Why Most Smart Store Pilots Fail (And How to Build One That Doesn’t) | 5IM

Summary

Omni Talk Retail Podcast Summary

Episode: Why Most Smart Store Pilots Fail (And How to Build One That Doesn’t) | 5IM
Release Date: July 2, 2025
Host: Omni Talk Retail
Guests: Troy Sidewick, G Store

---

Introduction

In this episode of Omni Talk Retail, hosts Chris Walton and Anne Mezzenga delve into the challenges and strategies associated with implementing smart store technologies. Featuring insights from Troy Sidewick of G Store, the discussion centers around why many smart store pilots fail and how retailers can develop successful, sustainable smart store initiatives.

---

The Importance of RFID and Advanced Inventory Management

Key Discussion Points:

Troy Sidewick emphasizes the critical role of RFID (Radio-Frequency Identification) and advanced inventory management systems in creating agile retail environments. He highlights that modern retailers need more than just basic stock tracking; they require dynamic systems that can respond swiftly to market changes.

Notable Quote:

"It's not just about knowing what's in stock, it's about being able to move fast when things change in the store." – Troy Sidewick [00:30]

Highlights:

• Foundation of RFID: RFID serves as the backbone for intelligent inventory systems, providing real-time visibility into stock levels.
• Layering Additional Technologies: Beyond RFID, successful smart stores incorporate technologies like visibility tools, exception-based workflows, and predictive alerts. These tools actively guide store associates on actionable tasks rather than merely displaying data on dashboards.
• Integrating Legacy Systems: Troy underscores the value of maintaining older technologies, such as handheld RFID readers, which can be complemented by newer overhead systems. This integration ensures that manual processes are minimized without displacing staff, allowing employees to focus on customer engagement and sales rather than inventory counts.

---

Addressing Incomplete RFID Tagging in Mass Retailers

Key Discussion Points:

Troy acknowledges that not all items in large retail environments are tagged with RFID, presenting a common challenge for mass retailers seeking to implement smart store technologies comprehensively.

Notable Quote:

"There aren't 100% or many aren't even 50% RFID tag. So it's just a playbook that has to be considered..." – Troy Sidewick [01:52]

Highlights:

• Strategic RFID Deployment: For items that are RFID-tagged, especially fast-moving apparel, overhead RFID systems can be highly effective. For non-tagged items, handheld scanners remain essential.
• Emerging Technologies: The future points towards integrating computer vision with RFID and existing systems. This combination will enhance stock accuracy and streamline inventory management by leveraging camera-based monitoring alongside traditional RFID and POS data.
• Comprehensive Solutions: A blend of advanced overhead readers, handheld scanners, and computer vision technologies will form the backbone of smart store operations in large retail settings.

---

Building and Running Effective Smart Store Pilots

Key Discussion Points:

The conversation shifts to the practical aspects of launching smart store pilots, focusing on the steps involved and the timeline for achieving meaningful insights.

Notable Quote:

"A typical pilot takes 60 to 90 days from time you kick it off until getting insights from that pilot." – Troy Sidewick [02:53]

Highlights:

• Pilot Duration: Successful smart store pilots typically span two to three months, allowing sufficient time to install technologies and observe their impact in a live environment.
• Live Fire Testing: Unlike passive installations, effective pilots involve active participation from store associates, testing the technology in real-world scenarios to assess its impact on operations.
• Behavioral Changes: Troy stresses that pilots should focus on transforming associate behavior and customer interactions, not just showcasing technology. The objective is to create "behavior changing labs" that demonstrate tangible improvements in processes like BOPIS (Buy Online, Pick Up In Store) accuracy and customer service efficiency.
• Measuring Success: Key metrics include reductions in BOPIS misses, faster product location by associates, labor savings, and enhanced focus on activities that drive sales and customer engagement.

---

The Future of Smart Store Technology: Orchestration Era

Key Discussion Points:

Looking ahead, Troy envisions the next phase of smart store technology as an orchestration era, where various devices and systems seamlessly interact to create a cohesive operational ecosystem.

Notable Quote:

"Tech becomes like a central nervous system so that these retailers and most importantly their associates can help the customers and help sales." – Troy Sidewick [04:15]

Highlights:

• Integrated Systems: Future smart stores will feature interconnected technologies that manage everything from planogram compliance and automated replenishment to staffing and shrinkage control.
• Central Nervous System: This orchestration acts as the store's central nervous system, coordinating different functions to optimize both inventory management and customer service.
• Comprehensive Automation: Automation will extend beyond inventory to include merchandising, fulfillment, and operational triggers, ensuring that every aspect of the store works in harmony to support sales and enhance the customer experience.
• Enhanced Associate Roles: With technology handling routine tasks, store associates can focus more on customer interactions and activities that drive sales, thereby increasing overall store effectiveness and customer satisfaction.

---

Conclusion

Troy Sidewick provides a compelling roadmap for retailers aiming to implement smart store technologies successfully. By leveraging a combination of RFID, computer vision, and integrated systems, and by focusing on behavior change and operational orchestration, retailers can overcome common pilot failures and build smart stores that genuinely enhance both operational efficiency and customer experience.

Final Thoughts:

"It's really all the orchestration around all this tech coming together." – Troy Sidewick [04:15]

---

This episode offers invaluable insights for retail executives and professionals looking to navigate the complexities of smart store implementations, ensuring that technological advancements translate into meaningful business outcomes.

Transcript

[A]

Foreign.

[B]

Minutes is G Store's Troy Sidewick to share his tried and true tips on tech for the world's smartest stores. Troy Many retailers are looking at tech like RFID and inventory management software to be more agile as they encounter more and more market uncertainty with what tech is critical for stores to have right now.

[C]

It's not just about knowing what's in stock, it's about being able to move fast when things change in the store. So the smartest stores are using RFID in their inventory systems as a foundation, but then they're layering on tech on top of that that helps them react faster. So think about visibility, exception based workflows, predictive alerts. So not just dashboards that are kind of collecting dust, but stuff that really actions the store associates and the people that work in the stores, what to do, telling them what to do. And for retailers that have some of this technology, but the older version, like the handheld RFID readers, that's perfect. So keep that and you can build on that with the overhead systems and the newer tech, the handhelds still come into play and still have a purpose. So the overhead readers we're deploying now eliminate the manual work and give stores and the associates time back. So it's not replacing the people, it's helping them focus on what drives sales and engagement with the customers. And not counting socks in the back of the store.

[A]

What if you're a mass retailer though, that might have some items that are RFID tag, but not all of them. What tech or what solutions do you put in place if that's the scenario.

[C]

And that's most of them, I think there aren't 100% or many aren't even 50% RFID tag. So it's just a playbook that has to be considered where you have overhead RFID for the fast moving apparel type of items. You keep your handheld scanning systems for other RFID that aren't as conducive for overhead. And, and then now we're seeing a lot of piloting around computer vision and that's where this is going to go. So cameras, looking at things, you know, and figuring out what your stock is combined with RFID and then combined with older school solutions like handheld readers and POS data, all that combined for those big stores will be the answer in the future.

[B]

Well, I love that older school solutions. All right, so if I'm a retail executive listening right now, Troy, and, and I want to, and I'm bought in on this whole smart store idea, what does a smart store pilot look like and how long does it take to get a pilot up and running?

[C]

Yeah, so it wasn't always this way and we weren't always this good, but we've become pretty good at moving fast. So a typical pilot takes 60 to 90 days to kick from time you kick it off until getting insights from that pilot. So, you know, there's plugging in things and there's installing things, but it's not about plugging in sensors and waiting. It's kind of like live fire testing with the store associates. So does it reduce the BOPIS misses or the skips in the BOPIS process or does it help associates find products faster to help the customer? Are we saving labor and focusing on what's really important for sales? So, you know, a lot of pilots are tech showcases. That's what you'll see when you go to customers and clients. That's not what these should be. They should be behavior changing labs where we change how the associates act with the customers in the store. And then they'll want this tech. If it's working, they'll want it and they'll ask for it after the pilot's done.

[A]

So where is the smart store tech kind of heading? Troy, what do we think we'll see after some of those deployments? Deployments have been done. Those pilots have been done. Where? Where? What is the art of the possible here?

[C]

So I think it's, it's kind of like the. I mean I've seen this in retail for a long time, this word, but I think we're really there in the orchestration era. So. So all these things, all these devices, the stuff we just talked about playing together, the magic is when they're all working together. So planogram compliance, automated replenishment from back of the house to the front of the house, Bopus triggers. So it's not just merchandise, it's not just inventory. It's like merchandising, staffing, fulfillment, shrink the store. Tech becomes like a central nervous system so that these retailers and most importantly their associates can help the customers and help sales. So it's really all the orchestration around all this tech coming together. Awesome.

[A]

Thanks, Troy.

[B]

Thank you, Troy.