Optimist Economy: Episode Summary – A Million Reasons to Raise the Minimum Wage

Released on July 22, 2025

Introduction

In this compelling episode of Optimist Economy, hosts Kathryn Anne Edwards and Robin Rauzi delve deep into the contentious and timely issue of raising the federal minimum wage in the United States. With their characteristic blend of economic insight and optimistic perspective, Kathryn and Robin explore the multifaceted arguments surrounding the minimum wage, its historical roots, current legislative efforts, and its broader societal implications.

Retcons and Updates

Timestamp: [00:00 – 02:30]

The episode begins with light-hearted banter as Kathryn introduces important updates and corrections to previous discussions. Notably, Kathryn addresses her earlier remarks on the estate tax, mentioning that Representative Sarah Jacobs has introduced the Legacy Act in Congress. This act aims to raise the estate tax and allocate a portion of its proceeds to a children's trust fund for childcare assistance. She emphasizes, “[02:26] Kathryn: ...it is version of what I had said. It is currently a bill in Congress,” highlighting hope for tangible policy solutions.

Robin adds, “[03:20] Robin: I don't think much will happen with this Congress, but it does mean that change can happen...,” reinforcing the notion that legislative progress is possible, even if challenging.

Kathryn also revisits their discussion on youth unemployment, acknowledging feedback and clarifying the broader implications of labor market disparities. “[05:20] Kathryn: ...the labor market is not always a kind place...,” she reflects, emphasizing the importance of understanding systemic issues rather than isolating specific groups.

Raising the Minimum Wage: Historical Context and Current Proposals

Timestamp: [10:23 – 26:04]

The core of the episode centers on the minimum wage, tracing its origins back to the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938. Kathryn shares, “[13:01] Kathryn: So, we first got the minimum wage in the Fair Labor Standards act...,” providing listeners with a foundational understanding of when and why the minimum wage was instituted.

Robin introduces the current legislative landscape, noting the bipartisan efforts to increase the federal minimum wage. “[12:07] Robin: ...a bipartisan bill introduced in Congress to lift the federal minimum wage from its current $7.25 an hour to $15 an hour...,” he explains, highlighting Senator Josh Hawley’s unexpected support for the proposal. Kathryn adds context, “[12:35] Kathryn: ...Hawley wants to raise the minimum wage everywhere so that Missouri remains competitive...,” shedding light on regional economic competitiveness as a driving factor.

They discuss the fact that 40% of the U.S. population already resides in states with a minimum wage of $15 or higher, primarily benefiting southeastern states that haven't independently raised their wages. “[12:28] Kathryn: That shocks Josh...,” she remarks, noting the irony that a Republican senator is championing a policy largely already implemented in other regions.

Economic Arguments: Pros and Cons of Raising the Minimum Wage

Timestamp: [27:04 – 37:14]

Kathryn and Robin engage in a nuanced discussion about the economic implications of raising the minimum wage. Kathryn explains the concept of the minimum wage being set in nominal terms, meaning it doesn’t automatically adjust for inflation. “[27:28] Kathryn: Nominal is the actual dollar amount...,” she elaborates, emphasizing that without adjustments, the real value of the minimum wage erodes over time.

Robin references a 2022 study encompassing 70 studies since 1992, which challenges the popular narrative that raising the minimum wage has no effect on employment. “[31:53] Robin: Yeah, the classic prediction of the minimum wage is that it raises the price of labor...,” he notes, underscoring the ongoing debate among economists about the trade-offs involved.

Kathryn offers her perspective, stating, “[30:01] Kathryn: The question of the minimum wage to me comes down to a couple of things...,” she posits that determining the appropriate minimum wage involves balancing the value placed on the lowest earners against potential economic drawbacks like minor job losses or price increases. She argues that the negative consequences are often overstated, “[31:02] Kathryn: The trade offs to having a minimum wage is that we might experience job loss...,” while emphasizing the positive impact on workers' livelihoods.

The hosts also explore the power dynamics in the labor market, suggesting that the minimum wage serves as a tool to empower workers who lack bargaining power. “[35:39] Kathryn: ...it was all there in the economy when the minimum wage was created...,” she explains, linking historical motivations to contemporary issues like wage gaps and worker exploitation.

Research Findings and Broader Implications

Timestamp: [37:14 – 45:54]

Delving into empirical evidence, Kathryn discusses how the minimum wage has historically contributed to reducing the black-white wage gap. Referring to legislative changes in the 1960s, she states, “[43:38] Kathryn: ...it was also expanded in coverage...,” highlighting how raising the minimum wage has tangible benefits for marginalized communities.

Robin brings up concerns about price inflation, questioning whether higher wages would lead to increased costs for consumers. Kathryn counters by explaining, “[37:26] Kathryn: A minimum wage increase can increase the price of goods...,” but argues that the impact is typically marginal. She shares observations from states like California, where recent wage hikes have led to only slight price increases in fast food, “[37:50] Kathryn: ...it raised prices at a very marginal amount....”

The conversation shifts to the potential for automation as a response to rising labor costs. Kathryn contends that the push towards automation is inevitable and not solely driven by minimum wage increases. “[38:38] Robin: One, they're going to do that...,” Robin asserts, while Kathryn adds, “[38:52] Kathryn: ...minimum wage, very good fall guy for certain choices...,” suggesting that technological advancements would occur regardless and that blaming the minimum wage oversimplifies the issue.

Practical Considerations and Policy Recommendations

Timestamp: [41:20 – 47:08]

Kathryn advocates for indexing the minimum wage to wages or inflation to maintain its real value over time. “[42:16] Kathryn: ...you would take the dollar amount...,” she explains, proposing a systematic approach to adjusting wages in line with economic indicators.

Robin and Kathryn discuss the political feasibility of raising the minimum wage, with Kathryn expressing optimism that political shifts towards populism could pave the way for a federal increase to $15 per hour. “[47:10] Kathryn: ...minimum wage is a gimme...,” she concludes, highlighting the widespread public support for such measures.

They also touch upon the balance between benefiting workers and sustaining small businesses, questioning whether it is more favorable to protect marginal businesses or empower millions of workers. “[46:12] Kathryn: ...protect them or the 15 million people...,” she muses, advocating for prioritizing worker welfare over the survival of struggling businesses.

Lighthearted Interlude: Executive Orders

Timestamp: [48:24 – 54:47]

Shifting gears, Kathryn and Robin engage in a humorous segment titled "Executive Orders," where they joke about whimsical policies such as preventing grocery stores from rearranging aisles or requiring moving vans to display clear signage. Robin shares listener suggestions like, “[49:07] Robin: Grocery stores will not be allowed to rearrange the aisles every eight months...,” adding levity to the discussion.

Kathryn introduces a more substantive idea about firms disclosing turnover costs, aiming to increase transparency regarding employer practices. “[50:42] Kathryn: ...you should have to say, how many people quit your company last year...,” she proposes, debating its potential benefits for job seekers and transparency in the labor market.

Conclusion: Spiritual Sponsors and Acknowledgments

Timestamp: [55:56 – End]

The episode wraps up with personal anecdotes and acknowledgments of spiritual sponsors. Kathryn enthusiastically recounts her affinity for the 1980s classic "Troop Beverly Hills," while Robin shares his appreciation for Girls' Weekend as his spiritual sponsor. They express gratitude towards their producer team, Andy and Sophie, cementing the episode's warm and community-oriented tone.

Notable Quotes

• “[02:30] Robin: All hope is not lost.” – Emphasizing optimism amidst legislative challenges.
• “[13:01] Kathryn: ...we first got the minimum wage in the Fair Labor Standards act...”
• “[27:28] Kathryn: Nominal is the actual dollar amount...”
• “[31:02] Kathryn: The trade offs to having a minimum wage is that we might experience job loss...”
• “[37:26] Kathryn: A minimum wage increase can increase the price of goods...”
• “[47:10] Kathryn: ...minimum wage is a gimme...”

Final Thoughts

In A Million Reasons to Raise the Minimum Wage, Kathryn and Robin effectively dissect the complex issue of the minimum wage through historical context, economic theory, and real-world implications. They balance critical analysis with an optimistic outlook, encouraging listeners to consider both the benefits and trade-offs of policy changes. Whether you’re an economics enthusiast or simply interested in understanding how wage policies affect everyday lives, this episode provides a thorough and engaging exploration of a pivotal economic topic.

Connect with Optimist Economy

For more insights, show notes, and member discussions, visit optimisteconomy.com. Share your questions or economic concerns at optimist.economymail.com. Support the podcast by becoming a paid member on Substack or Buy Me a Coffee.