Podcast Summary: "Papi Killed Mommy"
Episode: Letter from a Friend: Cheryl Mendel
Host: Nikki
Release Date: June 21, 2025
Introduction
In the poignant episode titled "Letter from a Friend: Cheryl Mendel" of the true crime podcast "Papi Killed Mommy," host Nikki delves deeper into the life and legacy of her mother, Stacey Wassolichen. This episode, released on June 21, 2025, features a heartfelt letter from Cheryl Mendel, one of Stacey’s closest friends, offering listeners an intimate glimpse into Stacey’s personality, relationships, and the impact she had on those around her.
Nikki’s Opening Remarks [00:00]
Nikki begins the episode by introducing herself and providing context for the bonus series of letters from her mother's friends. She shares her journey into podcasting, highlighting the emotional challenges and learning curve she has faced:
“It's been overwhelming, it's been triggering and honestly, it's the hardest thing I've ever done and I want to be upfront with you. I'm new at this, I am not a professional podcaster and the audio might sound rough around the edges, but I'm learning as I go and I promise I'll get better with each episode.”
— Nikki [02:30]
Introducing Cheryl Mendel’s Letter
Nikki explains that this episode features a letter from Cheryl Mendel, providing a personal account of Stacey’s life during the summer of 1976. Cheryl’s letter serves as a bridge to understanding the woman Nikki lost and the relationships that shaped her.
Cheryl Mendel’s Memories of Stacey [03:15]
Cheryl begins her letter by recounting the summer of 1976 in Downers Grove, Illinois, when she first met Stacey:
“It was the summer of 1976 when I first met Stacey Wassolichen. I was spending time with friends in the middle of Downers Grove, Illinois. We called it the Hood.”
— Cheryl Mendel [05:45]
She describes Stacey’s vibrant personality and the initial interactions that solidified their friendship.
Stacey’s Arrival and Integration into the Community [06:10]
Cheryl details Stacey's move from Phoenix, Arizona, and her initial behavior:
“At first Stacey was calling folks mutley and being rather loud about it. Stacey lived with her cousins. I did not know much about them, but I met and attended junior high with Joe back in 1974 and I knew his mother, Lily, was the sister of Stacey's mom, Bea.”
— Cheryl Mendel [07:20]
Despite her rocky start, Stacey quickly became an integral part of the community, earning nicknames for her aunt and uncle:
“Stacey had nicknames for her aunt and her uncle. Quite often she would refer to them as Aunt Lily Pad and Uncle Baby.”
— Cheryl Mendel [08:05]
Life in Downers Grove High School [09:30]
Cheryl reminisces about their high school days, highlighting Stacey’s charisma and the tight-knit group of friends they shared:
“Stacey was a beautiful girl with a big personality, a big heart, and a kind and gentle soul. Stacey attended Downers Grove High School with us, where Marty and I had English class together.”
— Cheryl Mendel [10:50]
She shares anecdotes about their favorite teachers and memorable moments, painting a vivid picture of their teenage years.
Stacey’s Passion for Music and Friendship Bonds [14:15]
Cheryl recounts a significant event that underscores Stacey’s love for music and her adventurous spirit:
“In 1977, Stacey, her cousin Joe, and his brother Harry went to the Rolling Stones concert at Soldier Field. It was their Hot Lips tour with Jeff Beck opening. Another no further explanation statement needed.”
— Cheryl Mendel [16:40]
This experience symbolizes the deep bonds and shared passions that defined their friendship.
Stacey’s Return to Phoenix and Lasting Connections [20:00]
After a year in Illinois, Stacey returns to Phoenix, but the friendship remains strong. Cheryl shares the excitement of visiting Stacey and meeting her family:
“Not long after she left, I was on the next plane. I was so excited. There I met her mother Bea, her brother Lance, her sister Wendy, and her closest friend, Lori Swift.”
— Cheryl Mendel [22:30]
She fondly remembers the activities they enjoyed together, emphasizing the enduring nature of their connection.
The Impact of Stacey’s Passing [27:50]
Cheryl reflects on the sudden loss of Stacey and the profound effect it had on her:
“Even though I knew Stacey for only a brief period, I found her to be full of passion and she loved very hard. Her sassy personality and her humor were contagious and it was all part of her charm.”
— Cheryl Mendel [30:10]
She expresses her lasting admiration and the void Stacey's absence has created:
“I know we'd still be great friends today and in my heart I always will be her friend.”
— Cheryl Mendel [31:45]
Nikki’s Closing Remarks [34:20]
Nikki concludes the episode by expressing gratitude for Cheryl’s heartfelt letter and encouraging listeners to support the podcast:
“If Cheryl's letter made you smile or cry or feel like you knew my mom even just for a moment, then I hope you'll stay with me. Because this is only a glimpse. The full story my mom's story deserves to be told out loud and in full.”
— Nikki [35:50]
She teases the upcoming main series, slated to premiere on July 8, and underscores the importance of listener support in uncovering the truth behind her mother's tragic death.
Key Insights and Themes
-
Friendship and Community: Cheryl’s letter highlights the strong bonds Stacey formed during her time in Downers Grove, illustrating the supportive community that surrounded her.
-
Personal Growth and Resilience: Stacey’s ability to maintain her vibrant personality despite challenges speaks to her resilience and the depth of her character.
-
Legacy and Remembrance: Through Cheryl’s recollections, listeners gain a deeper understanding of Stacey’s life, preserving her memory and legacy.
-
Emotional Journey: Nikki’s candid discussion about her experiences as a new podcaster adds a layer of vulnerability, emphasizing the personal nature of her quest for truth and justice.
Conclusion
"Letter from a Friend: Cheryl Mendel" serves as a heartfelt tribute to Stacey Wassolichen, offering listeners a window into her life through the eyes of a dear friend. This episode not only enriches the narrative of Nikki’s mother's story but also underscores the enduring impact Stacey had on those who knew her. As the podcast progresses, listeners can anticipate uncovering more layers of Stacey’s life and the mysterious circumstances surrounding her untimely death.
Support "Papi Killed Mommy":
Nikki encourages listeners to support the podcast to help keep her mother's story alive. Supporters receive personal emails and shoutouts in future episodes. Visit the support link or follow on social media to contribute.
For those seeking a deeply emotional and meticulously crafted true crime story, "Papi Killed Mommy" offers an authentic and moving exploration into a mother's life, her untimely death, and the relentless pursuit of justice by her daughter.