Loading summary
Transcript111 lines
- [00:00]
Grace Godvin
I've been working with a Nourish dietitian.
- [00:02]
Jack Wagner
For the last six months and it's been life changing.
- [00:05]
Grace Godvin
I've lost weight, healed my relationship with food, and have way more energy.
- [00:09]
Jack Wagner
Working with a dietitian online to create.
- [00:11]
Grace Godvin
A personalized nutrition plan was so easy thanks to Nourish.
- [00:15]
Nancy Martin
The best part?
- [00:16]
Grace Godvin
I pay $0 out of pocket.
- [00:18]
Jack Wagner
Because Nourish accepts hundreds of insurance plans, 94% of patients pay $0 out of pocket. Find your dietitian@usenourish.com that's usenourish.com at Designer.
- [00:31]
Nancy Martin
Shoe Warehouse we believe that shoes are.
- [00:33]
Jack Wagner
An important part of, well, everything. From first steps to first dates, from all nighters to all time personal bests.
- [00:42]
Steve Cook
From building pillow forts to building a.
- [00:44]
Jack Wagner
Life for all the big and small moments that make up your whole world.
- [00:49]
Grace Godvin
DSW is there and we've got just the shoes. Find a shoe for every you from.
- [00:55]
Jack Wagner
Brands you love at brag worthy prices at your DSW store or dsw.com.
- [01:09]
Nancy Martin
Welcome to Otherworld. I'm your host Jack Wagner. In the last episode we spoke to Emerson, a self described hardcore skeptic who had a very brief but strange encounter with a wolf during which he was chased, and then saw the wolf get up on his hind legs and continue running full sprint upright like a man would run. After this he did some research and discovered a local legend called the Michigan Dogman, a legend that may or may not be partly a hoax. After this, I decided to try speaking to some biologists or wolf experts in Michigan. Normally this wouldn't be something that's very hard for me to do, but nobody, and I mean nobody wanted to talk about the Michigan Dogman. However, they did send over the DNR data for Michigan and told me that there are no known wolves in the area where Emerson had this experience, which I thought was really interesting. This all led me to talk to the man who started this all, or at least named it the radio DJ Steve Cook. After speaking to him, it seems that the Michigan Dogman was definitely started as joke. The history behind it was made up by Steve, and Steve certainly fueled the fire of this hoax by releasing fake footage. But he also told me that he has talked to so many people over the years who he believes had very real encounters with something that sounded a lot like the Michigan Dogman. I think this story is a very realistic representation of the paranormal in general. Lots of fake material exists, people do make up stories and because of that much of the world assumes that it's all fake. Everyone wants things to be black and white, but it's just not the way this works. Well, on this show, we speak to a lot of people who thought something wasn't real until they saw it with their own eyes. And in the second part of this series, we'll be speaking to another person in Michigan who thinks they encountered the Dogman as well. However, the thing that this person saw seems quite different than what Emerson experienced. It comes from a woman named Grace, and I will let her take it from here. This is the Michigan Dogman, part two, and you're listening to Otherworld. Hello, is this Bobby?
- [03:58]
Grace Godvin
Yes.
- [03:58]
Nancy Martin
It is, at its core, the science.
- [04:00]
Grace Godvin
You can't argue with us.
- [04:02]
Jack Wagner
All of a sudden, it is up in the sky.
- [04:04]
Nancy Martin
It's almost frustrating that it's happening.
- [04:06]
Steve Cook
I'm literally.
- [04:06]
Nancy Martin
I'm gonna die.
- [04:07]
Jack Wagner
But its limbs were just, like, wrong.
- [04:11]
Grace Godvin
Everybody moves back into the night, even.
- [04:13]
Jack Wagner
If it takes them a minute. I'm grace. I am 31. I live in Los Angeles. I'm a director, and I grew up in Dallas, Texas. I went to Boston College, and then I went to work in New York. I actually worked at Saturday Night Live for a long time. And then I came to LA two years ago and have been directing for, like, three or four years and just directed my first feature. I'm engaged to a guy who's obsessed with Otherworld. My fiance's name is Jack, and I love him so much. And he moved to New York for me because he lived in Austin when we started dating, and then he very kindly moved to LA for me, too. So he's been following me around. So I have to tolerate, you know, things like his podcasts, him repeating the entire story of a podcast out loud, which podcasts can be riveting, but the retelling of them is less so. And he works at this Wine Story, works at Silver Lake Wine with a guy named Steven, who we love, and Steven introduced him to this podcast. I also have been seeing Otherworld podcast billboards all over town, but I. I would kind of send the picture of the billboard and Jess to the both of them, because I'm going to be honest with you, I am not a. I'm not a fan of this podcast only because I'm not. It's not you or the coasts. It's just. I don't like spooky stuff. I'm not into ghosts. I'm not into, you know, you know, unidentified flying objects or anything.
- [06:23]
Nancy Martin
Sure, sure.
- [06:24]
Jack Wagner
I'm just like, I'm sure it's out there. It's not like I'm.
- [06:27]
Nancy Martin
It's fine, Grace.
- [06:29]
Jack Wagner
It doesn't exist, but it's just not for me. And so they.
- [06:35]
Nancy Martin
Jack, it's not you. It's me.
- [06:37]
Jack Wagner
It's not me, it's you and Jack. But Jack's obsessed with it. Jack loves ghost stories. He loves that kind of stuff. So does Steven. And so they have, like. They, like, really created their friendship over this podcast. And now, I mean, we went to their house last night for a movie night. Like, we're very close with them, and it really. I think this podcast is part of that. And so I had never told him this. This. We call it Man Dog, but I'm hearing people call it Dog Man. My mom was in town a few months ago, and so I had two friends over for dinner, and I cooked dinner, and my mom was there, and our friends were talking about how they think there's, like, a ghost in their apartment. And then Jack was sort of pulling questions out, like, pulling answers out of them, because he was really interested in their ghosts. I mean, even in our house that I'm sitting in right now, we have. It's really old. It's from the 1920s, and a woman died here, and the lights act strangely, and Jack thinks it's a positive ghost. Only love and light exist, he's always saying. But I'm like, whatever, that's just an old house. And so we were sitting here, and he was like, at this dinner with my mom and my two friends, and he asked the table, he was like, does anybody else have any sort of otherworldly stories? Or. My mom looks at me and she goes, well, do you remember man dog? And I was like, oh, my God, I completely forgot about Man Dog. And obviously, Jack's ears perked up, and he was like, man dog? What are you talking about? And then my mom was like, well, we were in Michigan, and then Jack stopped her, and she goes, wait, you know, the Michigan Dogman is, like, a legend. And we didn't. We knew that, like, dog man, or man dog, as we call it, was sort of a, you know, a lore. But I didn't know specifically that the Michigan Dogman was this, you know, interest in a lot of worlds of otherworldly conversation. And so I remembered it, and my mom told a very brief version of the story, which is what I remember. But I haven't really intentionally, because Jack wanted me to do this podcast. I haven't really heard their full versions, because I think probably for the best for your storytelling and for this story, I could just tell my version of it. Because if you talk to my aunt, she might have a. I think memory works in very funny ways. So I think it might be more interesting if we tell you our raw versions of our stories. And so my mom told the story, the brief version that night, which was when we were driving through rural Michigan. We saw this dog with the face of a man. I kind of like, had put it back somewhere in my brain, but it wasn't something that was like, oh. It was like, oh, yeah, the man dog. It wasn't something that took me a while to recall. It was something I remembered immediately when my mom said that Jack was like, why haven't you've never told me that? That's the craziest thing that you've ever done. Why haven't you told me that? And I just hadn't even thought about it in a really long time. So I think it was just one of those things. I also am not a person who is like, that was otherworldly. That was spooky. I was just like, that was really weird. That dog had the face of a man. And so it wasn't something that would have. Would have like, been something that I would have been like, oh, my God. I had this spooky story. Because I really didn't have a spooky story in my head. It was more of like a crazy thing that happened to me. I was 13. My aunt had an apartment in Chicago and a house in Bu, Like a country house in Buchanan, Michigan. And we were going to visit her house because we'd never been there. And her husband is an artist who is very talented at a lot of things. And he. They bought this house in Buchanan and they. It was an old house that he modernized with, you know, a new architecture and an add on. And it was still. It had the sense of it being old. And the basement was really scary, I remember. But it was also a testament to their style. He loved mid century modern stuff. And my aunt has like a tiny collection of chairs that are all like famous mid century century modern chairs. Like, they're into that kind of stuff. I remember at night it was so dark and so quiet that you almost couldn't sleep. Only sounds you would hear were like howls and rustling and like the scariest shit ever. So sleeping there, I remember, was like a nightmare for me. And so we went out there from Chicago and we were there. I was 13. I was probably, you know, whatever how 8th or 9th grade. I ended up going to my mom's room and sleeping in her bed. I Remember, Because I was so scared. I remember also, like, it took a while to get anywhere because the roads, I mean, you were just so far out that your house would be 30 minutes away from wherever you were getting your supplies or going to a restaurant or. In my memory, it was very far away. And so they were all. And all the roads were super rural. You barely saw another car when you were driving down them. There were sort of just like land to the left and to the right. And so they had a nice house on their street, but the houses next to them were not very nice. Like they were really, you know, run down. And people clearly weren't keeping, you know, maintaining them. And they were a little spooky, you know, like, I wouldn't want to go there alone. Yeah. And everybody's house was super set back on their lots, so you could see them, but not completely. So it was also like that weird thing of not seeing anyone was sort of scary. Like you really did feel like you were alone. Everywhere you went, there weren't a lot of people around until you went to like a restaurant or a farmer's market. Then you would see a lot of people. But clearly these people are coming from all over the place. I remember not sleeping very well, obviously, because of the darkness and quietness. And we got up and we were like. We went to breakfast, we had lunch, we did the thing, we went and had drinks. And then I remember it being dusky. Like, I remember part of the reason we left was because it was getting. It could get dark soon. And so I remember we were driving from like one place to the next, and it takes a really long time. So we were going down these super rural roads. My aunt and uncle had this Land Rover. And I remember the Land Rover because when we were driving in Michigan, we would pull over all the time if there was like a dead animal in the road and she would check on it or. Or you know, if it was like a raccoon, she would like take its tail. She's very strange, but amazing. The four of us are in the car. My uncle was in driving the car. My aunt was in the passenger seat. My mom was on the left side in the backseat, and I was on the right side in the backseat. And we were driving. And obviously we were driving on the right hand side of the road. And you know, we'd just come from something. And I remember it being like a pretty rural part of the road and we kind of are driving. We see something ahead in the distance and it's sort of like a To me, I remember it being like. I didn't know what kind of animal it was because it was sort of. You know, when a dog is sleeping and it wraps itself up in itself. So we're driving and we see something ahead on the road, and I don't really know what kind of animal it is because it's sort of curled up in itself. And my uncle, I remember him being like, what is that? Like is. And then my aunt, we pull up next to. And my aunt, you know, she. She likes to check on animals, as I said. And so she was like. Wanted to get out and check on it. And my. I remember my uncle being like, no, stop. I don't think you should get out of the car. And he got out of the car, and I remember I was on the side of the road that had the dog on it. And so I remember, like, opening the door to the car and watching him go out and look at this do. And the dog stood up. When the dog stood up, I remember being like. Like, the thing I'll say is the dog to me reminded me, do you know when Sirius Black turns into a dog in Harry Potter? So I remember the dog having that kind of shape, like mangy, but skinny, but long, and sort of feeling sad for the dog because. Feeling like the dog maybe was abandoned or whatever. But when it stood up, it was very clear that the dog had confidence. And. And the dog. This is a weird thing to say, but it felt like the dog knew itself. You know what I mean? Like, the dog was very aware of itself and self assured. And I remember my uncle was like, whoa. And he took a few steps back. He slowly, slowly walked back to the car, and then he got in the car, he closed the door and said, look at that dog's face. Like, look at the dog's face. And as we turned back, I remember the dog started approaching the back of the car very slowly. And the dog, I swear to God, we look behind us and we're all looking out the back window, and the dog props itself up onto the car and looks at us through the back window. And the dog, I swear to God, had the face of a man. Like, it was a man's. It wasn't a threatening face, but it was very clearly a human man's face. Like, so masculine in the way that it reminded me of in my memory. It reminded me of like Cary Grant or. Or like Marlon Brando. Some, like, really distinguished, confident, you know, rugged, a little bit man. Like, truly like a leading man. You know how a dog's face is pointed with its nose and you know how like a pug is flat. It was neither of those things. It was sort of like the shape of a human. Like, it was rounded in a way that doesn't. That I've never seen in a dog before. Like it was. Or since I have two dogs, one sitting on my lap. And like, the funny thing about it was it was. Yeah, it was just like. It didn't have like a point to its face. It didn't have a smashed face. It had like a curve, curved human face. And so I remember that being the thing that made me be like, oh my God, that's the face of a man. Like, it wasn't a dog. The face, the body completely. But the face was strange in its. And the thing was, it looked at us too. So I think the looking at us, it looked at us and it felt like being looked at by a man. It didn't feel like when a dog looks at you, it felt like he was consciously recognizing that we, that he, that it was. That he was like, yes, I am a man. Like, he, he stood up on the back of the car to be like, I. Yes, you were right. I have the face of a man.
- [18:03]
Nancy Martin
And like, how did you know this wasn't. It sounds so stupid saying it like a man in a dog costume or something.
- [18:13]
Jack Wagner
Like, because it just wasn't. It was like, not like, it wasn't big, big. Well, the other thing too is like it's. It had paws and it had like skinny little legs and it. There's no way anything was inside of that creature. The body was so distinctly mangy and, and dog like. The other thing too is like, you know, you see coyotes in LA and you see. And I've seen wolves before, but it wasn't like that either. It was very much like the body was. Was almost too. I don't know what the right word is. Like, too gentle. Not gentle, but like soft and, and, and skinny. And to be a coyote or to be a wolf, like, it was definitely a dog. And the tail wasn't so coyote like either. The tail was the normal tail of a dog. Like, like not crazy big. It was just like. It felt to me like. Like my uncle used to have this dog named, named Digger. And it felt very much like the tail of Digger. But the coat was very dark. Like, the coat was sort of this like brownish, reddish, blackish coat, I remember. And then the face, the hair on the face sort of was less so. Like the hair. There was hair on the face, but it wasn't like, it wasn't like dog hair. And the features were distinguished. Like the lips were distinguished in a way that humans lips are distinguished. The eyebrows, it had like distinguished. And the eyebrows weren't even like comical eyebrows. Like it made sense for its face. The dog, because I was sort of recessed from it looked from afar to be like 60, 80 pounds, ish. And when it. I remember I turned back to see my uncle, like to look at my uncle when he was before, when he said, turn around and look at that dog's face. But I remember it looking smaller. And then when it came up to the side of the car, you know, Land Rovers are tall cars. And so I remember it thinking like, wow, this dog is really tall. Because the dog really was looking at us, like almost level to us through the back of the car. So I think the dog. I mean, I don't know how tall the dog was on all fours, but on two must have been maybe the height of a human man. So my uncle looks at us and is like, turn around and look at that dog's face. And we turn around and the dog has since approached the back of the car. And it was almost like, turn around and look at that dog's face. And then the dog, as if it knew that my uncle had said that, appeared in the back window, looking at us, very curious about us, but also confirming this is my face. You know, like, oh, you're asking about my face. Here I am. I remember being like mystified, almost like, whoa, that is crazy. That dog has the face of a man. I was 13. I wasn't, you know, maybe a complex thinker, but I was just like moved by seeing a dog with the face of a man. And my mom's. I remember looking at her after I saw the dog and she couldn't take her eyes off the dog. And she was just like. It was one of those things where it was just like, oh, my God. And it was that collective experience that we were all having where I think if I'd had this experience alone, I would wonder today if it actually happened. But because I looked into the face of all the people that were looking at this dog, we were all having this mystified sort of trance like experience for a moment that I knew it was real. And then I remember my uncle was like, we gotta get the fuck outta here. And, like, was like, we gotta go. And my aunt started going like, go, go, go, go. Because they were like terrified of. By that point, they were terrified of the dog. I was Totally in sort of this, like, trance, like, experience. But then when they broke me out of it to sort of with their own fear, I was like, oh, fuck, that is really scary. And then I remember thinking, like, this dog definitely knows where we live and definitely knows how to find us. Like, I don't know why I thought that, but I remember thinking that. So we, like, drove out of there. We, like, you know, he laid on the gas and we drove back to their house. We drove directly back to their house in Buchanan. And then I remember that night, like, I was in my bed and it was dark, and there were no lights. And the sound, it was very quiet. And then that night, I swear to God, there was so much howling. Like, there was so much howling outside. But it didn't feel like a lot of dogs. It felt like one dog or wolf or whatever. It felt like one animal was making a lot of noise. When we got back to the house, we called my uncle, who lives in Dallas now, because he's really into spooky stuff. He's like a conspiracy light kind of guy. And we called him, and I remember he Googled it while we were on the phone. And he was like, oh, there is this thing, this dog, man dog. At the time, we were calling him man dog, but he was like, there is this man dog theory that there is a man with a dog with the face of a man that many people claim to say they've seen. At the time, it wasn't in reference to Michigan. It was just like this thing he found on the Internet. And he asked us. I remember he asked us a lot of questions and was really, like, into the story, which is, I think, why. Another reason why I really remember this happening, too is because my uncle was so, like, shocked and surprised. Like, he was just surprised that we had run into something so mystifying. Like, he'd always wanted that experience for himself, maybe, and was really excited that we'd had it. In my memory, I think we were. Me and my mom were leaving the next day, and I think they drove us back to the airport. And I. The whole time, we were just like, not the whole time, but we were. We were like, that man dog was crazy. Like, that's the craziest thing. But again, something you need to know about me and my mom, too, is that we're not crazy ghost people. We're not crazy. Like, I mean, now thinking about it and telling the story, I'm like, maybe there is sort of this presence in that dog that I should have recognized and been more Consciously aware of in that moment, because he clearly was trying to say something, maybe, but we're not big, spooky people. So we kind of were like, that was the craziest thing ever. And then we kind of got on a plane and went back to Dallas and then. And every once in a while, we'd be all together, and we'd be. We'd tell the story to somebody, and we would talk about man dog. But it was more of a funny thing, because a dog with the face of a man, in a lot of ways, is ridiculous. And I think telling the story was really fun for us because we got to be like, yeah, that actually happened. There were four of us in the car, and that happened. And I think people were always really surprised by that. So that was fun for us. I mean, I think the thing that will be more interesting with my aunt than with me is that she was a full adult when this happened, and she knows that area very well because she had a house there. And she also, like, there's. The funny thing is when this got brought back up, there was no point where any of us were like, did that happen? We were all like, oh, yeah, man dog. And that, I think, is, to me, the most striking part about it is that there is. There was. It's not even like any of us were like, wait, what? Or, you know, like, oh, yeah. It was completely for everyone, like, yeah, man dog.
- [26:20]
Steve Cook
So my name is Nancy Martin. I am Grace Godvin's aunt. Her mother is my sister. And the two of them, Grace and her mom, came to visit my husband and I in southwest Michigan. I think it was about 2009. It was late afternoon, and we were going to go over to a place called Tabor Hill. It's a winery, and have a few glasses of local. Local white wine. I want to emphasize that this man dog sighting occurred before we got to the winery. We had just left our house, and we were on a road called Boyle Lake Road, locally nicknamed Boiled Head Road. It's very deserted. It's a gravel road. There's maybe four houses on it. It's probably two miles long. Three of the houses look like they should be torn down or they're abandoned. And then there's one very nice home that is lived in by a very brave woman from Chicago. She lives there by herself. And we were just coming upon her house. Dan was driving. I was in the passenger seat, and Grace and my sister were in the back seat. To our right, There was a gravel parking lot where people would come park their car. And put their boats in a little stream that took you to Boyle Lake. And it was apparently good fishing. And the parking lot was empty. And sitting in the middle of it was. And sitting, sitting very oddly was a dog. It was a big dog, wasn't recognizable as a breed, but it looked like, you know, I don't know, not a lab, not a golden retriever. It was a kind of a hairy big dog. And it was sitting with its two front paws, one crossed over the other. So it had this sort of. It was a weird way for a dog to sit. It was, in a way, it was kind of elegant looking. But it was odd to me that it would sit there in a parking lot, this big dog, and have its leg, you know, its front paws crossed. It had a human like face. It did not have a snout. It had a flat face. It sort of stood up. And the best way I can describe it is it sort of walked like John Wayne. It had a saunter. And it just started coming at the car. Not attacking, not fast, but it just started coming at the car. And for a moment everybody froze because it was odd. It really had a human face. And it was walking towards us. It just kept reminding me of John Wayne coming out of a saloon and kind of walking towards his nemesis. And I recognized it as a dog the way it was sitting in the parking lot. And when it started to walk towards us, I looked at its face. I could see these big, you know, round, human like eyes looking at us. No snout, a flat face. And it just started walking towards us. And at the same moment, we all panicked and started yelling at Dan to, you know, go, go, go, go, go. And we took off and the dog just stood in the parking lot looking at us until we, you know, turned off Boyle Lake onto Gardner and hightailed it to the winery. And we, we talked about it all night, or we talked about it while we were having drinks. And then when we got back to the house, I don't know who did it, but somebody we. We just kept calling it man dog because it looked like a man and a dog. And when we got back to the house, it most likely was Grace. We started. She must have started googling. And it turns out there is something called the Dogman of Michigan. Like if you Google Dogman of Michigan, there's websites dedicated to it, there's all sorts of sightings. You know, we refer to it as man dog just because we, you know, saw the. The dogman, whatever, before we knew it, that this, that we were not the only People that had seemingly not the only people that had this weird experience. I've never had any extra phenomenal, whatever they call them, you know, I don't think aliens have landed in my backyard. I don't haven't seen ghosts. You know, I haven't done any of that stuff. The only strange thing that has happened to me and to anybody I know who, which is my sister and Grace and Dan, was this, whatever this brief interaction with Mandog, you know, it's made me more open to when people tell me something that sounds screwy, you know what I mean? Like, oh, we had this experience instead of going, oh, you're ridiculous, you must have been drinking or, you know, you were. You're mistaken. I mean, I will tell you that I am in, not in my heart, but like, what I experienced was not a dog. It was some sort of mixed species. It had very, very human like tendencies. The face, the rest of the body looked like a dog. It was covered in fur. It had four legs. It had a tail. I don't remember if it had ears. I don't know. I remember its face looking very human and I remember its movements and its reactions and its gestures being more human than canine. So when people tell me nutty stuff, I'm more curious about it than I am, you know, sort of just disdainful of, you know. Well, you're crazy. I don't reject things out of hand. I think that's the impact it's had on me. Anything's possible.
- [33:16]
Nancy Martin
All right, we have to take a break, but we'll be right back with the rest of this episode.
- [33:29]
Grace Godvin
When you think about businesses that are.
- [33:31]
Jack Wagner
Selling through the roof, like aloe allbirds or skims.
- [33:34]
Grace Godvin
Sure, sure, you think about a great product, a cool brand and brilliant marketing. But an often overlooked secret is actually.
- [33:41]
Jack Wagner
The businesses behind the business.
- [33:43]
Grace Godvin
Making, selling, and for shoppers, buying simple.
- [33:47]
Jack Wagner
For millions of businesses, that business is Shopify. Nobody does selling better than Shopify, home of the number one checkout on the planet. And the not so secret secret with shop pay that boosts conversions up to 50%, meaning way less carts going abandoned.
- [34:02]
Grace Godvin
And way more sales going.
- [34:04]
Jack Wagner
So if you're into growing your business.
- [34:06]
Grace Godvin
Your commerce platform better be ready to.
- [34:08]
Jack Wagner
Sell whenever your customers are scrolling or strolling on the web, in your store, in their feed and everywhere in between. Upgrade your business and get the same checkout experience as business powerhouses like aloe, allbirds and skims. Sign up for your $1 per month trial period@shopify.com OdysseyPodcast all lowercase go to shopify.com OdysseyPodcast to upgrade your selling today shopify.com OdysseyPodcast do you know what went down at the Viper Room the night River Phoenix died? Or how about the mysterious death of Brittany Murphy? Are you aware of how Steve McQueen escaped murder at the hands of the Manson family?
- [34:48]
Nancy Martin
The obsessive killing of Dorothy Stratton?
- [34:50]
Jack Wagner
The real life murder that inspired David Lynch's Twin Peaks?
- [34:54]
Steve Cook
The three conspiracies surrounding Marilyn Monroe's death?
- [34:58]
Grace Godvin
These stories and more are told in.
- [35:00]
Nancy Martin
The new podcast Hollywoodland, where true crime and Tinseltown collide.
- [35:05]
Jack Wagner
Hollywoodland is hosted by me, Jake Brennan, creator of the award winning music and.
- [35:09]
Grace Godvin
True crime podcast Disgraceland.
- [35:12]
Jack Wagner
Follow and listen to Hollywoodland wherever you get your podcasts. Instacart is on a mission to have you not leave the couch this basketball season because between the pre game rituals.
- [35:22]
Nancy Martin
And the post game interviews, it can.
- [35:23]
Jack Wagner
Be difficult to find time for everything else. So let Instacart take care of your game day snacks or weekly restocks and.
- [35:29]
Nancy Martin
Get delivery in as fast as 30.
- [35:31]
Jack Wagner
Minutes because we hear it's bad luck to be hungry on game day. So download the Instacart app today and enjoy. $0 delivery fees on your first 3 orders. Service fees apply for 3 orders in 14 days. Excludes restaurants Marvel Studios Thunderbolts Will Take.
- [35:46]
Steve Cook
The world by storm.
- [35:48]
Jack Wagner
Yes, there's a big threat out there.
- [35:51]
Nancy Martin
And you're gonna help me stop it.
- [35:53]
Jack Wagner
Us.
- [35:54]
Grace Godvin
Why? You got someplace to be on May 2nd?
- [35:56]
Steve Cook
Avengers are gone.
- [35:57]
Grace Godvin
No one's coming to save the day their time.
- [36:00]
Jack Wagner
I think we could be the people that are coming has come being the hero. There is no higher calling.
- [36:06]
Steve Cook
Let's do this.
- [36:09]
Jack Wagner
Marvel Studios Thunderbolts only theaters May 2nd.
- [36:12]
Steve Cook
Get tickets now.
- [36:13]
Grace Godvin
This film is not yet rated.
- [36:15]
Jack Wagner
This episode is brought to you by Temptations Cat Treats. Your cat will come running for the perfectly irresistible Temptations Creamy Puree and Temptations Lickable Spoon Cat Treats.
- [36:27]
Grace Godvin
The best time to feed Lickable Cat.
- [36:29]
Jack Wagner
Treats to your cat is anytime. Feed by hand for a playful moment.
- [36:33]
Grace Godvin
In a bowl for a creamy treat.
- [36:35]
Jack Wagner
Or as a topper to make mealtime fun. Visit temptationstreats.com to learn more.
- [36:53]
Nancy Martin
Okay, thank you so much to Grace and Nancy for sharing that story. After hearing it, my first thought was that I really hope the image of a dog with a old Hollywood Clark Gable style human face doesn't appear in my head at any point when I'm trying to fall asleep. My second thought though was that whatever this thing was that they saw is really not similar to Emerson's experience. Emerson said that he basically saw a normal wolf, except for the fact that it got up on its hind legs. And Grace said that this was clearly a dog until they got closer and realized it was more of a dog with a man's face. But in both cases, they went looking for answers and found out about the Michigan Dogman and figured, this must be it. This must be what I saw. Shortly after interviewing Grace, to my surprise, I was finally able to get a hold of somebody who works with wolves. They do this in Minnesota instead of Michigan, but that's close enough for me either way. I just wanted to finally speak to somebody who knows about these creatures and ask them some very basic questions, like whether or not wolves display any strange behavior that might cause people to think they experienced something paranormal, like getting up on their hind legs and what they think about the entire Michigan Dogman legend. So I talked to Maeve Rogers. She works at a wolf research and outreach program in Minnesota. She previously worked with wolves in Yellowstone national park, and this is our conversation. Maeve, what title would you like to use? How shall I introduce you here?
- [38:52]
Grace Godvin
Well, Maeve Rogers, I am a education and outreach specialist for a wolf project in Minnesota, and I've spent a lot of time following wolves and watching them in multiple different environments. So I know a lot about them.
- [39:08]
Nancy Martin
How and when did you get started doing this?
- [39:11]
Grace Godvin
So I grew up in Northern Illinois, and I don't really know exactly when it started, but I have always had this deep fascination with animals, but wolves specifically. And in Illinois, we really don't have wolves. So as soon as I could, I moved to Montana to pursue, hopefully a career in wolves and went to Montana State University to study wildlife biology. And I chose this school specifically because of its close proximity to Yellowstone National Park. And eventually I was able to volunteer and work with the Yellowstone Wolf Project for four or five years. That was my start.
- [39:51]
Nancy Martin
And what do you do now?
- [39:52]
Grace Godvin
So, kind of around the time of the pandemic, I actually moved to Minnesota, up in some of the most remote parts of the state. But something about Minnesota just kind of piqued my interest because the wolves there act completely different from the wolves in Yellowstone, and I really wanted to explore that a bit more. So I am still currently in Minnesota working with wolves. So for the past four years, I have been up in remote Minnesota studying and tracking wolves out in remote landscapes by myself. Typically, a big part of my job is trapping wolves and putting GPS collars on them.
- [40:38]
Nancy Martin
Maeve, I wanted to ask you before we go further, the fine Biologist community of Michigan and wolf community of Michigan was really not interested in talking to me. Are you surprised by this?
- [40:52]
Grace Godvin
No, I wouldn't, I wouldn't say I'm surprised. I think kind of like the academic community and more professional community. Well, not that this isn't professional, but it's kind of like the professional wildlife community doesn't like to typically comment on certain stories that people have. I'm not very surprised to hear it though.
- [41:16]
Nancy Martin
Honestly, I am not super surprised either, especially the more I learn about the history of the Michigan dogman. But I did just want to ask very simple questions to these people originally. Now that I have you, the first question I have is are wolves known to approach people out in the wilderness or are they animals that are generally elusive and hide when they hear somebody coming?
- [41:44]
Grace Godvin
So I think this really depends, and it really depends, I think on the population of wolves you might be around. For example, when I worked in Yellowstone. Yellowstone has some of the most habituated wolves in the world. Just because they are super used to humans being around them, watching them every single day and tracking their movements in such open landscapes. They don't approach humans normally naturally. It's usually just a sign of habituation, as I said, just due to exposure to human presence without any sort of negative impact to them. Another way that wolves can get habituated to humans is through access to human food and trash. And this can lead to problems. But typically wolves do not approach people whatsoever. Wolves are truly some of the most, if not the most docile animal in the woods that you could come across, in my opinion. I have spent thousands of hours in the woods by myself and I have been attacked by a multitude of other animals, but never a wolf. I have been attacked on many occasions by mama grouse protecting her babies. I've also been attacked by white tailed deer on many occasions. Squirrels are also a lot more scary, in my opinion than wolves are. But yeah, I've never really felt threatened or scared of wolves. Even though they are a big predator. You know, generally they really don't want anything to do with you and will run the other direction. And I think that's something that a lot of people don't realize because of kind of the exaggerations with stories in our society. People think that just because a wolf is a predator, they might be threatening or aggressive towards people, which it can happen. I'm not saying that's impossible. It is very unlikely. And there are ways to go about handling a wolf encounter properly. I would always suggest just making yourself look as big as Possible menacing, aggressive, scream at the wolf, throw things at the wolf, chase the wolf. I've done all these things if I've felt like a wolf has gotten a little bit too curious and, you know, I've never had an issue. And again, with all the time that I have spent in the woods going to areas that wolves have directly spent time in, if anybody was gonna get attacked by a wolf, it probably would have been me by now. And I, you know, I still have not had any situation where I've truly felt fear around a wolf, but I still respect them as the wild animal that they are. And, you know, there is still like a little bit of an unpredictability about them, but it's not really something that I have come to fear through my experiences and knowledge.
- [44:34]
Nancy Martin
What did you think of the two stories that I told you about that we had on this show?
- [44:39]
Grace Godvin
Well, I mean, I think both sound pretty terrifying in their own ways. I am a little bit, you know, skeptical maybe because I haven't experienced something like that, and I come from a very scientific background, but I'm not really one to discredit anyone's experiences, especially because I wasn't there. But yeah, they do sound pretty weird, but terrifying nonetheless. I don't really know what I would do if I was in a situation like that, other than try to get away.
- [45:08]
Nancy Martin
Do wolves ever get up on their legs? I mean, a theme of a lot of these stories, especially with the Michigan Dogman, is bipedal behavior. Like, do wolves get up on their hind legs? And if so, why?
- [45:24]
Grace Godvin
So, in short, no, they do not. While dogs and wolves may occasionally rise on their hind legs for brief periods, this is often when they're trying to reach or interact with something. This is not a natural and definitely not an effective way for moving for them. They are quadrupods, so that means that they walk on four legs while we are bipeds and we walk on two. And dogs, like wolves, they're built for movement on all fours. And their skeletal and muscular structures are designed for speed and endurance when chasing fast moving prey. So not for upright bipedal walking, this would not be energetically efficient for them. They wouldn't be able to sustain the speed and distances that they need to take down these fast moving prey like deer, elk, bison. Wolves also have these elongated limbs and specialized joints that make them excellent runners and excellent for endurance. But they are definitely not built for walking on two legs like humans.
- [46:21]
Nancy Martin
So that being said, like, what do you think of this story of something that looked like a wolf Rising up on its hind legs and running full sprint.
- [46:31]
Grace Godvin
Definitely interesting. And I think stories like this, kind of just like stories in general, they often might arise from, like, a mix of human imagination and encounters with wildlife. I think wolves in particular have been a source of mystery and fascination due to their elusive nature and behaviors.
- [46:55]
Nancy Martin
You said that's really unlikely, but is it impossible? Is it a possibility that he saw a wolf displaying strange behavior, and is it common for wolves to display strange behavior? What an average person might think is strange?
- [47:12]
Grace Godvin
No, it is not impossible for wolves to go up on their hind legs. Like, I have seen wolves on their hind legs jumping for things and kind of bouncing. Like, if a crow flies around to kill. I've seen wolves get up on their hind legs and, like, snap at the air and try to get at them, but it's not like, a way that they would choose to typically move.
- [47:35]
Nancy Martin
What do you think of this whole Michigan dogman thing? Did you get a chance to look into this at all? Like, what do you think of that whole legend?
- [47:44]
Grace Godvin
I mean, growing up in northern Illinois, there's a town that was less than an hour away from me that kind of had a similar dogman story. And I think I kind of grew up hearing about, like, certain creepy things in the woods. And I always took an interest in them, I guess folklore in general. I think it's really fascinating. And again, I think that these stories often arise from, like, the mix of human imagination and encounters with wildlife. Folklore and myths, especially in, like, certain western narratives, have long painted wolves as symbols of danger and destruction. Many of us grew up hearing the tale of the big bad wolf. I did. But, you know, I always like to remind myself, too, that not everybody shares that perspective. And some native cultures, specifically have a different narrative where one where wolves are seen as brothers and their fate is tied to their own. So I think it's kind of like our views on wolves might be shaped by what we're exposed to growing up. And if people are people that you are around, fear of hate wolves, you know, you might too. And if you grow up respecting them, that perspective stays with you as well. Beyond cultural narratives, human wolf conflict is often intense, intensified by bad press and misinformation. You know, there's a lot of stuff out there about wolf depredation on livestock, and that's a huge conversation point when it comes to wolves. But here in North America, there's only been a few cases of wolves actually attacking and killing people. And by a few, I mean, like, two. But nothing in the lower. There's been no reported attack in modern history, at least of wolves attacking or killing people.
- [49:29]
Nancy Martin
How has the fear of wolves affected the wolf population in North America?
- [49:35]
Grace Godvin
Yeah, that's a good question. It has deeply affected the wolf population. You know, I think when Western settlers came in, they had ideas about things and kind of this idea that, you know, I guess, like, I believe our attitudes towards wolves say more about us than like the animals themselves. I think wolves represent the unknown, the wild, and like, untamed aspects of nature. And these are things that humans have long struggled to control, and they can be unsettling. And I think that we came in with this idea that we wanted to conquer nature. And wolves, along with other predators, were kind of looked at as just nuisance vermin that made living harder. And instead of trying to find a way to work alongside our wildlife, we just resorted to killing. So wolves were about the most widespread land carnivore mammal that we had here in North America. And due to predator eradication, wolves were completely eliminated from the lower 48 states. Wolves, along with other predators, were eliminated, but wolves kind of got hit the hardest. They lived in just about every state, across every different type of ecosystem, and were completely eradicated. Wolves do have a place in the ecosystem and a pretty important one as an apex predator. And after the eradication efforts in the 1970s, we created the Endangered Species act, kind of revolved around the wolf so that we could bring wolves back to places that they historically lived. And the hope is that we can have wolves be able to safely move into places like Wyoming and Idaho, down to Colorado, and eventually meet up with a small population of wolves, Mexican gray wolves in New Mexico and Arizona, and kind of start having more genetic connectivity throughout the populations there.
- [51:36]
Nancy Martin
So, Maeve, it sounds like you're a little skeptical of my dogman stories here.
- [51:44]
Grace Godvin
Yeah, I could maybe say that.
- [51:46]
Nancy Martin
That's your job though, right?
- [51:48]
Grace Godvin
It is, yes. I am very science based. I believe in data. Like, I really like to see hardcore data to, you know, start being able to draw conclusions. But, you know, that is the professional side of me. But then there's also the side of me as a biologist. I would think that having other species that are not yet discovered, even though we've probably been living alongside of them, is really interesting to me. But yeah, I can't really draw too many conclusions until I see evidence.
- [52:20]
Nancy Martin
I wanted to ask you, what do you think about the hyper focus on wolves in terms of paranormal beliefs, folklore, things like that? I mean, I know it's really easy for people to say that it's a frightening animal. People are scaring themselves imagining things. But, you know, you really don't see stories like this about bears. Not only that these stories exist across cultures throughout history. People having weird experiences, specifically with wolves. Like, what do you think of that pattern?
- [52:54]
Grace Godvin
Yeah, I think that alone is super fascinating. Especially long before modern technology allowed people to really communicate across continents and different cultures and people groups developed, like, eerily similar folklore and stories, like tales of large, mysterious creatures, whether they're wolves, like we're talking about, or Bigfoot, the yeti, or even dragons, like, exist across vastly different cultures. Yeah, it's just really interesting. Despite having no known way of sharing these legends at the time, it makes me wonder, like, why did these themes persist in human history? And while we can't draw definitive conclusion, it is really compelling to consider how our ancestors living in different environments and places, arrived at such similar narratives about the creatures.
- [53:39]
Nancy Martin
As a person who works with wolves, like, do you hear any strange stories about them? Are there any patterns to strange behaviors or experiences people have with wolves that you hear?
- [53:51]
Grace Godvin
For sure. I mean, I hear a lot of stories where, you know, they were out in the woods alone and got surrounded by this massive pack of wolves, and, you know, they were so scared that they had to climb up a tree and escape. I hear things like that all the time. I've heard many stories about people just being out in the wilderness, going down a trail or a road, and seeing this wolf track that was like the size of a dinner plate. I've heard that quite a bit. Or just wolves being, like, these massive, massive creatures, you know, that are 200 plus pounds, which is really funny because actually, up in northern Minnesota, where I work, the average size, the weight of a wolf is around 60 to 62 pounds. They really don't get too big.
- [54:36]
Nancy Martin
Maeve, I have to ask, have you ever had any strange experiences of your own while you're in the woods?
- [54:45]
Grace Godvin
Hesitant for this, but yes. I feel like, yeah, I mean, I've had this. I had one moment that I keep kind of going back to and really wondering, like, what actually happened. And in the moment, it was really terrifying. But kind of having some time away from it, I, you know, I have different ideas of, I guess, what I could have seen or what. What happened, but.
- [55:09]
Nancy Martin
Are you willing to share this?
- [55:11]
Grace Godvin
Yeah, I'll share. So a big part of my job, again, is just going out into the woods and figuring out what wolves are doing based on the GPS locations. We also work with a large array of remote trail Cameras. So on this day, I was maintaining a series of cameras that we had, like, way out in the middle of nowhere. You know, in a lot of places that we hike, I feel like people really haven't been in centuries because the places are just really unappealing. You know, there's a lot of, like, walking through swamps and bogs and, like, super thick forests with mosquitoes and ticks and everything. So I was way out there, kind of going down a little game trail, and I was using my phone to track the trail I was on and seeing exactly how far away I was from the camera. It just kind of felt like a lot of things went silent around me. And a lot of times when that happens in the natural world, that kind of means there's a predator or something that prey animals or birds feel that they need to conceal themselves around. So I, you know, deafening silence kind of. And I hear a snap of a twig or something in front of me. And I look up from my phone and I see something. Not exactly sure what it was, but it was large, about the size of the small sapling trees that were around the game trail I was walking down. So maybe anywhere from, like 6 to 8ft tall. And it's just this mass. I didn't really see any definitive features to cue me into what it was, other than it being gray. You know, I froze for sure. And I'm one of those people that kind of freezes in situations to try to get, like, a grasp of what could be going on. And I wanted to know how to appropriately react to the situation with whatever wildlife I was about to encounter. So I kind of just froze there. I'm literally employed to identify animals, and I'm very well versed with animals up in northern Minnesota. And I still can't, like, really describe what it was or what I even think happened. The only thing that I really remember is just gray. And it happened so fast, and it moved just in to the woods and out of sight. And I remember sitting there still in the silence, and all I could hear, and I just remember this moment very clearly was just boom, boom, boom. Just three very distinct bipedal steps going into the woods. And then nothing. It was silent. It kind of just felt and seemed like it disappeared because nothing else happened. After those three steps, I kind of snapped back to reality and dove into a bush next to me. Because then I was like, okay, what is. Something's going on here. I don't know what just went into the woods. And just that feeling of, like, not knowing what's around you is very scary. I stood just trying to hear anything else because I figured if it was a moose, I would be able to pick up on that a little bit more because moose are also very elusive and scared of people. But they're huge animals and when they get scared and start running through the woods, you're going to hear it and they're going to. You're going to hear their hooves hit the ground and their distinct gait with their forelegs crashing through the woods, hitting branches as they go, snapping logs and twigs and just creating a whole mess. But all I heard was silence and those three steps and nothing else. Yeah. So that I guess is my story. And I don't really have any other conclusions other than like, something was there, it was definitely alive. And I think the scariest thing that I could think of is honestly just a man being randomly out in the woods where I was and disappeared into the woods next to me. I consider myself to be pretty agile in the woods, but I don't know who else has that much experience going through the woods where I was and why anybody would be out there. But yeah, it just kind of disappeared.
- [59:28]
Nancy Martin
How does that make you feel, especially in the context of your skepticism towards what we've been talking about?
- [59:36]
Grace Godvin
Part of me feels like really frustrated that I couldn't figure out what it was because I really love seeing animals out and being able to like keep this list of like all these wild creatures that I've seen. And I think that's been kind of gnawing at me a little bit is not exactly knowing what I saw, whatever it was. But yeah, I think that that must be the most frustrating part is just kind of not really knowing what was there and I guess needing that validation and like the proof with my science side of the brain. But then like, the curious part of me really was like, well, what was that like? I don't know, it's hard to say. The biologist, like researcher side to me is very data oriented and very focused on science and needing like, definitive answers. But then there is this other side of me, like my personal side, I guess, that is super interested in all these other things, you know, that we will never be able to explain and never have answers for just because that's the world. And I don't think we were meant to know everything. You know, I've had interesting, like, unexplainable things happen that like, I can't really draw conclusions from. But I do know that we have these animal populations that live at such low Densities, whether they're endangered or threatened. You know, kind of like how wolves used to be. To me, it makes me think that, especially in the area that I've worked at, I've had to go and try to recover some of our dead study animals. And even though we know pretty much exactly where they are due to their GPS collars, it still can be incredibly hard to document things and to gain data and to recover animals that have passed. So it kind of makes me think that if there are other populations, part of me really is, like, so curious, and I want to, like, just know more and to be able to prove some of these theories and these, like, stories from folklore would be super interesting to me because how are all these different people across time coming with such similar stories? It just. It just piques my interest quite a bit. And just knowing what I know about, you know, more rare or elusive animals, they are hard to find even in modern day with the technology that we have. And we're still discovering new species, especially in the ocean. The ocean's not even, like it's barely been explored and researched, and we're still finding out so much more. I kind of think both sides blend a little bit that, you know, I'd like that hardcore data and science. But I am also super curious to the aspects that we don't know and we're still trying to figure out. And again, going back to wolves, they are some of the most studied land mammals and carnivores of all time, and we are still learning really important, fundamental things about them and their ecology. So the fact that something else could be out there, like, something. Some real aspects to these stories that people have is, yeah, just very compelling to me. Always open to it, because I'm super curious. But again, it's just like one of those things that I'd really like to see some proof.
- [63:18]
Nancy Martin
Okay. Thank you to Maeve for speaking with me. If you want to learn more about the work her and her organization does, they're called the Voyagers Wolf Project. I love it when I get an unexpected otherworld story like that, especially when it comes from somebody like Maeve. I was not entirely surprised by her skepticism about the Michigan Dogman. That point of view was kind of why I wanted to get somebody like her on the show to talk about this. One thing that did stick out to me was near the end when she mentioned how hard it is to recover bodies of wolves in the wild, even when they know the exact GPS locations of where they should be. I feel like anytime the existence of A mysterious creature gets brought up. People end up asking, why haven't they found any remains yet? It's a very fair question, but it's interesting to know that that's harder to do than most people realize. In terms of the Michigan Dogman, I think it's safe to say that the origins are a hoax. Steve made that pretty clear. But I don't think that means that all the people who have experienced something strange in Michigan related to wolves or dogs are just imagining it or creating a hoax themselves. My thoughts are that when people experience things like this, it's very confusing and destabilizing, and lots of times they go out looking for answers. I think the Michigan Dogman created a name, and it gave people in Michigan an answer to something that they didn't have an answer for before. People were suddenly able to apply a name to something that they had experienced long ago and something that people continued to experience. I think assigning names and categories to this stuff can be a bit of a distraction sometimes. That's one of the reasons why I rarely do it. I consciously avoid coming in at the end of these episodes and saying things like, this person clearly encountered a dogman. I mean, how could I or anyone possibly know that anyway? But when it comes to the paranormal, I really believe that this stuff could be caused by many, many different things. Or maybe a lot of it could all be connected to one thing. I have no idea. All of these experiences that we cover on the show could be connected to many different individual things, or maybe there's a few things causing it all, or maybe it's all just one thing. I have no idea. People have had strange experiences with wolves throughout time, and there is folklore from cultures all over the world. It's not just happening in Michigan. I think it's a really interesting pattern, and I honestly hope we get more stories like this in the future. Because if we're ever going to find answers to some of this stuff, I think the first step is to find patterns between these very strange experiences that people have. That brings us to the end of this episode. I want to thank Emerson Grace, Nancy, Steve Cook, and Maeve Rogers for speaking to us for this series. By the way, Steve Cook's album the Legend of Michigan's Dogman 25th Anniversary Collector's Edition, is available on Spotify for streaming if you're interested. It includes 10 different versions of the famous song. This has been the Michigan Dogman, Part 2. And you've been listening to Otherworld. Otherworld is executive produced and hosted by myself, Jack Wagner. Our theme song is by Cobra Man. The soundtrack of this episode is by North Americans. This episode was edited and engineered by Theo Schaeffer. Our artwork work is by Cul de Sac Studios. Nikki Kate Delgado is our Associate Producer. Production help by Haley Pearson. Please show us your support by subscribing, leaving a five star review and telling your friends about Otherworld. If you want to hear bonus episodes, you can become a patron@patreon.com Otherworld Our social media is Otherworldpod. Thank you to the team at Odyssey, JD Crowley, Jenna Weiss Berman, Leah Reese, Dennis, Rob Morandi, Eric Donnelly, Matt Casey, Maura Curran, Josephina Francis, and Hilary Shuff. Follow and listen to Otherworld now for free on the Odysee app or wherever you get your podcasts. And finally, if you or somebody you know has experienced something paranormal, supernatural or unexplained, you could send us your story@storiesotherworldpod.com.