Open Circuit: A Post-OBBB Market Recalibration – Detailed Summary
Released on July 25, 2025 by Latitude Media
Introduction
In the episode titled "A Post-OBBB Market Recalibration," hosted by Stephen Lacy from Latitude Media, industry veterans Kathryn Hamilton of 38 North Solutions and Costa Samaras from the Carnegie Mellon Scott Institute for Energy Innovation delve into the profound implications of the newly enacted One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB). This legislation is poised to significantly alter the landscape of clean energy in the United States by drastically reducing tax incentives and imposing stringent regulations on clean energy deployment.
Overview of OBBB and Its Impact
Stephen Lacy sets the stage by highlighting the explosive growth in power demand juxtaposed with the introduction of the OBBB, a bill expected to slash clean energy deployment by up to 60% over the next decade. This legislative move comes at a time when the Department of Energy (DOE) warns of an escalating blackout risk due to gaps in power supply and infrastructure development.
Notable Quote:
"Washington is saying go faster and slow down at the same time creating a high stakes bottleneck for developers, utilities and large energy buyers."
— Stephen Lacy [01:11]
Kathryn Hamilton references analyses from groups like Rhodium and Princeton, projecting a 57-62% decrease in clean energy capacity additions by 2025 and a half a trillion dollar reduction in clean energy investment by 2035. Additionally, there's an anticipated 820 terawatt-hour decline in clean energy generation and significant setbacks in electric vehicle (EV) adoption.
Notable Statistics:
- 80 to $300 annual increase in household energy costs.
- 8-9% rise in greenhouse gas emissions.
- Job losses ranging from 750,000 by 2030 to 1.7 million by 2035.
DOE’s Blackout Risk Report
The DOE released a controversial report alleging a 100-fold increase in blackout risk attributed to the growth of renewables. Kathryn Hamilton critiques the report, arguing that it overstates the risks while undervaluing the contributions of renewable energy to grid reliability.
Notable Quote:
"They overestimated the risk, underestimated the benefit, and then put their thumb on the scale of the solution."
— Kathryn Hamilton [33:36]
She points out flawed assumptions, such as the projected retirement of 104 gigawatts of plants by 2030 and the need for 100 gigawatts of new peak capacity, including 50 gigawatts for data centers. Hamilton emphasizes that these figures were derived from a national perspective, ignoring regional variances and the advancements in renewable technologies that bolster grid resilience.
Policy Shifts: From IRA to OBBB
Kathryn Hamilton provides a comparative analysis of clean energy policies before the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), during its implementation, and the subsequent reversal under OBBB. The IRA had introduced a plethora of tax credits across various technologies, catalyzing investment and development in the clean energy sector.
Notable Quote:
"The IRA was really an all of the above clean energy strategy, and it was really an all of the above clean energy strategy. There were some things that didn't make it into the bill, like transmission didn't make it into the bill."
— Kathryn Hamilton [12:05]
However, with the advent of OBBB, many of these incentives are being rolled back, particularly those supporting solar and wind, while leaving certain credits like geothermal, hydropower, and nuclear partially intact. This partial rollback creates uncertainty and hampers long-term planning for clean energy projects.
Foreign Entities of Concern (FIAC) and Supply Chain Restrictions
A significant component of OBBB involves the introduction of Foreign Entities of Concern (FIAC) rules, which impose stricter sourcing requirements for clean energy components. Kathryn Hamilton and Costa Samaras discuss the potential bottlenecks and uncertainties these rules introduce into the supply chain.
Notable Quote:
"This creates another veto point outside of legislation that either the administration can have in, at treasury or in other agencies that can say the way that we're interpreting this is, is this way."
— Costa Samaras [17:51]
The lack of clear guidelines on ownership structures and equipment sourcing under FIAC complicates compliance for developers, potentially leading to delays and increased costs. Kathryn emphasizes the need for transparent and actionable guidance to mitigate these challenges.
Permitting Challenges on Federal Lands
OBBB also alters the permitting landscape, requiring all solar and wind projects on federal lands to undergo direct review by Secretary Doug Burgum. Given Burgum's dual roles and the already strained capacity of the Department of the Interior, this change is expected to slow down the approval process for clean energy projects.
Notable Quote:
"It's already so hard to do. It's already so hard to build on federal lands."
— Kathryn Hamilton [24:02]
Kathryn highlights that public lands in states like North Dakota have underutilized potential for renewable energy development, with only 4% currently developed despite estimates suggesting 12.5%. The new permitting procedures could exacerbate existing delays, hindering the expansion of clean energy infrastructure.
Grid New Deal and Smart AI Fast Lanes Concept
In response to the challenges posed by OBBB, Costa Samaras introduces the concept of the Grid New Deal, a comprehensive federal initiative aimed at modernizing the electricity grid to support rapid electrification and digitalization. Complementing this is the Smart AI Fast Lanes policy, designed to manage the burgeoning electricity demand from AI-driven data centers while promoting clean energy solutions.
Notable Quote:
"The Smart AI Fast Lanes framework can use the private sector and philanthropy in this moment of policy uncertainty to get the outcomes that the companies say that they want, the communities deserve."
— Costa Samaras [53:27]
This approach advocates for public-private partnerships, leveraging philanthropic resources to invest in clean energy and transmission infrastructure, thereby alleviating the financial and logistical burdens imposed by federal restrictions.
Data Center Demand and Grid Stress Due to AI Boom
Kathryn underscores the rapid growth in electricity demand driven by the AI and data center boom. With estimates predicting an 8-10% increase in electricity demand by 2030 and 90% of data center growth occurring within the next decade, there is a critical need for infrastructure that can accommodate this surge without destabilizing the grid.
Notable Quote:
"If we get this wrong, I think what Catherine said, if we just go build a bunch of fossil plants and we load up rate payers with infrastructure costs and we impose new emissions on communities... we will never meet our emissions objectives and we'll never get to net zero."
— Costa Samaras [50:28]
He emphasizes that the AI surge serves as a stress test for the entire electrification framework, highlighting the urgency for strategic investments in clean energy, storage, and smart grid technologies to ensure reliability and affordability.
Conclusions and Future Outlook
The episode culminates with a consensus among the panelists on the necessity of proactive measures to navigate the post-OBBB landscape. While the legislation introduces significant hurdles, initiatives like the Grid New Deal and Smart AI Fast Lanes offer pathways to sustain and accelerate clean energy progress. Kathryn and Costa advocate for continuous engagement with policymakers, transparent guidance on new regulations, and innovative financing mechanisms to bridge the current policy gaps.
Notable Quote:
"We have to come together and find a way to build fast, clean and cheap."
— Costa Samaras [25:49]
As the U.S. grapples with balancing energy demand, economic growth, and environmental sustainability, the insights shared in this episode underscore the critical interplay between policy, technology, and market dynamics in shaping the future of the energy transition.
Key Takeaways:
- OBBB poses significant setbacks to clean energy deployment, with widespread impacts on investment, generation, and employment.
- DOE’s blackout risk report has been critiqued for its overestimation of risks and underestimation of renewables' reliability contributions.
- FIAC rules and stringent permitting are introducing supply chain bottlenecks and delaying renewable projects.
- Grid New Deal and Smart AI Fast Lanes present innovative solutions to modernize the grid and manage increased demand from AI and data centers.
- Urgent need for policy clarity and public-private partnerships to navigate the post-OBBB energy landscape effectively.
For more insights and up-to-date analysis on clean energy policies, subscribe to Policy Pulse at 38northsolutions.com.