Pablo Torre Finds Out: PTFO Exclusive – The NFL's Secret Collusion Case, Revealed

Release Date: June 24, 2025

In this groundbreaking episode of "Pablo Torre Finds Out," hosts Pablo Torre and Mike Florio delve deep into the National Football League's (NFL) clandestine activities surrounding a secret collusion case between the NFL Players Association (NFLPA) and the league's management. This long-form summary captures the essence of their investigative discussion, highlighting key points, revelations, and the implications of the findings.

1. Introduction to the Collusion Case

The episode opens with Pablo Torre expressing excitement over uncovering a 61-page secret document detailing a significant legal battle between the NFLPA and the NFL. Mike Florio introduces the core contention: the existence of the NFL Management Council (NFLMC) itself as a potentially collusive entity.

• Quote [00:06]: Mike Florio: “Isn't the existence of the Management Council in and of itself per se, collusive activity? The mere existence of it is collusive activity in my view.”

Pablo confirms both he and Mike have reviewed the document, setting the stage for an in-depth exploration of its contents.

2. Background: NFLPA vs. NFL – Allegations of Collusion

The crux of the document revolves around a closed-door hearing held over ten days in July and August 2024. Witnesses included high-profile figures such as NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell, quarterbacks Lamar Jackson, Kyler Murray, Russell Wilson, and various NFL team owners.

• Summary of Allegations:
  • Power Imbalance: The NFL's reluctance to offer guaranteed contracts, contrasting with other major leagues.
  • Collusion Claims: The NFLPA alleged that billionaire team owners conspired with the league office to disadvantage nearly 600 veteran players by avoiding guaranteed contracts.

Pablo notes that despite the gravity of the allegations, the union did not win the case, and no damages were awarded, which had been the public knowledge until the document's revelation.

3. The Deshaun Watson Contract and Its Aftermath

In March 2022, the Cleveland Browns signed Deshaun Watson to an unprecedented five-year, $230 million fully guaranteed contract, a move that deviated sharply from NFL norms. This decision catalyzed the subsequent investigative processes.

• Key Points:
  • Arthur Blank's Reaction: “$80 million above the highest contract ever given guaranteed in the history of the league... says a lot.”
  • Mike Florio [07:05]: Highlights the financial and strategic implications of the fully guaranteed contract, labeling it as potentially the worst transaction in NFL history.

4. Unveiling the Collusion Through Arbitrated Discovery

The arbitrator, Christopher Droney, employed an expedited discovery process to sift through extensive records, emails, and presentations. This process uncovered that during the March 2022 NFL annual meeting in Palm Beach, the NFLMC presented guidelines discouraging teams from offering fully guaranteed contracts, subtly enforcing a unified stance against such practices.

• Quote [13:04]: Pablo Torre: “If guarantees continue to grow... risk that they become the norm in contracts... can handcuff a club in the future.”

The arbitrator concluded that the NFLMC’s efforts were more than mere suggestions, indicating a push towards limiting guaranteed contracts across the league.

5. Leadership Changes within the NFLPA

Amidst these developments, significant leadership changes occurred within the NFLPA:

• JC Tretter, the President of the NFLPA, was cut from the Cleveland Browns in March 2022, capping his tenure as union president.

• Demora Smith, the Executive Director who had steered the union through tumultuous negotiations, also departed.

• Lloyd Howell was appointed as the new Executive Director, a move scrutinized for his background as CFO of Booz Allen, a firm embroiled in procurement fraud settlements shortly after his appointment.

• Quote [34:22]: Mike Florio: “An unbelievable development...how much did they know?...how much did they share.”

6. Examination of Star Quarterbacks’ Cases

The document scrutinizes the handling of three star quarterbacks—Lamar Jackson, Kyler Murray, and Russell Wilson—revealing how collusion tactics ostensibly suppressed their earnings through limited contract guarantees.

Lamar Jackson

• Issue: Jackson sought a fully guaranteed contract, leading to stalled negotiations and a reported malfunctioning microphone during crucial communications.
• Quote [39:26]: Pablo Torre: “I'm going to continue to request a. And this is in all caps, fully guaranteed contract...”

Kyler Murray

• Issue: Similar to Jackson, Murray faced limited guarantees despite strong performances. A private text exchange between Arizona Cardinals’ owner Michael Bidwill and Los Angeles Chargers’ owner Dean Spanos revealed coordinated efforts to limit guaranteed money in contracts.
• Quote [46:59]: Mike Florio: “It's the collusion in action.”

Russell Wilson

• Issue: Wilson requested a seven-year fully guaranteed contract when traded to the Broncos but did not receive it. Internal communication suggested efforts to align contract terms across teams to set unfavorable precedents for players seeking guarantees.
• Quote [50:55]: Mike Florio: “Mr. Treader testified that he would not have criticized Mr. Wilson if he had known that owners had a collusive agreement to limit guaranteed compensation.”

7. Internal Dynamics and Ethical Concerns within NFLPA

The episode uncovers internal strife within the NFLPA, highlighting JC Tretter's private disparagement of Russell Wilson, which contradicted his public stance on union solidarity.

• Quote [50:55]: Mike Florio: “Mr. Treader testified that he would not have criticized Mr. Wilson if he had known...”

This revelation raises questions about the integrity and unity of the union leadership, suggesting potential motives for suppressing the arbitration ruling.

8. Implications for the NFL and Future Collective Bargaining

The discovery of collusion tactics and leadership controversies within the NFLPA underscores a significant power imbalance favoring NFL owners. As collective bargaining negotiations loom, with discussions possibly centered around extending the regular season to 18 games, the union finds itself at a strategic disadvantage.

• Quote [62:11]: Mike Florio: “...the interests of the union, the interests of the players would be put behind the interests of those who lead the union.”

The episode posits that the secrecy and manipulation within both the NFL and NFLPA could have long-term ramifications for player negotiations and the overall structure of the league.

9. Conclusion: The Ongoing Struggle for Transparency and Fairness

Pablo Torre and Mike Florio conclude by emphasizing the need for greater transparency within the NFL and its union. The revelations from the 61-page document not only shed light on past collusion but also foreshadow future challenges in maintaining player rights and fair negotiations.

• Final Thoughts:
  • The uncovered documents serve as a catalyst for demanding accountability from both the NFL and the NFLPA.
  • As the power dynamics remain skewed, the episode calls for unified efforts to restore balance and ensure that players are adequately represented and compensated.

Follow Pablo Torre Finds Out:

• YouTube: Pablo Torre Finds Out
• Instagram: @pablotorrefindsout
• X: @pablofindsout
• Newsletter: Subscribe Here

This episode of "Pablo Torre Finds Out" offers an incisive look into the inner workings of the NFL's management and its interactions with the players' union, unveiling a saga of power, secrecy, and the ongoing quest for equitable treatment of athletes.