Open Circuit Episode Summary: "The Grid is Smarter. Why Aren't We Smarter About the Grid?"

Release Date: June 20, 2025
Host/Author: Latitude Media

Introduction

In this episode of Open Circuit, hosted by Stephen Lacy from Latitude Media, industry veterans Kathryn Hamilton and Jigar Shah delve into the complexities of modernizing the electrical grid. They explore why, despite technological advancements making the grid smarter, the coordination and integration of these innovations are lagging. The discussion is further enriched by guest Arushi Sharma Frank, founder of Luminary Strategies, a seasoned expert in grid flexibility and distributed energy resources (DERs).

Virtual Power Plants (VPPs): Potential and Challenges

The conversation begins with an exploration of Virtual Power Plants (VPPs)—a pivotal concept in grid modernization. Stephen Lacy poses a question about the current state of VPPs, to which Kathryn Hamilton responds with an engaging analogy:

Kathryn Hamilton [07:47]: "Our grid needs to be an orchestra... DERs and VPPs are like the string section, ensuring harmony without letting any single instrument overpower the rest."

This metaphor underscores the need for balanced integration of various energy resources to enhance grid stability and efficiency.

Jigar Shah elaborates on the practical challenges faced by utilities in adopting VPPs:

Jigar Shah [10:30]: "Utilities of the future will shift loads around that people don't care about, leveraging the connectivity of modern devices to optimize grid performance."

However, he highlights the mismatch between technological capabilities and current utility practices, emphasizing that utilities often rely on outdated models that don't fully utilize the potential of VPPs.

Regulatory Hurdles and Utility Resistance

A significant portion of the discussion centers on regulatory barriers that impede the widespread adoption of VPPs and DERs. Arushi Sharma Frank identifies three primary reasons the VPP market remains underdeveloped:

1. Conflict with Utility Business Models: Existing regulatory frameworks favor traditional utility investments over innovative DERs, creating structural conflicts.

2. Inadequate Cost Recovery Mechanisms: Utilities struggle to recover investments in software and operational improvements essential for DER integration.

3. Lack of Hybrid Financing Models: There is a scarcity of effective partnerships between utilities and private capital, hindering the financial viability of VPP projects.

Shah adds to this by pointing out the nuanced differences in utility behaviors across regions:

Jigar Shah [19:22]: "While utilities like Baltimore Gas and Electric are on board with VPPs, others like PG&E remain constrained by restrictive regulatory environments."

This disparity leads to uneven progress, with states like Texas and Florida making more headway compared to heavily regulated markets like California and Massachusetts.

Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI): Missed Opportunities

Transitioning to Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI), the panel critiques the initial rollout of smart meters, which largely failed to deliver on their promise of enhanced grid management and customer benefits.

Kathryn Hamilton [55:17]: "The first generation of smart meters was primarily for accurate billing and meter reading, not for enabling customer participation in grid management."

Arushi Sharma Frank labels the AMI deployment as "cart before the horse," arguing that the necessary programs and incentives to utilize AMI data effectively were not established alongside the technological installations.

She proposes five structural changes to maximize AMI's potential:

1. Enhanced Real-Time Grid Visibility: Integrate additional sensors to capture critical operational data.

2. Improved Geolocation Accuracy: Ensure precise mapping of customer locations to their corresponding grid assets.

3. Inclusion of Non-Metered DERs: Recognize and integrate energy resources beyond traditional metered devices.

4. Develop Robust DER Management Systems (DERMS): Move beyond AMI to implement systems that provide operational control and smart visibility.

5. Empower Customer Data Ownership: Allow customers to own and control their energy data, facilitating better integration with third-party aggregators.

Data Centers as Flexibility Resources

The discussion shifts to the role of data centers as potential flexibility resources for the grid. Research from Duke University suggests that with proper integration, data centers could provide significant load flexibility, thus alleviating grid stress.

Arushi Sharma Frank [67:45]: "Data centers are currently treated like 'Home Depots'—inflexible and unresponsive. We need to redesign incentives and tariffs to make them grid-friendly."

Kathryn Hamilton shares insights from her experiences in Virginia, highlighting how rural cooperatives face unique challenges in integrating data centers compared to investor-owned utilities:

Kathryn Hamilton [71:24]: "Co-ops must find innovative ways to incentivize customers to adopt backup batteries, enabling aggregation to support new DER-heavy data center loads."

This points to the necessity of tailored solutions that consider the diverse operational frameworks of different utility types.

Unlocking Grid Flexibility: Key Structural Changes

As the episode draws to a close, the panel distills three major structural changes needed to unlock grid flexibility:

1. Alignment of Government and Utility Objectives: Ensuring that state-level policies and utility goals are synergistic to promote efficient grid design and human welfare.

   Arushi Sharma Frank [77:57]: "There's too much differentiation and no one is talking to each other. We have to fix it."

2. Inclusive Access to Grid Flexibility Programs: Expanding benefits beyond information-rich parties to include underserved households, ensuring equitable access to grid flexibility solutions.

   Jigar Shah [79:22]: "If you're behind on your electricity bill, it strips you of your dignity. We need to make sure every customer class gets access to flexibility programs."

3. Integrated Cross-Sector Collaboration: Encouraging collaboration between diverse stakeholders—utilities, data centers, policymakers, and technology providers—to create holistic and scalable grid solutions.

   Arushi Sharma Frank [81:57]: "Different sectors need to meet and solve problems together rather than remain siloed."

Conclusion

This episode of Open Circuit offers a deep dive into the intricate dynamics of grid modernization. While technological advancements like VPPs, AMI, and flexible data centers hold immense potential, their realization is hindered by regulatory constraints, utility resistance, and a lack of cohesive strategies. The panelists advocate for structural reforms, inclusive program designs, and cross-sector collaborations to truly harness the capabilities of a smarter grid.

For more insights and in-depth discussions on the energy transition, subscribe to Latitude Media's newsletters and follow their podcast series.