Nightly Scroll with Hayley - Episode 50 Summary: "Mob Prosecutor Comey Plays Dumb After Calling To ‘86’ Trump"
Release Date: May 16, 2025
In Episode 50 of "Nightly Scroll with Hayley," host Hayley Caronia delves into the explosive controversy surrounding former FBI Director James Comey's recent Instagram post, explores President Trump's tumultuous relationship with the media, examines tragic incidents involving illegal immigrants, and addresses significant policy changes and societal issues. The episode is structured into several key segments, each providing insightful analysis and passionate commentary.
1. James Comey's Instagram Controversy
Initial Post and Immediate Reactions [00:00 - 05:03]
Hayley begins the episode by addressing James Comey's controversial Instagram post, where he shared an image of a shell formation along with the cryptic numbers "86 47."
Hayley Caronia [00:00]: "James Comey, he's under fire now for a deleted Instagram post in which he called to 86 47. He used to call President Trump a mob boss and he used to prosecute mobsters in New York for years. But he claims he didn't think 86 meant to kill Trump."
Hayley highlights the significance of the term "86," suggesting it carries violent undertones, especially given Comey's history in mob prosecution. She also references another individual, Ed Krasnstein, who mirrored Comey's post with similar cryptic numbering, further fueling suspicions.
Comey's Interview with Bret Baier [03:57 - 05:03]
Hayley plays a segment from James Comey's interview with Bret Baier on Fox News, where Comey addresses the implications of his post.
James Comey [03:57]: "He knew exactly what that meant. A child knows what that meant. If you're the FBI director and you don't know what that meant, right? That meant assassination. And it says it loud and clear."
Comey's strong language suggests a direct threat against President Trump, leading to widespread condemnation.
2. Analysis of the "86" Meaning and Comey's Motives [05:03 - 09:56]
Hayley dissects the possible meanings behind "86," emphasizing its historical context in mob terminology, where it signifies eliminating someone completely.
Hayley Caronia [05:03]: "James Comey knows about the mob. He also spent a very long time calling President Trump and others in his cabinet a mob boss and mob like."
She argues that Comey's intention likely extends beyond a benign message, considering his past statements and actions against Trump.
3. Impact on President Trump and Political Climate [09:56 - 13:10]
Hayley connects Comey's actions to the broader political tensions surrounding President Trump, suggesting that Comey's personal vendettas have intensified divisions.
Hayley Caronia [11:47]: "The Swamp tries to 86 Trump politically, and then when they fail, they openly, publicly call for him to be 86."
She underscores the dangerous rhetoric that fuels threats against the president, reflecting deep-seated animosity from certain political factions.
4. Reactions from Officials and Calls for Accountability [13:10 - 15:00]
The episode shifts focus to the responses from high-ranking officials. FBI Director Cash Patel and DHS Secretary Christine Ohm condemn Comey's post and initiate investigations.
Christine Ohm: "James Comey did call for the assassination of President Trump... DHS and Secret Service is investigating this threat and will respond appropriately."
Hayley advocates for stringent actions against Comey to prevent potential violence, drawing parallels to unchecked hate speech and its real-world consequences.
5. Tragic Case in South Carolina: Murder by Illegal Migrants [15:00 - 25:00]
Hayley narrates the heartbreaking story of Larisha Sherrell Thompson, a 40-year-old mother who was randomly ambushed and killed by six illegal immigrants in South Carolina.
Hayley Caronia [20:00]: "Six illegal alien teens, 13 to 21 years old... they pulled up beside her... shot her to death."
She criticizes the current immigration policies, attributing the tragedy to lax enforcement and highlighting the perceived dangers posed by illegal immigrants.
6. Voter Sentiments on Illegal Immigration [25:00 - 30:00]
Referencing a Signal poll, Hayley presents data showing overwhelming support among voters for the deportation of illegal immigrants.
Hayley Caronia [28:00]: "63.5% of voters... support deporting illegal aliens from the country. 90% of Republicans feel that you should deport all illegal aliens."
She contrasts this with the Democratic stance, which she argues contradicts voter sentiments, further fueling political polarization.
7. Policy Update: HHS Revises COVID Vaccine Recommendations [30:00 - 35:00]
Hayley shares the significant policy change from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), which has reversed CDC recommendations for COVID-19 vaccines for pregnant women and children.
Hayley Caronia [32:00]: "HHS is reversing the CDC recommendation... there's no reason why children need to be COVID 19 vaxxed."
She praises the decision, emphasizing the importance of evidence-based policies and expressing relief over the reduction in vaccine mandates.
8. Legislative Progress in California on Soliciting Sex from Teens [35:00 - 40:00]
The discussion moves to California's legislative efforts to criminalize soliciting sex from 16 and 17-year-olds, marking a shift from misdemeanors to felonies.
Hayley Caronia [38:00]: "The California assembly approved harsher penalties for soliciting sex from 16 and 17-year-olds, which is a win across the board."
She commends the bipartisan support for the bill, though she notes the remaining exceptions and the challenge ahead in the Senate.
9. Controversial Topic: Transgender Athletes in High School Sports [40:00 - 55:02]
Hayley and co-host Mikey engage in a heated debate over the inclusion of transgender athletes in female sports categories. They cite a specific case from a Pennsylvania high school where a transgender male athlete outperformed female competitors by significant margins.
Hayley Caronia [41:04]: "These trans athletes just want to solidify their college scholarships... They're losers. They want to wipe the floor with women to feel like winners."
The segment is marked by strong opinions against transgender participation in female sports, arguing it undermines fairness and opportunities for female athletes.
10. Positive News: Tiffany Trump’s New Baby [55:02 - 60:00]
Despite the intense discussions, Hayley shares a heartwarming update about Tiffany Trump welcoming her baby boy, Alexander Trump Boulos, celebrating a moment of joy amidst the chaos.
Hayley Caronia [55:02]: "Congratulations to the Trump family. I hope Tiffany and baby are doing well."
11. Scrolling Time: Societal Changes Due to Technology and Fast Food [60:00 - End]
In the "Scrolling Time" segment, Hayley and Mikey react to viral videos highlighting the decline of social interactions due to technological advancements and the shift in dining habits away from traditional chain restaurants.
Hayley Caronia [43:45]: "With the introduction of technology, streaming services make life so convenient that we end up removing social aspects of our lives."
They lament the erosion of community engagement and the rise of solo activities, attributing it to factors like the economy, social anxiety, and changing family dynamics.
Notable Quotes from Scrolling Time:
Mikey [51:09]: "Get the COVID vaccine shot, you are, in fact killing people."
Tiffany Trump [43:45]: "It's because they didn't have to manage their schedule properly... proper work ethic."
12. Q&A Segment: Listener Questions and Personal Insights [60:00 - End]
Hayley concludes the episode by addressing listener-submitted questions, ranging from generational shifts and media evolution to personal preferences in dating and social interactions.
Hayley Caronia [56:52]: "I think Gen Z is kind of the cutoff where maybe elder Gen Z... but the younger generation, it's really become maybe a depression thing."
She reflects on the challenges of forming new relationships in different locales and shares personal anecdotes about her own experiences and preferences.
Conclusion
Episode 50 of "Nightly Scroll with Hayley" offers a comprehensive and impassioned exploration of pressing political and social issues, anchored by Hayley Caronia's fervent conservative perspective. From dissecting high-profile scandals to addressing policy changes and societal trends, Hayley provides listeners with a blend of sharp analysis and candid commentary, ensuring a thought-provoking listening experience for those engaged with contemporary culture wars.