Fast Five Shorts | What Should We All Make Of IKEA's Secondhand Marketplace?

Summary

Omni Talk Retail Podcast Summary

Episode: Fast Five Shorts | What Should We All Make Of IKEA's Secondhand Marketplace?
Release Date: February 6, 2025
Hosts: Chris Walton and Anne Mezzenga

---

Overview of IKEA's Secondhand Marketplace Expansion

In this episode of Omni Talk Retail, hosts Chris Walton and Ben Mezzenga delve into IKEA's strategic move to expand its secondhand furniture marketplace. The discussion is sparked by a recent report from Euro News, highlighting IKEA's successful pilot projects in Madrid and Oslo. Encouraged by positive results, IKEA plans to extend this initiative across all of Spain and Norway by August 2025, with aspirations to eventually scale to all European markets.

Pilot Success and Expansion Plans

Chris introduces the topic by referencing the Euro News report:

“IKEA is looking to expand its secondhand furniture offering after test success... ‘it works. People like it,’ said Jesper Brodin, CEO of IKEA's largest franchise.” [00:00]

Jesper Brodin further elaborates on the success metrics:

“We have decided to expand it from Madrid to Spain and from Oslo to Norway in a couple of years. We want to scale it up to all markets in Europe.” [00:00]

The pilot projects attracted approximately 200,000 visitors to the IKEA pre-owned website, with a few thousand actively engaging in transactions.

Insights from the Hosts

Ben's Perspective: Embracing Circular Commerce

Ben, identified as the show's European correspondent, provides an optimistic view of IKEA's initiative. He emphasizes the alignment of IKEA's move with the growing trend of circular commerce:

“This whole area of circular commerce is really growing and the brands have been completely left behind... the user experience is good.” [01:16]

Ben highlights the user-friendly aspects of IKEA's secondhand platform, such as offering sellers the choice between cash payments or vouchers redeemable in IKEA stores, with a 15% premium over the sale value. This feature not only incentivizes sellers but also encourages reintegration of customers into IKEA's ecosystem.

Furthermore, Ben connects IKEA's initiative to broader social movements, particularly among Gen Z, who are increasingly prioritizing sustainable consumption:

“There's a whole movement on social networks like TikTok and on Instagram for trying to not shop in 2025... this is more about getting people to go to IKEA first when they're looking for home goods.” [04:19]

Chris's Perspective: Balancing Optimism with Skepticism

Chris offers a more measured stance, acknowledging the potential benefits while also raising critical questions about IKEA's sustainability practices. He points out the significant environmental impact IKEA has due to its extensive use of raw materials:

“According to Earthsight... IKEA uses 21 cubic meters of logs every year. That means one tree is logged every second to make an IKEA product.” [05:32]

Chris questions the true sustainability of IKEA's secondhand marketplace, pondering whether it's a genuine effort or primarily a marketing strategy:

“Is this new website just another form of rewatching, or will they honestly try to make a sustainable business out of it?” [06:04]

He expresses skepticism about the slow rollout, suggesting it might not solely be driven by business profitability:

“The rollout seems a little bit slow... I'm tempering the expectations here that it's all about the business value being accrued so far, but time will tell.” [06:10]

Ben concurs with Chris's cautious approach, acknowledging the validity of his concerns while still recognizing the positive aspects.

IKEA's Environmental Impact and Sustainability Communication

A significant portion of the discussion centers on IKEA's environmental footprint. Chris cites data from Earthsight, highlighting the company's extensive logging practices, which pose sustainability challenges. This raises questions about whether IKEA's secondhand marketplace genuinely addresses these environmental concerns or serves as a strategic facade to enhance the brand's sustainable image.

Jesper Brodin's enthusiasm for the secondhand marketplace is balanced by Chris's critique of IKEA's broader environmental impact. The hosts debate whether IKEA's actions are part of a genuine commitment to sustainability or a calculated move to improve its public image amidst criticism over raw material sourcing.

Conclusion: Balancing Business Objectives and Sustainability

The episode concludes with a nuanced perspective, balancing optimism about IKEA's secondhand marketplace with skepticism about its broader sustainability efforts. Chris advocates for a "wait and see" approach, recognizing the potential benefits while remaining vigilant about the company's environmental practices. Ben supports this balanced view, acknowledging both the marketing advantages and the genuine strides toward circular commerce.

“I think it's playing to all the right themes right now for Ikea to continue a sustainable business in all sense of the word.” [04:58]

Ultimately, the hosts agree that while IKEA's expansion into the secondhand market is a positive step towards circular commerce and aligns with current consumer trends, the true measure of its success will depend on the company's commitment to addressing its significant environmental impact.

---

Notable Quotes:

• Jesper Brodin on Expansion: “We have decided to expand it from Madrid to Spain and from Oslo to Norway in a couple of years. We want to scale it up to all markets in Europe.” [00:00]
• Ben on Circular Commerce: “The user experience is good... you get 15% more than the sale value.” [01:16]
• Chris on Sustainability Concerns: “One tree is logged every second to make an IKEA product.” [05:32]
• Ben on Marketing and Sustainability: “This is more about getting people to go to IKEA first when they're looking for home goods.” [04:19]
• Chris on Rollout Skepticism: “I'm tempering the expectations here that it's all about the business value being accrued so far, but time will tell.” [06:10]

---

This comprehensive discussion provides listeners with a balanced understanding of IKEA's secondhand marketplace expansion, highlighting both its potential benefits in promoting circular commerce and the critical environmental challenges that remain.

Transcript

[Chris]

IKEA is looking to expand its secondhand furniture offering after test success, according to Euro News, which. Ben, I have no doubt you read Euro News voraciously, right? It's always on your dial, Right. The decision comes after the Swedish multinational launched two successful pilot projects in Madrid and Oslo, which will be expanded to all of Spain and Norway until August, quote, it works. People like it, said Jesper Brodin, CEO of IKEA's largest franchise. Inca Brodin then went on to add, quote, we have decided to expand it from Madrid to Spain and from Oslo to Norway in a couple of years. We want to scale it up to all markets in Europe, end quote. He also said that the pilot in Madrid and Oslo led to about 200,000 customers visiting the IKEA pre owned website and quote, couple of thousand people also engaging, end quote. Ben, we go to you as the resident European on this show.

[Ben]

Are you surprised that IKEA European correspondent.

[Chris]

A European correspondent from Armitage. Yes.

[Ben]

Now you can put it on your LinkedIn, Ben. Now you can put it on.

[Jesper]

Yes.

[Chris]

Are you surprised that IKEA is expanding the reach of its online secondhand marketplace?

[Jesper]

I love this, I love this story. Or I'm all in on this. I think so. Couple of reasons. One, they've tested it, they've tested it on two cities. They would not be expanding it if it, if they weren't getting some positive results from that. So that's great, I think. I mean, the second is this whole area of circular commerce is really growing and the brands have been completely left behind. So where'd you go to buy secondhand furniture? It's Facebook Marketplace. Where'd you go to buy pre used sneakers? It's ebay, you know, whether it's Nike or whether it's Ikea, every the brand and the IP owners are playing catch up in this space. So activities, having been on the, the, the IKEA pre sale website, having looked at what they're offering through in Madrid, the CX is good, the user experience is good. You can choose to either be paid as a seller, you could be paid in cash, or actually you can get vouchers to be used in an IKEA store. But you get 15% more than the sale value. So it can drive some positive traffic back into the store, I think. Look, if they're trying it, it's good, they're expanding it. Uh, I'm, I'm all in on seeing brand owners be more active in circular commerce.

[Chris]

Got it. So, Ben, so I want to make sure I heard you right. So you think this, this signals that the concept is actually working and they think there's a business out of it.

[Jesper]

Okay. I'm 99% there that it signals it's working. I'm 1% there that it might be helping some challenges they're having with sustainability communication. So I'm, I'm, I'm favoring the 99%, but I do recognize it's a helpful part of a round of story giving.

[Chris]

Them the extreme benefit of the doubt. Okay, got it, got it, got it, got it.

[Jesper]

And I, and I look forward. Members of the Ikea team are going to be on the short Europe agenda, so we can, we can ask them that honest question then. But for now, I am giving the benefit of the doubt.

[Chris]

Yeah, that's right. And I think Ikea deserves the benefit of the doubt to some degree too. And what do you think?

[Ben]

I think you can't just look at it as whether or not this is working from, like a business profitability angle too. I think you have to consider that this is a very strong marketing hook as well. I think that there's a, there's a whole, like this this year in 2025. There's a whole movement on social networks like TikTok and on Instagram for trying to not shop in 2025. So these, this whole group of, especially Gen Z, who are trying to see what, what can I do for circular commerce to buy as little as possible this year. And this is, this concept of what Ikea is doing has been alive and well, especially in like, the consignment space, for a long time. And I've, I've lived it for years now where when I need something new, I know I have a credit or I know I have a gift card to Ikea. That's going to be the first place that I'm going when I'm looking for new furniture, because I have that credit to use. And so I think that this is more to me about getting people to go to Ikea first when they're looking for home goods or houseware products than it is about, like, how it's really contributing to Ikea's bottom line when I return my Billy bookcase and am I buying something that day? But, but yeah, I think it's playing to, playing to all the right themes right now for Ikea to continue a sustainable business in all sense of the word.

[Chris]

All right, well, so I'm gonna, I'm gonna kind of wedge myself in between the two of you. I think, like, I think, I think kind of, I think there's bull on dang. But I'm. I'm a little more like, wait and see with this, I think, because I. I'm. I'm not surprised that they're rolling it out at all. You know, that's the thing fundamental here. I'm not surprised for. Basically for the reason you said. An. But there's. There's really two reasons I thought of, like, one, and Ben, I think you'll appreciate this the most. One, they're Swedish. Like, it's in their ethos, like, you know, to. To. To take this position. Right. And so. And then number two. And Ben, you alluded to it in some ways, and, and this goes back to what you said in the marketing hook. They are also public enemy number one on a lot of sustainability factors, like raw material sourcing in particular. So did you know, for example, that according to Earthsight, which is an organization that monitors the environment, environmental impact of businesses, IKEA uses 21 cubic meters of logs every year. That means one tree is logged every second to make an IKEA product. Every second. One. One tree is logged every second to make an IKEA product. Now, I'm no expert.

[Ben]

Like, what. What about Wayfair and some of these, I mean, compared to what?

[Chris]

Well, I mean, just like, like, is that.

[Ben]

Are they, like, the number one abuser?

[Chris]

It's the biggest furniture manufacturer in the world, I think. I'm not 100 sure. But, like, that's just a lot of locks, right?

[Ben]

Yes.

[Chris]

And so the real question is, it's just a lot of logs, right? I mean, I hate to say it. It's just a lot of logs, right? So the real question is, is this new website, just right now, another form of rewatching, or will they honestly try to make a sustainable business out of it? The one thing that makes me skeptical is the rollout seems a little bit slow. Like, you're going from Madrid to Spain, like, and then you're talking about rolling out naturally. So I'm just, you know, I'm tempering the expectations here that, that it's all about the business value being accrued so far, but time will tell. That's my take.

[Ben]

Yeah, I think that's a really smart call out, Chris. I agree.