Nonprofit Leadership Podcast: Developing Your Own Personal Growth Plan

Host: Rob Harter
Guest: Doug Paul, We Are Catapult
Release Date: January 27, 2025

Introduction

In the January 27, 2025 episode of the Nonprofit Leadership Podcast, host Dr. Rob Harder delves into the critical topic of developing personal growth plans for nonprofit leaders. With a focus on addressing the pressing issues of recruitment and retention within the nonprofit sector, Rob welcomes Doug Paul from We Are Catapult, an organization dedicated to supporting nonprofit leaders and organizations in scaling and enhancing their impact.

Guest Introduction: Doug Paul from We Are Catapult

Doug Paul brings extensive experience in strategic planning and leadership development tailored for nonprofits. We Are Catapult prides itself on going beyond traditional fundraising and development strategies, offering comprehensive services that address the evolving challenges nonprofits face in a rapidly changing world.

Key Discussion Topics

1. Recruitment and Retention Challenges in Nonprofits

Rob initiates the conversation by highlighting the intertwined nature of recruitment and retention in the nonprofit sector. He observes:

“Recruitment and retention are really two sides of the same coin in my mind. [00:01]”
— Dr. Rob Harder

Doug concurs, emphasizing the difficulty in maintaining staff within nonprofits, attributing it not solely to post-COVID dynamics but to broader systemic issues:

“Retention is becoming increasingly more difficult... compensation equals salary plus meaning. [03:02]”
— Doug Paul

2. The Role of Strategic Outsiders and Inflection Points

Doug explains the importance of strategic outsiders during pivotal moments in a nonprofit's lifecycle, which he terms "inflection points." These moments can either propel an organization to new heights or lead to its decline. He illustrates this with the example of a founder transitioning out of their role:

“Our expertise is not in leading day to day... it's around those inflection point moments. [06:03]”
— Doug Paul

Rob adds that nonprofits often struggle to pivot effectively during these critical times, underscoring the necessity of external support.

3. Adapting to Rapidly Changing Culture

The conversation shifts to how rapidly evolving cultural dynamics impact nonprofit strategies. Doug notes:

“Culture is accelerating, reinventing itself now at a rate of every 18 months... [03:47]”
— Doug Paul

He stresses the need for nonprofits to embrace innovation as a core component of their culture, advocating for dedicating a portion of efforts to research and development:

“Innovation has to become a core tenet of our culture... [09:10]”
— Doug Paul

4. Strategy Development in Nonprofits

Doug highlights a significant gap in many nonprofits: the lack of a coherent strategy. He references Richard Rumelt's work on good versus bad strategy, emphasizing that:

“Most organizations don't have a strategy at all. [10:20]”
— Doug Paul

He explains that a robust strategy involves clear hypotheses and actionable steps, contrasting it with mere goal-setting, which lacks the "how" component:

“Strategy is answering the how question... [12:19]”
— Doug Paul

Rob echoes this by pointing out that while nonprofits are passionate about their missions ("the why"), they often falter when it comes to strategic planning ("the how").

5. Compensation: Pay Plus Meaning

A central theme of the discussion is the delicate balance between monetary compensation and the intrinsic meaning derived from nonprofit work. Doug introduces the formula:

“Compensation equals pay plus meaning. [20:01]”
— Doug Paul

Rob builds on this by advocating for better pay within nonprofits to match the high expectations and professional standards required:

“If you expect high quality and professionalism, you need to pay for that too... [20:34]”
— Dr. Rob Harder

6. Leadership Development and Personal Growth Plans

The episode delves into the importance of personal leadership growth. Doug describes We Are Catapult's Leadership Intensives, which involve:

• Personal Wiring Analysis: Understanding individual tendencies and life experiences.
• Strategic Planning: Crafting actionable plans aligned with personal and organizational goals.
• Ongoing Support: Quarterly check-ins to monitor progress and adapt strategies.

He emphasizes that leadership is inherently personal and that true growth involves aligning one's authentic self with their leadership role:

“It's about being the you-sized version of you as a leader... [26:29]”
— Doug Paul

7. Retention Strategies and Addressing Hidden Drivers

Addressing retention, Doug introduces three critical questions leaders should regularly ask to uncover hidden motivations and fears among their team members:

1. What am I afraid of losing?
2. What am I trying to hide?
3. What am I trying to prove and to whom?

These questions aim to foster a culture where team members are motivated by a shared mission rather than external rewards:

“Regularly ask... What am I afraid of losing? What am I trying to hide? What am I trying to prove and to whom? [29:42]”
— Doug Paul

Insights and Conclusions

Throughout the episode, Doug Paul and Dr. Rob Harder underscore the multifaceted challenges nonprofit leaders face, particularly in navigating recruitment, retention, and strategic planning amidst a rapidly changing cultural landscape. Key takeaways include:

• Strategic Outsiders can provide invaluable perspectives during critical organizational moments.
• Innovation should be ingrained in nonprofit culture to adapt to swift changes effectively.
• Clear, Actionable Strategies are essential for aligning daily operations with overarching missions.
• Balanced Compensation Packages that merge fair pay with meaningful work are crucial for retaining talent.
• Personal Leadership Development empowers leaders to bring their best selves to their roles, enhancing organizational health and impact.

Notable Quotes

• “Compensation equals pay plus meaning.”
  — Doug Paul [20:01]

• “Strategy is being able to see... how to deal with barriers.”
  — Doug Paul [11:00]

• “Innovation has to become a core tenet of our culture.”
  — Doug Paul [09:10]

• “What am I afraid of losing? What am I trying to hide? What am I trying to prove and to whom?”
  — Doug Paul [29:42]

How to Connect with Doug Paul and We Are Catapult

For listeners interested in furthering their leadership skills and enhancing their nonprofit's strategic direction, Doug Paul invites you to visit We Are Catapult:

• Website: wearecatapult.org
• Resources: Access articles, downloadable eBooks (e.g., "Three Leadership Skills for the Future"), and engage in conversations about leadership development.

Final Thoughts

This episode of the Nonprofit Leadership Podcast provides invaluable insights for nonprofit leaders striving to develop their personal growth plans and navigate the complexities of their roles. By integrating strategic planning, fostering innovation, and balancing compensation with meaning, leaders can enhance both their personal effectiveness and their organization's impact.

Thank you for tuning into the Nonprofit Leadership Podcast. To stay updated with more insightful episodes, subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, Amazon, Google Podcasts, or visit nonprofitleadershippodcast.org.