask me.” [35:51]

5. Viral & Cultural Stories

A. North Carolina’s “Arena’s Law”

• Named after a Ukrainian refugee murdered on public transit, the law aims to limit bail and increase mental health intervention for repeat offenders.

  “Making change in her honor I think is really, really great.” — Hayley [37:08]

B. Violet Affleck’s Masked UN Speech

• Ben Affleck & Jennifer Garner’s daughter addressed the UN as a masked Covid activist, prompting skepticism and mockery from Hayley and Andy.

  “I can’t hear you. Take your mask off.” — Hayley [40:03] “Why are you wearing safety goggles? Like, she looks like she's getting ready to go play paintball.” — Andy [41:09] “Nobody has ever told her no in her whole life. … This is a resume filler for Violet Affleck.” — Hayley [42:09]

C. Medical Misinformation & Tylenol Debate

• Hayley discusses resurgent discourse about Tylenol’s safety during pregnancy, using it to highlight shifting science and distrust of mainstream medicine.

  “People had to find out the hard way… Science is supposed to evolve.” — Hayley [44:53]

D. Trump’s “Walk of Fame”: Presidential Troll

• Trump’s newly nominated “Walk of Fame” features all presidents, but for Biden simply lists “Joe Auto Pen Biden,” with Hayley and Andy mocking the symbolism.

  “He’s a quintessential troller. Trump is that.” — Andy [47:36]

6. Scroll Time: The Weird Law Segment

[48:19 – 55:31]

• Connecticut bans first cousin marriages starting Oct 1, prompting laughter and banter about cousin relationships in Southern states.

  “If you’re a freak and you love your cousin, you have a few days left to marry them in Connecticut.” — Hayley [49:10]

Other Bizarre Laws Highlighted:

• In Alaska: Illegal to push a live moose out of an airplane.
• In Montana: You can’t leave a sheep unattended in a truck.
• In Washington: Harassing Bigfoot is a felony.
• In Nebraska: Illegal to fish for whales.
• In Virginia: Illegal to tickle a woman.
• In Alabama: Illegal to wear a fake mustache to church if it causes laughter.
• In Texas: Illegal to tie an elephant to a parking meter.
• In Arizona: Donkeys may not sleep in bathtubs.

7. Education Indoctrination: Christian Identity Movement Confusion

[55:45 – 60:49]

• Hayley follows up on a viral TikTok: a student misread a sociology textbook labeling “Christian” identities as a white supremacist group due to lack of context on “Christian Identity Movement.”

  “If you don’t have that context, of course you think that. … I’ve never heard of this in my life.” — Hayley [58:41] “This feels like an easy way to indoctrinate college kids. Let’s throw a chapter about something that we just created.” — Andy [60:42]

8. Memorable Moment: Mini Horse Therapy Keyboards

[61:42 – 62:23]

• Light-hearted close: Miniature therapy horse wakes up children from anesthesia by playing a keyboard.

  “If I have woken up from anesthesia and that thing was playing that keyboard, I would just ask [it] to kick me in the side of the head and put me back to sleep.” — Andy [61:57] “No way to wake up!” — Hayley [62:10]

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• J.D. Vance on political violence:

  “If you want to stop political violence, look in the mirror.” [14:58]

• Hayley on left-wing rhetoric:

  “Everything aggressive overreach. They said 1930s... They use words like Gestapo and Nazi to talk about ICE agents sitting members of Congress.” [13:00]

• Andy on Jimmy Kimmel’s apology:

  “He sort of scathed around saying, I’m sorry. Flat out says, I’m sorry. But 22 million Americans were impacted worldwide… wish that he would just never made that joke…” [19:38]

• Hayley on Hillary Clinton’s self-awareness:

  “Stop demonizing the other side. Says the woman who called us a basket of deplorables.” [30:51]

• On Connecticut’s cousin marriage ban:

  “If you’re a freak and you love your cousin, you have a few days left to marry them in Connecticut.” — Hayley [49:10]

Overall Tone and Closing Thoughts

Hayley maintains a fiery, irreverent tone throughout, mixing media criticism with pointed humor and cultural commentary. Her skepticism toward the institutional left is sharp, yet often wrapped in satire and banter with Andy. The segment-heavy format keeps the episode fast-paced, providing both serious critique on political violence and lighter moments on social absurdities.

Listeners come away with a clear conservative viewpoint, a sense of frustration at political and media hypocrisy, and a few laughs at the expense of both coastal elites and government bureaucracy.

For full context or more details, including video clips referenced, catch the episode replay on Rumble or your favorite podcast app.