Podcast Summary: Not Just the Tudors – Episode: Cesare Borgia

Release Date: January 16, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of Not Just the Tudors, hosted by Professor Susannah Lipscomb, the focus shifts from the familiar Tudor dynasty to the enigmatic and influential figure of Cesare Borgia. Joined by Professor Catherine Fletcher of Manchester Metropolitan University, the discussion delves deep into Cesare’s rise, his military campaigns, political maneuvers, and the enduring myths surrounding his legacy.

Background: The Rise of the Borgia Dynasty

Professor Lipscomb sets the stage by outlining the origins of the Borgia family's ascent to power:

Professor Susannah Lipscomb [04:46]: "Cesare Borgia is one of history's most enigmatic and controversial figures. Remembered for his ruthless ambition and tactics, his life was a whirlwind of power, betrayal, and intrigue."

The Borgia legacy begins with Alfonso de Borgia, who becomes Pope Callixtus III in 1455, followed by his nephew Rodrigo Borgia, ascending to the papacy as Pope Alexander VI in 1492. Rodrigo’s strategic placements and alliances set the foundation for Cesare’s ambitions.

Cesare’s Transition from Ecclesiastical to Secular Power

Professor Fletcher explores Cesare’s early life and his transition from a religious role to military leadership:

Professor Catherine Fletcher [06:01]: "Cesare was doing rather well at university—he was a brilliant law student at the University of Pisa. Even his critics acknowledge his intelligence."

At just 16 years old, Cesare is nominated Bishop of Valencia in 1492. However, by 23, he shifts towards a secular military career, leveraging the substantial income from his ecclesiastical positions to fund his ambitions.

Military Campaigns in Romagna

Cesare’s military endeavors in the Romagna region are a testament to his strategic prowess and ambition to carve out an independent duchy:

Professor Catherine Fletcher [09:24]: "Cesare is trying to make himself Duke of the Romagna, carving out a chunk of the Papal States to establish his own independent rule."

Supported by French backing through his marriage to Charlotte d'Albret, Cesare targets key towns like Imola and Forli, aiming to consolidate power and establish a stable territory under his control.

Siege of Forli and Its Political Implications

One of Cesare’s most notable military successes is the Siege of Forli, which significantly impacted the political landscape of Renaissance Italy:

Professor Catherine Fletcher [10:51]: "Forli is under the rule of Caterina Riario Sforza, a formidable figure. Her eventual surrender to Cesare solidifies his power but also feeds into the myths surrounding his ruthlessness."

The capture of Forli not only demonstrated Cesare’s military capability but also highlighted the volatile alliances and rivalries among Italian nobility. The treatment of Caterina Riario Sforza further fueled tales of Cesare’s brutality, although historical accounts remain inconclusive.

Reputation and Influence on Machiavelli’s The Prince

Cesare Borgia’s reputation for cunning and ruthless political strategies significantly influenced Niccolò Machiavelli, inspiring his seminal work, The Prince:

Professor Catherine Fletcher [15:22]: "Machiavelli praises Cesare, noting his ability to inspire loyalty and his strategic brilliance, even as he critiques his ultimate failure."

Machiavelli cites Cesare as a model of effective leadership, emphasizing his ability to maintain control and manipulate political landscapes. However, Cesare’s downfall also serves as a cautionary tale about the fragility of power without stable political backing.

Technological Innovations and Military Strategy

Cesare’s collaboration with Leonardo da Vinci introduced innovative strategies in his military campaigns:

Professor Catherine Fletcher [18:13]: "Leonardo’s accurate maps of cities like Imola provided Cesare with strategic advantages, enabling precise and effective military maneuvers."

While Cesare explored advanced siege technologies, it was Leonardo’s meticulous mapping that offered practical benefits, underscoring the importance of intelligence and planning in warfare.

The Downfall of Cesare Borgia

The demise of Pope Alexander VI in 1503 marked the beginning of Cesare’s decline. Without his father’s influence and facing opposition from rival factions and new leadership under Pope Julius II, Cesare’s power rapidly eroded:

Professor Catherine Fletcher [28:18]: "With the election of Julius II, Cesare lost his primary source of support. Spanish backing was withdrawn, leading to the loss of his territories and eventual imprisonment."

Cesare’s attempt to negotiate with Pope Julius II failed, resulting in his exile and eventual capture. His escape to Navarre and subsequent death in battle in 1506 underscored the precarious nature of power during this tumultuous period.

Legacy and Myths Surrounding Cesare Borgia

Despite his relatively short life, Cesare Borgia left an enduring legacy, often overshadowed by myths and exaggerated tales of his cruelty and immorality:

Professor Catherine Fletcher [35:18]: "The myth of the Borgias, particularly Cesare's reputation, is inflated by anti-Semitic and anti-Spanish sentiments, as well as Protestant critiques of the Catholic Church."

Stories like the "Banquet of Chestnuts", where Cesare allegedly orchestrated a notorious party with courtesans, contribute to his infamous image. However, Professor Fletcher asserts that many of these tales lack substantial historical evidence and are products of posthumous myth-making.

Professor Catherine Fletcher [26:23]: "Burkhardt’s account of the banquet might have elements of truth, but it's challenging to determine the exact scale and nature of such events."

Conclusion

Professor Susannah Lipscomb and Professor Catherine Fletcher provide a nuanced view of Cesare Borgia, balancing his historical achievements with the myths that have clouded his legacy. Cesare emerges as a complex figure—ambitious, intelligent, and strategically adept, yet often maligned by exaggerated tales of ruthlessness. This episode sheds light on the intricate power dynamics of Renaissance Italy and encourages a reevaluation of Cesare Borgia beyond the stereotypical villain.

Professor Susannah Lipscomb [37:56]: "Cesare's reputation is more a product of myth than his actual deeds. Understanding him requires disentangling historical facts from the legends that have grown around him."

Looking Ahead

Tune in next time as Professor Catherine Fletcher joins Professor Susannah Lipscomb to unravel the mysteries surrounding the unsolved murder of Juan Borgia, one of history’s most intriguing cold cases.

Produced by History Hit. For more episodes and exclusive content, visit historyhit.com/subscribe.