Pablo Torre Finds Out

Episode: "World War Tree: The Agony and the Ecstasy of Competitive Bird-Watching"

Date: July 8, 2025
Host: Pablo Torre
Guests/Co-reporters: Mickey Dujay, Sharon Stiteler (a.k.a. Birdchick), Charles Clarkson (“Birding Jesus”), Peter Kastner (“Inspector Kastner”)

Episode Overview

This episode explores the intense, eccentric, and sometimes comically passionate world of competitive bird-watching, or “birding.” With the help of correspondent Mickey Dujay, Pablo Torre is inducted into the quirky culture of birders — from spiritual pursuits and competitive list-making, to the personal agony of chasing your “nemesis bird.” The episode is part field documentary, part zoomed-in portrait of human obsessions, and it’s peppered with insights from experts, legendary birders, and moments of Pablo’s own journey in Central Park hunting his assigned nemesis, the Northern Parula warbler.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Rise of the Side Quest Hobby (01:07–02:30)

• The Zeitgeist: Mickey notes an explosion of “side quest” hobbies in 2025, thanks to changing work-life dynamics: “We are living in a golden era of side quests... All of these pastimes are really booming.” (01:07)
• Bird-watching has emerged as an unlikely yet booming pursuit — one that blends outdoor adventure, mindfulness, and, increasingly, competition.

2. The Concept of the “Nemesis Bird” (02:32–06:33)

• Origin Story: Mickey recounts an encounter at a party of “serious bird watchers” who introduce him to the idea of a nemesis bird — a species that perpetually eludes you, becoming an obsession.
• Birding as Sport: Pablo draws parallels between bird-watching’s “honor code” and self-policing in sports like pickup basketball (04:26–05:05).
• The Chase: Birders develop extensive knowledge but still fail to spot their nemesis, feeling both haunted and motivated by the elusive bird.

Notable Quote:

• “A nemesis bird, it turns out, is a flying Moby Dick. It is the creature that keeps eluding you.” — Pablo Torre (04:42)

3. The Ecstasy of the Birding “Find” (08:24–12:17)

• Expert Testimony: Sharon Stiteler (“birdchick”) describes the rush of finally spotting one’s nemesis bird, likening it to a rare high, “up there with like having a 16-year-old scotch or a really amazing orgasm” (08:38).
• Personal Stories: Sharon, going through a divorce, becomes obsessed with finding the spruce grouse. Her tale involves new relationships, wild offers, and a literal fall off her bike in pursuit — ending in fist-pumping, life-affirming triumph.

Notable Quote:

• “I kind of describe my perfect day as getting the trifecta of birding, bike riding and banging.” — Sharon Stiteler, birdchick (08:45, also 09:05)
• “Seeing your nemesis bird — it’s a top five life moment.” — Sharon Stiteler (11:43)

4. Birding’s Competitive Evolution: From Opera Glasses to Apps

(12:45-19:41)

• Historical Context: In the late 1800s, bird-watching shifted from hunting to observing, thanks in part to ornithologists like Florence Bailey and Edmund Seles.
• Modern Birding, Huge Numbers: Birding today is worth $300 billion in the U.S., employing a million people (16:32).
• Gamification: Apps like eBird (Cornell Lab of Ornithology) gamify birding, with leaderboards and logged sightings, sparking both community and controversy.

Notable Quote:

• “Birding as a hobby even contributes $300 billion in revenue to the United States.” — Charles Clarkson (16:32)

5. The Dark Underbelly: The Big Listers and Their Arms Race

(19:41–34:54)

• The Big Listers: Competitive birders catalog every species they’ve seen (“life lists”). Hitting 8,000 is “insane;” 10,000 is nearly mythical. Only 10 people have ever surpassed 9,000.
• Inspector Kastner vs. Dr. Jason Mann: The episode chronicles a real-life rivalry for the title of world’s greatest birder:
  • Kastner’s Guinness World Record exploits, penchant for numbers, and cloak-and-dagger tactics to keep his sightings secret.
  • Mann’s rapid rise, questioned credibility, and accusations of “fishy” species logged from far-flung and nearly inaccessible locales.

Notable Quotes:

• “To me, 10,000 is like the ultimate... an almost unattainable goal.” — Peter Kastner (21:34)
• “All of a sudden… two people doing it and claiming it on the same day is just nuts. The birding world exploded.” — Peter Kastner (29:41)
• “Either this guy is the luckiest birder alive, having rediscovered several lost species, or his list is not to be trusted.” — Pablo Torre, reading a community post about Dr. Mann (31:18)

6. The Birding Jesus View: The Spiritual, Non-Competitive Path

(34:18–39:27)

• Birding as Spirituality: Charles Clarkson (“Birding Jesus”) finds competition antithetical to the deeper joy and mindfulness of birdwatching: “That’s kind of the antithesis of why I love birds.” (34:49)
• The narrative shifts to the journey, not the number — appreciating the moments, immersing oneself in nature and the search itself.

7. The Holy Grail: The Spiritual Find of a Lifetime

• Clarkson’s Nemesis Bird: After a decade pursuing the elusive rufous-vented ground cuckoo — revered as “the ghost of the forest” — Clarkson finally finds it, describing a tearful, transcendent moment:
  • “Based on its jizz… everything about this bird screamed rufous-vented ground cuckoo. So my heart absolutely stopped.” (37:29)
  • He’s moved to tears and calls his wife, only for her to say, “I’m so happy for you. I’m going into Home Depot. I’ll call you later.” (39:22)

Key Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

• Birding Ecstasy:
  08:38 Sharon Stiteler: “When you do finally see a bird that you’ve been looking for, it’s a dopamine rush. It is a high…up there with…a really amazing orgasm.”

• Lifelong Pursuit of Numbers:
  21:34 Peter Kastner: “To me, 10,000 is like the ultimate.” 22:33 Pablo Torre: “He’s saying that he intends to see a new bird species every other day for the span of his entire life... which seems…impossible.”

• Suspicion & Rivalry:
  29:41 Peter Kastner: “After a lifetime of nobody ever coming close to 10,000, two people doing it and claiming it on the same day is just nuts...the birding world exploded.”

• Skepticism of Mann’s Claims:
  31:18 Pablo Torre (reading from a forum): “Either this guy is the luckiest birder alive…or his list is not to be trusted.”

• High Art of Birding:
  34:49 Charles Clarkson: “Viewing them [birds] as a source of competition… that’s kind of the antithesis of why I love birds.”

• Transcendent Encounter:
  37:29 Charles Clarkson: “My heart rate went up... everything about this bird screamed rufous-vented ground cuckoo. So my heart absolutely stopped.” 38:32 Charles Clarkson: “Yes, well, yes, I did have tears in my eyes.”

• Humor and Touches of Absurdity: 33:44–34:04 (On bird watching slang):
  Mickey Dujay: “That’s jizz, Pablo.”
  Pablo Torre: “You got me? Yeah, I’m hooked.”

Field Report: Nemesis Bird Quest in Central Park

(41:05–49:37)

• Launching the Quest: Pablo, Mickey, and Birding Jesus (Charles Clarkson) set out in Central Park, donning gear and guided by expert knowledge.
• The Assigned Nemesis: Pablo’s nemesis bird is officially designated as the Northern Parula, a small, yellow-bibbed warbler whose song is so high-pitched that some people can’t even hear it (40:35–40:47).
• Comedic Nature Doc Parody: Throughout, a narrator parodies David Attenborough-style, describing Pablo as the rare “Filipino American Podcaster” caught in the wild.
• The Climax (Not): Despite valiant searching and humorous banter, the team does not spot the nemesis bird. Instead, they hang up a “Have you seen this bird?” flyer with Pablo’s hotline (50:28) and joke about the innuendo-laden culture of birding.

Notable Quotes:

• “The name of my nemesis bird is the northern parula.” — Pablo Torre (47:07)
• “We have not seen the nemesis bird yet. But the nemesis bird also hasn’t seen us.” — Pablo Torre (48:01–48:04)
• “Even though I’ve gained a nemesis, I’ve also gained a friend.” — Pablo Torre (50:04)

Themes and Takeaways

• Agony and Ecstasy: Birding contains both the torment of obsession and the thrill of discovery.
• Spiritual vs. Competitive: The hobby is divided between “big listers” treating it like sport and “birding believers” seeking transcendence.
• Community & Comedy: Obsession leads to humor, rivalry, camaraderie — and tons of innuendo.
• Modernization: Technology has gamified birding, for better or worse, deepening rivalries but democratizing access.
• Serendipity Over Success: The pursuit is often more meaningful than the outcome — both for birds and for life’s quests.

Useful Timestamps Quick Guide

• 01:07 — The rise of “side quest” hobbies
• 02:32 — Defining and describing the “nemesis bird”
• 08:38 — Birdchick on the ecstasy of the chase
• 13:36 — Birding goes mainstream; historical turn
• 16:32 — Birding becomes a billion-dollar industry
• 19:41 — Gamification and eBird controversy
• 21:34 — Inspector Kastner’s 10,000 species ambition
• 29:41 — Two birders claim 10,000 in one day — controversy erupts
• 34:49 — Birding Jesus on birding as spirituality, not sport
• 37:29 — Spiritual “find” of the rufous-vented ground cuckoo
• 40:10 — Pablo’s nemesis bird revealed: the Northern Parula
• 41:05–50:04 — Field expedition in Central Park searching for the nemesis bird
• 50:04 — “Even though I’ve gained a nemesis, I’ve also gained a friend.”

Tone and Style

The episode walks a sharp line between high-energy journalistic exploration, wry humor, and genuine profundity. The conversational banter, playful innuendo, and faux-nature-documentary narration evoke a tone that is as irreverent as it is deeply curious. The speakers embrace the obsessions and eccentricities of their subjects, creating a portrait of birding that is both hilarious and moving — perfect for listeners who appreciate insight, competition, and, yes, a little bit of joyful weirdness.

For more about Pablo Torre Finds Out:
YouTube Channel
Newsletter