Episode Summary: You Might Also Like: Revisionist History Release Date: March 28, 2025
Introduction
In this episode of Revisionist History, host Malcolm Gladwell embarks on an unconventional journey to defend a seemingly universally criticized children's show: Paw Patrol. Despite widespread disdain among parents, educators, and intellectuals, Gladwell reveals his unexpected admiration for the franchise. This episode delves into the intricacies of Paw Patrol, exploring its impact on children's cognitive development and societal values.
Paw Patrol: A Cultural Phenomenon
Gladwell begins by introducing Paw Patrol, a multi-billion-dollar franchise centered around a team of heroic puppies who undertake various rescue missions in the fictional towns of Adventure Bay and Foggy Bottom. He highlights the show's immense popularity among toddlers, surpassing iconic characters like Elmo and Mickey Mouse.
Notable Quote:
"Among toddlers, Paw Patrol is bigger than Elmo. It's bigger than Mickey Mouse. Just ask my daughter."
— Malcolm Gladwell [04:08]
Despite its appeal to young audiences, Gladwell points out the widespread criticism the show faces. Parents and educators argue that Paw Patrol stifles children's creativity and problem-solving skills by presenting problems that are invariably resolved swiftly and predictably.
Notable Quote:
"Like the Reddit thread, Paw Patrol has ruined my child's brain. Everything about Paw Patrol is awful. The yelling and constant panic. The stereotypes, the terrible design, the tropes. I wish it would disappear from the face of the earth and take all of its merch with it."
— Reddit User [04:28]
Behind the Scenes: Insights from Creators
Gladwell interviews Cal Brunker and Bob Barlan, the writers behind the Paw Patrol movies, to uncover why the show resonates so deeply with children.
Notable Quote:
"The structures are so clear and consistent from episode to episode that it really pulls them in and they're able to feel comfortable and confident in that world of storytelling."
— Cal Brunker [09:18]
Brunker explains that the show's predictable structure allows children to engage confidently, knowing what to expect. This consistency fosters a sense of security and participation among young viewers.
Gladwell also shares impressive statistics, noting that Paw Patrol has spanned 11 television seasons and grossed $350 million from two feature films. He emphasizes that the show's approach to problem-solving is methodical and reinforces the idea of community and cooperation.
The Criticism: An Expert Perspective
To present a balanced view, Gladwell brings in Angus Fletcher, a neuroscientist and narrative theorist at Ohio State University, who offers a scathing critique of Paw Patrol.
Notable Quote:
"It's designed to anesthetize your brain. I mean, I feel like I'm mainlining horse tranquilizer. It's a show that is studiously designed to interrupt active thought."
— Angus Fletcher [16:35]
Fletcher introduces the concept of "vacuous agon," a term coined by his colleague Mike Benvenisti, describing narratives where conflicts are resolved effortlessly, eliminating any genuine tension or need for critical thinking.
Notable Quote:
"They're deleting their capacity to develop an awareness of other answers to problems. You're removing that source of natural creativity."
— Angus Fletcher [25:43]
He argues that by consistently solving problems instantly, Paw Patrol hampers children's ability to engage in counterfactual causal thinking, a crucial cognitive process for developing problem-solving skills and resilience.
Defense and Alternate Theory: Paw Patrol as Canadian Propaganda
Undeterred by Fletcher's critique, Gladwell presents his "Alternate Paw Patrol Theory," positing that the show's underlying message aligns with Canadian societal values of peace, order, and good government.
Notable Quote:
"Paw Patrol is an homage. It is the elaboration of the notion of peace, order, and good government."
— Malcolm Gladwell [28:51]
Gladwell connects this to the Canadian national narrative, suggesting that Paw Patrol embodies an idealistic view of municipal competence and interagency cooperation. He contrasts this with traditional American individualism, framing Paw Patrol as a representation of collective societal efforts to address communal issues.
Notable Quote:
"It's the end. It's like the nadir of comedy, because... Just relax, preschooler. Don't worry about this big, bad world you're entering in, because it's just fine. Don't even use your brain."
— Angus Fletcher [23:45]
Despite Fletcher's strong opposition, Gladwell argues that the show's portrayal of selfless heroes and community-focused problem-solving provides a positive framework for children, aligning with Canadian cultural values.
Cultural Comparisons and Final Reflections
Gladwell draws parallels between Paw Patrol and other cultural icons, such as Superman and Saul Bellow's literature, to underscore his argument that the show promotes a utopian vision of society where collective action prevails over individual heroism.
He contemplates the broader implications of Fletcher's criticisms, acknowledging the potential drawbacks but ultimately advocating for the positive messages Paw Patrol imparts to its young audience.
Notable Quote:
"A world where there is a puppy optimized for every kind of peril. Where help arrives at the very moment it is summoned. Where the heroes work not to benefit themselves, but the community in which they live."
— Malcolm Gladwell [40:47]
Conclusion
In this thought-provoking episode, Malcolm Gladwell navigates the contentious discourse surrounding Paw Patrol, balancing expert criticism with cultural analysis. Through engaging interviews and insightful comparisons, he presents a nuanced perspective on how children's media can shape societal values and cognitive development.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
-
"Among toddlers, Paw Patrol is bigger than Elmo. It's bigger than Mickey Mouse. Just ask my daughter."
— Malcolm Gladwell [04:08] -
"Like the Reddit thread, Paw Patrol has ruined my child's brain. Everything about Paw Patrol is awful."
— Reddit User [04:28] -
"The structures are so clear and consistent from episode to episode that it really pulls them in and they're able to feel comfortable and confident in that world of storytelling."
— Cal Brunker [09:18] -
"It's designed to anesthetize your brain. I mean, I feel like I'm mainlining horse tranquilizer. It's a show that is studiously designed to interrupt active thought."
— Angus Fletcher [16:35] -
"They're deleting their capacity to develop an awareness of other answers to problems. You're removing that source of natural creativity."
— Angus Fletcher [25:43] -
"Paw Patrol is an homage. It is the elaboration of the notion of peace, order, and good government."
— Malcolm Gladwell [28:51] -
"A world where there is a puppy optimized for every kind of peril. Where help arrives at the very moment it is summoned. Where the heroes work not to benefit themselves, but the community in which they live."
— Malcolm Gladwell [40:47]
Additional Information
-
Production Team:
- Produced by Nina Bird Lawrence, Lucy Sullivan, and Ben Nadaff Haffrey
- Editor: Karen Shakurji
- Fact-Checking: Sam Russik
- Engineering: Nina Bird Lawrence
- Mixing and Mastering: Echo Mountain
- Production Support: Loup Lemond
- Executive Producer: Jacob Smith
- Special Thanks: Sarah Nix and El Jefe Greta Kung
-
Support and Sponsors:
- Capital One Bank Guy advertisements interspersed throughout the episode
- Nissan Murano, Reese's Chocolate Lava Big Cup, and other sponsors featured in promotional segments
-
Cosmetic Elements:
- Musical interludes from the Paw Patrol Theme Song punctuate the episode, enhancing the discussion's thematic focus.
This episode of Revisionist History offers a compelling examination of children's media, urging listeners to reconsider the subtle influences embedded within popular shows like Paw Patrol. Through Malcolm Gladwell's balanced approach, the episode invites a deeper conversation about the role of storytelling in shaping young minds and societal values.